[Page 1]
The Necessity of holding fast the Truth.
REVELATIONS III. 3. Remember therefore, how thou hast heard, and received, and hold fast.
VERY dear Friends and Brethren! You may remember that the Builders of the Wall of Jerusalem, after the Babylonian Captivity, were obliged because of Opposition, to carry a Sword in one Hand to protect, as well as a Trowel in the other to build; and thus must Zion's Builders do, now in this Time of Opposition, and Temptation. We are told in the Prophecy of Ezekiel, Chap. 33. that if the Watchman sees the Sword coming on a Land, blows the Trumpet, and warns the People, however insuccessful his Labours may prove to some, he will nevertheless deliver his own Soul: But that if he does not give seasonable Warning, the Blood of those that perish will be required at the Watchman's Hand.
My dear Friends! to prevent unreasonable Prejudice against this Performance, because of my opposing some Persons in it, who make a fair Shew in the Flesh, I may observe and [Page 2] assure you, that Conscience inform'd by the Word of God, constrain'd me to do what I have done, in detecting and opposing the erronious Notions, of a pernicious new Sect of People, called Moravian Brethren, or Hezenhouters, who have lately come from Germany into this Country. Love to God, and his dear and precious Truths, which are secretly undermin'd by the extraordinary sly concealing Arts of the Moravians, obliges me to speak out expresly, in order, as far as it shall please the God of Truth to bless the same, to give Check to the Spread of that Plague of Leprosy.
I stand here in this Desk in the Name of the great and dreadful God, and in the Room of our Lord Jesus Christ, to sound the Alarm-Trumpet, and give fair Warning to this dear Flock in particular, and to the Inhabitants of the Land in general; by informing and assuring them, that a Spirit of Error and Delusion is gone forth to deceive the World. He that hath Ears to hear, let him hear. I freely venture my Character, and am ready, God assisting, to sacrifice my Liberty, and my Life, in Defence of the blessed Truths of the Reformation, and in detecting the Erronious.
If any out of a childish Credulity, or peevish Obstinacy, will not take the Warning given; my Soul shall weep in secret Places for their Pride!
I cannot stand as an unconcern'd Spectator, to behold the Moravian Tragedy; my Heart bleeds within me to see the precious Truths of Christ opposed, slighted and trodden under Foot, by our new Reformers; and that under a Pretext of extraordinary Sanctity, Love and Meekness! My Soul, come not into their Secret; unto their Assembly, mine Honour, be thou not united! It is enough to make a Heart of Iron bleed, to see Foxes, little Foxes, slily creeping into God's Vineyard, and spoiling the Vines, and tender Grapes, i. e. young Christians, with Enthusiasm, Pride, Error, and Nonsense!
But I hasten to consider the Words of our Text, which is an important Counsel, given by our Lord to the Church of Sardis, to reflect upon and call to Mind, the Truths they had formerly heard, as well as the affectionate Dispositions with which they heard them; and that they would use all proper Means to preserve and retain them; a Counsel very [Page 3] proper for the perilous Times in which we live. The Direction our Lord gave in Respect of hearing the Word elsewhere, strengthens in my Opinion the aforesaid Explication; in one Place he says, Take heed what ye hear, and in another, Take heed how ye hear; and indeed in the Nature of Things the Manner of doing a Duty, supposes the Matter without which it cannot exist.
In discoursing upon this Subject, I shall endeavour to speak to the following Heads.
- I. Shew what Truths we should more particularly remember and hold fast.
- II. Shew what is supposed by and implied in our remembering them and holding of them fast.
- III. Why we should remember them and hold them fast.
And then improve the whole.
I. One Head of Discourse, is to show, What Truths we should more particularly remember and hold fast.
To what I would offer under this Head more directly, I would beg Leave to premise a few Words, concerning the Nature and Kinds of Truth. Here I may observe that Truth in it's general Nature, consists in Agreement, and is threefold, viz. metaphisical, logical, and ethical; the first is the Agreement between the Appearance of a Thing, and the Thing itself represented by it; the second consists in the Agreement, between the Mind and the Thing it conceives of; i. e. when the Mind conceives of any Thing, really as it is; the third consists in an Agreement between our Words and Minds; i. e. when we speak what we think; the first Truth is opposed to Paint and Varnish, the second to Error and Falshood, and the third to Lying; which consists in going against the Mind.
Now my dear Brethren! There are these Truths following more especially, which ye should hold fast to the Death; namely,
1. The Doctrine of CONVICTION by the Law of God, whereby the Sinner is made sensible of his Sin and Misery, before he obtain converting Grace; if we let this precious Truth go with the Moravians; or in Compliance to a noted Person among them, (who asserted in New-Brunswick, that [Page 4] Conviction is not necessary to Conversion, but hurtful; and that the Presbyterian Doctrine, respecting preaching of the Law is false) I say if we drop the Doctrine of Conviction; I see no Ground of Hope, that ever a secure World will be alarm'd. And truly those suppos'd Conversions, which are not preceeded by a Work of the Law, are either in general, strong Workings of the Fancy and Affections, mov'd in a natural Way, as in Tragedies; or the common Workings of the Spirit as in time Believers, and stony Ground Hearers, or a Delusion of Satan!
Does not Scripture and Reason hold forth the aforesaid precious Truth; our Lord promis'd the Spirit to convince Men of Sin, of Righteousness and Judgment, John 16.8, 9. He invites the Weary and Heavy-laden to come to him, and promises them Rest, upon their so doing, Mat. 11.28. He farther informs us, that he came not to call the Righteous, but Sinners to Repentance. That the whole need no Physician, but the Sick. Was not the Prodigal made to see first that he was perishing, before he came to his Father? Luke 15. Have we not three thousand Examples of this at one View? Acts 2.37. I might add the Example of the Jaylor, who said trembling, What must I do to be saved? Acts 16. and of Paul, who being convinced in his Way to Damascus, said, Lord what would thou have me to do?
Now that the Law is the usual Mean of Conviction, appears from these following Places of Scripture, Rom. 8.15. For ye have not received the Spirit of Bondage again to fear, but the Spirit of Adoption, whereby we cry Abba Father. Observe here, that these Gentile Christians of the Roman Nation, had the Spirit of Bondage first; and whence had they this, by the Preaching of the Gospel? no surely, but of the Law. Hence the Apostle saith, that by the Law is the Knowledge of Sin, Rom. 3.20. and that before the Law came he was alive, (i. e. in his own Apprehension) but when the Law came, Sin revived and he died, Rom. 7.9. i. e. when the Law was bro't powerfully home to his Heart by the Holy Ghost, he saw his dead State; this is further confirmed, Gal. 2.19. For I thro' the Law am dead to the Law, that I might live unto God; i. e. I thro' the Law, as an Instrument apply'd, am dead [Page 5] to the Law considered as a Covenant of Works; or dead to all Dependance upon Law-Righteousness for Justification.
The Apostle proposeth this Question, Gal. 3.19. Wherefore then serveth the Law? he answereth, that it was added because of Transgressions; i. e. it was added as an Appendix to the Covenant of Grace, to convince Men of their Transgressions. Hence the same Apostle saith, Rom. 5.20. Moreover the Law entered that the Offence might abound; and indeed the Case is really so, the Law as a Sword must enter our Consciences, before Sin will abound in our Apprehension sensibly: Is the Law then against the Promise, (saith the Apostle, Rom. 3.21.) God forbid. No the Law is good, if it be used lawfully, if it be preached not as a Covenant of Works for Justification; but as a Mean to convince Sinners of their Guilt and Misery, their Inability to fulfil it, and so of their absolute Need of Christ, and the Mercies of the New Covenant thro' him. And thus instead of opposing Christ and the Covenant of Grace, it is the most effectual Mean of promoting our Esteem of and Complyance with both. The Law was our School-Master to bring us to Christ, that we might be justified by Faith, Gal. 3.24. And that altho' Believers are now under a milder Dispensation, of the Gospel, than the Jewish Church was; being freed from the Yoke of the ceremonial Law entirely, and from the frequent and terrible Inculcations of the moral. Hence is that of the Apostle, Heb. 12.18. We are not come to the Mount that might be touched, and that burned with Fire. — But to Mount Zion the City of the living God.
The Gospel Church being come to her full Age, is treated as such, and hath more Knowledge of her Priviledges than the Jewish, who was but in an infant State; yet Unbelievers are in the same Condition now as then. Mark 16.16. John 3.36.
It would be no Priviledge, but a great Loss to the Gospel Church, to be depriv'd of this twofold Use of the Law; namely, to convince Sinners & direct Saints. Do we make void the Law by Faith, says the Apostle; nay we establish the Law.
Reason it self will instruct us, that until poor Souls be alarmed out of the deep Sleep of Sin, they are not disposed [Page 6] to value Mercy thro' Christ much, nor to desire after it, and labour for it, with due Earnestness and Importunity: And until they feel a Work of the Law discovering and humbling of them, they are neither disposed to bow before a sover [...] God, nor to give him the Glory of his Grace, both which are necessary Duties. To talk of using the Gospel as the only or principal Mean of the Conviction of Sinners, is very ignorant and foolish, and shews little Knowledge of divine Things; it's just like putting the Plow before the Oxen. To offer a Remedy before the Disease and Danger is opened, is but to please and deceive a wicked World, and make them sleep the faster in their dangerous Security! Does not the Experience of good Men, confirm this Truth of Conviction? Methinks dear Brethren! we should be willing to part with the last Drop of Blood out of our Veins, before we part with it, Remember therefore how thou hast heard and hold fast.
2. Ye have heard FAITH explained, as consisting (principally) in our receiving Christ Jesus, in all his Offices, and upon his own Terms; namely, those of taking up the Cross, Self-denial, and following of him, and that with Humility, Deliberation, Readiness, and Resolution. This the holy Scriptures expresly assert, John 1.12. Col. 2.6. Mat. 16.24. Luke 14.28. Luke 19.5. 2 Tim. 3.12. Hold fast this precious Truth, my dear Brethren! against the pernicious Doctrine of the Moravians; who hold that Faith consists in a Perswasion that our Sins are pardoned, and that Christ died for us; this Notion wants a scriptural Foundation, and is contrary to Reason. Assurance is a Fruit of Faith, and therefore it's distinct from its Nature, and so separable: The Apostle Paul observes, Ephe. 1.13. that the Ephesian Christians were sealed with the Holy Spirit of Promise, after they believed. Here you may see that they had Faith before they attained to the comfortable Knowledge of it: The Apostle John also speaks to the same Purpose, 1 John 5.13. These Things have I written unto you, that believe on the Name of the Son of God, that ye may know▪ that ye have eternal Life. It is also evident from the Nature of Things, that a Thing must be before it be known to be.
[Page 7]If the Essence of Faith consisted in the aforesaid Perswasion, then the Loss thereof would destroy the very Being of Faith, and so prove a false and perverse Doctrine to be true, namely the falling away of the Saints. For we find according to the holy Scriptures, that the Saints of God are exposed to long Desertions, distressing Doubts and Fears, yea to Despair itself. Isa. 50.10. Who is among you, that feareth the Lord, and obeyeth the Voice of his Servant? and walketh in Darkness, and seeth no Light, let him trust in the Name of the Lord, and stay himself upon his God. See also the distressing Case of the Psalmist, Psal. 77. he refused to be comforted, remember'd God and was troubled.— his Spirit was overwhelmed. And of Heman, Psal. 88. I am as a Man that hath no Strength, like the slain that lie in the Grave, whom thou remembrest no more; thou hast laid me in the lowest Pit, in Darkness, in the Deeps, thy Wrath lieth hard upon me, and thou hast afflicted me with all thy Waves. I hope you will not reject these Proofs, because they are produced out of the Old Testament, after the Example of the Moravians. Truly if the Old Testament be rejected, I can see no sufficient Reason, why the New should be received; for the latter is but a Fulfilment of the former, and a Superstructure built upon that Foundation; and if the Foundation is overset, the whole Fabrick is ruined. But to return,
If the Nature of Faith consists in the aforesaid Perswasion, then upon the Supposition that universal Redemption is a false Doctrine, (which I shall afterwards prove) and that it is every Man's Duty to believe; it will follow according to this Scheme, that some are obliged by the Command of God to believe also, that Christ has died for them, when the Case is not so.
If there be such a Thing as Presumption, namely, a believing that our Sins are forgiven, when they are not forgiven, (which I shall afterwards prove) and that this Presumption is sinful, then according to the Moravian Notion of Faith, (which is the same with the Antinomians) God himself has obliged natural Men by his own Precept, to commit Iniquity, which is a monstrous Blasphemy! In short this Antinomian Moravian Faith, looks more like a strong Presumption, [Page 8] than the Faith of God's Elect. In the Parable of the Sower, our Lord informs us, that some Seed fell upon stony Places, and forthwith it sprung up, because it had no Deepness of Earth; and in his Explication thereof, he saith, but he that received the Seed into stony Places, the same is he that heareth the Word, and anon with Joy receiveth it, yet he hath not Root in himself. (Mat. 13.) but the good Ground is said to bring forth Fruit with Patience. Luke 8.15. The poor Man that believ'd in the Gospel, cry'd with Tears, Lord I believe, help my Unbelief. Our Saviour reproved his Disciples sharply for the Weakness of their Faith, for their Slowness to believe, Luk. 24.25. Then he said unto them, O Fools and slow of Heart to believe! True Faith is certainly opposed by our corrupt Nature, and by Satan. Hence we are bid to fight the Fight of Faith, 1 Tim. 6.12. and said to wrestle with Principalities and Powers, Eph. 6.12. True Faith grows from small Beginnings to greater Strength; hence the Faith of the Thessalonians is said to grow exceedingly, 2 Thes. 1.3. What then can we reasonably suppose that Faith to be, which has no humbling Preparatives, no after Conflicts and Troubles, and consists not in a receiving of Christ, or entire resting upon him for Salvation? What is it but a sorry Mushroom of a Night's Growth, unworthy of the Name of Faith.
In the mean Time, I will not pretend to limit Omnipotency; the great Lord of the Universe may in his absolute Sovereignty, possibly in some few Instances vouchsafe his Grace in an extraordinary Manner; but the general Course of his Proceedings, if we believe the Scriptures is agreable to the aforesaid Representation. Possibly some few Persons have a full Assurance at their first Closure with Christ; but that this is not general, is evident from what has been already offered.
If it be urged in Favour of the Moravians, That if the aforesaid Notion of Faith be a Mistake, it is but what many of great Note, among the first Reformers maintain'd.
A. Supposing it were so, it would not alter the Nature of Error, because some good Men were guilty of it. We are to follow the best of Men, no farther than they follow Christ; [Page 9] will it excuse the horrible Crimes of Murder and Adultery, because David was guilty of them?
But the Truth is, I know of none of the Divines properly call'd reformed, who have maintain'd upon the Moravian Plan, that Faith consists in a Perswasion that Christ died for us. If any of them have professed that Assurance was included in the Nature of Faith, yet it ought to be considered that they did not at the same Time hold universal Redemption; which much alters the Case, for when a Person believes that Christ died for every one, it must needs be very easy and natural to believe, that he died for him; for the Latter is necessarily included in the Former: But it is not so easy to believe that Christ died for us upon the Scheme of particular Redemption.
Besides some of the reformed Divines who have given into the aforesaid Notion of Assurance, have distinguish'd it into different Degrees, and thereby signify'd that it was not their Opinion, that all who believed had the highest Degree of Assurance, which seems to be the Moravian Notion.
Not to say that it is more excusable that some in the Dawn of the Reformation, thro' the Heat of Debate with the Papists, (who believe that Assurance is not attainable) should be drawn into another Extream, than that so long after the Light of the Reformation had shone, in its meridian Glory, a new Sect who profess a singular Sanctity should embrace the aforesaid pernicious Error; which tends so much to distress many of the poor Saints of God, without just Cause, who ought to be comforted, and so to embarress their Way to their Father's Kingdom.
If it be again objected, That to say that Assurance is not included in the Nature of Faith, or necessarily annexed to it, is to encourage Presumers.
A. No, by no Means! For tho' a Person may have true Faith, and not know that he hath it, yet he must needs know the Actings of his own Soul. Ordinarily he can remember that he has been made sensible of his total Want of Faith, John 16.8, 9. his Inability to believe, as well as the Opposition made against his Faith; his affecting Apprehension of Christ's All-sufficiency and Willin [...]ness to save; and [Page 10] his Dependance upon Christ's Righteousness alone for Acceptance, under a Sense of the Insufficiency of his own. He must also be sensible of some Change wrought upon his Will, Affections, and Practice; tho' he may question whether they be of a saving Kind.
Now if a Person imagines that he hath Faith, and has not found the aforesaid Experiences, he deceiveth himself. Such Persons as do rest securely upon this Ground, viz. That Persons may have Faith and not know it, and neither press after Assurance, nor bewail the Want of it, and are Strangers to the Experience of a Work of the Law and Gospel upon their Hearts, are miserable Hypocrites!
I think that the Command of God to examine ourselves, and make our Calling and Election sure, plainly supposes the Uncertainty of our Knowledge about them, before the Use of these Means.
My dear Brethren! Let us hold fast this precious Truth, against all Opposition whatsoever.
3. Ye have heard, that FAITH is the MEANS of JUSTIFICATION, and of absolute NECESSITY to eternal Salvation. These Things, the Scriptures of Truth fully assert, Rom. 3.28. Therefore we conclude that a Man is justified by Faith without the Deeds of the Law; and Mark 16.16. He that believeth shall be saved, but he that believeth not shall be damned. Let us hold fast these important Truths, my dear Brethren! against the perilous and pernicious Doctrines of the Antinomians and Moravians, namely, That those who are justify'd, are justify'd from Eternity in the Sight of God, and actually from the Time of Christ's Death, and that Faith is not necessary to Salvation.
Now because that eternal Justification, is the proton pseudos, the first and fertile Falshood of all the Antinomian Abominations, the fatal Fountain from which those poisonous Streams do flow, which dishonour the Religion of Christ, contradict its grand Design (which is Holiness,) and sap its very Foundations; I think it needful to offer a few Considerations, to overset this Monster of Impiety. And here let me observe, that the Doctrine of eternal Justification, contradicts the holy [Page 11] Scriptures, which inform us that we are justify'd by Faith. Rom. 3.28.
Now if we are justify'd from Eternity, we are justify'd before Faith, (for Faith is wrought in the Elect in Time, Eph. 1.13.) and then must not those Scriptures, according to this Plan be false, which assert our Justification by Faith? For is it possible fairly to reconcile a Justification from Eternity, and a Justification in Time together, a Justification before Faith, and after Faith together? I see not how it can be done, until Time and Eternity, before and after, be proved the same.
The sacred Scriptures inform us, that all the Elect as well as others, are by Nature Children of Wrath, under the Curse of the Law, under the Condemnation of the Gospel, and guilty before God, Eph. 2.1. Gal. 3.10. John 3.18, 36. Rom. 3.19. Now to say that those were justified from Eternity, is to assert the greatest and most irreconcilable Contradictions: it is in Effect to say, that the Elect are freed entirely from the Guilt of Sin, but are notwithstanding under the full Weight of it; that they are cursed and blessed at the same Time; under Wrath, and Heirs of the Promise; Children of God and of the Devil at the same Instant; condemned and justified at once. Now can any living Man reconcile those contradictory Propositions, without overthrowing the Nature of Things, and blending Light with Darkness? Supposing this impossible Chimera to be true, viz. That a Man should be in the aforesaid contrary States at one Time, and bro't to the Confines of the Grave, where must his Soul go at its Exit? not to Heaven, for he is under the Curse of the Law, the Condemnation of the Gospel; not to Hell! for he is freed from the Guilt of Sin, and has a Title to eternal Glory; where must it go then, but to the feign'd Purgatory of the Papists? Do not therefore wonder, that some of the Moravians, and Long-Beards, who are their Brethren (in Respect of their Spirit and main Principles) should stumble into the ridiculous Notion of turning Hell it self into a Purgatory, by believing that the Torments of the Damned there, are but for a certain Space of Time: However this Notion is so gross and scandalous, that some of the Moravians are ashamed to own it.
[Page 12]This Fancy of turning Hell into a Purgatory, is worse than the Notion of the Papists, because they believe the Eternity of Hell Torments as to some. — It oversets one of the principal Barriers against Vice and Incentives to Religion and Vertue, it tends to disband the World, and open the Flood-Gates to all Immorality and Anarchy.
It is vain for the Patrons of the aforesaid perilous Figment, to urge in Defence thereof, this Plea, that the original Word for Eternity, signifies but an Age, or some Ages, for the same Word is apply'd to God and to the Happiness of the Blessed, and therefore they may from hence as justly argue, that the Happiness of the Blessed, yea that the Being of God himself, shall last but for a few Ages, which is damnable Blasphemy! In the 25th Chapter of Matthew and last Verse, the Happiness of the Saved, and the Miseries of the Damned are set in a direct Antithesis or Opposition, and the same original Word is apply'd to both; therefore they may as well conclude, that the Former will be temporary as the Latter.
It is notoriously derogatory to the Satisfaction of Christ, and to the infinite Justice of God provoked by Sin, to imagine that Creatures can make Atonement for it, and so pay the utmost F [...]thing. The Damned being covered with Wrath, and unable either to bear the Load, or escape from under it, will be filled with Rage and Blasphemy against God, and so will increase their Guilt instead of atoning for it. But to return from this Digression.
The sacred Scriptures represent Justification, as an Act, or Sentence passed in Time coming, therefore it cannot be from Eternity; see Gal. 3.8. The Scriptures foreseeing that God would justify the Heathen thro' Faith, preached before the Gospel unto Abraham. See, Faith must be preached before the Heathens Justification, how then could they be justified from Eternity, was Faith preached from Eternity? Gal. 2.16. Even we have believed in Jesus Christ, that we might be justified by the Faith of Christ. Rom. 4.23, 24. Now it was not written for his sake alone, that it was imputed to him, but for us also, to whom it shall be imputed, if we believe in him. Isa. 53.11. By his Knowledge shall my righteous Servant justify many. Isa. 45.2, 5. In the Lord all the Seed of [Page 13] Israel shall be justified. Rom. 3.30. Seeing it is one God, who shall justify the Circumcision by Faith, and the Uncircumcision thro' Faith. The Order in which our Justification is plac'd, is set in a strong Light, Rom. 8.33. Moreover, whom he did predestinate, them he also called, and whom he called, them he also justified, and whom he justified, them he also glorified. Excellent Mr. Flavel observes, ‘That it is absurd to place Vocation before Predestination, or Glorification before Justification; sure then (says he) it must be absurd also, to place Justification before Vocation; the one as well as the other, confounds and breaks the Scripture Order; you may as well say Men shall be glorified that were never justified, as say they may be justified before they believed or existed.’
How irrational and unaccountable it is, to believe that any should be justified from Eternity, will appear, if we consider a little the Nature of Justification; which is an actual freeing of Persons from the Guilt of Sin, and giving them a Right to Salvation.
Now how can any be freed from the Guilt of Sin from Eternity, unless we suppose them actually guilty of Sin from Eternity. But how can Creatures act, before they are, or exist? Every Creature is the Birth of Time, before he is conceiv'd in Time, he is subject to no Law; and where there is no Law, there is no Transgression actual, and where there is no Transgression either actual or virtual, there can be no Guilt; for that is an Obligation to endure Punishment for Sin, thro' the Force and Virtue of the Threatnings annexed to the Breach of the Law; and where there is neither Guilt, nor Sin, nor Punishment, there can be no Justification, which is a Freedom therefrom.
To say that the Elect are justify'd from Eternity, is in Effect to say, that nothing sinn'd from all Eternity, and that nothing was justify'd, which is absurd! for the Elect before they exist are nothing in Respect of actual Sin.
If it be objected, that what has been said will oppose the D [...]rees of God. I answer no, by no Means! for the Decree considers future Beings and future Actions, Eph. 1.4. But Justification respects Persons present or existing, and [Page 14] Actions past. It is a real or actual Change of the State, and respects a Sinner as actually ungodly, Rom. 4.5. But can that which is not, be really and actually changed? Can a Person be ungodly before he is at all in Being? Besides I see not how this Difficulty can be removed that lies in the Way of eternal Justification, viz. It will suppose that the Sin of Mankind, and their Justification from it, bore an equal Date; both being eternal, for in Eternity there is no before or after. Now this is impossible in the Nature of Things, that actual Freedom from Sin, should be parrallel in Duration with Sin itself, for the latter in the Order of Nature and Time goes before the former.
It is very shocking to consider, what Dishonour this Doctrine of eternal Justification, reflects upon our Lord Jesus Christ, and how it saps the very Foundations of his Gospel.
It is a Branch of the Redeemer's Glory, that he has satisfied divine Justice for his People's Sins, and paid their Debts by his Blood and Obedience. Gal. 3.13, 14. 2 Cor. 5.18—21. Phil. 2.8. But according to the Plan of eternal Justification, there was no Sin to be satisfied for, no Debt to pay; for can it be supposed, that a Creature can sin before Eternity, or that after he is justified from Sin, he is notwithstanding in Debt by it to divine Justice? this would be a Justification, and no Justification! Well, if there be no Debt to pay, Christ's Satisfaction is destroyed; for it is hereby rendered needless and useless. And thus you see a Foundation Truth, namely the Satisfaction of Christ destroyed, by this Antinomian Moravian Doctrine of eternal Justification! Luther justly observed respecting Justification, That it was the Article of a standing or falling Church; now when it is judged to be eternal, it is made null and void as has been observed.
If the Elect are justified from Eternity, then how can our Lord be said to be their Saviour? seeing that according to this Scheme, they were never liable to Destruction. If it be said, that the Elect were not justified till the Time of Christ's Death, then what became of those that died before it? Could those be saved who were not justified? How unjustifiable and uncharitable must it be, to condemn to the [Page 15] Flames in Effect, all those that died before the Coming of our Saviour?
The Doctrine of eternal Justification renders Faith unnecessary, (in an absolute Sense) for according to that, the Elect are justified before it. And by the same Argument it strikes down the Foundations of Repentance, it represents Sin as a meer Trifle, not worthy of our Fear or Sorrow, by signifiing that God is at Peace with those that are under its Dominion! it takes away all Arguments of Terror, by which a secure World should be alarmed, and opens deadly Avenues to all Manner of Licenciousness; and thus it tears up by the Roots all natural and reveal'd Religion!
If it be objected that Christ was a publick Person, and therefore that what he did and suffered, is to be looked upon as done and suffered by those he represented.
A. As none are guilty of Adam's Sin, tho' he was a publick Head of the Covenant of Works, till united to him by a Participation of the same Nature with him, so none are justified by the Righteousness of Christ the second Adam, until by Faith they receive it, and are thereby united to him.
It will not avail to say, that because God's Nature and Love are unchangeable, that therefore the Elect were justified from Eternity. A. It will not follow, tho' God is not changeable, we are, and there is a manifest Difference between God's Purposes and the Execution of them; the aforesaid Reasoning would conclude the World and all the Creatures in it to be made from Eternity, because there was a Purpose concerning their Production from Eternity. But this is false, therefore the other is so, which is built upon the same Plan of Reasoning. As to what the Scriptures say concerning the everlasting Love of God to his Elect, I think that usual Distinction which is observed by sound Divines, helps to remove the Difficulty, viz. That there is a Love of Benevolence, and Complacence, the former signifies the gracious Purpose of God towards his Elect, and the latter the Delight he takes in them when converted, Cant. 2.14. it is only in the former Sense the Lord is said to love his Elect before their Conversion. Besides it cannot be truly said of God that there is any proper Passion in him. If any by the everlasting [Page 16] Love of God to his Elect, imagine that the Guilt of Sin is removed from them actually, before they exist or believe, which is the Point in Question, they expresly contradict both Scripture and Reason. Joh. 3.18. Reason teaches that (non entis nulla sunt accidentia) that which is not, cannot be either justified or condemned; where there is no Guilt it cannot be removed.
Not to add that to set forth God's Love, as in every Respect the same to those who are under the Dominion of Sin, and to those who are freed from it; is to cross the Current of Scripture, which represents the blessed God as angry with Sinners, and pleased with his sincere Servants thro' his Son. It also tends to make us look upon Sin as a very Trifle, which we need not be much concerned about any Way.
Behold my dear Brethren! what a dismal Foundation is here laid for all Manner of Impiety, and that under the specious Umb [...]age of Gospel Knowledge and Sanctity! These Passages of Scripture, viz. where Christ is said to be the Lamb slain from the Foundation of the World; and that God was reconciling the World to himself, not imputing their Trespasses to them, 2 Cor. 5.19. and that Christ has made Peace thro' the Blood of his Cross, Col. 1.20. and Rom. 5.9, 10. and that the Grace of God in Christ was given us before the World began; can consistently with the Current of Scripture, the Analogy of Faith, and Dictates of right Reason, be supposed to mean no more than these Things following, namely, (1) That there was a gracious Purpose in God from Eternity, to vouchsafe Blessings on his People in Time. (2) That there was a sufficient Foundation laid by the Sufferings and Obedience of Christ, for the actual Reconciliation of the Elect to God in Time. (3) That there was and is a Sufficiency of Grace treasured up in Christ as Mediator, Head of his Church, and Fountain of Influence, to be communicated to the Elect upon their Closure with him. Which in some Places of Scripture is represented by the Time past, to shew the Certainty of the Event. For the same Reason the Coming of our Lord to Judgment is represented as present tho' it be future. Rev. 1.7.
[Page 17]If this Distinction be offered to paliate the Antinomian Doctrine, which I am opposing, namely that the Elect are justified from Eternity as considered in Christ, but not as considered in themselves: I answer, that it is impossible to reconcile two contradictory Propositions, or to blend Light and Darkness together: the plain English of the aforesaid Distinction is just this, that the Elect in different Respects, are in contrary States at one Time, at once they are both justified and condemned, this is in the Nature of Things impossible; for if they are justified they can't at the same Time be condemned, because Justification is a Freedom from it: we may say with as great Reason that the Elect (as considered in the Decree) were effectually called, sanctified, and saved from Eternity actually, which is false and absurd, or that we our selves in the aforesaid Respect, existed and acted from all Eternity, which you know is ridiculous!
If it be again objected, That Things to come are present with God, that one Day is with the Lord as a thousand Years— therefore the Elect are justified from Eternity, in the Sight of God: I deny the Consequence, for by this Way of Reasoning the World would have been actually made from Eternity, in the Sight of God; which is false. Jehovah who is all Eye, looks not on Things in a false Light. If it be reply'd, that the Elect had a Representative from all Eternity, but the World had none, and therefore that the Case is different; to answer this I offer these two Things, (1.) That according to the Antinomian Moravian Scheme of eternal Justification, there was no need of a Representative at all, there being nothing to pay. And (2.) As to the World, it had all the Representative it was capable of, and there was any Necessity for, namely the Decree of God, that Pattern in the Mount, according to which, this spacious and magnificent Structure was exactly form'd.
Again may we not say, that Things past are present with God, as well as Things to come. And hence may we not argue after the aforesaid Manner thus, viz. That the World is still a creating in the Sight of God, that the Flood now covers it, that the Cities of the Plain, viz. Sodom and Gomorrah, &c. are now a Fire, that Israel is passing thro' the Red [Page 18] Sea, fighting with Og King of Bashan, and Sihon King of Heshbon. What mad Work would it be to form our Prayers according to this Scheme, namely, to pray for the Protection of Adam in the Garden, of Noah in the Flood, of Lot in Sodom, and of Israel among their Enemies? May we not conceive of a Debt's being fully paid by a Surety, and yet such a Plan laid previous to it, that the Debtor shall have no actual Interest therein, or actual Benefit thereby, until he be enabled to come up to such honourable Terms, as shall express his Sense of the Benefit, and Gratitude to his Benefactor.
4. Ye have heard, that unconverted Persons are under the LAW, and that the LAW is a Rule of Life to Believers. And does not the Scripture say so? Rom. 3.19. Whatsoever the Law says, it says to those that are under the Law, that every Mouth might be stopped, and the whole World become guilty before God. Here observe, that some, yea that all are, while in a State of Nature, under the Law, and guilty before God. Take Notice that the Apostle spake these Words to the Roman Gentiles, who enjoyed the Gospel Dispensation; and does not the same Apostle tell the Galatians, Gal. 3.10. That every one is cursed, that continueth not in all Things that are written in the Book of the Law to do them. But why should the Apostle speak of the Law at all to the Galatian Gentiles, if it belong'd to none but the Jews, as the Moravians dream?
Does not the Apostle pronounce Peace upon those, who walk according to this Rule, and has not our Saviour assured us, that he came not to destroy the Law, but to fulfil it? Let us hold fast this precious Truth, my dear Brethren! against the dangerous and detestable Doctrines of the Moravians, one of whom asserted in New-Brunswick, that the unconverted Gentiles were not under the Law, and that the Law was not a Rule of Life to Believers. O my dear Brethren, do not these Notions tend to dreadful Security, and Licenciousness? for if there be no Law, there is no Transgression. According to this Notion the vilest Wickedness would be no Sin, and so there would be no Cause of Sorrow for it. Seeing the moral Law is grounded upon the unalterable Natures, Relations, and Reason of Things, and consequently invariably [Page 19] holy, just, and good; the Transcript of the moral Excellencies of the divine Nature; and thus the very Standard and Scale of Goodness, which is but a Conformity to the supream Being. It cannot therefore be changed. It must then be exceeding dishonourable to the most high Jehovah, and wounding to the true Interests of his Kingdom, to speak diminitively of his blessed Law! This, this, oversets the very Foundations of Religion, and rends in Pieces all the Barriers between Virtue and Vice, this leaves us without a Rule of Action, and so exposes us as an easy Prey to the Wiles of enthusiastical Delusion. And how can it with Reason be supposed, that natural Men should be freed from the Law, as a Covenant of Works, which they have broken, until they be made sensible hereof, and comply with the Terms of the new Covenant? Can a Person have any Interest in the Benefits of a conditional Contract, until he complys with the Terms or Condition, upon which a Right to the Benefits is suspended? Although there be no proper Conditions in the Covenant of Grace, yet there are Terms, or Conditions improperly so called, which have a suspending Virtue thus far, viz. that we have no Right to the Blessings of the new Covenant, till we are enabled to comply with them. Until Faith be formed in us, we are under Condemnation: it is true we have no Power to believe of our selves, neither is there any Merit in any Act of ours, to deserve a Blessing: But God who is absolute Sovereign of the World, and Lord of his own Treasures, has been pleased to constitute this Method, for the Conveyance of his Benefits; which reflects Honour upon his Wisdom. This represents the State of Sinners in such a Dress of Terror, as has a Tendency to affect and alarm them, and so prepare them for the dear Redeemer. This opens the Aggravations of Sin, and in a Glass presents to our View its malignant Nature and crimson Aggravations, in a strong and affecting Light; which nobly tends to raise our Indignation against it: And this points to an unerring Director of our Way, which is worthy of our Esteem and Reverence, and most conscientious Observance!
If any should object, That some Passages of Paul's Epistles seem to speak slightly of the Law, it ought to be considered, [Page 20] that some in his Day, as well as in other Ages, depended upon the Works of the Law for Justification, Rom. 10.2, 3. and some laboured to introduce the Observation of the ceremonial Law. These Things the Apostle opposes: in the Passages refer'd to, he speaks not of the moral Law, absolutely and in it self considered, but respectively as pointing to the aforesaid Abuse of it, which some were guilty of. If the Apostle had spoke slightily of the mor [...] Law considered absolutely, he would have contradicted himself, for elsewhere he gives it high and honourable Epithets and Encomiums, by calling it holy, just and good.
Neither does he speak slightily of the Ceremonial considered in it self, as introductory to a brighter Dispensation of the Gospel, for in that Respect it was worthy of Esteem; but comparatively, as being obscure and inferiour, when compared with the more spiritual and more clear Dispensation of the Gospel since the Coming of our Lord, and as unnecessary to be observed, after the Advent of the Antitype.
If any do farther object, in Favour of the Antinomians and Moravians, that Luther the famous Reformer in Germany, was of their Opinion respecting the Law, as appears by many diminitive Expressions of his in Relation to it, in his Explication of the Epistle to the Galatians, and elsewhere.
A. No, by no Means! Luther was far from being an Antinomian, he has wrote expresly and pungently against their pestilent Notions. If it would not swell this Essay to too great a Bulk, I would transcribe a Letter of his against them, in which he stings them with a poignant Style and brands them with the most contemptible Epithets. He expresly says, that they were one of the Blasts, which the Devil had blown at him. He did by his Reasoning put to Silence one of the Heads of that Party, who kept still during Luther's Life; but afterwards blaz'd abroad his own Shame. Where Luther speaks severely of the Law, it is only in Respect of the following Abuse of it, namely, when Believers under Temptation and inward Distress, apply it to their Terror and Condemnation. For elsewhere he speaks honourably of it, asserts its Necessity, and describes its Use, in preparing Persons for Christ, and in directing Believers. If any desire more [Page 21] full Satisfaction about this, let them read that excellent Book of famous Rutherford, entitled, A Survey of Antinomianism; where he has largely vindicated Luther from the Aspersions of the Antinomians. It ought also to be considered that Luther was a Man of strong Passions, and therefore whatever he express'd, he set in a strong Light.
5. Ye have heard much of the Danger of PRESUMPTION, and our Inclination to it naturally. This is agreable to the Word of God. Solomon observes, that There is a Way which seemeth right unto a Man, but the End thereof is the Way of Death. Prov. 14.12. and 16.25; and elsewhere he saith, There is that maketh himself rich, and yet is poor. The Prophet Jeremiah observes, That the Heart of Man is deceitful, and desperately wicked, who can know it? Jer. 17.9. What our Lord charges upon the Church of Laodicea, may be apply'd to the natural Disposition of all Mankind; all are inclin'd by Nature to think themselves rich, and encreased with Goods, while in the mean Time they are poor, and miserable, and blind, and naked. Rev. 3.17. If we were not inclined naturally to deceive our selves, what Need would there be of so many Commands in Scripture, To examine our selves, whether we be in the Faith; and that we be careful, that we don't deceive ourselves: And what Need of such a Description of the uncomfortable and dangerous State of the Deceived, as is mentioned, Isa. 44.20. He feedeth upon Ashes, a deceived Heart hath turned him aside, that he cannot deliver his Soul, nor say is there not a Lie in my right Hand?
Does not the Ignorance of God, and our selves, which is natural to us, as well as our native Arrogance, and immoderate Self-Love, dispose us to think better of our selves, and our State towards God, than we have Reason? And if we think our State is good, when it is bad, are we like to be distressed about its Danger, and use earnest Labour for Deliverance? No surely! Danger unperceived how great soever it be, will not excite to any valuable Purpose, our Fear, Sorrow, or Labour. And may the Unconverted expect Mercy from God, without the Use of those appointed Means? No surely! those that would obtain the heavenly Inheritance, must strive to enter in at the strait Gate. Let us therefore [Page 22] hold fast this precious Truth, my dear Brethren! against the corrupt Doctrine of the Moravians, one of whom asserted in New-Brunswick, that there was no such Thing as spiritual Presumption. Dear B [...]hren! how horrible is this Position, and damning to the Souls of Men! can any Thing be invented of worse Tendency, to delude the World!
6. Ye have heard that Redemption is PARTICULAR, or that Christ has not died for every Child of Adam (Head for Head) but only for a certain Number. And thus speaks the Scripture. Jesus tells us that he laid down his Life for his Sheep, (in Contradistinction to the Goats) Joh. 10.14, 15. I am the good Shepherd, and know my Sheep, and am known of mine. — And I lay down my Life for my Sheep. By the Term Sheep, it appears by the 14th Verse, we are to understand the Elect, because they know Christ, and are known of him. This farther appears from these following Scriptures, Joh. 10.26, 27, 28. Ye believe not because ye are not of my Sheep, as I said unto you; my Sheep hear my Voice, and I know them, and they follow me, and I give unto them eternal Life, and they shall never perish. Our Lord in those Verses informs us, that the Reason why some believ'd not on him; was because they were not his Sheep: That is, were not eternally elected. He also farther informs us, t [...] all his Sheep are converted in Time, and saved after [...] so that Conversion and Salvation extends, as far as the Death of Christ.
Our Lord also assures us, that he prays not for the World, Joh. 17.6, 9. I have manifested thy Name to the Men thou gavest me out of the World, thine they were, and thou gavest them me: I pray for them, I pray not for the World, but for them which thou hast given me, for they are thine. Can you think that Jesus would lay down his Life, his Blood, for those he would not spend his Breath in Prayer for? Did not our dear Redeemer thank his Father, that he hid these Things, (meaning the special Knowledge of the Things that concern Salvation) from the Wise and Prudent, and reveal'd them to Babes, and that because it so seemed good in his Sight. Math. 11.25, 26.
[Page 23]Altho' the Ransom that our Lord paid, by his Death and Obedience, was, consider'd in it self, sufficient in Value, to have redeem'd the whole World; yet its Efficacy depended upon the Father's Destination, and the Redeemer's Intention. He died (as I have observed) for his Sheep, the Goats being excluded, Math. 25.32.— He died for his People, Tit. 2.14. Mat. 1.21. For his Church, Act. 20.28. Eph. 5.25. For his Children, Heb. 2.3, 14, 15. For his Seed, Isai. 53.10. For those the Father gave him to be redeemed, Joh. 17.2.9. Joh. 6.65. Joh. 17.24. Father, I will that they also, whom thou hast given me be with me, where I am, that they may behold my Glory. Now we are told, that him the Father always heareth; if so, then Christ has died only for those that are sav'd.
To suppose that Christ died for every Man (Head for Head) is attended with many Absurdities, particularly with these following.
According to the universal Scheme, our Lord must have died for those that were actually damned before his Death, which is ridiculous!
And seeing these Universalists, whether Jesuits, Socinians, Remonstrants, Moravians, and all the Tribe of Enthusiasts, who sincerely hate the Doctrine of particular Redemption; I say, seeing they own that the greater Part of Mankind will be damned at last according to the Scriptures, which inform us, that strait is the Gate and narrow the Way, which leads to Life, and few there be that find it; that Christ's Flock is a little, little Flock, a few Jewels, a Remnant, a few Berries, upon the uppermost Bows, (comparatively considered) I say, seeing they own these Things, they are unavoidably led to this Dilemma, namely, either to invalidate the Sufficiency of Christ's Satisfaction, or to charge God the Father with Injustice, in requiring a double Satisfaction for the same Offences; once by Christ on the Cross, as their Surety and Representative, and again of their own Persons in Hell. I see not how it is possible, for any Universalist fairly to remove this Difficulty. Besides, it appears to me, that Free-will is necessarily implied in the Doctrine of universal Redemption; without this it cannot be held consistently, as may appear thus;
[Page 24]If the Application of this supposed universal Redemption, be made only to some, and that not of Works done by the Creature, but by Way of absolute Sovereignty and pure Grace, as the Calvinists maintain according to the Scriptures; For it is not of him that willeth, nor of him that runneth, but of God that sheweth Mercy; Then to what Purpose does the Doctrine of universal Redemption signify, but to amuse; for it turns to the same Issue, with particular Redemption upon this Plan; and allows no greater Priviledge to Mankind in the least Degree, only it's not consistent with itself, for it is a Redemption and no Redemption. If Redemption be supposed to extend farther than Election, and be of any avail to Mankind, then the turning Point must be the Free-will of the Creature, and not the Will or Grace of God. This the Jesuits and Arminians are sensible of, and therefore maintain the Doctrine of Free-will, tho' falsely yet consistently with their Scheme. Yet they try to cloak their foul Opinion with fair Language. For my own Part, I can't but suspect the Moravians or some of them at least, to be guilty here, viz. of holding the Doctrine of Free-will, tho' they do disclaim it in Word, because the Doctrine of universal Redemption leads so directly to it.
But in what strong Terms does the Word of God disclaim all Pretence to a Free-will in Man, by assuring us that we are while in a State of Nature, dead in Trespasses and Sins, Eph. 2.1. That we can neither do, nor will, nor think Good, as of our selves, Phil. 2.13. 2 Cor. 3.5. That none can come to Christ, except the Father draws them, Joh. 6.44. That God hath Mercy upon whom he will have Mercy. So then it is not of him that willeth, nor of him that runneth, but of God that sheweth Mercy. Rom. 9.15, 16.
If Christ died for the whole human Race Head for Head, it may be asked, whether God the Father and our Lord Redeemer intended, they should be all saved yea or not? If he did not intend it, then to what Purpose is the Death of Christ, to all those who were not designed for Salvation? does not this look like Mockery and Illusion. But if it be supposed, that God did intend the Salvation of all the human Race by the Redeemer's Death; altho' but a few of them [Page 25] attain the same; then will it not follow, that something like either Ignorance, Weakness, and Changeableness, must be charged upon the Almighty.
If he intended the Salvation of all by the Redeemer's Death, and knew not in the mean Time, that the most would not attain it; then is not the Knowledge of the Almighty finite and imperfect. Now the Knowledge of God is not like the Knowledge of Creatures, namely, something distinct from the Faculty receiving, but his very Being, (for he is as the Schoolmen say justly, simplex actus, a simple Act) then is his Being finite and imperfect, and so by Consequence he is no God.
But if God knew, when he is supposed to have designed the Salvation of all, that the most would never attain it, would not this be a great Weakness and Vanity, to intend a Thing which he knew would never come to pass?
If the Lord intended the Salvation of all, must it not argue great Impotency, and Dependance on Creatures, to fail of compassing his Designs? Must not Jehovah upon this Plan, be almost as unhappy as any of his Creatures, because of a continual Succession of Disappointments? And does it not suppose a Change in his Being, when he is supposed to will the Salvation of a Creature at one Time, and it's Damnation at another. For is not his Will himself or his Being? If the Almighty were compounded of different Things, as Creatures are, some Agent must exist before him, to make the Composition, and there might be a Dissolution of it into it's constituent Parts. Now both these apply'd to the Deity are blasphemous.
But does not the Scripture represent him, to be far from the Shadow of Change? And don't Reason teach us, that if he changes he must change for the better or worse, or into an equal State to what he was before; but either Way he must be supposed imperfect, before or after the Change; and so no God: For the Idea of a God essentially includes in it, the highest Perfection.
How can it be, that Christ should die for all, seeing the inseperable Consequences and Benefits of his Death do not belong to all? our Adversaries themselves being Judges. [Page 26] The Benefits I mean are such as the Freedom from Condemnation, Rom. 8.34. Reconciliation to God, Rom. 5.10. Effectual Calling, Ephes. 1.13. Remission of Sins, Mat. 26.28. Sanctification, Joh. 17.19. The Love of God, Joh. 15.13.
If it be objected, that in many Places of Scripture our Lord is said to die for all. It may be replied,
(1) That our Lord is said in no Place to die for all, and singular, which is the only Thing in Question.
(2) This Note of Universality, all, frequently in Scripture, excludes Distinction, but not Exception. See Rom. 10.11, 12. Gal. 3.26, 27, 28. Rom. 11.32. He concluded all under Unbelief, that he might have Mercy upon all. Here the Word all seems only to remove the Difference between Jews and Gentiles, Ephes. 2.14, 15, 16. Rom. 3.29. and alludes to the Promise made of old to Abraham, viz. that in him all the Families of the Earth should be blessed, Gen. 22.18. Whence he is called the Heir of the World, Rom. 4.13. Which is notwithstanding expresly restrain'd, Gen. 21.12. Rom. 9.6, 7.
May the GOD of Truth succeed with his Blessing, what has been offer'd. I add no more at present.
[Page 27]
SERMON, II.
REV. III. 3. Remember therefore how thou hast heard, and received, and hold fast.—
MY dear Brethren! You may remember, that in treating upon this Subject, I proposed the following Method, namely, 1. To shew what Truths we should more particularly remember and hold fast. 2. Shew what is supposed by and implied in our remembering them and holding of them fast. 3. Offer the Reasons Why we should remember them and hold them fast. And then improve the whole.
In Pursuance of the Method aforesaid, I had gone no farther in the preceeding Sermon, than the first Head of Discourse; in treating upon which, the last Truth which I mentioned, was that of particular Redemption. The last Objection against the aforesaid Truth then observed, was that in many Places of Scripture Christ is said to die for all. In Answer to this Objection, two Particulars were then offered, which I shall not now resun [...]; but shall proceed to observe,
(3.) That the Word all does not constantly signify the Singulars of every Kind b [...] only the Kinds of Singulars. Rev. 5.9. Rom. 14.2. Mat. 4.23. and 12.31.
(4.) Sometimes the Word all, signifies only a considerable Number: Thus all Creatures are said to go into the Ark to Noah; whereas it was only some of every Kind: Again [Page 28] we are told that all Men followed Christ, whereas it was only some in Judea. We also read of all the World's being taxed in our Saviour's Time, whereas it was only the Roman Empire: Yea the Phrase every Man, is not taken in a universal Sense always. See 1 Cor. 4.5. there it is said, that at the Coming of our Lord, then shall every Man have Praise of God; whereas it only intends every good Man.
If it be further objected, that Christ is frequently said to have died for the World, Joh. 1.29. and for the whole World, 1 Joh. 2.2.
The second Answer to the preceeding Objection may with some Alteration be easily applied here, [...]iz. that by the World we are to understand whatever is contradistinguish'd from the Jewish Church, namely the Gentiles. Rom. 4.13. For the Promise, that he should be the Heir of the World. Rom. 11.12. Now if the Fall of them be the Riches of the World, and the diminishing of them the Riches of the Gentiles, how much more their Fulness? So that the Sense of the Places objected, is that Christ did not only die for the Jews, but for the Gentiles. And indeed this Doctrine of the Partition Wall's being broken down, was somewhat difficult for the Jewish Church to receive at first, as appears by Peter's Vision and Defence, before the Brethren at Jerusalem.
Some do object▪ that Place of Scripture, Heb. 10.29. that there Christ is said to die for them, that trampled under Foot the Blood of the Covenant, whereby they were sanctified, and called it an unholy Thing.
Ans. The Thing it self speaks, how ca [...] one be sanctified really, and yet trample under Foot the Blood of the Covenant, and so commit the unpardonable Sin? Surely he that is born of God cannot sin in this wise, 1 Joh. 5.18. But by the Blood of the Covenant by which he was sanctified, the Apostle intends the Son of God; he himself being Interpreter, Heb. 2.10, 11.
Some do object the following Places of Scripture, viz. that Christ is said to die for them that perish. 1 Cor. 8. Rom. 14.15.20.
Ans. The Apostle, as appears by the Context, in those Places referred to, adviseth to avoid the Use of indifferent [Page 29] Things, such as Meat [...] and Drinks, least that our Brother should be offended and sin, and so if possible perish. Mat. 24.24. or least that our Brother (for whom in a Judgment of Charity Christ died) should sin, and perish.
Some object the following Place of Scripture, 2 Pet. 2.1. where Christ is said to die for false Prophets, that denied him.
Ans. Some apply this to God the Father, because that the Word despotes, which is translated Lord, is never apply'd to our Saviour, but to God the Father, Luk. 2.29. Jude 4. It is farther observed, that the Word agoradzein signifies not here to acquire by the Price of Blood, but to acquire simply, Isai. 55.1. So that the Sense of the Place i [...] that God Almighty brought the false Prophets by the prea [...] of the Word, to the external Communion of the Church, in which they acknowledged God to be their Lord, and Governour. Others apply this Place to Christ, and offer this Gloss upon it, viz. that Christ may be said in some Sense to buy even those that perish; in as much as they enjoy the Forbearance of God, and many other temporal and spiritual Benefits by the Death of Christ; by an earnest Endeavour to improve which, they may have much Comfort in this World, much Sin may be prevented here, and their Miseries lessened in the next Life. Others put this Sense upon the Place, that some did deny the Lord Christ, for whom in a Judgment of Charity he died.
Dr. Whitby charges the following Absurdity upon particular Redemption, viz. that it is inconsistent with the Command to believe to the saving of the Soul.
Ans. This Objection is grounded upon a false Notion of Faith, as tho' it consisted in a Belief, that Christ died for us in particular, which has before been confuted. All to whom the Gospel comes, are obliged to believe in Christ, that is, to receive him by a living Faith, Joh. 1.12. and this being done, and not before, they are obliged hence, to conclude that Christ died for them. Some there be who imagine, that the Doctrine of particular Redemption, is inconsistent with preaching the Gospel; which is called a Door of Hope, a Day of Grace; and that it is a meer mocking of Sinners to offer Salvation to them upon this Plan. I will [Page 30] beg Leave to offer the Sum of Dr. Ridgeley's Answer, "Here let it be considered, (saith he) by a Day of Grace,
1. That we don't hereby intend, such a Dispensation in which all Men might repent and believe, and so obtain Salvation by their own Power; this would be to ascribe to Man, what is peculiar to God. Nor that God will give special Grace to all that sit under the Gospel. As for the Hope of the Gospel, we cannot understand any Thing else thereby, but that all without Distinction are commanded and encouraged to wait on God, in his instituted Means of Grace, with a Peradventure that he will be gracious; this being the ordinary Way in which he works Grace. And if there be any Conviction of Sin, this gives farther Ground of Hope.
2. As to preaching of the Gospel, the Doctrine of particular Redemption, hinders not Christ's being offered to the Chief of Sinners: and the Proclamation of Grace being made publick, to all without Distinction. This will appear if we consider what is done, when Christ is offered to Sinners, here let it be observed.
1. That God has given us no Warrant to enter into his secret Determinations, respecting the Event of Things: or to give any Person Ground to conclude, that they are redeemed, and have a Warrant to apply to themselves the Promise of Salvation, while in an unconverted Estate.
2. When Christ is said to be offered to Sinners, in the Preaching of the Gospel, that which is intended thereby is his being set forth therein, as a most desirable Object, and that he will certainly save all whom he effectually calls, inasmuch as he has purchased Salvation for them.
3. It includes in it an informing of Sinners, that it is their indispensible Duty and Interest to believe in Christ; and in Order thereto, that they are commanded and encouraged to wait on him, for that Grace which can enable them thereunto. And as a farther Encouragement to let them know, that there is a certain Connection between Grace and Salvation: So that none who are enabled to come to Christ by Faith, shall be rejected. This is the Preaching and Hope of the Gospel, which is not in the [Page 31] least inconsistent with particular Redemption.
Thus far he.
As to that Method of preaching the Gospel, which some modern Enthusiasts are guilty of; namely using Means to cure and comfort, by speaking much of Christ's Sufferings, and his Love, before they try to convince of Sin, and Danger by the Law; it serves only to amuse the Ignorant and Inconsiderate, and to prevent their Conversion to God, by the natural and childish Working of their Passions, moved by soft Expressions, which they are apt to depend upon in the Room of it. It is a daubing with [...]ntemper'd Mortar, a setting the Cart before the Oxen, such a Kind of Preaching by soft Methods of Address, may make a Show upon weak Minds, but is never like to do real Good.
To assert universal Redemption, and then to tell us, that Faith consists in a Belief that Christ died for us in particular, has as dreadful a Tendency to flatter and please a carnal World, to fix them in a miserable Security, and to delude them to Damnation in Multitude [...], as almost any Scheme that has ever appeared on the Stage of the World. Every pious Bosom should beat with burning Indignation against such a horrid Scene!
As to the preceeding Objection, concerning the Day of Grace, the Door of Hope, and Offers of Salvation, as tho' they were inconsistent with particular Redemption; I shall beg Leave to offer one Particular more by Way of Retorsion, thus,— Is there not as great an apparent Inconsistency between the certain Fore-knowledge of God, and those Things now mentioned, as in the Case of particular Redemption? If the Jesuits, Arminians, Remonstrants, and Moravians, do not acknowledge God's infinite and certain Fore-knowledge, do they not in Effect deny his Being, for is not his Being and Knowledge the same? But if they do own it, let them reconcile it with the Day of Grace, Offers of Mercy, &c. and that will sufficiently answer the aforesaid Objection.
I may add to what has been before observed, this Particular, viz. That many of God's Children know the Falshood of universal Redemption, by their own Experience; being at Times made sensible thro' the Operations of God's blessed [Page 32] Spirit, of the transcendant Sweetness of distinguishing Grace! That which stirs up the Spleen and Rancour of many natural Men, (because of their Blindness, Pride, and Selfishness,) viz. That God should chuse some and pass by others, transports their Souls with humble Admiration, Love, and Gratitude; and in this they imitate their dearest Lord, Mat. 11.25. O 'tis a doleful Spectacle to see any grow indifferent and lukewarm about this precious, precious Truth, which has been sealed to their Souls by the Holy Ghost, because of the fair Appearances of some stragling Strangers.
To talk of holding particular Election and universal Redemption together, is Nonsense and Jargon. To reconcile them is as impossible, as to make a Rope of Sand. If this be the Moravian Simplicity, to believe Nonsense and Contradiction, may the good God deliver my Soul from their detestable Mysteries. Remember therefore how ye have heard and received, my dear Brethren! and hold fast this precious and valuable Truth of particular Redemption, against all false Apostles, and seducing Spirits, to the Death.
It is contrary to my intended Brevity, to speak any longer upon this Head; any that would desire to see this Subject more fully handled, let them read judicious Dr. Ridgeley's Discourse upon it, in his late Body of Divinity.
7. Ye have heard of the IMPERFECTION of the best of God's People on Earth. And thus speaks the Scriptures of Truth, Eccles. 7.20. For there is not a just Man upon Earth, who doeth Good and sinneth not, says Solomon. If thou Lord shouldst mark Iniquity, O Lord, who shall stand, says the Psalmist, Psal. 130.3. In many Things we all offend, says the Apostle, J [...]. 3.2. If we say we have no Sin, we deceive ourselves, and the Truth is not in us, says the Apostle John, [...] Joh. 1.8. All the Blunders of the Servants of God recorded in the old and new Testament, are so many Proofs of this sad Truth! See the Examples of Abraham's Equivocation, Sarah's Unbelief and Lying, Noah's Drunkenness, and Lott's incestuous Uncleanness, Worldliness, and ill Manners in chusing the most fertile Country, before the more honourable Person Abraham had his Choice; Jacob's Deceitfulness in the Affair of the Birth-right; and the Cruelty of a Number [Page 33] of the Patriarchs in the Matter of Shechem. Moses his Unbelief and Murmuring at the Waters of Meribah. Job's Impatience and cursing the Day of his Birth. Jeremiah's Fall into the same Iniquities. Elijah's Murmuring under the Juniper Tree. David's Murder and Adultery. Solomon's Uncleanness and Idolatry. Jonah's Pride and Peevishness in the Affair of Nineveh. Peter's Denial of his Master with Curses, and equivocating. And does not the blessed Apostle Paul call himself a wretched Man, because of his indwelling Corruptions? Rom. 7.
And indeed the Wisdom of God appears in suffering Corruptions to infest his People, in this militant State, as the Amorites and other Heathen Nations did his People Israel, who were as Goads in their Sides, and Thorns in their Eyes. For hereby a necessary Occasion is presented for the Exercise of their various Graces. Hereby they have continual Occasion for the deepest Humiliation, and most painful Labour: Hereby their Esteem of Christ is heightned, and their Self-Diffidence increased: Hereby their Affections are gradually weaned from the Things of Time, and set upon more suitable, noble, undecaying, invariable, and satisfactory Enjoyments: Hereby the frightful Gloom of Death is in a Measure changed, to a believing Eye, and it puts on an Angel's Form; because thro' this the devout Soul, pained and wearied with its incessant Corruptions, wings its Way to God, to th [...] Kingdom of the Blessed, where unmix'd Light, unallay'd Beauty, unstain'd Purity, and transcendant Love, have their perpetual Residence.
If that Passage in the Epistle of John be objected, where it is said, that He that is born of God sinneth not, neither can he sin.
Ans. If we take that Place in a Consistency with those before mentioned, (and surely the Scripture is harmonious) it can intend no more than one or both of these following Particulars, namely, (1.) That they can't commit the unpardonable Sin. Or (2.) That those who are born of God cannot go on (ordinarily) in a Course of Sin against Light, because the Seed of God, i. e. a divine Principle of Life is in them, and therefore disposes them to a contrary Temper and Course.
[Page 34]But Paul the Apostle speaks of some that were perfect in his Time, Phil. 3.15.
Ans. Sometimes this Word only signifies Sincerity; thus it is said of Job, that he was a perfect and upright Man: Here by the Figure Hendiadis, one Thing is expressed by two Words. This Kind of Perfection every good Man hath. Sometimes this Word signifies a Perfection of Degrees, i. e. when all Corruption is entirely rooted out of the Soul, and a Man is advanced to the highest Degree of Goodness. This the Apostle Paul disclaims in the 12th Verse of this Chapter, Not as tho' I had already attained, or were already perfect, but I follow after. Sometimes the Word perfect, signifies a greater Degree of confirmed Goodness than many others have attained to: Hence the Apostle John speaks of Babes, young Men, and Fathers in Christ. It is in this Sense that I believe the aforesaid Text is to be taken; for while the Apostle rejects any Pretence to a Perfection of Degrees, he acknowleges this comparative Perfection, as in the Text before cited.
But are we not commanded to be perfect as our heavenly Father is perfect? and does not this shew that a Perfection of Degrees is attainable in this Life?
Ans. No, it does not; for the Command is not the Measure of our Ability, but of our Duty. The blessed God indeed gave our first Parents, and us in them, before the Breach of the Covenant of Works, an Ability to do what was required of us; but they lost this for themselv [...] [...]d us, by Transgression. Hence we are told that all have sinned and come short of the Glory of God. Now can it be supposed with any Reason, that the Creatures Trespass should lessen the Creator's Claim of Right to their Obedience; or that he should be obliged to model his Laws, which are grounded upon the unalterable Nature of Things, according to the Measure of their contracted Weakness? No surely. If a Person should lend another a Sum of Money, and he should play the wilful Bankrupt with it, might not full Payment be legally demanded, and in Case of Failure, Imprisonment inflicted?
But tho' we cannot attain to a Perfection absolute and personal, yet thro' divine Assistance, we may obtain gradual [Page 35] Advances in Grace and Holiness, and so greater Nearness to it; and is not this a sufficient Incitement to religious Labour? And thro' Faith in the Redeemer we may obtain an absolute imputed Perfection. Hence Believers are said to be compleat in him, and he is said to be made to them Wisdom, Righteousness, Sanctification, and Redemption, [...] Cor. 1.30.
Our insisting upon the Imperfection of the Saints, in publick Discourses, instead of being an Encouragement to Impiety, is a strong Inducement to Holiness; for it serves to preserve Hope, which is the Spring of Motion, and Fountain of Action, in the Bosoms of gracious Persons, who are deeply sensible of their Defects. Those dear Mourners in Zion, are ready to be discouraged sometimes, because of the Sight and Sense they have of their Corruptions: for this they sometimes reject their State, and say in themselves, O! can it be possible that such Corruption can consist with the Grace of God? O was there ever on the Earth such a monstrous bruitish Creature as I am! For this their Hands hang down, and their Knees are feeble, for this (or on this Account) they are in the utmost Agonies, sometimes can hardly swallow their Spittle, and would chuse Strangling and Death rather than Life. Now to preach up Perfection to such poor humble Souls, who have a View of the spiritual Extent of the Law, and especially to signify that Conversion consists therein, this adds Affliction to the Afflicted: This makes those sorrowful whom God would have made glad: This strengthens Satan's Temptations, whereby he labours to perswade them that they have no Grace: This dispirits them in Obedience. Whereas the contrary Doctrine builds up their Hope, and so excites their Admiration, their Love, and their Contrition. O it melts their Hearts like Wax, and fills their Souls with Amazement! to think that so great, so holy a God should take any favourable Notice of such sinful, ungrateful, and backsliding Worms as they. This, this fires and enflames their Souls with strong Emotions of affectionate Love and Gratitude! O what shall I do for this gracious blessed God who is so good to me? O the surprising Riches, and amazing Glories of his pure, pure Grace! This strengthens the feeble Knees, and says to those of a fearful [Page 36] Heart, be strong. This endears the blessed Jesus to their Souls, and makes them see their absolute Need of him. And thus, my dear Brethren, it encourages and excites to walk in the Ways of religious Obedience. Therefore let us hold fast this precious Truth, against the detestable Doctrine of the Moravians, and other Enthusiasts, who assert Perfection.
One of principal Note among the Moravians, spake to this Purpose in New-Brunswick, and two of that Sect, who were in Company with him, asserted that they had been without Sin for several Years; both which Particulars you may see in the annexed Appendix. Well then; shall we believe the Apostle John or not, that they are Liars, and that the Truth is not in them? We think we may safely apply to ourselves, what is said of the Church of Ephesus, Rev. 2.2. that we have tried them which say they are Apostles, and are not, and found them to be Liars.
For my own Part, I must declare to the World, that I think the Moravians, at least some of them, are not so candid as to this Point, and many others, as the Generality of other modern Enthusiasts, who own the Doctrine of Perfection expresly and openly, while some of the Moravians labour to hide their Opinion, and tho' they own it in Fact and Reality in other Words, yet some of them don't like to own it in so many Words expresly. If they use this Art, to prevent the Odium, which would justly come upon their Sect, by their false Doctrine; and to impose upon the Ignorant and Credulous, and so to encrease their Party, it is exceeding base indeed. If this be their Simplicity, may the good Lord deliver us from it!
8. Ye have heard that CONVERSION consists in the Infusion of a divine Principle of Life. And thus speaks the Scripture, Eph. 2.1. Joh. 5.40. Joh. 10.16. Joh. 5.25. Let us hold fast this precious Truth, against the pernicious Doctrine of the Moravians; one of principal Note among whom asserted in New-Brunswick, that a Man was converted when he had an abiding Sense of his Sin and Misery. At this Rate, Cain, Ahab, and Judas, were converted Persons. And in the mean Time he condemned the State of David when he committed Adultery, of Peter when he denied his [Page 37] Master, and of Paul as described in the 7th of the Romans: What dreadful Work is this!
Dat veniam Corvis, vexat censura columbas; this Censure approves the Ravens and condemns the Doves. According to the aforesaid Notion, Men would be converted first, and convinced afterwards; which directly contradicts all that has been said before concerning the Necessity of a preparatory Law-Work, and is real Nonsense.
9. Ye have heard that the Guilt of Adam's Sin is IMPUTED to all his Offspring, Christ excepted; whose Conception was extraordinary and miraculous, by the Power of the Holy Ghost. Hereby he was freed from the Stain of original Transgression, which infects all those, who are propogated by natural Generation.
Our Lord not descending from Adam, in a natural Way, was not numbered in him; and for this Reason as well as on the Account of his being God-Man, he did not, and I may say could not, break the Covenant of Nature. If he had broken the first Covenant, he could not have been the Head of the second.
Our Lord was born, not by Virtue of that primitive Benediction. Gen. 1.28. Grow and multiply: But by Virtue of that gracious Promise. Gen. 3.15. And I will put Enmity between thee and the Woman, and between thy Seed and her Seed, it shall bruise thy Head, and thou shall bruise his Heel.
Now that the Sin of Adam in eating the forbidden Fruit, is imputed to his Posterity, is evident from the following Places of Scripture, Rom. 5. [...]2, [...]4, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, Wherefore as by one Man Sin entred into the World, and Death by Sin, and so Death passed upon all Me [...] for that all have sinned. Nevertheless Death reigned from Adam to Moses, even over those that had not sinned, after t [...]e Similitude of Adam's Transgression, who is the Figure of him that was to come. By the Offence of one Judgment came upon all Men to Condemnation. Eph. 2.3. And were by Nature Children of Wrath even as others. Whence is it that Jews and Gentiles should be by Nature Children of Wrath, or have Wrath for their Inheritance, if there was no natural and common Guilt? Is there not a plain Difference between Nature and Practice? Rom. [Page 38] 3.19. Whatsoever the Law says, it says to those that are under the Law, that every Mouth may be stopped, and the whole World become guilty before God.
Now if Jews and Gentiles are by Nature Children of Wrath, and if all the World be under the Law, and guilty before God, while in a State of Nature, then Infants are guilty of original Sin, before they be capable to commit actual; for they have the human Nature, and are a Part of the World: and indeed this appears the more evident, from their Liableness to Death, which the Apostle represents to be the Wages of Sin, and brought into the World thereby, Rom. 6.23. Rom. 5.12.
The Ground of the Imputation of Adam's Guilt to us, is not so much in the Nature which we derive from him, (he could not communicate a better than he had, and the second Adam has derived the humane Nature from our first Parents) as in the Covenant made with him, and his Posterity after him, of which we have an Account in the following Places of Scripture, Gen. 2.16, 17. In this Covenant, the great God contracts with his Creature as with a Servant, by Way of sovereign Empire; prescribing to him what Terms he pleased. In the threatning of Death in Case of Disobedience, is doubtless imply'd a Promise of Life in Case of Obedience; and hence it is expresly call'd a Covenant, Hos. 6.7. But they like Adam, have transgressed the Covenant.
That Adam's whole Posterity was involved in his Guilt, in eating of the forbidden Fruit, and in the Miseries consequent thereupon, is written as with a Sun-Beam in that famous Scripture, Rom. 5.12, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19. there Death is said to pass upon all, and that because all had sinned.
Now it can't be in Reason supposed, that they could sin actually and personally before they had a Being, therefore it must be by Imputation.
Does not the universal Experience of all Adam's Posterity, loudly proclaim the aforesaid Truth? If his Transgression was not imputed to them, whence should spring their early Propensity or Inclination to Vice, before they have Time to contract it by Practice and Example? Can a Stream flow without a Fountain, a Branch grow without a Tree? Does [Page 39] not Mankind by some Kind of actual Imitation, approve the original Trespass, and so transfer its Guilt upon themselves? Whence should come that Train of Miseries, that Complication of Calamities, that make all the Creation groan, and infest the whole humane Race, if the Sin of Adam be not imputed?
How is it that tender Infants, before they become capable of actual Offences, should be exposed to Death it self, in its most hideous Form, and to all those Diseases which are the Ushers of it? Will not the Judge of all the Earth do right? Will the just God inflict capital Punishment where there is no Transgression, either imputed or inherent? Does the Almighty afflict willingly, or grieve the Children of Men? No surely! Shall the Wages of Sin be paid without any Relation to the Work? Yea the Apostle asserts, 1 Cor. 15.22. That in Adam all die. Now seeing that Death is the proper Wages of Sin, by divine Ordination, it must be supposed that all sinned: but Persons not existing, could not sin any other Way than by the Imputation of the first Transgression.
It is evident from the Parrallel drawn by the Apostle Paul, between the first and second Adam, that the first was a publick Person as well as the second; see Rom. 5. 1 Cor. 15. They are spoken of, as if there were but these two Persons in the World, because they were Heads of different Covenants, viz. of Works, and Grace; and Representatives of different Posterities, viz. natural and spiritual. Yea Adam is expresly said to be the Figure of him that was to come.
The History of the first Man gives farther Confirmation to the aforesaid Truth, where we read that all the Good and Evil that befell him, were ascrib'd to him, as a publick Person; who was to be the Example and Pledge of his Posterity. Before the Fall the original Righteousness he possess'd, and Empire over the Creatures, as well as his Marriage and Blessing, respected all; and after the Fall the Miseries which befel him, respected not only himself, but all his Posterity.
Most certainly we sinned after the same Manner in Adam, as we are justify'd in Christ; namely by Imputation: and if the first be deny'd, why not the latter? and then the Foundation of the Gospel is overset, and nothing left in the [Page 40] Room of it, but a System of moral Virtue. And it may be observed in Confirmation of what has been now offered, that the Denial of original Sin imputed, naturally leads to, and often issues in, the Denial of the Saviour's imputed Righteousness to Justification.
I cannot see any Unreasonableness in the Assertion, of the first Man's representing his whole Race, seeing that the Benefits of his Obedience, if he had stood, would have redounded to his Posterity, as really as if they had personally kept the Covenant. Now by a Parity of Reason, it is but just that they should be exposed to the Disadvantages of his Fall.
The Situation of Mankind in having one common Representative, was better than if every Man had stood for himself, Head for Head: which appears thus; Adam had not only as great a Capacity to stand, considered in a private Character, as any other could be supposed to have, being made upright, as Solomon observes: He had a perfect Knowlege of the divine Mind, so far as concerned his Duty and Happiness; a universal Rectitude which spread through his whole Soul, and governed all his Powers and Passions.
But besides this, he had the Consideration of thereby securing the Happiness of his whole Offspring, to incite him to stand, and the Ruin of his whole Race to deter him from the contrary: And are not these important Motives to generous Minds? Now if every Man had stood for himself, without any publick Representative, they could not have had those Incentives to Perseverance in Goodness, and consequently there would not have been such a great Probability of their Standing. Besides Adam being newly form'd, had a fresh Sense of creating Goodness, which must needs offer additional Influence to his Love and Obedience. By these Considerations it appears that Man's Condition in having a federal Head, was better than if it had been otherwise.
God Almighty undoubtedly foresaw, that all Adam's Posterity, would have yielded to the same satanical Temptation with him, had they been thereto exposed; and therefore seeing that that was certainly future, it might possibly in some Sense, be esteemed as committed.
[Page 41]Again, it is certain that the whole World of Mankind then existing, did sin, and that thereby the Friendship of God with the whole World perished, and consequently with their Posterity, seeing that Children are but Parts or Pieces of their Parents.
It must be confessed that God is the Sovereign of the Universe, the great Potter, and we but Clay in his Hands; that he has an absolute Right to do with his own as he pleases.
It is indeed a marvellous Instance of divine Goodness & Condescension, that the great Lord of the Universe, should stoop so low, as to enter into any Covenant with his Creatures at all, and much more so when in the Manner before related!
To have Representatives, is not unusual in civil Affairs. Do not Embassadors represent the Prince and Nation that sends them to a foreign State, and are not their Speeches and Actions interpretatively the Speeches and Actions of all their Constituents?
Do not Parents personate and oblige their Children unborn, by their civil Transactions respecting them; and when they covenant for their Benefit, who does or who justly can blame the Practice?
And seeing that to have a federal Head, or common Representative, by Way of Covenant, was as has been observed, the best Situation that Man could be in, respecting the primitive Covenant Transaction, if they had had their own Choice, whom could they have chosen, that was so fit to occupy that Place, that important Province, as him who was the Parent and Original of the whole humane Race, and otherwise so qualified, as has been before hinted.
The Pelagians, Socinians, Jesuits, Arminians, Remomstrants, Moravians, and all other Enthusiasts, so far as I know, do oppose the aforesaid momentuous Truth, which has so direct and noble a Tendency to humble the Pride of Man, to make him sensible of his Misery, and so to prepare him for the dear Redeemer. Some of the Objections that are bro't by the aforesaid Adversaries, are such as these following,
1. They say, we did not exist or consent, when our first Parents sinned.
Ans. Tho' we did not exist or consent actually, yet we [Page 42] did exist, consent, and have sinned virtually, interpretatively, or in our Cause, in one Adam. Rom. 5.12.
2. They say that it is unreasonable to imagine, that that Sin which was pardoned in Adam, and so does not exist, should be imputed to his Offspring.
Ans. Tho' that first Sin does not exist physically, yet it does ethically, or morally; the Pardon of Sin does not take away its Being, but only its binding Power, from those to whom it is apply'd.
3. They object, that it is inconsistent with the Omniscience and Truth of God, to reckon him to have sinned, who has not sinned, and with his Justice to punish him.
Ans. It's true, it is inconsistent with God's Omniscience, to reckon him to have sinned actually, who has not sinned actually; but it is not inconsistent with his Omniscience, to reckon him to have sinned virtually, or in the Cause, who has not sinned actually, or in his own Person: Neither is it unjust to punish him, who has only sinned virtually, as we see in the Case of Infants, who feel the Force of Death. We may reasonably argue from Fact to Right in Respect of God. We are sure that whatever he does he has a Right to do; for as his Wisdom is infallible, so his Holiness is inviolable: He is a Rock, his Ways are perfect, a God of Truth, and without Iniquity, just and right is he.
4. Christ denies that the Parents of the blind Man sinned.
Ans. That intends no more than this, viz. That neither his ow [...] nor his Parents Sin was the Cause procuring of that particular precise Calamity, with which he was afflicted: But that the principal Design hereof, was that the Works of God might be made manifest in him!
5. Some object this Saying of our Lord, concerning little Children, that of such is the Kingdom of Heaven. Mar. 10.44. and it is elsewhere said, that they are holy, 1 Cor. 7.14. and we are told that we must be like them.
Ans. They are not so by Nature, but by Grace in Christ who has received them. Ephes. 2.1, 3. It is only in Respect of Humility and Freedom from Malice, that we are enjoyn'd to imitate them; in Malice we should be Children, but in Understanding Men.
[Page 43]6. Some object that Place in Ezek. 18.4, 20. where it is said, that the Son shall not bear the Iniquities of the Father.
Ans. The Place speaks concerning the personal Sins of private Parents, that these are not imputed to their Offspring if they make not themselves Partakers of them, and not concerning the Transgression of our common Pa [...]nt, in whom all sinned. Rom. 5.12.
The Semi-pelagians, and Jesuits, do after a Sort acknowlege that there is such a Thing as original Sin, but believe that it is wholly taken away by Baptism. But the Ridiculousness of this will appear if we consider that Baptism is but an outward Ordinance, which can be of no saving Service to us, unless the Thing signify'd by this external Symbol, be confer'd. Thus speaks the Apostle, Gal. 6.15. that neither Circumcision availeth any Thing, nor Uncircumcision, but the new Creature: And elsewhere he tells us, that Circumcision is nothing, and Uncircumcision is nothing, but the keeping of the Commandments of God. Was not Simon Magus baptiz'd? and yet he remain'd in the Gall of Bitterness notwithstanding. It is a vain Thing for any to depend on lying Words, saying, The Temple of the Lord, the Temple of the Lord are these; for without Conversion there is no Salvation.
The Arminians and Moravians, imagine that the Guilt of original Sin is taken away from all an [...] [...]gular, by the Death of Christ; and some to prove this, [...]duce that Place of Scripture, John 1.29. Behold the Lamb of God, that taketh away the Sin of the World.
Ans. It is true, Jesus Christ does take away the Sin of the World; by his Blood he removes its Guilt, and by his Spirit its Dominion: but is it not contrary to both Scripture and Reason to imagine, that Guilt should be taken away before Faith? Rom. 3 28. Joh. 3.36. Or that the Guilt of Sin should be remov'd, and its Power remain? Surely those that are justify'd are also called. Rom. 8. Or that the Guilt of original Sin should be remov'd, and that of actual remain? Are we not informed that the Blood of Christ cleanseth from all Sin? Can any Sin be pardoned, till a Person be ingrafted into Christ, and hear his Voice? And does not our Saviour assure us, that to all such he gives eternal Life, and [Page 44] that they shall never perish? Joh. 10. Then i [...] the Guilt of original Sin was removed from all, by Consequence all would be saved; but this is contrary to many express Declarations of Scripture, which inform us, that strait is the Gate, and narrow the Way that leadeth unto Life, and but few find it.
To say that the Guilt of original Sin is removed, and that the Guilt of actual remains; is in Effect to say, that a Person is at once half justify'd and half condemn'd; in Christ, and without him; alive, and dead; Children of God, and of the Devil, at the same Time: and pray where shall such mongrel Monsters go at Death? Mr. Pool justly observes in his Synopsis, that the Word Sin in the Text aforesaid, is put collectively or synechdochically, for all Sin; and that the Word World, as before observed, intends both Jews and Gentiles. What can be the Meaning of the aforesaid Notion, but to set fallen Man on his Legs again in his own Conceit? and secretly to establish the darling Idol of Free-will, to the Dishonour of Free-Grace, and the Disparagement of the divine Sovereignty!
It is but to little Avail to acknowledge hereditary Corruption, and in the mean Time to deny the Imputation of its Guilt; for then it is but an Infelicity or Unhappiness, and no Fault. The Tendency of this seems to be only to amuse Mankind, and not to humble them at all. Persons are apt to be more easily dec [...]d with such sort of People; while they express in strong [...]erms the Corruption of Nature, one would think they were sound, as to the Doctrine of original Sin. I was thus imposed upon my self by one of Note among the Moravians for a Time, until I searched him more closely, and then I found him tardy; he possitively deny'd the Imputation of the Guilt of the first Sin, and endeavoured to baffle all the Arguments I offered in Confirmation of it.
But pray how can those Moravians, and their Arminian Brethren, account for a Conveyance of original Corruption, without any Imputation of Guilt? I know of nothing in Scripture or Reason to support it; if they do let them produce it.
Now is it any Wonder that the Moravian Sect are easy, when such stupifying damnable Doctrines are advanced among them? When we seriously consider the gross Ignorance of a principal Person of their Party, as to many of the fundamental [Page 45] and most important Doctrines of Christianity, viz. Conviction, Conversion, Faith, Justification, &c. which we may reasonably suppose, has Influence upon many of that Sect; together with their slighty Experiences, (for the most Part) without a prepa [...]atory Work of the Law; and having generally, (so far as I can learn) no Complaints about their Corruptions, and the Weakness of their Faith: as also their schismatical, sly, inconsistent, and jugling Practices, in proselyting Persons to their Party, and drawing them away from the precious Truths and true Fold of Christ, to their detestable Jargon; It will take a large Stretch of Charity, to conclude that there is the least Measure of saving Grace in them, notwithstanding of all their great Appearances.
Once more, If it should be objected, (more generally) by any that favour the Moravian Sect, as it has been done by Dr. Whitby, Whiston, and other Patrons of Arminianism, that the peculiar Doctrines of Calvinism, were unknown in the Church till the Time of Austin, which was in the latter End of the fourth and Beginning of the fifth Century. I shall beg Leave to offer learned and pious Dr. John Edwards's Answer to this Cavil, (in his Book upon the Defects of human Learning,) which is as follows, viz.
‘St. Augustine, in his Book of the Good of Perseverance, Chap. 15. quotes some Authors who were before him, for the Doctrine of Predestination; it is not to be doubted, saith he, but that they knew Predestination; and as for other Points, which go along with Predestination, as original Sin, &c. this Father produces the Testimony of Justin Martyr, Ireneus, Cyprian, Hilary, and others, to confirm what he had said on those Heads.’
Before the Time of infamous Pelagius, the Founder of those unhappy Principles, from which as Fountains the tainted Streams of Arminianism have and do flow; we have no Account of any Controversy among the Ancients, respecting those Points, which were the Subjects of Debate between Austin and Pelagius. Probably this was the Occasion, why some of the Fathers do not write so distinctly, correctly, and consistently, about these Points, as after the Time of Austin.
[Page 46]But having the express Testimony of Scripture and Reason upon our Side, we think it the best and surest Antiquity!
But I hasten to consider another Thing proposed, which was, ‘II. To shew what is supposed by, and implied in, our remembering and holding fast the Truths of Christ. And,’
1. I think it naturally and necessarily supposes, our Liableness to forget and loose Truths which we have once received, (and perhaps with sensible Complacence) in Judgment, Affection and Practice. Thro' our Ignorance, Corruption, Credulity, and the plausible Arts of Seducers, who lye in wait to deceive, there be so many doleful Instances of this, in Writings both sacred and prophane, that it is needless to say any Thing farther in Confirmation of it: Only this may be added, that the Command in our Text is grounded thereupon. There would be no Need of enjoining us to remember and hold fast, if we were not inclined naturally to let the precious Truths of Christ slip out of our treacherous Memories, and to turn from them to Error and Vanity, in our corrupt Affections!
Since we have fallen from the God of Truth by the Breach of the first Covenant, Error is co-natural to us, our Hearts are a fit Soil to hatch and cherish that Cockatrice, and because many Errors do either more openly or covertly befriend Sin and Security, therefore we are naturally inclin'd to receive them, and revolt from the Doctrines of Truth to them!
Besides the Devil who is the Father of Lies and Errors, has in our fallen State an unhappy Access to our Souls, and if permitted, can easily represent Things in such a false Light, as to raise a Prejudice in our Minds against Truth; and so endanger our Apostacy therefrom. Hence Satan is justly call'd a Spirit of Error, a seducing Spirit. But,
2. The Command in our Text supposes the dangerous Consequences of forgetting the Truth, and letting it go, otherwise the contrary Duty would not be therein, with so much Earnestness pressed.
When the Eye of the Body is blinded, one walks in continual Danger, and knows not whither he goes; Persons may be then led any where to their Hurt; they may be conducted [Page 47] contrary to their Expectation, to the Camp of their Enemies, instead of Friends, as the Syrians to Damascus.
And how much more dreadful is it, when the Eye of the Soul is blinded, I mean that leading Power, the Understanding! When false Teachers, by their bewitching Charms, and jugling Arts, do blind Men's Minds, they may then triumph over them, as the Philistines over poor Samson, when they had pluck'd out his Eyes.
As Truth has great Power to excite to Holiness, so Error to Sin, either open or secret, of Heart or Practice. How strangely does it elate the Mind with Pride, in Respect of Men's own Attainments, and possess it with Prejudice against the Sons of Truth! Error disconforms the Mind to the God of Truth, it often turns Zeal into a wrong Channel, and separates chief Friends. Hereby Churches and Families are torn in Pieces, with Breaches wide as the Sea. Some otherwise valuable Persons being poisoned with Error, have made it their Business to pull down with great Industry, that Good which they once laboured to build up. Error in the Mind is the Fountain from which springs Error in Practice; and indeed the former is generally more difficultly cured than the latter, because Persons have more Excuses for the one than the other. Mistakes in Opinion are not so easy to be discern'd, as in Practice. But,
3. The Command in our Text implies, that there are proper Means to be used to prevent the aforesaid Evil, and Loss consequent upon it: Otherwise to what valuable Purpose would the Command serve? Now the Means are such as these following.
1. Humility. The God of Truth dwells with the Humble; whereas spiritual Pride (more especially) is often the Fore-runner of a Fall in Doctrine or Practice; and indeed this Pride is sometimes much disguis'd with a Kind of Zeal, and Appearance of Humility, which is perhaps undiscern'd by the Person that has it.
But in my Opinion a Disposition to separate from a true Church, because many of her Members are unconverted, and some are under Deadness, is a Sign of a proud Spirit: Were not the Pharisees of old proud Separatists?
[Page 48]Our Lord allows the Wheat and Tares to grow together till Harvest. But some rash Zealots are for parting them, or plucking them up directly, altho' they thereby risque the Safety of the Wheat.
It is also an Instance of Pride to despise and sligh [...] Ministers or People that are unconverted, or supposed to be so. Is not the Language of such a Practice, as the Prophet Isaiah describes it, Stand off, for I am holier than thou? Any that are unconverted, are Objects of Pity, and not of Contempt; neither does our Opinion of Men's inward States, which is an uncertain Thing, dissolve our Obligation to express that Honour, which is due to their different Stations.
But on the contray those that walk humbly, walk safely, and none but they.
2. Earnest Labour, (by reading the Scriptures, Meditation on them, comparing Scripture with Scripture, hearing the Word preached) in order to understand the Truths of Christ more thoroughly, and in their Connection.
It is also exceeding necessary to be well acquainted with the Catechisms of the reformed Churches, which give a summary View of the Principles of Religion; and with those approved Books which do explain them. In particular, I would earnestly recommend to your Perusal, Mr. Vincent's Explication of the Assembly's Catechism, which is a most valuable precious Performance.
And here I must take Leave to observe, that the Practice of staying at Home, rather than going to hear such Ministers, (sound in Principle and regular in Practice) as are judg'd by some to be unconverted, is unscriptural and of dangerous Tendency (in my Opinion,) for it hangs the whole Weight of the publick Worship of God, upon the uncertain Judgment of Men. Tho' unconverted Ministers are not likely to do so much Good as others, yet seeing that many of them, doubtless, do preach the same Word of God, which others do; why may not the sovereign God, who permits them by his Providence to come into the Ministry, bless his Word delivered by them, for the Good of Mankind?
Besides, the aforesaid Practice of staying at Home, &c. opens a Door to Delusion by false Teachers, as well as to Confusions [Page 49] and Schisms in the Church of God. People are naturally inclined to Extreams about Ministers, either to make no Difference at all, or to make too much. Certainly the Corinthian Disease is dangerous, when one says, he is of Paul, and another of Apollos. Surely Ministers should neither be slighted, nor idoliz'd!
I must declare to the World, that I dread the Tho'ts of Schisms & Separations in the Church of God; because of the dismal Handle that is hereby given to Seducers, to promote their erroneous Tenets; and also because of the Dishonour that is hereby cast on God's Name, Ways and People: hereby wicked Men are strengthned in their Prejudices against Religion; hereby Professors are diverted from promoting God's Work, to personal trifling Controversies of no Moment. Therefore when the Case so happens, that People are dissatisfied with their Minister, and cannot get Edification by his Ministrations, after long and impartial Labours to this End; it seems most adviseable for them humbly and peaceably (in a regular Manner) to seek to get an Assistant with him, if the Place be able to support two; but if not, to ask Leave of their Pastor and other Church Officers, to go where they are more edifyed: in the mean Time laying aside all rash Censures. And should not Ministers also for Peace sake, deny themselves, and consent to the reasonable Proposals of their People, waving all exasperating Reflections upon their dissatisfyed People, and more especially in their publick Performances? O may the God of Peace, incline us to study and pursue, the Things that are for Peace!
3d. Means, is humble importunate Supplication to almighty God, the God of Truth, for Instruction in the Knowlege of Truth, and Establishment therein; and that under a deep Sense of our Ignorance and Foolishness: If any Man lack Wisdom let him ask it of God; who gives liberally and upbraids not. It is with believing Expectations, that we should ask these Blessings from God: thereby God is glorified, and engaged by Promise to help his People.
But the Time is elapsed, and I must add no more at present.
[Page 50]
SERMON, III.
REV. III. 3. Remember therefore how thou hast heard, and received, and hold fast.—
SEEING the Truths of Christ are a most valuable and sacred Depositum, transmitted to us thro' much Expence of Labour and of Blood; it would be base, ignoble, and ungrateful in us to lose them, thro' sordid Negligence and Indifferency; or to suffer them, thro' Cowardise, to be betray'd and undermined by Impostors; without signifying our Sorrow for the Injury, and attempting to make some Defence.
Forasmuch as the Church of Christ is begirt with numerous Enemies, of various Forms; Enemies open and secret, who labour almost incessantly, either by Force or Fraud, to corrupt her in her Principles, it is of the last Necessity, to be constantly upon our Guard, and especially in a Time of publick and epidemical Infection; lest we be betrayed into the Labyrinths of Error and Mistake, by the plausible Pretences of Seducers.
To this End, it is exceeding needful to use those Means, which tend to our common Security. In the last Sermon, under the second general Head proposed, I made mention of three Means, which I judge proper to help us to retain the Truths of Christ; to which I would now add, these following, namely, in the
[Page 51]4. Place, It is also exceeding necessary, to implore the God of all Grace, that he would please of his infinite Mercy to give us to feel the special and powerful Influence of Truth upon our Minds and Hearts, that so we may be moulded into the Image thereof, and thus transformed from Glory to Glory.
Altho' the bare doctrinal Knowlege of a true System of religious Principles, be a valuable Privilege, in as much as it is a needful Preparative to that which is of a saving Kind; yet it is dangerous and destructive, to rest satisfied with it, without the Experience of its Power and Influence. Rom. 2.17,—20.
A hearty and enduring Endeavour, with all Humility, to conform in Practice to the Truths we know, is a necessary Mean to obtain Establishment in the Truth, and farther Instruction. If any (saith our Lord) doth the Will of God, he shall know of the Truth whither it be of God. Perseverance in the Acknowledgement of the Truth, is God's free Gift, without which we cannot stand. Now if we are not faithful in acting according to what we know, God's Spirit will be grieved, and we are in Danger of being given up to a Spirit of Error and Delusion. Rom. 1.21. 2 Thes. 1.10, 11, 12.
5. If we would hold fast the Truths of Christ, we must avoid unnecessary Conversation with Persons grosly and fundamentally erroneous. Those that bring not the Doctrine of Christ with them, we must not receive them into our Houses, or bid them God Speed; for if we do we are Partakers of their evil Deeds. See 2 Epist. of Joh. 8.9, 10. Look to your selves therefore, that we lose not those Things we have wrought. We are commanded to mark those that cause Divisions, and to avoid them. Now Persons may be said to cause Divisions, when by false Doctrine (and especially about important Points) they alienate the Affections of good Men from each other, and break them into different Parties. Rom. 16.17. Now I beseech you, Brethren, mark those which cause Divisions and Offences, contrary to the Doctrine which ye have received, and avoid them; for they that are such, serve not our Lord Jesus, but their own Belly, and by good Words and fair Speeches, deceive the Hearts of the simple.
[Page 52]Our Lord directs us to pray that we may not be led into Temptation. Now if we are fond of erroneous Strangers, and needlesly rush into their Conversation, do we not contradict our Prayers by our Practice? There seems to be a bewitching Power that sometimes attends (thro' the just Judgment of God) the Conversation and Labours of false Teachers. How affectionately does the Apostle Paul speak about this, to the erring Galatians, Gal. 3.1. O foolish Galatians! who hath bewitched you that you should not obey the Truth?
It is storied of the Labadists, an enthusiastical Sect that sometime since appeared in Holland, but is now happily evanished, that such bewitching Charms attended their Conversation, that few who conversed much with them escaped th [...] Infection; and therefore that the Reverend Messieurs Bracel and Coleman, eminent Ministers who wrote against them, would not run the Risque of much Conversation with them, especially in their Society.
6. In order to hold fast Christ's precious Truths, it is needful to wave a positive Conclusion respecting the good State of Strangers, wh [...] we have not [...]ufficient Evidences for it, in respect of their Principles, Experiences, and Practice. Rash judging either Way is certainly u [...]easonable and prejudicial; when Persons do speedily, without sufficient Grounds, conclude Strangers, who come among them, to be pious, and perhaps eminently so, because of their fair Appearances in Behaviour, without examining their Principles. By this rash Method of proceeding, their Affections are apt to be unreasonably engaged in their Favour; and these being inflamed, do give a secret wrong Byass to their Judgment: and thus they lay themselves open to all Manner of Delusion: thus they lay a dangerous Train to blow up their own sound Principles, before they are aware. Their foolish Love makes them turn Advocates for Seducers: And in the mean Time while they extol their apparent Piety to others, and put favourable Glosses on their damnable Errors (by which they strengthen their Party, and become Partakers with them in their Wickedness) they themselves by Degrees drink them in. Some unhappy Effects of this Practice have appeared [Page 53] already, and more probably will by and by follow [...] [...]his fair Warning is not taken.
7. It is necessary in order to hold fast the pre [...] [...]hs of Christ, to distinguish between Men's States and [...]s. Supposing Men's States towards God were good, [...]ould that make false Principles true? o [...] should it induce us to receive them? If good Men are doing that which is bad, should not they be opposed, with a Zeal equal to the Importance of their Errors? Did not the Apostle Paul withstand the Apostle Peter to the Face, because he was to be blamed?
8. In order to hold fast the precious Truths of Christ, a godly Jealousy of Strangers, who conceal their Principles, is but reasonable and necessary. Hiding of religious Principles looks like a Consciousness of Guilt; it is so far from scriptural Simplicity, that it looks like Trick and evil Design. On the contrary, it is said of our Lord, that he spoke nothing in secret, i. e. he used the most publick Methods of communicating his Doctrines to the World. The Coming of the Son of Man is represented by the Light's shining from the East to the West; which is open and conspicuous. As Truth needs no Corners or lurking Places, so it seeks them not; but is willing to be publish'd on House-Tops, that it may be known of all. But false Teachers are won't to use private sculking Methods; they creep into Houses, and lead Captive silly Women; and often by them their Husbands, and others are corrupted.
9. In order to preserve our selves and our Posterity from the Infection of Error, I think it is needful to use (in our proper Spheres) all suitable Means to obtain a godly, learned, and regular Ministry. In ordinary Cases, when any of these Qualifications is wanting, the Churches Safety is indangered in a greater or lesser Degree. Surely the Ministry should be committed to able, as well as faithful Men; Men that are apt to teach, and able to divide the Word aright, as well as convince Gainsayers, or stop their Mouths. When ignorant Novices are admitted into the ministerial Order, they are apt to be puff'd up, to the Churches great Prejudice, as well as their own; and to spread Error, when they know it not. To say, that these Qualifications may be ordinarily attained [Page 54] without humane Learning, is notoriously enthusiastical and foolish. For it is an Expectation of an End in ordinary Cases, without the Use of proper Means tending thereto. Instead of trusting in God, this is a tempting of him. He who acknowleges, that the Scriptures, which are the Rule of our Faith and Practice, were originally written in other Tongues than are now Vulgar, must have a weak Mind, an enthusiastical Heart, or a hard Forehead, if he denies the Necessity of humane Learning. In short, either humane Learning is necessary, or there must be Inspiration, to supply the want thereof. Do not therefore wonder at the enthusiastical Talk of the Moravians, viz. ‘That Persons must speak no more in religious Matters, then God has wro't in their Hearts.’ This I take to be Inspiration, in other Words; especially when it is consider'd in Connection with their Advice against preparatory Studies. Methinks, it is in a manner Self-evident, that all those who deny the Necessity of humane Learning, in ordinary Cases, to prepare Persons for the Ministry, are Enthusiasts.
Whatsoever good Appearance, thrusting out ignorant Persons (how pious soever) into the Ministry may have, yet it is a dangerous Practice, tending directly to divide and corrupt the Church of God, and bring the Ministry thereof into Contempt. Besides, when Persons intrude into the ministerial Work, without any previous Trial and Licence, from those who by Virtue of their Office are constituted Judges in such Cases, it is doubtless our Duty to discountenance them, let them pretend what they will. None should take this Honour to himself; but wait for God's Call and Appointment. If any irregularly assume the Posts of Officers, in the State or Army, it turns all into Confusion; and thus it is in the Church of God. Therefore all proper Care should be taken to prevent Intrusions, which are pregnant with mischievous Consequences.
10. Another Mean to hold fast Christ's precious Truths, is to confer with our spiritual Guides, about Points that are controverted; to hear patiently, and consider calmly their Reasonings; and to take Care, that we do not entertain unreasonable Prejudice against them. When the Spouse inquired [Page 55] where her Beloved fed, and made his Flooks to rest at Noon, she was bid to go forth by the Footsteps of the Flock, and feed her Kids beside the Shepherds Tents.
Now, we should frequently and feelingly reflect upon the Truths which we have heard, and remember with what Affection we have heard them.
And it is our Duty to hold them fast, in the following Respects; namely,
1. In the Judgment and Assent of our Minds. We should esteem and approve of them, and judge them worthy of all Acceptance; more valuable than the finest Gold, and sweeter than Honey and the Honey-Comb; right, equal, holy, just, and good; worthy of our Labour and Purchase; but not to be parted with at any Rate. Hence is that Injunction, Prov. 23.23. Buy the Truth and sell it not.
2. We should hold fast the Truths of Christ in our Affections. As Truth should be high in our Esteem, so our Affections should be fixed upon it. Hence the Apostle pray'd Night and Day for the Thessalonians, that they might be filled with the Knowlege of his Will, in all Wisdom and spiritual Understanding. The Apostle John speaks of his loving an honourable Lady in the Truth, i. e. because of the Truth; as he himself explains the Phrase in the following Verse, namely the 2d Verse of his second Epistle.
3. We should hold fast the Truth in our Profession. If we will not confess Christ before Men, he will not confess us before his heavenly Father. And indeed if we will not profess the dear and precious Truths of the Redeemer, we are not worthy to be called his Disciples. If we are ashamed of him and of his Truths in the midst of a froward and adulterous Generation, of us will the Son of Man be ashamed, when he comes in the Glory of his Father, with the holy Angels.
4. We should hold fast the Truths of Christ in our Practice. Hence we are commanded to adorn the Doctrine of God our Saviour in all Things. We should walk as Lights in the World, that those who seek to accuse our good Conversation in Christ may be ashamed. We should hold forth the Word of Truth in our Practice, that thereby the Ignorance of foolish Men [Page 56] may be put to Silence. O it is to be lamented, if possible with Tears of Blood! when the Enemies of Truth get seeming Occasion of Reproach and Triumph, by Blunders in the Lives of the Professors of it. O let us be careful that the Interests of Truth suffer not, thro' our Misconduct! let us endeavour to remove Occasion from those who seek Occasion!
By our Practice, we should shew to the World our Abhorrence of Deceivers, and fundamentally erronious Persons, as we would do of Persons that have Plague Sores upon them; unless it be to convince, reclaim, oppose and confute them. It is an inconsistent, unjustifiable Weakness, to pretend to hate Error, and yet court the Company of Schismaticks, Enthusiasts, Seducers, and Hereticks. No Love to Persons should equal our Love to the dear and precious Truths of Christ. Those Persons who dare presumptuously and needlesly rush into the Company of Errorists, seem to have either little Love to Truth, or little Sense of their own Weakness. I am apt to think that such Persons would take more Care of their Bodies in a Time of Infection, than they do of their poor Souls. But I proceed to consider the last Thing propos'd, ‘III. To shew why we should hold fast the Truths of Christ.’ And,
1. We ought to do so, because it is the Command of God, in the Text, which I am now considering: And elsewhere, the Lord enjoins us by his sovereign Authority, to hold fast the Form of sound Words, 2 Tim. 1.3. To contend earnestly for the Faith which was once delivered to the Saints, Jud. 3. To catch the Foxes, the little Foxes that spoil the Vines, because the Vines have tender Grapes, Cant. 2.15. To beware of false Prophets, and Wolves in Sheeps cloathing, Mat. 7.15. To beware of the Leaven of the Pharisees, Math. 16.6.
2. Truth is the Foundation of all practical Goodness. It is the Mean (1) of our Illumination: the Psalmist observed that God's Word was a Light to his Feet and a Lamp to his Path. (2) of our Sanctification: Sanctify them thro' thy Truth, thy Word is Truth. 1 Pet. 1.22. Seeing ye have purifyed your Souls in obeying the Truth, thro' the Spirit. [Page 57] (3) of our Consolation. Psal. 119.50. This is my Comfort in my Affliction, for thy Word hath quickned me. The sweet Truths of God's Word are the Fountain of our Comfort, and Foundation of our Hopes. Persons do grow in Grace just as in the Knowlege of Truth; and hence we are bid to grow in Grace, and in the Knowlege of our Lord Jesus Christ. Whatever Persons may imagine or pretend, in Respect of their Frames and Comforts, if they grow more dark and ignorant as to the Knowlege of Truth, we have no Reason to think, if they have any Grace, that they grow in it; but rather that they go backward: and if their Errors be many and fundamental, its probable they are under a Delusion of the Devil.
3. We should remember and hold fast the Truths of Christ, because of their Author and Tendency. God the Father is the God of Truth: The Son of God is the Way, the Truth and the Life: The holy Spirit is a Spirit of Truth: The Law of God is Truth and Righteousness: The Gospel is a Gospel of Truth, it is stil'd emphatically the Truth. The Children of God are Children of Truth; Children that won't Lie: The Promises and Threatnings of the Word are true as Truth it self; they are harmonious, firm and stedfast. Now the Tendency of Truth is to conform us to the God of Truth, who is its Parent and great Original. And is not this our highest Honour, and our greatest Interest?
4. Such as do not love the Truth, are in Danger of Delusion and Damnation. 2 Thes. 2.9, 10, 11, 12. Even him whose coming is after the working of Satan, with all Power and Signs and lying Wonders, and with all deceivableness of Unrighteousness in them that perish; because they received not the Love of the Truth that they might be saved; and for this Cause God shall send them strong Delusion, that they should believe a Lie, that they all might be damned, who believed not the Truth, but had Pleasure in Unrighteousness. Observe, my dear Brethren, that when Satan the Father of Error and Lies, draws People from the Truth, there is a Power attends his Workings, and that his Instruments carry on the Affairs of his Kingdom with great Deceit.
[Page 58]5. We should hold fast the Truth, because it is a Fruit of the Spirit, Eph. 5.5. It is mentioned to the Reproach of some, that they made Ship-wreck of Faith, and turned from the Truth to Fables, 1 Tim. 1.19. 1 Tim. 1.4, 6.
When Persons fall from the Truths of Christ, they shew a childish Weakness and Fickleness. Children are fond of new Things, of Things that look bright, tho' they be of little Value; their Tinsels and Toys, are in their Opinion great Riches. Thus young Novices in Christianity, who are just beginning the Christian Course, ignorant in a great Measure as to Christian Principles, but full of Affection and Self-conceit, when a Moravian comes among them, sets down a while, and looks very harmless and innocent and sober, gives some Smiles, and talks about the Blood of Christ, in their mystical Way; and of Love, Love!— O brave! How are they taken with it directly, as a Child with a Rattle! His very simple loving Looks, make them think he is almost an Angel. O what a fine Man is this! O the reformed Churches are not fit to be mentioned in the same Day with this fine new Sect! They grow weary of the old stale Truths of the Reformation, they want to change their Principles almost as fast as their Almanacks; with the Athenians they must have something new.
Such who change their Principles for the worse, bring great Dishonour upon God's Name, as well as Grief to his People, and Injury to his Kingdom. O it causes the holy Name of God to be blasphemed, when Persons who are either really or apparently religious, turn with every Blast, and soon suffer themselves to be smil'd out of their Religion! And those who are enabled of pure Grace to adhere to the dear and precious Truths of Christ in a Time of Temptation and Apostacy, O it covers their Faces with Shame, and fills their Hearts with Grief, to behold those with whom they were won't to take sweet Counsel, herding with Hereticks and Enthusiasticks, and turning Fugitives from the Truths and Camp of Christ! Tell it not in Gath, publish it not in the Streets of Askelon, lest the Daughters of the Philistines rejoyce, the Daughters of the Uncircumcised triumph, and [Page 59] say, thus would we have it? Saints are hereby stumbled, and Sinners prejudiced, and the Ways of Zion mourn.
6. By holding fast the Truths of Christ, we shall prove that we are living Members of the Church militant; which is called the Pillar and Ground of Truth, 1 Tim. 3.15. And elsewhere it is said concerning some, who lived in the apostolick Times, that they went out from them, because they were not of them. And hence it is said that Heresies must needs come, that those that are approved may be made manifest. For indeed it shews a weak Head, or a false Heart, or violent Temptations of the Devil, to be suddenly tossed about with every Wind of Doctrine, by the Slight and Craftiness of those that lie in wait to deceive. By speaking the Truth from our Hearts, we shew our selves to be Members of the Church triumphant. Psal. 15.2. By cleaving to the Truths of God, we shew our selves to be guided by the Spirit of God; for he is promised to lead the People of God into all Truth: And hence he is called the Spirit of Truth, Joh. 14.17.
7. Methinks the Sufferings and Blood af the innumerable Army of Martyrs, in Testimony to Truth, should inspire us with a holy Magnanimity and unshaken Stedfastness of Resolution, to suffer the Loss of every Thing that is naturally dear to us, rather than forsake the dear and precious Truths of the blessed Jesus. Let us behold the Cloud of Witnesses, that have gone before us; those heroick brave and gallant Souls, in Defence of precious, precious, precious Truth, have swam thro' a Sea of Sorrows, of Sufferings, and of Blood, to their Father's Kingdom. Away, away then with that accursed Indifferency, and Lukewarmness, about Christ's precious Truths, which some do falsely call Charity and Catholicism! Let us rise up and plead the Cause of Truth, and defend it to our dying Breath. The more others do trample upon Truth, the more let us esteem and value it; the more dear let it be to our very Souls. O let us stoop down, and with the humblest Reverence, and most passionate affectionate Affection, let us take this inestimably valuable Jewel out of the Dirt, and put it in our inmost Bosoms!
[Page 60]
REFLECTIONS.
From what has been said we should be induced to examine our selves, as to our Respect to Truth, and the Influence it has upon us. It signifies little, my Brethren, to profess Regard and Love to Holiness, while Truth, precious Truth is slighted. It is a childish Weakness, to call it no worse; it is a beginning at the wrong End of Religion; it is just as if a Man should shew great Regard to the Superstructure of a House, and neglect the Foundation. What signify fair Shews of Love and Holiness, without Truth for their Foundation? They are only Blinds to deceive the Simple, Rattles to please Children.
It is a plain Sign of an enthusiastical and deluding Spirit, to slight that precious System of Truths, which we have laid before us, in a most plain consistent and excellent Manner, in our Westminster-Confession of Faith, and Catechisms; among which we see a strong Connection, and charming Harmony; and in which, if we are not blinded with Ignorance or Prejudice, we may perceive a transcendent Beauty, a direct Tendency to exalt all the Honours of the divine Attributes, to humble the Pride of Man, and conform him to the Deity, in universal Goodness and Holiness: There Vice, of every Kind & Form, is justly represented in its own native Dress of Horror and Meanness: There sincere Holiness is fix'd upon it's proper and impregnable Basis; and open'd in it's vast Extent and attractive Magnificence, and encourag'd with all proper pertinent and powerful Incentives: There the Creatures Crown is cast at the dear Redeemer's Feet, and all the Glory of it's Happiness, ascrib'd to the Mediation of our great Immanuel: There the astonishing Beauties of the pure, free, sovereign, rich, inexhaustible and glorious Grace of God, are unvail'd, in a consistency with the Creatures Duty; so as hereby to establish the Interests of Vertue and Piety, upon the most prevailing and ingenuous Motives! Now I say to slight such a blessed Self-consistent System of Principles, and in the Room thereof, under a Pretence of Holiness in a superior Degree, to introduce a Bundle of inconsistent Jargon, Contradictions, [Page 61] Nonsense, and damnable Errors; Errors that affect the very Foundations of Religion, both in Doctrine and Practice;— is it not vile Enthusiasm, and detestable Delusion?
Certainly the Case of such who have known the Truths of Christ, and turn from them to Vanity, Lies, and Nonsense, is more inexcusable, than of those who have been breed up in Ignorance. O what a foolish Choice do they make, in bartering away the finest Gold for the basest Dross? What unaccountable Ingratitude do such express to the great and good God, for all the religious Privileges & Means of Improvement they have had? They turn their Backs upon the unsullied Snow, and sacred Sweets of Lebanon, and pursue after poisonous Streams and muddy Waters.
To pretend to introduce into one Communion, all that have an Appearance of Experience, Affection, and Piety, without searching into their main Principles, without a Concurrence in them (as I have Reason to think the Moravians do) is to build Babel over again, and promote the Confusion of Languages.
It cannot be reasonably expected, that such a confus'd Medley, such a heterogeneous Mixture will stand long, for it has no solid Foundation to stand upon. To pretend to promote Love and Union, by concealing our Principles and lessening our Regard to Truth, is to do Evil that Good may come. Indeed it is the direct Road to Division and Contention; and this the Event proves. To love Persons in a general View as Christians, without due Respect had to their main peculiar Principles, is an unreasonable childish Passion, more sit for Children and Simpletons, than for Men of Understanding. For, as Solomon observes, the simple Man believes every Word, Prov. 14.15. A pretended Union without a System of Principles acknowledged, is rather a Confederacy, than a scriptural Union. It is infinitely more candid, to let others freely know our Scheme of Principles, that so they may judge of them; and in Things of smaller Moment, to use Moderation and Forbearance; and to make no more Terms of Communion, than Christ himself has [Page 62] fixed. Any other Union is neither rational, nor desirable, and deserves not the Name of Union.
But the Moravian Concealment of their pernicious Principles, seems to be a Fulfilment of St. Peter's Prophesy, concerning false Teachers, that they should privily (or covertly) bring in damnable Heresies. Plutarch's Story of a Boy that carried something under his Cloak, may be applied to them. The Boy was asked by a Stranger, What it was he carried so closely under his Cloak? To whom the Boy answered, you may well know, that it is something I don't intend you shall know, by so carrying it. All Religion that is worth a reasonable Man's Choice is gone, when Truth is gone. All that is left is childish Fancy, enthusiastical Folly, and painted Pageantry.
For any Men to pretend to know certainly who are gracious, as one of the Moravians did in my hearing, is to assume an incommunicable Prerogative of God: and to run upon this false Plan in Church-Matters, is to turn all into the wildest Disorder and Confusion.
Methinks the Consideration of the Truths of God, may justly alarm the Secure and Impenitent, and excite them to fly from Sin to God, and humble themselves before him, and seek his Favour; seeing that all the Threats of God are pointed at them like so many burning Thunderbolts, which the Truth of God will oblige him to discharge at them, except Repentance intercept the falling Blow. All the Examples of the divine Severity against the Impenitent, which are recorded in both the Testaments, are shocking Momentos to a secure World!
But let all devout Souls, who have felt the proper Influence of Truth upon their own Hearts and Practices, and still retain a Regard thereto, Rejoyce. Go on, my dear Brethren, in the blessed V [...] of Truth, and ye shall receive a Crown at last! The Consideration of God's blessed Truths may support you, in all Manner of Distresses, whither it be by Persecution from open or covert Enemies, or misguided Friends. The God of Truth, whose Cause you plead, will sooner or later comfort your Hearts, and crown you with Protection, and Songs of Deliverance.
[Page 63]It is true, Enthusiasts and Errorists themselves will talk of Persecution; but it is not the Punishment, but the Cause that makes a Martyr. Those that suffer for Error, suffer for Sin, and not for God. Blessed be Jehovah, that so many in the Land, have a Regard to the dear and precious Truths of Christ! O may God increase their Number, their Zeal, and their Love!
The Consideration of the Truths of Christ, yields sweet Support under Temptation, Desertion, and every other Calamity. God is faithful who has promised to relieve his People, and able also, as well as willing and gracious. He has given many Examples of his Kindness this Way in Times past; yea, he has confirmed the Truth of his Promises, by an Oath, that we might have strong Consolation. The Truths of God are firmer than the Foundations of Mountains. They are try'd in the Fire seven Times. The Heavens and Earth may and shall pass away, but the Truths of God shall stand stedfast to all Generations. We may lean the Weight of our everlasting Salvation upon the Truth of the least Promise of God. Indeed Brethren, it will never fail us.
He that hath an Ear to hear, let him hear the Command of our Lord, viz. to beware of false Prophets, who shall come unto you in Sheep's cloathing, but inwardly they are ravening Wolves. This Scripture (in my Opinion) is justly applicable to the Moravian Brethren. They have a Sheep's Coat on, they seem to be mighty mild, harmless and innocent in their Looks, but inwardly they hold dividing dangerous [...] Principles: You may know them by their Fruits, like Wolves they cruelly scatter the poor Sheep of Christ, by their damnable Doctrines. Beware, my dear Brethren, of the Leaven, the false infectious Doctrine of those Moravians, who like the Pharisees of old, are proud Seperatists, make broad Philacteries, and compass Sea and Land to make Proselytes. Some of which, become seven-fold worse, if possible, than themselves.
Beware of the Depths of Satan, Rev. 2.24. Observe (says Mr. Henry) that these Seducers, call'd their Doctrines Depths, Mysteries, perswading the People that they had a deeper Insight into the Mysteries of Religion than others, [Page 64] but Christ calls them Depths of Satan, a Mystery of Iniquity. To talk of increasing Love to Christ, in uncouth Terms, respecting his Wounds, while Truth is abandoned as a Fugitive, is ridiculous Giberish; for Christ is the Way, the Truth, and the Life. To talk of a Simplicity, which consists in real Folly, in believing Contradictions, in tamely yielding up Christ's precious Truths, because of the superficial Appearances of seducing Strangers, is very unaccountable: What is this Simplicity, but the detestable Doctrine of the Roman Catholicks, new vaump'd by the Moravians? who are as subtle a Sect of People, and that under a Pretence of Simplicity, as has appeared on the Stage of the World for many Years.
I can't but think, and that from some particular Knowlege of the Conduct of some of them, that they fall far short of many other Enthusiasts, in Candor and Honesty. Watch therefore, my dear Brethren, stand fast in the Faith, quite you like Men, be strong. O be not as Children tossed to and fro with every Wind of Doctrine, by the Craftiness of those who lie in wait to deceive. Away with those sorry Shews of Zeal, Piety and Meekness, which have not Truth and Humility for their Foundation. May the God of Truth graciously baffle all the crafty Schemes, and coloured Intrigues, of all schismatical, enthusiastical and deceitful Babel-builders! who under the Mask of Humility and Love, declare their Pride and Enmity in separating from the Protestant reformed Churches, and in despising and tearing of them in Pieces, as far and as fast as they can. Who that has got the least Spark of Love to the God of Truth, can be altogether tame and silent upon so mournful an Occasion, and patiently suffer the carved Work of the Temple to be pull'd down by proud Seperatists? Was not Meroz cursed, because he did not come up to the Help of the Lord against the Mighty? What, my Brethren, shall we thro' base Indifferency, let those dear and amiable Truths, which have cost our Ancestors Blood, slip away by Moravian Hands? God forbid! Let us awake, my Brethren, out of stupid Indolence, and sordid Lukewarmness, and with humble, impregnable Fortitude, contend for the Faith once delivered to the Saints!
[Page 65]But pray, why do any esteem this new upstart Moravian Sect? Is it,
1. For their Shew of Meekness and Harmlessness? But may not Persons, under this Guise, have cruel Designs and Dispositions? Don't our Lord tell us, that Wolves shall come in Sheeps Cloathing? And what is this Sheeps Cloathing, but a Covert of Meekness and Harmlessness? But what Evidence have we that the Moravians are really meek, when we see them not exposed to Temptations? They generally shun Debate, which would try their Meekness: but if any of them happen to be try'd a little, they shew their Weakness as much as other People. Besides, it ought to be considered, that there is a threefold Meekness, viz. 1. Natural; springing from a natural Temper of a milder Mould. 2. Moral; proceeding principally from selfish Considerations; these two are of little Moment. And 3. There is a sinful Meekness; that is, when Persons are Lukewarm about God's Truths, as the Moravians are. But while the Moravians cover themselves with a Sheep-Skin, like cruel Wolves they scatter the poor Sheep of Christ. Like Foxes they craftily and sneakingly creep into the Vineyard, and spoil the tender Grapes with their detestable Delusions. How very different are the Fruits of their coming into this Country, from the Reverend Mr. WHITEFIELD'S? His plain and pungent Preaching of the Truths of the Reformation, united generally the Hearts of good Men thro' the Land. But the Moravians where-ever they have any Influence, divide the People of God, and set them a jangling.
How very different are these Men from the Spirit of Luther, whom they pretend a Respect to. He was so zealous for Truth, that he expressed himself thus, respecting it, viz. That Madness was better than Mildness in the Cause of God: Rather, said he, let Heaven and Earth rush together, than one Crumb of Truth should perish. Potius Caelum et Terra ruerent, quam una mica veritatis periret. Or,
2. Is it because they smile generally, and appear loving? But, Brethren, is not this Judas-like, to betray us with a Kiss? For while they shew such Love, they draw pious People into Error, and so set them a quarelling with one [Page 66] another. If this be their Love, may the good Lord deliver us from it! Shall we suffer them to smile us out of our Principles? Then I'm sure we are poorly grounded in them. Away, away with such sordid Complyance!
3. Is it because they profess they are Catholick, or against all Sectarianism? This is indeed a most subtle Devise: for while they talk so, they are busily making a new Sect; and those that join with it, how ever ignorant, erroneous, or dark in Experience they be, they are presently esteemed and caressed, while all others who will not join with them, how knowing and experienced soever they be in Christianity, are despised. Besides, as I am informed, they will join with no Church but their own. Or,
4. Is it because of their Shew of Humility, while in the mean Time they undervalue all but themselves? Some of the Heads of that Party, have spoken most reproachfully in New-Brunswick of all the Protestant reformed Churches. One of them in my hearing compared them to Babel. Is this Humility, to imagine themselves more advanced in Grace, than all the World besides? I'm sure, it's of a different Stamp from that of the Apostle Paul, who look'd upon himself to be less than the least of all Saints. And those whom they proselyte, in the midst of their ignorant Zeal, betray horrible Arrogance, in proudly disdaining all the Churches of Christ when compared with their Sect.
5. Is it because they have the Appearance of great Mortification? I answer, their Mortification is not agreable to the Scriptures; because they are ignorant of a preparatory Work of the Law. If we may believe Count Zinzendorf, when they are converted in their Way, they are free from Complaints of Sin and Struggles with it, and so get into a Sleep. What is this but the Fruit of Blindness & Delusion? To the Law and to the Testimony: if they speak not according thereto, it is because there is no Light in them. Or,
6. Is it because they say they have Communion with God, and in Consequence hereof Joy and Sweetness? I answer; When we consider the Antinomian Principles they hold, concerning Faith and Justification, as well as the proud Effects of their pretended good Frames, and that under a Mask of [Page 67] Humility; as also their denial of a Law-Work; We have great Reason to suspect their Communion to be but a Delusion of the grand Enemy, and their Joys to be the Joys of Time-Believers, and Stony-Ground Hearers. See Heb. 6.4. True Communion with God does certainly humble the Soul. Isai. 6.4. Job 42.5, 6. It's no new Thing for Antinomians and Enthusiasts to talk of Joys and Comforts. The old Antinomians were won't to commend their Principles to others by this, that they were an experienced Cure to all Soul-Trouble. And it's true enough, they are a Cure, but a false one.
The Moravians, with their Brethren the Antinomians, and other Enthusiasts, seem to forget both the Doctrine and Practice of Repentance. I don't remember to find any thing of it in the Count's Sermons, neither can I perceive any thing of it in their Practice. But why should they repent, while they pretend to Perfection? No, no; they have got above that in their own Conceit. Now seeing their Comforts don't come after the Exercise of Repentance for Sin, have we not Reason to suspect them?
7. Is it because they travel and take great Pains? I answer, Did not the Pharisees of old compass Sea and Land, to make one Proselyte; and when he was made, was he not twofold more a Child of Hell than themselves? And do not Jesuits, and many other Enthusiasts, travel still? But what Good do the Moravians do by their travelling, unless it be good, to sow Tares, to corrupt and divide religious People? Or what Good can reasonably be expected from Persons, who reject the [...]aw of God, and think it not their Duty to make Application to unconverted Persons in a State of Security, either to alarm or direct them. See the Count's Sermons, Pages 69, 70.
But they are deny'd to the World. Ans. So was Diogenes in his Time. So were the false Teachers in Paul's Time, who try'd to Reproach him. 2 Cor. 11.12. And do not the begging Friars among the Papists, as also their Monks and Nuns, give up all their worldly Goods? Peter seems to boast of their leaving all for Christ, Mat. 19.27. But did not Judas do this, as well as the rest? Did not Ananias [Page 68] and Saphira put the chief of their Estate into a common Treasury, for the Maintenance of others? Acts 5. And this they did freely, for there was no Necessity laid on them to sell their Possession. Acts 5.4.
Plato and Josephus relate of the Essenes, a superstitious Sect among the Jews, not much better than the Pagans, that they contemned the World; they were not only exceeding abstemious as to sensual Pleasures, but so far despis'd Riches, that none was admitted into their Society till he had parted with all his Possessions.
Yea, many of the Pagans contemned Wealth, particularly among the Lacedemonians. It is reported of Phocion, who was forty five Times chosen Governour of Athens, and had thereby the greatest Opportunity to enrich himself, that he lived in a State of voluntary Poverty: when Alexander offered him a Donation of nineteen Thousand Pounds value, and besides his Choice of one of the four Cities of Asia, for his constant Support, he refused both. Epaminondas, the brave Theban General, in the midst of Opportunities to enrich himself, liv'd so meanly, that he had but one Coat; so that when that was sent to the Fullers, he was oblig'd to keep at Home till it was brought back. Many more Instances of the like Nature, might be added; but these at present may suffice.
But methinks, my dear Brethren; the Consideration of that glorious State, which the Sons of Truth shall be introduced into, after a few Moments expire; should invite them to be earnest in Defence thereof against all Seducers, and patient in enduring their unjust Reproaches. After a few Moments more are elapsed, the Children of Truth shall walk with God in White, in a Robe of Honour, in a State of Blessedness. I say, they shall walk in the Galleries of Paradise, and drink the Streams of Nectar and Ambrosia. There all Sighing and Sorrow will for ever expire; and in Place thereof shall succeed the greatest, sweetest, surest, most satisfactory, and sinless Joys. There Reproach, Error and Contest will be for ever banished; and pure Truth, unfading. Honour, and uninterrupted Rest, take Place thereof!
[Page 69]The Children of Truth (such who have experienced its Energy, and walk'd according to its Direction) shall carry Crowns of Victory upon their Heads, and Palms of Honour in their Hands!
There Impurity and Sin will not be so much as mentioned!
There the eternal God will be beheld, in all the dazling Glory of his Attributes, in all the shining Charms of his Word and Works!
There the dear Redeemer will be admir'd, and adored, by all the Hosts of Heaven; while they attentively view his mediatorial orient transcendent Excellency!
There the Understanding will be pleas'd, with the noblest Entertainments, of the sublimest Knowlege, attain'd with Ease, and to the utmost Perfection!
There the pure Springs of Truth will be fully open'd and run in liquid and incessant Rivulets, thro' all the Paradise of God: The Understanding shall no more be clouded with Ignorance, or tainted with Mistake!
There the Will shall be satisfy'd, with enjoying the supream Good!
There the noble Soul of Man in all-its Powers, will be freed from its present Clogs and Incumbrances, which obscure its Views, obstruct its Peace, and retard its Motions!
There it will expand all its Wings, and embrace a Good suited to its spiritual Nature, noble Original, vast Desires, and incessant Duration!
There the eternal God will be worshipped in the perfection of Beauty, without Sin and without Uneasiness: No discording Sound shall ever be heard from the Harps of those heavenly Choristers!
There the inferiour Passions of the Soul, shall ever keep their proper Channel, and observe due Degrees of Motion!
There the original Beauty, and ancient Harmony, that adorn'd the Soul, before its fatal Fall from God, shall be restor'd to the highest Perfection; and that which is in Part shall be done away.
There no Fear of any impending Evil or Calamity, shall ever perplex, disturb or distress the pious Bosom: No, they [Page 70] shall be fully assur'd of the perpetual Continuance of the divine Favour; a pleasing Calm and undisturbed Serenity, shall still possess the Soul, without Murmur or Uneasiness!
There no erroneous Sentiments, no ungenerous Jealousies, shall stain the Beauty, interrupt the Pleasure, or mar the Harmony of Society; neither of these shall have any Access to, or Residence in that Seat of Truth and Purity, of Love and Peace!
There Temptations shall come to a perpetual End; that envious and malignant Spirit shall no more sully our Innocence, or disturb our Peace, by his Temptations which will then cease for evermore: What amazing Sweetness, must issue from the View of the divine Attributes? When the Vail which now intercepts our Sight is removed, and they appear in their native Charms, their open'd Oriency and Lustre! If the smallest Glimpse of one of the divine Perfections, sometimes transports the Soul into Extasy and Ravishment, what will the immediate uninterrupted and united View of them all, effect! O the inexpressible Blessedness of the Glorify'd!
What endearing Sentiments of Soul must inspire the Children of Truth, while they behold the enthroned Jesus array'd with the brightest Majesty, and most awful Glory; while they see the Signatures of his dying Love, and recount the Labours of his Life, and Sorrows of his Soul for them!
O when they revolve in their Minds the humble and astonishing Stoop of condescending Majesty, in the whole of our Lord's Humiliation, with the gracious Design thereof, how deeply will it affect their Hearts, that he who was the Sovereign of the World, should come in the Form of a Servant, that we might be made the Sons of God; that he who was Rich should become Poor, that we thro' his Poverty might be made Rich; that the Chastisement of our Peace was laid upon him, that thro' his Stripes we might be healed!
There the Contrivance of the gracious Covenant will be perfectly laid open, wherein the harmonious Display of God's venerable Attributes has appeared to the Astonishment of the angelick Throng, who stoop down to behold the unsearchable [Page 71] Depths of divine Grace in the Redemption of Mankind by the Blood and Obedience of the Lord Jesus Christ! Herein Wisdom devis'd a Way to satisfy divine Justice, and yet save the guilty Criminals from merited Destruction. So that Justice can demand no more, and Mercy is cloathed with a Coat of Arras, vested with stately Charms, and attractive Magnificence.
There the Works of Nature and Depths of Providence will be fully unfolded, to the equal Astonishment and Delight of all the Inhabitants of Heaven. The secret Springs, the strong Connection, and sweet Relation of Providences, with their Conduciveness to compass one uniform noble Design, namely, the manifestative Glory of God, and in subordination thereto, the special and enduring Good of his People, will be discovered!
Here sometimes the great God makes Darkness his Pavilion, and hides the Face of his Throne; his Footsteps are in the great Deep, and we cannot sound the Depths of his providential Actings by the Line of our shallow Reason but the End will crown the Scene, beautify the whole Piece, and magnify the Glory of it's Author.
There will be no Objects of Misery, on Account of Error in Principle, or Impiety in Practice, to invite our sympathetick Tears and Sorrows; no Allay of Grief or Pain to disturb our incessant Felicity!
There our Father's Face will never be hid from us any more, by a gloomy Desertion; but we shall without Interruption and Period, enjoy the bright Meridian of his Love, which is better than Life it self!
There no Diversity of Sentiment shall mar the Sweets of social Worship, but unallay'd Harmony and inimitable Beauty, shall ever adorn the Courts above, and bless those calm Regions of Light, of Life, of Day!
But indeed all Words and Images of Thought, even of the boldest and most exalted Kind, saint before the Paradise of God, and cannot convey sufficient Ideas of it.
[Page 72]O may the great and gracious God, the God of Truth, direct us into the Paths of Truth and Holiness, and keep us by his Grace in them here, until our destin'd Time is elaps'd, and then translate us into his own Kingdom of Glory and Blessedness, thro' Jesus Christ our Lord,
AMEN!
Here the Count asserts, that the Saints are poor and needy in Heaven.
Here Perfection is asserted. It's likewise suppos'd in this Paragraph, that God is not the Author of that Holiness which is in his People.
Here Perfection is deny'd. A new Purgatory discover'd. And Sin asserted to be something material.
Perfection asserted.
[Page 79]Perfection.
Persons not rejected for Sin, but Unbelief: Here its insinuated, that Unbelief is no Sin; and yet the Cause of Rejection.
Gross Impiety the directest Road to obtain Grace & Mercy.
Sin no Hindrance, and moral Vertue of no Service, to obtain Grace.
Free-will asserted.
Universal Salvation asserted.
Spiritual Sloth necessary in order to obtain Grace.
Enthusiasm encouraged, in a pretended waiting upon the Voice of God, without the Use of Means.
[Page 80]Those no Witnesses of Christ, who urge the Use of Means, in order to obtain Grace.
A preparatory Work ambiguously and slily denied.
The active Obedience of Christ excluded from being a Cause of Salvation. The Moravians speak much of the Blood and Wounds of Christ, but as to his active Obedience they are silent.
Christ a Propitiation for Sins after Death. Here the Salvation of the Damned, is insinuated.
The actual Justification of all, from the Time of Christ's Death.
[Page 81]A preparatory Work unnecessary.
A preparatory Work necessary.
A preparatory Work, ordinarily, unnecessary.
Universal Salvation, expresly asserted.
Immediate Inspiration insinuated.
Holiness no Duty.
The Law the Cause of Sin.
Such whose Contest with Sin Paul speaks in the seventh of the Romans, no true Christians.
[Page 82]Perfection attained by all true Christians.
A Conquest over Sin easy; for such as get their Necks out of the Collar of the Law.
Free-will asserted.
To be a Minister of Christ, an easy Task.
Preparatory Studies, unnecessary for Ministers.
The Priests Lips must keep Knowlege; yet, teaching was no Part of their Office!
Inspiration ambiguously asserte.
[Page 83]The Use of Means necessary.
An Election at the Time of Christ's Death. Eternal Election incompleat. Something besides the good Pleasure of God, the Cause of Election. Eternal Justification insinuated.
That historical Faith is saving.
The Perfection of the Saints; or Christ's Imperfection asserted.
No Means to be used with the Unconverted, either to instruct or awaken 'em. Natural Men can have no true Knowledge of our Saviour.
[Page 84]Natural Men must not be condemned.
Ministers must not preach Terror.
Pagans free from the Curse seemingly insinuated.
All of the Threatnings and Exhortations of the New-Testament, not applicable to the present Times.
The Threatnings applicable to formal Christians only.
[Page 85]Original Corruption taken away by Baptism.
The falling away of the Saints.
Persons may be really sanctified, and yet not love the Lord Jesus Christ, suppos'd by this Paragraph.
Full Assurance universally necessary to Salvation.
Assurance easy to be attained.
Those that want Assurance, under the Curse.
The Nature of Assurance, that it is no more than a common Conviction.
All pious Persons compleatly happy in this Life!
Universal Redemption asserted.
[Page 86]No Means must be used with the Unconverted, to convince them of their Misery.
The Law no Mean of Conviction under the Gospel.
The Blood of Christ the Mean of Conviction.
Convinced Persons are spiritually alive: and at the same Time condemned and dead.
Persons lost, condemned, & that have no Part in the Kingdom of God, are found, and converted; O horrible Jargon!
[Page 87]A Person under Conviction, is a Child of God.
The Saviour pays a Ransom in Time, f [...] People under Conviction. This invalidates the Sufficiency of Christ's Satisfaction on the Cross.
Conviction necessary in order to receive Grace, and Benefit by the Gospel. Sound Doctrine.
Universal Redemption asserted; and, Universal Salvation insinuated.
The Guilt of original Sin removed from all, by the Redeemer's Sufferings.
The popish Doctrine of the Sacraments conferring Grace, from the Work done.
[Page 88]The Saints falling from Grace insinuated.
A new Explication of original Sin; as mysterious as Jacob Bemy's, Tincture and Turba.
Daily sinning surprizing to the Moravians!
The Cause thereof is the Law of God!
The Gospel takes away the Force of the Law.
The Gospel turns the Soul from Ordinances, to the Heart, the Unction &c. This looks like the Light within as a Guide.
'As oft as there is 'Opportunity.
Mysterious Jargon!
Perfection again asserted.
[Page 89]Whoremongers and Murderers must believe that their Ransom is paid, and their Wounds healed.
Presumption encouraged, as the Way to Salvation!
Perfection asserted in the most peremptory Manner.
Perfection asserted.
Free-will asserted.
The Conflict mentioned in the seventh of the Romans, belongs to Philosophers and Pharisees.
[Page 90]An Insinuation against the Use of Reason and Pains in opposing of Sin.
Here the Man after God's own Heart is condemned, as a Servant of Sin, because of his Desertion and Temptation!
To strive against Sin exceeding dangerous.
Moravian Perfection easy to be attained.
The horrible Mystery of the Moravian Gospel, is to cast God's holy Law behind their Backs!
[Page 91]Moravian Converts quite free from Satan's Temptations!
The Moravian Life, no State of spitual War; but a Life of Quietism or Rest.
Moravian Converts spiritual Sleepers.
Young Converts, in a State of compleat Happiness, and Rest.
Moravian Converts at their new Birth, Men in Christ.
It's a Sign of no Grace, to think that Persons at their Conversion, are but Babes in Grace; and do sin sometimes.
[Page 92]Moravian Converts past all Danger.
Moravian Converts free from Sin at their Conversion.
If Sin be not worth a Thought, what becomes of Repentance?
Moravian Mortification of Sin exceeding easy!
A Moravian Convert is once exposed to the Temptations of Satan, but obtains an easy Conquest.
Perfection asserted.
A Difference between a Child of God, and a Soldier of Christ.
Sin easily conquer'd.
Sin not worth the Cast of the Eye, how then shall we mourn over it?
Imperfection asserted.
[Page 93]A physical Energy ascrib'd to Baptism, which may be lost.
The active Obedience of Christ past over in the Moravian Instructions.
The Use of Means rejected, and a Door opened to Licentiousness.
Here one that is spiritually alive, is said to be sensible of his lost State, if he does not acknowledge &c.
Here it is suppos'd that one may be spiritually alive, and hear Christ's Voice, & yet not acknowlege Christ to be his Lord and Master.
Wholesome Doctrine against Presumption.
The Law a Mean of Conviction sometime.
[Page 94]A little of the Truth must out sometimes.
Angelical Perfection ordinarily attain'd at Conversion in a Moment.
A good Thought at Death sufficient to obtain Happiness.
The Instance of the Thief not at all extraordinary.
Here's large Encouragement to Sin and Impenitency.
Ministers may not use the civil Law, to acquire their Right.
Moravian Ministers not subject to the Law.
[Page 95]A Difference between Ministers and others, in respect of civil Rights asserted.
Ministers may neither demand or possess, their civil Rights, suppos'd by this Paragraph.
Two sorts of Persons among the Moravians, who have no systematical Connexion of the revealed Word.
Two sorts of Moravian Converts, not led by the written Word.
[Page 96]The pious Actions of religious Men do not come from God, as the efficient, but permissive Cause.
In the Moravian Judgment, it's a Dream of Moralists, to look upon Holiness to be a Duty.
Free-will asserted.
Perfection & Perseverance therein asserted.
The first Part of this Paragraph is dark Doctrine.
Perfection asserted.
Increase of the Knowledge of Sin in one's self asserted.
If Sin be quite forgot, what becomes of Repentance?
[Page 97]Perfection asserted.
Moravians loose the Experience of Evil, by the disuse of it, and so become ininnocent.
No spiritual War in good Men.
Perfection asserted.
Moravian Converts not compleatly happy, but perfectly freed from fleshly Lusts.
Some not capable of Grace. God's Call according to foreseen good Dispositions in the Creature. God's Call depends upon the Creatures Will.
The perfect Holiness, and perfect Happiness, of all the Saints in this Life asserted. The Word Fellow-Citizens alludes to Ephes. 2.19.
No Duty but to believe.
[Page 98]Sincerity, Charity, Humility &c. no Duties, under the Gospel Dispensation!
We need not be sollicitous about any Thing, besides Faith, viz. Charity, Chastity, Repentance!
Here a dismal Door is opened, to all Manner of Licentiousness!
Faith asserted to be the only Mean to effect Faith. Nonsense, and Gibberish!
To say that any Thing is a Mean to produce it self; supposes that it exists before it has a being: which is impossible in the Nature of Things.