OF THE Antiquity, Tradition, and Succession, of Mystical Divinity Among the GENTILES, FROM THE Testimony & Confession OF AN Eminent Adversary.
AS Adam was the common Parent of all Man-kind from the Creation, so was Noah the common Parent of all Man-kind who have lived since the Flood. And of Noah it is recorded, that he was a just Man, and perfect in his Generations, and that he walked with God, Gen. 6.9. And that he was 600 years Old when the Flood of Waters was upon the [Page 2]Earth, Gen. 7.6. From whence we may reasonably believe that he could not but be well acquainted with all the Knowledge of his Ancestors. And what this Walking with God doth imply, we may understand from the rest of the History, and the Apostles Observation, Heb. 11.7. viz. not only a careful Observance of all the General Rules of Righteousness transmitted from Adam to his Posterity, but a ready Obedience and Conformity to all special Declarations and Manifestations of the Will of God to him. Instances of which are those Commands of God, and his Obedience thereunto; in Building the Ark, which undoubtedly exposed him to much trouble, by Questions concerning it, and to various Censures, Gen. 6.14, 22. He did, notwithstanding, according to all that God commanded him, so did he; and in going into it with the several sorts of Creatures, Gen. 7.1, 5, 7, 9. and in going out again at the Command of God, Gen. 8.16, 18. In his Walking with God in this manner, he could not but, besides all the Knowledge which he had received from his Ancestors, learn much more by the immediate Teachings of God. And it is not to be questioned, but, as he was instructed by his Ancestors, so he was careful to instruct his Family & Posterity in all necessary Knowledge; amongst which, that of Walking with God was some of the chief. And this being so, I see no reason, [Page 3]Why other Nations should not have derived their Knowledge, with their Descent, directly from Noah? or, Why we should suppose the other Branches of his Posterity to have all received their Knowledge, of Divine and Sacred things especially, collaterally from that of Abraham, rather than directly and lineally from their common Ancestor Noah. As Noah offered Sacrifice, Gen. 8.20. and Abraham offered Sacrifice; so we find Priests and Sacrifices among other Nations. Such was MELCHIZEDECK, a Priest of the most High God, Gen. 14.18. And certainly it was by Revelation from God, or some Divine Means, that PHARAOH understood that it was because of Sarah, Abraham's Wife, that the Lord plagued him and his House, Gen. 12.17. as we find it expressed afterward in the like Case of ABIMELECH, Gen. 20.3, 6. God came to Abimelech in a Dream by Night, and said to him, Behold, thou art but a dead Man, for the Woman which thou hast taken: for she is a Man's Wife. And another PHARAOH acknowledged Joseph to be a Man, in whom was the Spirit of God, Gen. 41.38. and when he raised him to the greatest Preferment in the Kingdom, gave him for a Wife the Daughter of an Egyptian Priest, ibid. v. 45. And Moses Married the Daughter of a Priest of Midian, JETHRO, Ex. 2.16, 21. who was a good Man, and a Worshipper of the true God, [Page 4]as appears, Ex. 18.9, 10, 12. And the Means then to Inquire of the Lord were common to them, and to other Nations: As REBEKAH, Gen. 25.22. So BALAAM, Numb. 22.8, 9, 18, 19, 20: 23.4. went to inquire of the Lord, and received Answers from Him. And about this time JOB is believed to have lived, who was a Holy Man, and offered Sacrifices, and had Visions.
By these Instances, and others that might be noted, we may understand, that in those ancient times it was believed, in all Nations, that there were Means, whereby Men and Women might come to have some Acquaintance and Communication with God; and what these Means were, is well worth our Inquiry.
That the JEWS had anciently their Schools or Colleges of Prophets, we may observe in the Sacred Scriptures. And though what were their Institutions, and their Instructions, and Orders there prescribed, is not in the Scripture particularly related; yet in the Particulars mentioned they seem to have been much the same with what was practised by the Ancient Christian Anchorets and Coenobites.
If we inquire amongst other Nations of most ancient Note and Fame for Knowledge in Divine matters, the Egyptians and Chaldeans are the most considerable. And the Means recommended by them do so well agree with the Mystical Divinity delivered by divers Christians, [Page 5]that some Opposers of this Divinity think they have sufficient ground to derive it from them; and supposing that a Prejudice to it, have taken the pains to do it. ‘If the CHALDAICK ORACLES (saith one of considerable Learning, Name, and Place) were still extant, which were frequently quoted by Plotinus, Jamblicus, Porphyrius, and Proclus, (who did wholly approve the Chaldaick Theology; and from them in a great measure the Fragments were preserved) we might more fully manifest these things; yet as they are, they give us sufficient ground to draw the Fundamentals of this Mystical Divinity from thence. For they speak of God's being united to the Soul, by the Soul's clasping God to herself; and that not by any act of the Ʋnderstanding, but by the Flower of the Mind; (the very Phrase used by Proclus, and the same which the Mysticks call, the Fund of the Spirit;) of the Soul's being inebriated from God, (which Plotinus calls, being drunk with the Divine Nectar) and Psellus explains, of Divine Illuminations and Extasies; of Abstraction from the Body, and extending the Mind upwards, and hastening to the Divine Light and the Beams of the Father; with several other passages to the same purpose.’
And for the EGYPTIANS, the same Author tells us,
That Jamblicus, in his Book [Page 6]of the Egyptian Mysteries, (which he writ in answer to an Epistle of Porphyry to an Egyptian Priest, and wherein Proclus saith that he writ like a Man inspir'd) discourses at large concerning Divine Extasies, and Visions, and Inspirations; in which he describes the Persons just after the Mystical way, as no longer leading a humane Life, or having any Operations of their Senses or Ʋnderstanding, but their Mind and Soul is only in the Divine Power, and not in their own, being acted and possessed wholly by it. Afterward he sets down the several Degrees and Kinds of those; in some, they have only Participation; in others, near Communion; and in the highest of all, Ʋnion. In some of these, he saith, the Body wholly rests, and sometimes breaks out into Singing, and all expressions of Joy: sometimes the Body is raised up from the Ground, (as M. Teresa thought hers) sometimes it swells into a greater bulk, and sometimes the contrary. Then he lays down Rules to know Divine Inspirations by: viz. by Enquiring, In what manner God appears? Whether an appearance of Fire come before Him? Whether he fills up and acts the whole Soul, so that there is a Cessation of all its own Acts? For this he makes the main Character of a Divine Inspiration, that the Persons are wholly taken up and possessed by the Deity; from whence follows an Extasie and alienation of the Senses: But if [Page 7]either the Soul acts, or the Body moves, then, he saith, it may be a false Inspiration. No Man can express himself more emphatically concerning the Excellency of Contemplative Prayer than Jamblicus doth: This quickens the Mind, inlargeth its Capacity, opens the Secrets of the Divinity, and fits it for Conjunction and Ʋnion with God; and never leaves Men till it hath carried them to a State of Perfection; and by degrees doth alter and change Men, that it makes them put off Humane Nature, and bring them into such a State of Dei-formity, that they become Gods. The first degree of Prayer, saith he, brings to a State of Recollection, and hath some Divine Contact, which helps our Knowledge: The second carries the Soul to a nearer Communion with God, and excites the Divine Bounty to freer Communications to it: But the third is the Seal of the ineffable Ʋnion, which makes our Mind & Soul to rest in God, as a Divine Port or Haven. And he concludes his Book with saying, That this Ʋnion with God is Man's greatest Perfection, and the End of all Religion among the Egyptians; whose Mysteries his Design was to explain and vindicate. Many other Passages might be produced out of him, concerning the Knowing of God by Divine Contact, and the Insufficiency of any Act of the Mind for this ineffable Ʋnion: but these are enough to shew how well acquainted Jamblicus [Page 8]and (if we believe him) the Egyptians were with the profoundest Secrets of Mystical Divinity.
There is a Book translated out of Arabick, intituled, Of Divine Wisdom according to the Egyptians, wherein are many things to this purpose; but our Author takes notice but of one passage in it, which he sets down as the Words of Plato. But before we come to Plato, it is fit to be noted, that PYTHAGORAS and the PYTHAGORIANS could not but be well acquainted with this Mystical Theology, though they did not ordinarily deliver it in such express terms; but in a more occult manner. For it is known & confessed,
That Pythagoras himself was from his Youth greatly inclin'd to an Inquisition into Religious Rites and Mysteries: That he travelled into Egypt to hear their Priests, was there 22 Years, had recommendations from the King to the Priests, and was permitted to acquaint himself with all their Learning; entred into the Egyptian Adyta, and was instituted in things unexpressible touching the Gods; gave himself exact Information concerning Persons and Things, not omitting any Person eminent at any time for Learning, or any kind of Religious Rites; or any Place, where he conceived he might find somewhat extraordinary: That he went thence to Babylon, and continued there [Page 9]12 Years, conversed with the most Eminent of the Chaldeans, as also with the Persian Magi, who entertained him very courteously, & gave him insight into their more hidden Mysteries, and Religious Rites; and, without doubt, with the most Eminent for Knowledge of the Jews, in both places; and likely enough, as Selden and others think, with Ezekiel in particular.
That he made Theology, or the Knowledge of God, the First most Universal Being, the Centre of all his Philosophy: That he was by way of Eminency call'd, [...]; and his Philosophy, [...]; because he treated chiefly of God, his Nature and Worship: That he was a great Devoto, or Advocate for God, his Worship, and Sacred Institutes: That the Confederation of his Coenobium (for so they called it) or College, had reference to some Divine Temperament, and to Union with God, and to Unity with the Divine Soul: That the Institutions of his Society and Sect, for the Admission and Probation of Disciples, distinction of Persons, Reverence to their Elders, Celibacie, Communion of Goods, Retirement from the World, &c. were very much the same with those of the Esseans, and the Christian Coenobites afterward: That of the differing Sects afterward none did Pythagorize more than Plato, especially in Divine matters, as Aristotle and Laertius have observed: yea, that the choicest of his Metaphysick [Page 10]Contemplations seem to be traduced from Pythagoras and his Followers: and that Plotinus did more clearly explicate the Principles of the Pythagorick Philosophy, as well as of the Platonick.
And from all this put together, we may very reasonably conclude, especially if we take in what is related by Jamblicus, That he continued 3 days and 2 nights, at one time, in the same Posture, without taking either Meat, or Drink, or Sleep, lib. 1. cap. 3. That he must have been well acquainted with this Mystick Theology, which was in such Esteem with both; those, from whom he received Instructions; and those, who received from him: and that in Plotinus and others, we read the Pythagorick as well as Platonick Principles; and that in both was a mixture of the Judaick, and what was derived by all from the Common Parent Noah. To this I will add only a Passage or two of his, out of Demophilus:
Being born of God, and rooted in Him, let us cleave to our Root. For the Streams of the Waters, and the Sprouts of the Earth, if they be cut off from their Root are dry'd up and wither away, p. 11. Is not this the very Doctrine of our Saviour, The True Light, which lighteth every Man, who cometh into the World, of being born of God, and abiding in the Vine?
It cannot by any means be, that one and the same Person should apply himself to Pleasures, to the Body, to the getting of Riches, and also to God. And is not this also the very Doctrine of our Saviour; Ye cannot serve God and Mammon? But he goes on: For he who is given to Pleasures, the same will also be careful for the Body; but he who is careful for the Body, he will also study to get Riches; and he, who studies to get Riches, will necessarily be Ʋnjust: But he who is Ʋnjust, is both impious toward God, and unjust toward Men: and therefore, although he sacrifice (whole) Hecatombs, he is (but) the more impious, and far from God and all Religion, and deliberately Sacrilegious: Wherefore it behoveth to avoid every voluptuary Person, as impious and sacrilegious, p. 12.
You cannot well say that he is a happy Man, who relies upon Friends, or Children, or any transitory and fading thing; for all these are instable things: But to rely upon ones self and upon God, that only is firm and stable, p. 12.
A wise Man sent hither Naked, will naked (or stript of all) invoke Him, who sent him: for God hears him only, who is not incumbred with Impertinences, p. 9.
A Divine Sense ( [...]) solidly joyns us to God: For like must necessarily be joyned with like, p. 9.
The same which I have said of Pythagoras, [Page 12]may in effect be said of SOCRATES also, both as to the Disposition of his Mind, as to his Travels for acquiring of Knowledge, and as to his Principles, from the Observations and Confessions of such as were no Friends to Mystick Theology: They were Scholars in the same Schools, and received the Tradition of the same Doctrine, as did Plato also from thence, and from them; so that I may dispatch this in a few Observations of what is known and confessed concerning him.
That he had as clear Notions as any touching God, his Nature, Unity, and other Sacred Mysteries, which he could never have attained unto, but by some borrowed Tradition, &c. That he asserted, That Virtue is neither by Nature, nor by Teaching, but by Divine Inspiration: and that all true Knowledge of God comes by Divine Infusion; and called God his Tutor: That while Man is subject to, and under the Impression of Corporal Images, sensible Forms, and terrene Affections, he is not rightly disposed for Divine Contemplation, which requires a Mind defecated, &c. That Divine things and Mysteries cannot be comprehended but by a refined Judgment, by such as have their Souls abstracted from all Corporal Images, Impressions and Affections; and therefore Men should be very intent on getting a Reformed Life, that the Mind being exonerated of its depressing Lusts, might, [Page 13]by a natural Vigour, lift up it self to Eternals, and by that Purity of Intelligence, contemplate the Nature of that Eternal Incommunicable Light, where the Causes of all created Natures live in Stability, v. Aug. de Civ. Dei, lib. 8. c. 3. And as to his own Life, That he instituted his whole Life, even from his Childhood, by the assistance of his Divine Inspiration, which he called a Daemon, a Voice, a Sign. And that Plato reports of him that he stood a whole day without any alteration in the same posture, his Mind being abstracted with pure Contemplation; and that Favorinus in A. Gellius saith that he did this often.
And now to return to our principal Author, and the Words of PLATO in him, which are these: ‘Being often in the Depth of Contemplation, my Body being left behind, I seemed to enjoy the Chief Good with incredible pleasure. Wherefore I stood as it were astonished, finding my self to be a part of the upper World, and to have obtained Immortality, with the clearest Light; which cannot be expressed with Words, nor heard with Ears, nor understood by the Thoughts of Men: and then he describes the Sadness he felt at the decay of that glorious Light, and the pleasure which returned with his former Extasies. The Words are: At last my Intellect being wearied with this Contemplation fell back into phantasie, and then that Light failing I became [Page 14]somewhat sad: But again having left my Body, returning thither again, I perceived my Mind abounding with Light, and that flowing then into the Body then raised above it.’
Nor of Plato himself doth our Author take any more notice then of that one passage; but of the later Platonists, Plotinus, Jamblicus, Porphrygius, and Proclus, who, as he saith out of Psellus, did wholly approve of the Chaldaick Theology: he gives us some larger Tasts; and particularly,
‘The short account of Plotinus his Hypothesis, is this; That the Soul of Man being immersed in the Body suffers very much by reason of its Ʋnion with it; by which means it is drawn to the Affections of the Body, and to a Conversation with Sensible things, and so becomes Evil and Miserable: That its Good and Happy Condition lyes in being like to God, not in regard of Ʋnderstanding, but a State of Quiescency: That the Practice of the Virtues of the Active Life is insufficient for Assimilation to God; but in order to it, those which are properly Intellectual are most necessary, whereby the Soul draws it self off from the Body. Thus for the Soul to act by its self, is Wisdom; Introversion, is Temperance; Abstraction from Matter, is Fortitude; to follow Reason, is Justice: That by the Practice of these the Soul purifies its self, i. e. casts off the things without its self, and so recovers its Purity, by [Page 15]bringing those things into Light again, which lay hid under the rubbish of Sensible things before, so that the Soul did not know them to be there; but for the Discovery of them, it was necessary for the Soul to come near a greater Light than its self: and to bring the Images which are in it to the true Originals. The way of Purifying the Soul, he calls by the Names of Abstraction and Recollection; which he else-where expresses by awakening the Soul out of Sleep, wherein it was disturbed by sensible Images; not as though the Soul had need of any other way of Purifying, but only restraining it to its self by taking away that load of Matter which oppressed it; and then it naturally endeavours after the nearest Ʋnion with the first Being; which he calls the True Being, and the super-Essential Being. And he saith, When the Soul endeavours after this Ʋnion, it must lay aside all sensible and intellectual Images of things, and make use only of the purest and supream part of the Mind; (or the Fund of the Spirit) that God then is not to be considered under the Notion of Being, but as something above Being; and that we are not either to affirm or deny any thing of Him: that, Our Contemplation of Him is not by Knowledge, or any Intellectual Operation; but by a Divine Presence, which far exceeds any Knowledge: for Knowledge, he saith, hinders Ʋnion: therefore we must go beyond Knowledge, and be [Page 16]abstracted from all other Objects; and be united to Him only by the Power of Divine Love; from whence follows a clearer Light in the Soul: And in this State, saith he, there is not only a Cessation of Passion, but of Reason and Ʋnderstanding too: neither is the Person himself, [...], like one in a Rapture or an Extasie he enjoys God in that State of Quiescency, as in a silent Wilderness; which he calls, being in God; and in other places, seeing God in themselves, being the same with God, being one with God; and which is the highest of all, being God: which is the perfect State of Dei-formity.’
Of Porphyry, who was a Disciple and Confident of Plotinus, the same Author gives us this account: ‘That he looked upon the Theurgick Way, as lyable to deceit, and not capable of advancing the Soul to highest Perfection. Which Theurgick Way lay in the initiating of Men in some Sacred Mysteries, by partaking of certain Rites and Symbols, by which they were admitted to the Presence of some of their Deities; the End whereof, as they pretended, was, reducing the Souls of Men to that State they were in before they came into the Body. So St. Austin tells us from Porphyry, That they who were purified after this manner did converse with glorious appearances of Angels, which they were fitted to see: but Porphyry himself, as he [Page 17]did not utterly reject this Lower and Symbolical way; so he said, That the Highest Perfection of the Soul was not attainable by it; but it was useful for purifying the Lower part of the Soul, but not the Intellectual. By the Lower part he understood the Irrational, which by the Theurgical Rites might be fitted for Conversation with Angels; but the Intellectual part could not be elevated by it to the Contemplation of God, and the Vision of the things that are true. And herein he placed the utmost Perfection of the Soul in its return to and Union with God in this upper part, or Fund of the Soul: for the utmost the other attained to, was only to live among the Aetherial Spirits; but the Contemplative Souls returned to the Father, as he speaks, which, as many other of his Notions, he borrowed from the Chaldaick Theology. To shew what this Intellectual or Contemplative Life was, that should bring Mens Souls to this State of Perfection, Porphyry writ a Book on purpose, Of the Return of the Soul, as St. Austin tells us, who quotes many passages out of it; and this particular Precept above all the rest, That the Soul must fly from all Body, if it would live Happy with God: which is all one with Abstraction of Mind, and pure Contemplative Life. In that Book he complains that there was no Perfect Way yet known to the World for this End; not the Indian, [Page 18]Chaldaick, or any other. But what that was which he meant, appears by what he saith near the end of the Life of Plotinus, where he hath these Words: The Scope and End of his Life was Ʋnion and Conjunction with God over all: and four times, saith he, when I was with him he attained to this Ʋnion, by an unexpressible Act of the Mind: which he before sets forth, by a Divine Illumination without any Image or Idea, being above the Ʋnderstanding and all intelligible things. And he saith of himself, that he was once in this State of Ʋnion, when he was 68 Years of Age. Which Holstenius understands of an Extasie he then fell into; and imputes it to the depth of his Melancholy joyned with his abstracted and severe Life, his frequent Watchings, and almost continual Exercise of Contemplation. For all these things were remarkable in him: and Eunapius saith of him, That he was so little a lover of the Body, that he hated his being a Man; and being in Sicily, he was almost famished by Abstinence, and shunned all Conversation with Mankind: as he begins the Life of Plotinus; That he was like one ashamed that his Soul was in a Body. So that we find the Foundation here laid, (saith our Author) not only for the Mystical Ʋnion, but the Abstraction of Mind necessary in order to it: and that it doth not lye in any Intellectual Operations, but rather [Page 19]in a Cessation of these Acts, is likewise expressly affirmed by Porphyry. Many things, saith he, are said of Ʋnderstanding things that are above the Mind; but the Contemplation of those things is better performed, [...], otio & vacatione Intellectûs, as Holstenius renders it, rather by the Rest and Cessation of Operation in the Ʋnderstanding, than by the Exercise of it; as many things, while a Man wakes, are said of him that he does when he sleeps, but the Knowledge and Perception of them is by Sleep; for things are best understood by Assimilation. And elsewhere he saith, That our manner of Ʋnderstanding all things is different according to their Essence; those things above the Mind are to be known, [...], in the way of unknowing, and after a super-essential manner; where we see the very Phrases of Dionysius used by him; and in many places he speaks of the Minds abstracting and loosing it self from the Body, and drawing it self nearer to the First Being; of the Souls being in God; of the pure and clear Light, which follows the Abstraction of the Mind; of the State and Life of Contemplation, and the Virtues necessary thereto; such as Abstinence from the Actions of the Body, and from Affections to it, which, saith he, raise the Mind to the super-essential Being. And he very much disparages the Active and Political Life in comparison with this; the End of one, being only [Page 20]Mens living according to Nature; but of the other, Assimilation to God: He that lives according to Practical Virtues, is only a Good Man; but he that lives the Life of Contemplation, is a God. From whence we understand the Deiformity of the Mystical Divines, being attainable by the Life of Contemplation. The Way laid down by him for Purifying the Soul is this: 1. The Foundation of it is for the Soul to know it self, i. e. to consider, that it is in a strange place, and bound to a thing of another Substance. 2. Recollection, or gathering it self up from the Body, to be free from the Affections of it: In order to which he adviseth to deny the Body in its Appetites and Pleasures, and to shew as little Care of it, and Concernment for it, as may be: by degrees to lessen all sense both of Pleasure and Pain; and so to come at last to a Freedom from the Passions of the Body. Then he describes the Superlative Being, and saith, that it is neither Great, nor Little, but above both; and is neither Greatest nor Least, but above all; and that his Presence is not Topical, but Assimilative; and that the only Way for our Souls to recover themselves, is, to bring them into themselves; by which Means the True Being is present with them, and we become united to God. Which Ʋnion of the Soul with God, Holstenius thinks it very probable that Porphyry understood by the Book which he mentions in the Life of [Page 21] Plotinus, called, [...], the Sacred Nuptials, because both Plotinus and he supposed this Union to be wrought by the Power of Divine Love, as well as the Mystical Divines; and Porphyry saith, upon the reading of it, some thought him Mad, because there were several things spoken in it after a Mystical and Enthusiastical manner; for which he was highly applauded by Plotinus.’
Jamblicus was Porphyry's Disciple, but out of him our Author recites no more than what is set down before concerning the Egyptian Mysteries: but out of PROCLƲS, another Platonick Philosopher, who lived long after these, and of whom Marinus gives this Character, towards the Conclusion of his Life,
That his Soul was so recollected and drawn into its self, that it seemed to be separated from the Body while it remained in it; he hath this passage: In the beginning of his Theology, saith he, he distinguisheth between that Intellectual Faculty in us, whereby we are capable of Ʋnderstanding the Nature and Difference of Intelligible Idea's, and that which he call [...], the Summity, as the Mysticks speak, and pure Fund of the Spirit, which, he saith, is alone capable of the Divine and Mystical Ʋnion; so he calls it, [...]. For, saith he, though there be many Intellectual Powers in us, yet it is by this only that we can be united to the Divinity, [Page 22]and be made partakers of it. For we cannot reach the Divine Being either by our Senses, or by Opinion, or by Apprehension; no nor yet by Ratiocination, [...]. It remains therefore, that if the Divine Nature can any ways be known by us, it must be by the Essence of the Soul. For the Soul being drawn into its own Ʋnity, and removing from it self the Multiplicity of its Powers, it ascends to the greatest height of true Contemplation. While the Soul looks about on things below it, it sees nothing but Shadows and Images of things: When it comes to a State of Introversion, then it sees its own Essence and Operations of the Ʋnderstanding: But when it searches deeper, then it finds the Mind within it self, and the several Orders of real Beings: When it goes yet farther into the most secret Closet of the Soul, there it contemplates, as it were blindfold, the Divine Beings, and the first Idea's or Ʋnities of Beings. And this, saith he, is the most excellent Operation of the Soul, in the Rest or Quiescency of its Powers, to stretch it self toward the Divine Nature, and dance, as it were, round it, and to raise up the whole Soul towards this Ʋnion with it, and abstracting it self from all Inferior Beings, to rest upon, and be conjoyned with that Ineffable and Super-essential Being. And by this means the Soul comes to have the truest Ʋnderstanding of all things.
[Page 23] All these Notions, (saith our Author) both among the Chaldeans, and the Platonick Philosophers, are built upon a very ancient Hypothesis, but very different from that of Christianity; which Hypothesis being granted, this Mystical Divinity appears with some face of Reason, and colour of Probability.— It was this; That the Souls of Men did exist in another World long before they came into the Body; that in their Descent to the Body they had an Aetherial Vehicle joyned to them; which upon the conjunction of the Soul and Body became the Means of Communication between them, and takes up its chief Seat in the Brain, which is the same which we call the Imagination: that the Soul being in this state is apt to be much inveigled with Kindness to the Body, and so forget its Return home: that the Body is capable of doing the Soul mischief no other way, being it self under the power of Fate, then as it draws it downward: that the Mind, being the upper part of the Soul, is always acting; but we know not its operations but only by the Impressions they make upon the Phansie: that the Mind hath the true Idea's of things within it self; but we are deceived by the Representations conveyed by our Imagination; and therefore our Ratiocination is very short and uncertain: that our only way of Recovering our Souls, is by drawing them off from the [Page 24]Body, and retiring into themselves; and that upon this the Mind hath the Divine Being so nearly conjoyned to it, that it passeth into a Divine Nature, and recovers its former State, when it parts from the Body. But because it is not to return alone without the Aetherial Vehicle it brought with it, therefore the Chaldeans and Egyptians had several Sacred and Symbolical Rites for the purifying of the Vehicle, as they called it, which they made necessary for this End: and with them Jamblicus joyns, but Porphyry thought them not necessary, but that Philosophy and meer Contemplation would purifie enough without it. This is the true Account of their Hypothesis, as may be fully seen in Hierocles and Synesius, without going farther; and was the first Foundation of Mystical Divinity, which I will not deny to be well enough accommodated to it. But it is as remote from Christianity, as the Hypothesis it self is.
This is said by our Author to disparage Mystical Divinity; because he supposeth it will not be consented to by any that are Friends to it. But how doth it appear that this Hypothesis was the first Foundation of Mystical Divinity; which, for any thing he hath shewed to the contrary, may be more ancient than it? His bare affirmation in his own Case certainly is not to be admitted for Proof. But in case that were admitted, [Page 25]how is that different from Christianity; for he would not say contrary; though, no doubt, many of his Readers would be apt to take it so? The Jews did believe it before our Saviour's time; the Apocrypha doth favour it; the Apostle's Question concerning the Man, who was born Blind, doth favour it; nor doth our Saviour's Answer at all contradict it, but rather suppose it: and it hath been asserted by Learned Men, both of the Church of England and other Protestants, from Proofs of Scripture, as well as Reason. His Conclusion also is observable, that Mystical Divinity is as remote from Christianity, as the Hypothesis it self; such another cautious Expression not to expose himself, but by which the generality of his Readers may easily be imposed upon. Truth is a very venerable thing; and Divine matters ought to be treated with great Reverence; the very Heathen Mysticks would have thought so, whatever our Rationatists think.
Besides these ancient Philosophers, our Author takes notice of the like Notions and Practices among other Gentiles, even at this day; but of what antiquity amongst them he saith not. It is taken from a Letter of Monsteur Bernier to Monsieur Chaplain, dated 4 Octob. 1667, concerning the Gentiles of Indostan, wherein he gives an account ‘of certain Orders of Religious among them, who make Vows of Chastity, Poverty, and Obedience, living in Convents [Page 26]under Superiors, who are commonly called Jauguis, i. e. united to God, who used themselves to many Hardships, and were looked on as so many Eremites by the People, being accounted true Saints, illuminated and perfect Jauguis: These are People that have entirely abandoned the World, and sequestered themselves into some very remote Corner or Garden, like Eremites, without ever coming to the Town. If you carry them any Meat, they receive it; if they do not, 'tis believed that they can live without it, and subsist by the sole Favour of God in perpetual Fasting, Prayer, and profound Meditations: for they sink themselves so deep into these Raptures, that they spend many hours together in being insensible, and beholding in that time, as they give out, God himself, like a very bright and ineffable Light, with an unexpressible Joy and Satisfaction, attended with an intire Contempt and forsaking of the World. For thus much one of them, that pretended he could enter into this Rapture when he pleased, and had been often in it, told me; and others that are about them affirm the thing with so much seriousness, that they seem to believe it in earnest, that there is no Imposture in it.’
To these others might be added, who have had the like Notions, and used the like Exercises, as well anciently, as at this time. Such as the Indian Brachmans or Gymnosophists, the Persian Magi, and the Druides, who are said by some to [Page 27]have been as ancient as Abraham's time. The Character given by Bardisanes Syrus of the BRACHMANES, that they neither worship Images, nor eat what is animate; neither drink Wine, or Beer; are far from all Malignity, attending wholly to God; is comprehensive enough to take in both the Austerities and Contemplations of those before-mentioned. But the religious Care of the Ancients to conceal their most Sacred Mysteries from the Vulgar, and their communication of them principally by successive verbal Tradition, is a great reason that we have so little of this in any Writings, not only of the rest, whom we call Heathens, but even of the Jews, and Christians. However, it is plain by what is collected by our Author, that these Notions and Exercises were not first introduced by Plotinus and his Disciples, but derived to them from the Egyptians, and the Chaldeans. And if it be inquired from what Original they derived them, it will be hard to discover any other than either Abraham and his Posterity, as many assert; or at least the common Parent Noah; so that what our Author has collected to disparage Mystical Theology, being well considered, will prove a notable Recommendation of it. For as it is most reasonable to believe that Noah did instruct his Posterity in all things of greatest Importance to them; and that the Knowledge of them was transmitted to after-Generations, and in particular [Page 28]to the Chaldeans and Egyptians in some sort or other; but to the Jews intirely, and without Mixture of Corruptions; so it is not to be doubted, but such inquisite Persons, and especially into Divine Mysteries, as Pythagoras, Socrates, and Plato, Men of such extraordinary qualifications, and so favoured as they were, must have obtained a compleat Knowledge of them from all these Nations; and especially at that time, in and after the Captivity, when they seem by Divine Providence to have been carried away out of their own Countrey for that very end and purpose, that God's dealings with them might be more fully known to other Nations. For the Posterity of Abraham was undoubtedly designed by Almighty God to be a Light and Admonition to the Gentiles, even from the beginning in all their various States; in Egypt, in the Wilderness, in the Land of Canaan, in their Captivity, and in their Dispersion to this very day. Nor do I at all doubt but there was so much Knowledge of Truth derived from them to other Nations, as together with what is observable in the Works of God, and what was received from the Common Ancestors, was sufficient for the Salvation of all, who used and improved the same as they ought; and for the just Condemnation of the rest, who neglected it. And therefore, if we find that these Men were acquainted with the Mystick Divinity, that is, with the thing, whether [Page 29]under that Name or any other, it matters not; if we find undeniable Evidence of it among the Chaldeans and Egyptians, and others before; if we find the most ancient Christian Asceticks well acquainted with it, and much, or rather altogether in the Practice of it, before Dionysius his Theologia Mystica was known in the World; this put together is such a Constellation of concurrent and corroborating Evidences, that whencesoever that Name, and some Terms and Expressions, which seem somewhat uncouth, came in after Ages, yet that the thing it self must have been derived from some very ancient common Original to those Nations; and to those Christian Asceticks, not from the Collections of the Adversaries of Christianity, (which is a meer groundless Oratorical Fiction to expose it) no more than from Dionysius, whom our Author doth not believe to have been so ancient; but either from some of the first Converts of the Jews, or, which seems more likely, from a Divine Conduct and Inspiration: for they were many of them unacquainted with Humane Learning. Nor do I see any reason to think that the Institutions of the Sons of the Prophets among the Jews were much different from the Mystical Theology, which is thus opposed by our Author; but rather that the same Institutions were conveyed, as Secrets, by Tradition to some principal Men of all Nations, from the Common Parent Noah.
And indeed, if we do but fairly, that is candidly and without Prejudice, consider that Account of this Divinity, which our Author hath chosen for his purpose to collect from a late Author, Father Austin Baker and Mr. Cressy's Preface, I suppose it will sufficiently recommend it self, as no improper or unlikely Method to have been used by the ancient Prophets. ‘Let the Reader judge of it (saith he, and so say I) by these Passages in his (viz. Mr. Cressy's) Preface: 1. The only proper Disposition towards receiving Supernatural Irradiations from God's Holy Spirit, is an Abstraction of Life; a Sequestration from all Business that concerns others; and an Attendance to God alone in the Depth of the Spirit. And a little after: 2. The Lights here desired and prayed for, are such as do expell all Images of Creatures, and do calm all manner of Passions; to the end the Soul being in a Vacuity, may be more capable of receiving and entertaining God in the pure Fund of the Spirit.’ Thus far our Author out of Mr. Cressy. But I think fit to add to these two, the rest of his Characters of Divine Inspirations whereby they may be distinguished from Fanaticism. 3. The Prayer here acknowledged to be the most effectual Instrument to procure Divine Light, is a Pure, Recollected, Intime (or most inward) Prayer of the Spirit. 4. Here are no new Speculative Verities or Revelations of Mysteries pretended; no private new-found-out [Page 31]Interpretations of Scripture bragg'd of. 5. Here the Established Order of God's Church, and the Ʋnity essential thereto is not prejudiced. Yea, the Inspirations expected and obtained by Pure Internal Prayer do more firmly and unalterably fix Souls under this Obedience, and to this Order and Ʋnity. 6. Our Lights teach us to attend only to God and our own Souls, and never to interess our selves in any Care or Imployment about others, till evidently God's Inspirations force us, and External Authority obliges us thereto. 7. Our Lights make us to fear and avoid all Super-eminence and Judicature, all sensual Pleasures, Desires of Wealth, Honor, &c. 8. And lastly, Our Lights, if they should chance sometimes to be mistaken by us, no Harm at all would accrue to others, and not any considerable prejudice to our selves; because, as hath been said, the Matters in which they direct us, are in their Nature indifferent, and are ordered only toward a more perfect Loving of God, and withdrawing us from Creatures. §. 33. The contrary or different Characters of phanatick false Lights, I pass by for brevity sake.
Out of Father Baker himself he produceth these amongst others: Such (contemplative) Souls are not of themselves much inclined to External Works, (except (saith Father Baker, which our Author leaves out) when God calls them thereto by secret Inspirations, or engageth them therein by Command of Superiors) [Page 32] but they seek rather to purifie themselves, and inflame their Hearts to the Love of God by Internal Quiet, and Pure Actuations in Spirit; by a total Abstraction from Creatures; by Solitude, both external and especially internal; so disposing themselves to receive the Influxes and Inspirations of God, whose Guidance chiefly they endeavour to follow in all things. * And, The proper End of a Contemplative Life is the attaining unto an Habitual and almost uninterrupted perfect Ʋnion with God in the supream point of the Spirit; and such an Ʋnion as gives the Soul a Fruitive Possession of him, and a real Experimental Perception of the Divine Presence in the Depth and Centre of the Spirit, whith is fully possessed and filled with him alone; not only all deliberate Affections (saith Fa. Baker) to Creatures being excluded, but in a manner all Images of them also, at least so far, as they may be distractive to the Soul. And he adds: The Effects of this blessed Perceptable Presence of God in Perfect Souls are unspeakable and Divine: For he is in them both as a Principle of all their Actions Internal and External, being the Life of their Life, and Spirit of their Spirits; and also as the End of them, directing both the Actions and Persons to himself only. He is All in all things unto them: A Light to direct securely all their Steps, and to order all their Workings, even those also which seem the most Indifferent; [Page 33]the which, by the Guidance of God's Holy Spirit, do cause a farther Advancement of them to a yet more immediate Ʋnion. He is a Shield to protect them in all Tentations and Dangers; an internal Force and Vigour within them to make them do and suffer all things, whatsoever his pleasure is they should do or suffer. They not only believe and know, but even feel and tast him to be the Ʋniversal Infinite Good. By means of a continual Conversation with him they are reduced to a blessed State of a Perfect Denudation of Spirit, to an absolute Internal Solitude, a Transcendency and Forgetfulness of all created things, and especially of themselves, to an Heavenly-mindedness and fixed Attention to God only, and this even in the midst of Employments to others never so distractive; and, finally, to a gustful Knowledge of his Infinite Perfections, and a strict Application of their Spirits by Love above Knowledge, joyned with a Fruition and Repose in Him with the whole extent of their Wills: So that they become after an inexpressible manner Partarkers of the Divine Nature; yea, One Spirit, One Will, One Love with him, being in a sort Deified, and enjoying as much of Heaven here as Mortality is capable of.
The special Means for obtaining such spiritual and extraordinary Favours from God, are doubtless very desirable to be known; and these our Author sets down in the Words of O. N. who [Page 34]purposely writ in Answer to him upon this Subject, viz. (besides a watchful Guard, saith he, for keeping the Conscience clean, as much as may be, not only from Mortal, but also Venial Sin) Much frequent and continued Vocal or Mental Prayer; much Solitude, and Mortifications of our Flesh; and Abstraction of our Thoughts and Affections from any Creature; much Recollection, and withdrawing from abroad into our selves; much Meditation on such selected Subjects, as may rather inflame our Affections than increase our Science; and when once we find these enkindled, the Endeavouring a Quiescence, as much as we can from former Discourse, (those actions of the Brain and Intellect now hindering the Heart and Will) and the bringing of our selves rather to a simple Contemplation, to exercise Acts of Love, adhere to, sigh after, and entertain the Divine Object thereof. And here (saith he) if his Divine Majesty please to advance us any higher to such Unions with Him, as are not in our power, and wherein we receive rather than act, and he operates in us rather than we our selves, we embrace them with all Humility and Gratitude; if otherwise, we acquiesce in our best endeavours, and longing after him with Patience, though enabled also to these only by his Grace. This our Spiritual and Mystical Masters teach us; and thus, after this way, which these Men stile Fanaticism and Enthusiasm, we endeavour to procure a more strict [Page 35]Acquaintance and Converse with God, and herein to follow the Example of our Fore-Fathers.
‘Elsewhere, saith our Author, he (Fa. Baker) describes the Progress towards this State of Perfection thus; That he who would come to it must practise the drawing of his External Senses inwardly to his internal, there losing, and, as it were, annihilating them: then he must draw his Internal Senses into the Superior powers of the Soul, and there annihilate them likewise: And those Powers of the Intellectual Soul he must draw into that which is called the Ʋnity; and to that Ʋnity, which alone is capable of perfect Ʋnion with God, must be applyed and firmly fixed on God, wherein the perfect Divine Contemplation lyes.’ It is true, these words are in Father Baker; but they are but what he saith we read in other Authors: and besides he adds: ‘Now, whether such Expressions as these will abide the strict Examination of Philosophy or no, I will not take on me to determine. Certain it is, that by a frequent and constant Exercise of Internal Prayer of the Will, joyned with Mortification, the Soul comes to operate more and more abstracted from Sense, and more celebrated above the Corporeal Organs and Faculties; so drawing near to the resemblance of the Operations of an Angel or Separated Spirit.’
By this we may perceive, that it is not difficult, as our Author saith, to put together some [Page 36]of their Words and Phrases, as an Account of their Divinity; (p. 285.) and what Account that is. But besides these, there are some other passages which he recites; and in them some, which he construes, as he doth these and other things; and some Expressions, which may seem hard Sayings to one, who is not willing to understand them, or consider them as terms of Art, and allow them a candid Construction; and may afford Matter for Exercise of Wit to such as are disposed to sport themselves with Matters of Religion. The wicked Spirit does easily insinuate himself into, and impose upon Persons ingaged in Controversy; they are ordinarily like Souldiers ingaged in War, act as if all was Lawful, whereby they can incommode an Adversary, without due regard to Charity, Truth, and that fair Dealing and Kindness which Christianity enjoyns to Enemies; and too often behave themselves like such Souldiers, as are loath to have an End of a War lest they should want Employment, trifling and skirmishing at a distance, with vain Words and Shews: and the consequence in each is frequently the baffling and disparaging of the Cause they are ingaged in, and giving advantages to their Adversaries. And I wish this Author, by his management, hath not given too much Advantage, or at least Occasion, to the common Adversaries, Infidels and Deists. But as to this cause, O. N. hath so [Page 37]fully answered all Cavils at the Terms of Art, that it seems he left little to be replyed to: and therefore, for Answer, our Author is reduced to these two shifts: 1. To inculcate the Unintelligibleness of Mystick Theology, from the cessation of the discursive Faculty at the time of Contemplation, (which is all that the Mystick Writers intend) as if all Men, in the very act of intent listening to Sounds, or beholding something extraordinary, did not the like in a great measure. 2. To make a great Bravado, as if he had the Authority of the whole Church of Christ against all Visions, immediate Revelations, Extasies, &c. in the case of Montanus; Whereas what was condemned in Montanus and his Companions, was not the pretending to Visions and Revelations; but pretending such to be Divine, which were not; but Diabolical, as appeared both by the Manner, and by the Matter, being Heresie: as is very plain in the ancient Writer in Eusebius, l. 5. c. 16. When the Faithful throughout Asia had met often, and in many places of Asia, upon this account, and had inquired into this New Doctrine, and determined it to be prophane, and rejected this Heresie, they were expelled out of the Church. And before he relates how Montanus his Ambition gave the Enemy an Entrance into himself, and he was filled with the Devil, and of a sudden possest with a furious and frantick Temper of Mind, &c. So he [Page 38]saith of Theodotus, that he was possest with a false Extasie, which plainly implies true ones believed then, contrary to what our Author doth pretend. To say that it hath no Foundation in the Christian Doctrine, and yet to pass by so many Testimonies of Scripture produced for it, with no better answer than what amounts to a Concession, deserves no other reply than only to note it. To mistake and mis-represent Mens Words through Ignorance, is a Fault, but more especially in Men pretending to Learning and Knowledge; yet hath that some excuse, by reason of the Humane Infirmity incident to all. But to do it wilfully, deliberately, and seeking Occasions, is not only different from, but contrary to the Spirit of Christianity. But what is it then, if it be in despight of that which is really true, and the Operations of the Spirit of Grace? To say that the Case of Montanus was the very Case of Mystical Ʋnions; and that the Spirit of Montanus was rejected in the Christian Church as a Fanatick Enthusiastical Spirit; as if the Case of Mystical Unions was the Case of that Spirit so rejected, with other expressions to like purpose, are fit to be considered afterward, if they were not well considered before-hand. There is a passage, which he recites out of the Spiritual Exercises of the Jesuites, p. 31, 32. edit. 1574. viz. It is the great Perfection of a Christian to keep himself [Page 39]indifferent, to do what God shall reveal to him; and not to determine himself to do what he hath already revealed and taught in the Gospel: which is very gross indeed, if the meaning be what he would have us to believe; and indeed so gross, that it is not to be believed to be their meaning, if it be to be found there, and fairly translated: but since it is capable of another construction, viz. not to confine ones self to what is revealed in general; but to be indifferent, as to things not determined, but lest indifferent, to do as God shall direct: I know not what can be said of any weight against it: Such a Construction had been but according to their own Rule: Christianum unumquemque pium debere promptiore animo Sententiam seu Propositionem obscuram alterius in bonam trahere partem, quam damnare, &c. Exercit. Spirit. p. 65. edit. Ant. 1676. 8o. which had been more worthy of our Author's Observation. Nor do I see any reason to alledge, as an Instance or Proof of their Fanaticism, that Custom of Ignatius and his Companions, related by Orlandinus, lib. 1. n. 111. viz. In any matter of Debate they were to joyn together in Prayer; and after seeking God, what Opinion the most were of, that they resolve upon. Where was the Fault in this? in joyning in Prayer? or in agreeing with the Majority? If the Odium of the Name will excuse any thing with the vulgar; yet it [Page 40]becomes neither Christianity, nor Ingenuity, nor is it consistent with true Prudence, to condescend to such mean Objections. Over-doing doth often spoil a good Work, and disparage and discredit the Author. The Errors and Miscarriages of Devout People ought to be pitied, mentioned with Grief, and not exposed beyond Truth or Necessity: For that makes sport for the Devils and wicked Men; gives Scandal to weak Men; promotes Uncharitableness and Irreligion; and discomposeth and disordereth the Spirit of him that doth it. He who judgeth others, ought to take care that they rise not up in Judgment hereafter against himself. How will that Fanaticism, which carries Men to the farthest part of the World for the Conversion of Infidels to Christianity, rise up in Judgment against them, who suffer their own Parishes and Diocesses of professed Christians at home, to sink into Insidelity, for want of due Care and sufficient Instruction? And how will the Excess of Devotion (if it be so) in some Spiritual Writers, rise up in Judgment against such as will be found to have given occasion to Tepidity, Carelessness, and Neglect of the most Spiritual Exercises of Religion?
NOTES and OBSERVATIONS to discern Illusions, from Divine Inspirations.
THERE is another part of the Quarrel, which our Author hath to this Mystical Divinity, besides that, that it is unintelligible, as he says, viz. That it leads Persons into strange Illusions of Fancy; which he takes to be a great Injury, not only to those Melancholy Souls that are led through this Valley of Shades and Darkness; but to the Christian Religion it self. Which, if true, is a just Cause of Quarrel indeed: But if well consider'd, no greater Cause than others have against the Holy Scriptures, because some wrest them to their own Destruction, 2 Pet. 3.16. It is true, many Persons have been impos'd upon by their own Fancies; and many more by Satan transformed into an Angel of Light: but must we therefore deny that there are any true Divine Illuminations, Inspirations, Motions, or Communications? It is therefore very necessary to be well considered, How they may be distinguished. And because O. N. in the Book which our Author answers, hath a Discourse on that Subject, which hath passed his Examination without any hard censure, which is an implicit Approbation, that may not improperly here be added.
FOR the discerning of such Illusions, proceeding from Satan, from the true Inspirations of God's Holy Spirit, we affirm, That many Notes and Observations there be, whereby they may be known, if not certainly whether Divine, as to their Original; (where no Spirit of Prophecy or Miracles:) yet whether containing Truth, and advancing Vertue, as to the Matter; and whether any way noxious and hurtful, either to the Person that receives them, or others. And this is abundantly sufficient. Now for these Notes of discerning them, I need referr the Reader to no other Book then to the Doctor's Martyr, Sancta Sophia, (though he was pleased to take no notice of them there) in the Preface, from §. 29. to §. 35. Again, in the third Treatise, p. 268. from §. 9. to §. 22. where, after directing a strict Observation to be made concerning the Person, whether, 1. viciously inclin'd; 2. arrogant and proud; or, 3. curious; 4. or much addicted to melancholy, there are particularly cast off, and marked out for Satanical Illusions; among others, these: ‘All such pretended Inspirations or Revelations as do invite the Person to say or do any thing contrary to the Catholick Faith, Obedience, Humility, Peace, and Unity, Honesty, Parity,’ and any other Divine Vertue: but especially contrary to the Catholick Faith, or Obedience; for instance, as the attempting to make any new and seditious Reformations; as likewise, when the Persons obstinately believe these Revelations to be of God, after they have been condemned by experienced Superiors and Directors. All such, I say, are condemned for Satanical Illusions, which cuts all the nerves of all such pretended Revelations as can any way disturb the Church's Faith, or Peace; and most of all, of those Enthusiasms and Fanatick [Page 43]Frenzies which have been so common among Protestants. — §. 14.
Lastly, in all these Pretensions, where there is any greater difficulty of discerning the Good and Divine from the Bad and Satanical Spirit, we have a judge to repair to, the Governours of the Church; The Spirits of the Prophets, saith St. Paul, are subject to the Prophets. — §. 15.
But there are other Influences and Inspirations of the same Spirit, directing us also in Actions in their own nature Indifferent, or of Counsel, and on either side lawful, and free from Sin; some of which Inspirations cannot be tried, or distinguished from Enthusiasm, by any such way as the former; which, because they are much spoken of by the Mysticks, and are very necessary for advancing Christians in the way of Perfection, it seems requisite, for the freeing these also from Mistakes, to give the Reader here some account of them. §. 18.
1. We must know then (as Sancta Sophia, Tr. 1. p. 57. and others have discoursed more at large) that there are two Spirits within us; (that is, all the Regenerate) the Holy Spirit, and that of Corrupt Nature assisted with the Suggestions of the Devil, who took a kind of Possession of us upon Adam's Fall, Eph. 2.2. That this last Spirit is never totally expell'd or silenc'd in us during this Life; but tempts us still, Gal. 5.17. And that its Suggestions may appear many times like the Motions of God's Spirit; pretending Good Ends, the performing some Duty to our selves or our Neighbour, our advancement in Vertue, and the like: That the Effect of the first of these Spirits, Sanctifying Grace, received in our Regeneration or Justification, is, in its infusion, ordinarily but as a small Seed, 1 John 3.9. 1 Pet. 1.23. Mat. 13.31, [Page 44]33. or spark, capable of a daily growth and increase; and which, with the co-operation of our Free will, and further Aids, that are from time to time received from God, works in us at length a total Reformation, and Christian Perfection; which, so many among the Regenerate as do attain, are said in a more special mannner to be Spiritual Persons, and to have the Spirit of God: And in this sense the Apostle writes to the Corinthians,— I, Brethren, could not speak unto you as to Spiritual, but as to Carnal, and as to Babes in Christ, 1 Cor. 3.1. and so, ver. 3. For ye are yet Carnal, and Walk according to Man: that is, ye are Babes only in Christ, and so in some degree Carnal, and walking according to the natural Man still, and not as yet entirely Spiritual. And frequent mention we find in the Scriptures of these several Degrees and Growths in a Regenerate Condition. (It being God's Pleasure, that the New Man, as the Old, should grow by degrees, and not be made compleat in us all at once.) Mention, I say, of some Babes and little ones, and to be fed as yet only with Milk: Of strong Meat, and Wisdom, and higher Mysteries, only to be delivered to, and spoken amongst, the Perfect. See Heb. 5.12, 13. 1 Pet. 2.2. 1 Cor. 3.1: 1.2, 6. Of growing in Grace, and receiving Increase from God, 2 Pet. 3.18. Col. 2.19. Of the new Man being renewed day by day, 2 Cor. 4.16. Of arriving to a perfect Man unto the measure of the Stature (or Age) of the Fulness of Christ, Eph. 4.13. Of the Apostles labouring to present every one perfect in Christ Jesus, and that they might stand perfect, and full in all the Will of God, Col. 1.28: 4.12. and of this Perfection still containing in it higher and higher degrees; Not as if I had already attained, saith the Apostle, Phil. 3.12.
Though therefore by this Principle of a New Life, and the infusion of the habitual Grace of Charity, we are already translated from the former being of corrupt Nature to a Divine being of Supernatural Grace, freed, at the first, from the former state of Mortal Sin, and from the Slavery and Captivity we suffered under its Dominion; yet hath not this Spirit as yet attained such a soveraign Empire and Mastery over the importunate Solicitations of Concupiscence, and the natural Inclinations of our Will and Affections, as that we do not still fall frequently into many lesser, and those call'd Venial Sins; or at least, as to Actions that are not sinful, but in their nature indifferent, or lawful, that we do not, for the most part, still prosecute those that are more grateful, or advantageous to our present Carnal desires, and our Sensual or secular designs: Though such Actions are no way expedient for us, nor acceptable to the Holy Spirit, in which now we live; nor do conduce to our growth in Grace, but are great hinderances thereof; and though these Acts, contained indeed within the compass of lawful, yet often expose us to Occasions of Sin. Now, so long as we stay here, and advance no further, we appear but as Infants, and Babes in Grace, it having not as yet obtained its perfect Reign in us, either over our Concupiscence, which carries us still into frequent venial Sins; or over our Nature and Will, which carries us, in other matters lawful, to those satisfying our natural Condition. But, when we are come to have potestatem voluntatis nostrae, as St. Paul expresseth it, 1 Cor. 7.37. come once to act seldom according to [...], Concupiscence, to fall seldom into Venial Sin, especially with advertency and unsurprised; and the Holy Spirit to have a more absolute power over Sense, Reason, our own [Page 46] Will, Propriety, and Self-love, as to these things lawful, but not expedient; when come to St. Paul's omnia mihi licent, sed ego sub nullius redigar potestate, 1 Cor. 6.12. and to his corpus in servitem redigo, 1 Cor. 9.27. and to act more constantly according to the Spirit, moving now more perceptibly in us, and giving the Law to us, when Grace is, as to these non-expedients, also predominant, and sole Mistress; ordering all things (without our reluctance, or also with our zeal,) to the greater Love, Praise, Honour of God, and the doing of all things in order to his Will, so far as it is made known to us by this his Spirit, then are we arrived to a full growth, to a compleat Man in Christ, to a state of Perfection, such as this Life attains: but few Regenerate there are that do not, by their own disorders, die in their Spiritual Youth, before they come to such a mature Age. As therefore, in our Regeneration, a Man is removed from the state of Sin into the state of Grace; so the Church desires in that which is called (from some high Mysteries it speaks of as to the supream Effects of this Grace) Mystical Theology, to advance those, already in the state of Grace, to that of Perfection; and from the Spirit Dwelling, to it more absolutely Reigning in us, which finds so many great Rewards, not only in the next, but this present Life. §. 19.
2. We must know therefore, That to such end this Holy Spirit received in our Regeneration assisteth and worketh in us, not only as to affording generally to all good Christians that seriously endeavour to save their Souls, such internal Illuminations and Motions as are sufficient to direct them for the resisting of any sinful Temptation, or to perform any necessary act of Vertue, in Circumstances wherein they are obliged to [Page 47]it; but also, in affording us Light and Ability in all indifferent Actions and Occurrences, (with which may be also joyned all the Acts of Christian Vertues, when no necessity obligeth us to do any of them, and so when it is lawful for us, without Sin, to do or omit them) whereby we are guided to make such a Choice, as is more conformable to God's Will, and, particular Circumstances considered, may much more advance us in the Love of God, and Christian Perfection, and whereby we may avoid such other of them as may be suggested, either by corrupt Nature, or the evil Spirit, under pretence also of some Good End, but to defeat a Better. For the Holy Spirit excites us and assists us, not only in doing Duties of necessary obligation, or in the avoiding what is prohibited, and performing what is commanded by God under penalty of Sin; but in all these Acts also, that may any way tend more to God's Glory, or to our greater Perfection; though these be such as we may without sinning chuse or refuse.
For in this I may say, that the Holy Spirit in us is like to Concupiscence in us; the one continually exciting us unto that which is Better, as the other to that which is Worse. See the Apostles description of these two inmates, Rom. 8.1. &c. and Gal. 5.16, 17, 18. where he saith, v. 7. that Spiritus concupiscit adversus Carnem, & Caro adversus Spiritum— and that sibi invicem adversantur. And ibid. v. 18. as also Rom. 8.14. That those who are God's Children, or Regenerate, aguntur Spiritu, are acted by the Spirit: It guides us into Truth, Jo. 16.13. brings things forgotten to our Remembrance, Jo. 14.26. gives Knowledge and Arguments to one, Act. 6.10. Ʋtterance and Eloquence, and the power to perswade, to another, Act. 2.4. To another Wisdom, or a good Judgment, [Page 48]1 Cor. 1.5: 12.8, 9, 28. Prudence in Governing; in executing anothers Commands, Rom. 12.6, 7. To another Courage, and Boldness, Act. 4.29, 31. It opens Mens Ʋnderstaendings and Hearts, and renders them docile, and apt to believe, Luk. 24.8. Act. 16.14. Eph. 1.18. What is there that is not done in us by this Holy Spirit, when we are employed about any thing that tends to the Glorifying of God, the Father, or the Son? So is our regenerate Life wholly managed by this Spirit, as the Natural is by the Soul; and, if not obstructed, works in us a continual growth in Grace, till we come to a perfect Man in Christ, 2 Pet. 3.18. Eph. 4.13. Therefore the Apostle exhorts his Converts, Gal. 5.25. that as they live (their new Life) in, or by, the Spirit, so they would walk in it, (according to its directions:) And that they would mind or affect the things of the Spirit, (or the things it minds them of:) Because, [...], within them is Death in the end; but the [...], within them is Life and Peace to them: Exhorts them also, Eph. 4.30. with no corrupt and fruitless Communication to contristate or grieve this Spirit.— Tim. 4.14. not to neglect it.— 1 Cor. 15.10. That it should not be void (or idle) in them— 1 Thess. 5.19. not to quench it. Eph. 5.18. To replenish themselves with it. And 2 Tim. 1.6. continually to revive it— Rom. 12.11. to be fervent in it; without which the Apostle saith, 2 Cor. 3.5. we cannot think a good Thought; and our Lord, Jo. 15 5. that we can do nothing. §. 20.
3. These Actions of the latter kind, we are now speaking of, that may be lawfully done, or omitted, the one or the other performed, without any guilt of Sin, are either such, as, by the Evangelical Counsels, and the dictate of rectified Reason, are clearly [Page 49]discerned by us; the one to be better, and more to lead to Christian Perfection than the other; or such, where we have some doubt of these two Actions, good or lawful, which is the better, or more expedient. In the former of these we may safely conclude, that that which is manifest to us to be the better, as to our Perfection, is the motion in us of the Holy Spirit; and that the doing it, is the doing the Will of God in this matter; and that so often as we reject or neglect this, so often we contristate the Spirit, (that would thus conduct us to Perfection,) and refuse to do God's Will, when this is known to us; whose Will it ought always to be presumed to be, that we should do that which is clear to us, all things considered, to be best, for his Glory, and our Good, to be done; though such omission or neglect amounts not to a Sin, but to a Failing so much in Perfection. And indeed the not vigilantly observing these Motions of the Spirit within us, and the not hearkening to and obeying them when evident to be such, or also the not preconsulting by Prayer what it adviseth, but rather precipitating our Action to prevent it, is the reason of so many their no greater Improvement in the Spirit, and that they are such strangers to it, and It to them, is a check to the further and stronger operations of it in the Soul; (for, Who would offer Counsel, seldom or never accepted, or asked?) abates the Fervour and Solace that there would be in prosecuting its Suggestions, and leaves us guilty of much Unkindness and Ingratitude. For, as St. Bernard, Cum hae Sancti Spiritus circa nos dispensatoriae quidem vicissitudines vigilantissime non observantur, fit, ut nec absentem desideres, nec presentem glorifices, in Cant. Serm. 17. When these condescending vicissitness concerning us are not most watchfully heeded, it comes to pass [Page 50]that thou dost neither desire him when absent, nor glorifie him when present.
But in the latter Actions, wherein we have some cause of doubt, which is best, and yet wherein the making a good choice may be exceedingly beneficial to us, (according to the variety of our Temper and Condition) to the better ordering of our Life and Service of God, such Illumination and Direction of the Holy Spirit, or also a clear discerning thereof, is obtained especially by much Purity of Conversation, and Abstraction from Worldly things; by frequent Recollection, and Introversion, and attendance on God, in the perfectest Practice of Prayer we can attain to. For God hath graciously declared to us in the Scriptures; That the effectual Prayer of a Righteous man (as that of Elias) availeth much, Jam. 5.17. That he heareth not Sinners, but if any one be a Worshipper of him, and doth his Will, him he heareth, Jo. 9.31. That all things whatsoever we shall ask in Prayer, (that is, such Persons) not doubting, but believing, we shall receive them, Mat. 21.22. Mar. 11.23. That if we abide in Christ, and he in us, ask what we will, and it shall be done unto us, Jo. 15.7. (because indeed such ask by the Spirit of Christ, who liveth in them, and so ask according to God's Will.) That if we keep his Commandments, and do what is pleasing in God's sight, what-ever we ask we receive of him, 1 Jo. 3.22. That if we ask any thing according to his Will he heareth us, (and grants our requests,) 1 Jo. 5.14. that though we know not what we should desire, or pray for as we ought, Rom. 8.26, 27. (that is, as to temporal Prosperity, or Afflictions, or such like things, of which St. Paul there speaks, what therein is best for God's Glory, or our own Proficiency) yet the Holy Spirit within us with unutterable Groans and great Ardour interceedeth for [Page 51]us according to God's Will; and that God knoweth its Mind, (though not expressed in Words) and granteth its requests: that the same Spirit searcheth the profound things of God, (and what is his Will) and revealeth them to us; that natural Reason is not able to understand them, but they many times seem Foolishness to it: but the things of the Spirit are discerned only by the Spirit, 1 Cor. 2.10. &c. Most of which Texts seem to be spoken, not only of our petitioning God concerning the necessary means of our or others Salvation; but more universally of all sorts of Requests concerning the things of this Life, and any things that are in their nature indifferent, and lawful; and of his Spirit directing us to ask and do in them what is his Will; and of his granting those to us which may be best for us; wherein God heareth, and granteth the Petitions of his Saints much sooner than of others. §. 21.
I say then, since God in the Scriptures hath declared these things, and made these Promises, that he will not deny what we ask according to his Will, we may rationally presume and be piously confident, that he will grant our Request, when this is, only to know his Will, that we may do that which is according to it; and we may safely take that for his Will, to which, after such Addresses, and other due Preparations made, we shall find our selves more strongly inclined; and also take such Inclination to proceed from the Operation of God's Spirit, either illuminating sometimes our Understanding, in discovering to it some Reasons not so well discerned; or else disesteemed, and thought inconsiderable before; Or sometimes more confirming to us the Judgment our own Reason made of the thing before: Or sometimes effecting a strong and suddenly injected Inclination [Page 52]in the Will, so swayed without any preceeding Reasons, or discourse of the Intellect presented (to) it: Or sometimes causing an extraordinary Tranquility, Consolation, and Satisfaction to accompany such our Election; (According to the Rule of Abbot Isaac in Cassian, Collat. 9. c. 32. Cum orantes nos nulla interpellaverit haesitatio, si obtinuisse nos in ipsa orationis effusione, quod poscimus, senserimus, non ambigamus preces nostras ad Deum efficaciter penetrasse; where note, that the Devil, or any Creature, cannot work so immediately and intimately on our Understanding and Will, as God's Spirit doth; but by the use of Phantasms, or Images; of the Spirits, Humours, &c.) Or, where no such preponderation to any side is perceived in the Soul, then we may presume this to be his Will, that, making use of our best Reason, or others Advice, without any Solicitude, we take either side. §. 22.
Now, in the discerning of these Divine Illuminations and Inspirations, from Enthusiasms; or the Motions of the Good, from those of our own, or a Bad Spirit, in these matters; as any one hath attained to a greater Perfection in Prayer, and Mortification and Purity of Life, they attain hereby a greater measure of God's Spirit, and hence its Illuminations and Inspirings in them are also much greater and stronger, and more intimately effective on the Soul, than any other Motions, from whencesoever they come, can be; and so also these become more evident to such, and many times are so clearly discerned by them, from the Supernatural impression they make upon the Soul, as that it cannot resist, disbelieve, or any way doubt of them, that they are Supernatural and Divine. So St. Austin relates of his Mother Monica, that she clearly knew such Supernatural actings in her [Page 53]from her own Imaginations; Dicebat enim, discernere se nescio quo sapore, quem verbis explicare non poterat, quid interesset inter revelantem Te, & animam suam somniantem, Confess. l. 6. c. 13. For she said, she did discern, by I know not what Savour, which she could not explain in words, what difference there is between Thee revealing, and her own Soul dreaming. And indeed, if such interior Divine Operations were not sometimes certainly discernable, how could St. Paul be assured, when he intended to Preach the Word in Asia, and again in Bithynia, (a most Charitable design!) that the Spirit forbad it; and not rather the Enemy of the publishing of the Gospel? Act. 16.6, 7. or, That it was by Revelation, and not a Fancy of his, that he ascended to Jerusalem, Gal. 2.2. or, That it was the Holy Spirit that testified, and not Mens Fears, that much Affliction should happen to him there? Act. 20.23. How the Corinthians knew, when they had a Revelation, that it was not a work of their own Imagination? since all these things were transacted only interiourly in the Soul, and it was the Holy Spirit only, that in all these gave the Evidence to it self. A certain Assurance then, it cannot be denyed, that some at sometimes may have of Divine Operations in them. But yet it is not affirmed here, that all Persons, less advanced in Prayer, and Purity of Life, or also the greatest Saints at all times, discern the Operations of the Holy Spirit within them so clearly in this sort of Actions, as not to be sometimes mistaken; and it is sufficient, that Persons piously disposed, and frequent in Prayer, may have a rational presumption of it, as hath been said. Neither is any more communicated unto them, perhaps, for the better preserving of their Humility. And that no absolute Certitude is herein [Page 54]to be expected, is a thing often confessed by Sanctae Sophia. See 1 Vol. p. 139. and p. 137. §. 23.
4. But in case such Divine Inspirations be sometimes mistaken, yet can no damage come thereby, I mean as to committing any Sin; 1. The Subject of them we speak of here being Matters in themselves indifferent, and on any side lawful. See Sancta Sophia 1 Vol. p. 143. 2. No Command of Superiors in these any way neglected. 3. No Neglect, besides using Prayer, in practising any other means of making a secure Choice, either in weighing Reasons on all sides, or taking Advice from others: Only the devout Soul, in using these endeavours, yet relies not on them, but on the Directions of God's Holy Spirit, working continually in the Regenerate, both by prevenient and subsequent Grace; makes no sudden Resolutions, nor rushes hastily upon any Action; but diligently hearkens first to this internal Guide, what it may tell her is best; desiring faithfully, all natural Passions and Self-love laid aside, to correspond with all its Motions; the careful Observers of which, with a pure Intention of Mind, may be justly presumed seldom to want them, though they do not so certainly know them; and mean while such Persons, if not free always from Mistakes, yet are secure in this sort of Actions we speak of, from entertaining any sinful Enthusiasm; or such, as any other Person (except by Divine Inspiration) can either censure or discover. §. 24.
Here the Author proceeds to another Discourse, which being no less necessary for this purpose, than pertinent to the Subject of Mystick Divinity, it may be both proper for this place, and also useful and grateful to many devout People, to add part of it. It is of
Directions given by Spiritual Writers concerning Prayer and Devotion.
FIRST for Preparation for Prayer, they are advised (1.) to a serious Endeavour at all times to keep their Conscience clear from all Sin, even the least, as much as Humane Frailty permits; and to a Care of avoiding the Occasions thereof; without which Endeavours our Devotions cannot be acceptable to God, as to the receiving from him any great plenty of his Grace: And (2.) at times of Prayer to Abstraction from all Secular Business, Recollection of the Mind and Thoughts from all Creatures, and all Objects of the Exterior Senses.
And then to begin at first with Forms for all Occasions of Vocal Prayer, where Novices, saith he, begin, and which the most perfect also frequently return to. §. 25.
From these they are led on to Mental Prayer; in which the Cessation from External Action renders the Inward more attent and affective; more free from Distraction of the Senses, and from the Wandring of the Thoughts. For this many useful Subjects of Meditation are recommended, chiefly touching our own Misery, the Mysteries of our Salvation, and the Divine Perfections.: 1. Of [Page 56]their Natural Condition, the Heinousness of Sin, the Divine Justice, the bitter Passion of our Lord in Satisfaction for Sin, the Terrors of Death, Judgment, and Hell, to plant in them the Due Fear of God, and advance in them all sorts of Mortification and Purification from all Habits of Sin. 2. Of the Life of our Lord, and the Lives of his Saints, for Imitation and Growth in Vertue. And, 3. of the Divine Perfections and Benefits, both received and promised; of the Graces and Operations of the Holy Ghost in us, and the Abilities for doing Good and pleasing God restored to Man by it, if attentively observed and obeyed; to advance them in all Spiritual Grace and Christian Perfection, and to enkindle in them an ardent Love of God; the Acquisition of which Love, and not of Knowledge, being chiefly designed in them. §. 26.
When by the Practice of these Meditations they are well prepared, they are directed, by laying more aside their former Reasonings and Discoursings of the Brain, (with the frequent stroaks of which they have already kindled this Fire in the Heart) how to exercise these Affections now, in that Lesson of Loving God with all the Heart, and all the Soul, and all the Mind, and all the Strength, Luke 10.27. in a more simple and quiet Intuition and Contemplation, Advertency and Admiration of the Divine Beauty, and Perfections; and in more fervent and amorous Colloquies with God; in Praising, Thanking, Solacing her self with him, whilst she casts her eye upon his infinite Mercies past and promised; in many Resolutions for the future to serve him better, and no more so to grieve and offend him; in offering all she hath, she can do, or suffer, to his Service; and in putting her self in a posture of Silence and [Page 57]Attention, to hear what he may be pleased to speak to and in her: speak to her, not only in Guiding and Admonishing in all necessary Duty, but also in things indifferent, or also good, but not necessary, when several of them happen to fall under deliberation; in which she also desires to be instructed by him, that she may still chuse and do, that which may better please him, and wherein his Holy Will may be more perfectly accomplished. §. 27.
Which Acts of Love, when once to a competent degree facilitated in us, as they fill the Soul with great Consolations, so they exceedingly help to advance it in all Christian Duties and Vertues. For Love will not be idle, and works in us now with much more Fidelity and Alacrity, as doing all things not out of Fear, but Affection; and not to obey, but please her Beloved, and gain from him also a reciprocal Love. And when a Soul is arrived so far, through the constant Exercise and Custom of Prayer, and other Mortifications necessary to it, that these Acts of Love, and of the Will, (of which there are many several Degrees surpassing one another) are rendered easie and frequent, and upon every Occasion speedily resumed, without any or much preceedent meditation; which Acts before were difficult and rare: And when the Soul, by reason of the greater Sweetness she finds in this latter affective Meditation, as I may call it, returns not to the former inventive Meditation without some reluctance, this is the first Entrance into that which is stiled a State of Perfection, such as Humane Industry attains; namely, wherein the Will assisted with Grace excites it self to these Acts of Love and simple Contemplation. Of which Practice thus St. Bernard, De interiori Domo, c. 14. Jam fortasse [Page 58]ascendisti, jam ad cor tuum rediisti, & ibi stare didicisti: nec hoc sufficiat tibi; Disce habitare, & mansionem facere; & qualicunque mentis vagatione abstractus fueris, illuc semper redire festina. Absque dubio per multum usum quandoque tibi vertetur in oblectamentum in tantum ut absque ullâ laboris difficultate possis ibi assiduus esse; quin imo poena potius tibi sit alibi quam ibi moram aliquam facere. ‘Thou hast now perhaps ascended; thou hast now returned to thy Heart; and hast learned to stand there: Nor let this suffice thee: Learn to dwell, learn to make thy abode (there.) And with whatever Wandering of Mind thou shalt be withdrawn, make haste always to return thither. Without doubt by much use it will at one time or other be turned to Delight to thee, insomuch, that without any laborious Difficulty thou may'st be there continually; yea, rather it will be a Pain to thee to make any stay any where else than there.’ Thus He; yet is the Soul not directed here to remain idle, stupid, or unactive, but to return to its wonted Meditations; and if neither fitly disposed for these, to Vocal and set Forms of Prayer; or also to Reading, when the Sweetness of such Contemplation ceaseth. §. 28.
Devout Souls advanced hitherto are directed and provoked to yet much higher flights, and by their continued Devotions to prosecute a further Fruition of that Object, which hath no bounds. To this purpose, for their Encouragement, is declared to them, from Persons experienced therein, the many rich Rewards of Prayer; the Supernatural Elevations that God is pleased to advance some Souls to, who have been much practised in this Holy Exercise, and the more free and familiar Manifestations of himself that he makes to them in several manners mentioned [Page 59]before; wherein the Soul doth not now act so much, as, in a great Quietness, Silence, and rest of its former natural Operations, is more immediately moved and acted by a more special Presence of God in it, who sometimes with the Touches and Influences of an extraordinary Grace doth illuminate, inflame, and ravish the Soul, and causeth in it an ineffable and transporting Delight in Contemplating what is shewed to it of the Divine Beauty and Perfections; perceiving in it self a most ardent Love, and this Supernaturally infused; when also are communicated to it many times Coelestial Secrets, and Divine Mysteries, and future Events, by internal Words and Revelation. All which things are received by it with a great Tranquility, and Attention, and Cessation of the Natural use of its Faculties, Sensitive or Intellectual: Nor seems it in its own disposal whilst it hath these Touches, but both doth and must see, and think, only what his Divine Majesty will have it; and this only so long as he pleaseth. Nor can any of these things by any Art or Industry of the Soul be attained or procured when she will, but all is Supernatural, and as well above the Operations of common Grace in us, as of Reason. In which Supernatural and Extraordinary Divine Impressions upon the Soul, the Experienced also observe two sorts of Motions in it: Either a very intimate Retreat and Recollection of the Soul from Exterior Objects, as it were into some interior part of it self, removed from the Thoughts or Remembrace of Creatures or Worldly things; which is often joyned with a Retiring also of the Vital Spirits, more or less, from the outward parts of the Body left sometimes in such Recollection without Sense, Motion, or Heat. Alienatio Mentis à Sensibus Corporis, S. Augustin (in [Page 60] Psal. 67.) calls it, ut Spiritui quod demonstrandum est demonstretur. Such perhaps was that Extasie of St. John, when he is said to have been in the Spirit, Rev. 1.10. Or, 2. an Elevation, Rapt, or Flight of the Soul as it were above it self, and as if it were to depart presently out of the Body, and the Person to suffer a present Dissolution. Avolatio Mentis, as S. Bernard expresseth it. Such seems that of St. Paul, 2 Cor. 12. §. 29.
These things are not handled as Rules of Devotion, but as a Reward of it; and as things only in God's, not our Power. Yet are these Rich Gifts of God and Pregustations of the State in the World to come recommended to signifie the many noble Effects and powerful Influences, which such Favours have upon those who receive them, as to the compleating them in all Christian Perfection; that is, in the perfect Love of God; all these Divine Inactions tending still to a clearer Manifestation of God to the Soul, and so to the wounding it more deeply with the Love and Longing after him, and after the Suffering and Doing any thing with all Alacrity for him; and the Graces that are received disposing us still to others higher, if the Soul correspond to them as she ought. If I persevere (saith S. Bernard (in Cant. Serm. 69.) speaking of these Favours) to correspond to this Condescention, as much as I can, with meet Affections and Actions, and the Grace of God be not in vain in me, the Father and the Son will ever make their Abode with me.
We are also told, That, though upon no Preparations and Predispositions in us, whatever such Favours do necessarily follow, yet without these God doth not usually grant them: That Active Contemplation is the ready way to Passive; and, That [Page 61]though in the higher degrees of them they are but rare, and given to few, yet in some inferior degree they are communicated to many: and however, That an Active Contemplation and Fruition of God by Love, (spoken of before) and the Great Advancement in all Christian Vertue gain'd thereby, (if we be admitted to no higher things, of which true Humility always esteems its self unworthy) is a sufficient Recompence in this World for any Pains of ours in Purging of our Life, and close Attendance on God in Solitude and Prayer, which is undertaken for it.
Lastly, since such Christian Perfection chiefly contains in, and depends upon the Exercise of the Affective part of the Soul, and not on high Knowledge or Speculation, therefore it is recommended as attainable by all Sexes and Conditions, and all are equally encouraged in the Prosecution of it. For the Grace of Contemplation, as S. Gregory observes, in Ezek. hom. 17. is not given to the high, and not given to the low; but this do often the highest, and often the lowest; more often those who are remote, that is, from Worldly Cares, but sometimes those who are in a Married State receive. §. 30, 31.
More of this he hath afterward, which I shall here add, as followeth:
Of the Steps, in order to the highest State of Perfection, which this Life arrives to, mentioned in Sancta Sophia, p. 32. 1. The first, is the way of External and Imaginary Exercises of Prayer; that is, using the Discourse of the Understanding, and Meditations, as also Vocal Prayer; then which Step, Sancta Sophia observes, many go no further, but end their days in it; that is, in such Meditations is taken up the most part of their Devotions.
2. The second Step is, the Exercise of the Will and Affections, which, after long practice, breaks forth into continual Aspirations and Elevations thereof.
3. The Third, is, Divine Inaction, or the extraordinary, and supernatural, and more sensible Operations of God's Spirit in the Soul, wherein God acteth more than she, and which are not in her power at all to procure sooner, or retain longer, then God pleaseth: of which much hath been said before.
4. After which usually, in the Intervals of those Coelestial Visits, do follow great Desolations of Spirit, as the Experienced have described them; partly arising from the sense of her Loss, and an impatient longing after these Favours, once tasted; and partly out of a great nauseating, and disrelish that she hath now of those entertainments of the Creature, from which she formerly received some Content. Such we may imagin was that of the Prophet David, when he said; Heu mihi, quia incolatus meus prolongatus est, And Concupiscit & deficit anima mea, in atria Domini, And after a Non movebor in aeternum, (Psal. 29.) an Avertisti faciem tuam, & factus sum conturbatus. §. 63.
But not only this; but God also sometimes withdraws even from his greatest Saints, and that for some long duration of time, any sensible assistance at all of his Grace, leaving the Soul as it were in its pure Naturals, and as if he were quite departed from it, in great Aridity, Obscurity, Solitude, Pressure and Heaviness, disgusted with all things, she knows not why; performing still her Devotions, and accustomed Duties of Piety, and the Service of God, as formerly, but without any sensible comfort in such [Page 63]Performance; Meditation, Aspiration, Reading, very difficult, sterile, insipid, and seeming without Fruit; only forbearing her Consent to any Sin, Vanity, or Sensuality, and not seeking any secular Consolations. Much discouraged also at such times many are, in imagining, that God hath so deserted them, for Failings in their Duty, or for something wherein they have offended his Divine Majesty, which doubles this Anguish. Or, if not this, at least they imagin it to be caused by some great Indisposition of Body, (as it is granted sometimes partly it may) so as some begin therefore to dispense for a time with the former Exercises of their Devotion, and other pious Employments. But notwithstanding many times in these, the poor Soul is mistaken; and this strange dejection of Spirit comes, without any such respects, meerly from the sole Will of God, and is the ordinary course of his proceeding with those also, who are by his former Graces well grounded, and arrived to some degree of Perfection, and is sent only for their much greater Advancement therein, and the rendring them more capable of higher Favours; and therefore ought, as such, to be entertained with all Equanimity, Patience, Resignation, and Conformity to his Will.
These Consolations and Desolations take, as it were, their certain turns in them, as they do, in a lesser degree, in all the Regenerate; they have by course a Day, and a Night; an Ascent towards God, and a Descent, and decadence into themselves; a Vivification by and in him, and a Mortification in themselves; a Summer, wherein the Branches shoot forth, and Fruit comes to Maturity; and a Winter, when the Root spreads more, and the Tree becomes more surely fixed. To all God's Children do these Vicissitudes [Page 64]happen; but these in a higher degree to the further advanced in Perfection; and the greatest Favours are preceeded with greater Desolations; and these ordinarily proportioned one to the other. And always necessary, less or more, are such Purgations and Refinings of the Soul by these interior Crosses, because always something in them is amiss, and as yet imperfect. Our natural Corruption is still producing something in us to be amended; and some Self-will and Self-love to be parted away by this sharp Remedy, whilst we are in this Life. And the Benefit of these Desolations, if rightly complied with, as well as of Divine Consolations, is very great in many respects. §. 64.
For herein it is, that the Soul comes most perfectly to know it self, and all other Creatures; to see its own Nothingness, and to be most perfectly purged and cleansed from all Self-love and Propriety: and herein it is most especially taught — non quiescere in donis Dei, sed in Deo; and Adorare Deum in Spiritu & Veritate; not, in Devotione: and Exercere se ad Deum in adversis, sicut in prosperis; the seeking Gust, and Suavity, and Consolations, even in Spiritual things, being one of its Imperfections, since these are not God himself. Herein it is, that the Soul is preserved amidst such Divine Favours, which are apt to inflate it, in a due and necessary Humility; (Angelus Satanae colaphisans, ne magnitudo Revelationum extollat me, saith the Apostle after his Rapt.) Herein its true Love and Adherence to God; (Qui veniendo adjuvat; and then, derelinquendo probat: Donis firmat; and then, Tribulationibus tentat; saith St. Gregory, Moral. l. 20. c. 19.) its Perseverance and Loyalty are especially discerned, in keeping constant in the Service of him, when deprived of [Page 65]all Consolation in it; avoiding any application to the Comforts of the Creature, when God hath thus as it were dismissed, and cast it off: But resigning it self, and loving its Misery for his Sake, and because it is his Will that it should be so. An Exercise wherein our Lord himself was pleased to be tried, (that he might become a merciful High Priest before God, and experimentally) that he might compassionate our Infirmities in the great Desolation he underwent in the Garden, the Night before his Passion, Heb. 4.15: 2.17. Where, caepit pavere & taedere, saith the Evangelist, Matt. 26.37, 38. And that sad Expression came from him, Tristis est anima mea usque ad mortem: Tarry here, and watch with me, Mark 14.34. Yet these Desolations also, in a Soul thus far advanced in Grace, are not void of a mixture of Joy and Satisfaction, that it hath always in God's Will being performed in them; which Will of God now, in whatever happens, is a constant Consolation to it; and the Apostles Precept, 1 Thess. 5.16, 17. of Semper gaudete, is thus accomplished in such a Soul, as well as his orate sine intermissione; and go together. For there cannot want Content, where the Mind hath its Desire; nor doth such a Mind want this that is unanimous with the Divine Will: the want of which Conformity, is only from the loving of something that is against his Will. Worldly Sorrows, saith St. Gregory, affligentes cruciant; but these Spiritual, reficiunt dum affligunt. In the one is, In afflictione maeror; but in the other, In merore laetitia, Moral. l. 23. c. 13. Nay, more true Sweetness [...] these Sorrows, than in the other Joys: And the abstaining in such a sharp Tryal from all Sin against God, or seeking Comfort from any thing besides Him, or giving over her accustomed [Page 66]Exercises of Piety, argues also then a close Ʋnion of the Soul with God, though not so sensible; and that when it thinks it self farthest from him, it is in some sort nearest to him. Lastly, by and upon these Spiritual Desolations ordinarily it is, that the Soul afterward receives higher sensible Visits, and Caresses from God, then any former were; for which the Soul seems best prepared by this her extream Poverty and Lowness; and then it is, if ever, the Soul receives them with more Gratitude; and both highlier values them, and villifies its self. And it is God's ordinary way to exalt us in proportion to our Humility, and to be Adjutor in tribulationibus, as in opportunitatibus, when also the Soul is more endeared unto him by her Sufferings. All this I have said, to shew that these Spiritual Desolations (of which this Author Ironically saith, Then, when one would least expect them, follow, &c.) are a necessary part of the Way to Perfection; and that the resistance of such Pressures when they come, or a non-compliance with them in shewing much Irresignation and Impatience, in seeking to relieve such Spiritual Desertions with some secular Contents, in relaxing former Holy Practices, and the like, disappoints the Soul of those following Consolations, which are the proper Reward of these Sufferings, and disturbs God's Work in her, and good Intentions toward her; and hinders her Growth in Vertue, by her retaining still those Imperfections, and that Self-love, which these, rightly received, would have purged and mortified. This of the fourth Step to Perfection, Desolation.
5. The Fifth, is a State more settled, constant, and tranquil, where neither these Desolations are so frequent or necessary; nor those Coelestial Visits so violent, or so short. §. 65.
To these I shall add two or three of his Answers, to Objections and Cavils, such as I think most pertinent for Common use: and first, whereas upon the first Step his Adversary descants thus: ‘A sad Case to end our days as Christ and his Apostles did, who used this low dispensation of Praying to the last. But, alas! they never understood these Ʋnions with God in the Fund of the Spirit; they taught Men a plain and intelligible way of Serving God, and bid them look for Perfection in another World.’ To this he replies;
I ask, Did our Lord and his Apostles end their days only, or chiefly, in the first Step here, that of Meditation, and Discursive or Vocal Prayer, and never ascend to the second Step, exercising more therein the Will and Affections in Aspirations, and Elevations of the Soul to God? What think we of the most exalted Disciple St. John, every where discoursing so much of Love? and of our dwelling, by Love, in God, and God in us? 1 John 4.16. What of those Precepts, Pray without ceasing, 1 Thess. 5.17. Watch and pray always, Luk. 21.36. And with all Perseverance therein? Eph. 6.18. Are these to be understood only of Vocal and discursive Prayer, the first Step; or not rather of Effective Prayer, the second; (according to that, Qui semper desiderat semper orat;) which latter is also much easier to be continued? Again; What think we of our Lord's spending so long time in Prayer, often mentioned in the Gospels? Rising up a great while before day, for this purpose, Mar. 1.35. Again; retiring into the Wilderness, for a great vacancy to it, Luk. 5.16. Before the day of the Election of his twelve Apostles, (the twelve Foundations of his Church) ascending into a solitary Mountain, and there spending the whole Night in Prayer, Luk. 6.13. His [Page 68]ascending again into another Mountain, before he took his last Journey to Jerusalem, for the accomplishing of his Passion, taking three of his Disciples with him, where all the Night again was spent in Prayer; for it is said, he descended not from the Hill till the next day: and that there the three Disciples were surprised with Sleep, Luk. 9.37, 32. In which Prayer they saw his Countenance changed, and an anticipated appearance of his Glory, such as he shall have when he comes to Judgment, 2 Pet. 1.16. and an Apparition also of Moses and Elias, they by a supernatural Illumination knowing also who the Persons were, Matt. 16.28. and his Disciple Peter in such an Extatick Joy, as that he cryed out, Bonum est esse hic, &c. Luk. 9.33. not knowing, saith the Evangelist, what he said. So, in our Lord's being in Prayer, presently after John's Baptizing him happened the Vision of the Heavens opened, the Holy Ghost descending upon him in a Bodily shape like a Dove, seen by the Baptist, Luk. 3.21, 22. and a Voice from Heaven speaking to him, as here, Thou art my beloved Son, Luk. 9.35. And then a Rapt of the same Spirit that carried him into the Desart; where also we may rationally imagin his time to have been wholly spent in Prayer and Devotion, and this in such a degree, as to suspend and supercede the ordinary Functions of Nature, as to Eating and Drinking; and in these his Prayers the Tempter to have assaulted him. What think we again of our Lord's Infremuit Spiritu, once and again, in his Prayer to his Father for the Resurrection of Lazarus? Joh. 11.33, 38. of the ravishing Expressions of his Love, and tender Affection, and Aspirations after a perfect Union of all his with Him, and his Father, in his Prayer after his last Supper, [Page 69]delivered, Joh. 17. from ver. 20. to the end. And, lastly, of his [...] in the Garden, with few Words, but much Passion, being in an Agony, and sweating Blood, and making frequent acts of Resignation, and Conformity to the Will of his Father. What think we again of St. Peter's Extatical Prayer, and his Vision on Simon the Tanner's House-top, Act. 10.9. and again, St. Paul's in the Temple, Act. 22.17. Whilst I prayed, I was in an Extasie, &c? Did our Lord and his Apostles, in the Devotions here mentioned, not ascend at all to that which the Mysticks make the second Step to Perfection, the Aspirations and Elevations of the Will and Affections; but only stay on the first Step? and, Did they understand nothing of that the Mysticks call passive Ʋnions with God? Their Extasies and Raptures, and their being in the Spirit, their [...], 2 Cor. 12.4. and [...], Rom. 8.26. argue otherwise. But then are Passive Ʋnions the obscure and unintelligible way of Serving God, that the Church teacheth in her Rules of Devotion; or, the end rather which her plain and intelligible way sometimes attains to? Lastly, Is there not in some sort a State of Perfection also in this World? 1 Cor. 2.6. we speak Wisdom among the Perfect. And Phil. 3.15. let us, as many as be perfect, be thus minded. And Luk. 6.40. Every one that is perfect, shall be as his Master, (that is, in Sufferings like him.) The Author may do well to review this passage of his. §. 66.
The repairing to Prayer, in the best manner we can make it, is a proper, natural, and most efficacious way to obtain a supernatural Light (from God's Spirit) to discern his Will in all our Actions; speaking of such as are indifferent, and such wherein neither we, nor any others, have any external certain Rule, [Page 70]all Circumstances considered, whereby we may be guided, as we have in all such other Actions, the Lawfulness of which is doubted of; which yet is not said, as if Prayer were the only means of our direction in these, so as to exclude the making use of either our own Reason, or other Mens Advice, as is said before. §. 76.
This is not making Enthusiasm, but Prayer, a means to obtain the Illuminations of God's Spirit, to shew us, in two things suggested to us, which of them comes from It, or which is more conformable to God's Will, that so we may follow and obey it: and, What a Christian is he, that being doubtful, especially in two affairs of much concernment, which to make choice of, doth not retire to his Prayers, desiring God to direct him in such a particular, and promising to do that which he shall be pleased, by any way, to signifie to him to be more conformable to his Will, and more conducing to Christian Perfection, (as certainly the one may be much more than the other, although both contained within the general bounds of Good, or indifferent?) And then, what Illumination he Prays for, why may not he also expect? Again, Who is there, much frequenting Prayer, that doth not perceive in them some Illustrations and Influences entring, and injected as it were into his Mind, without his own procurement, touching a more perfect knowledge of himself; or the immense Love of God to Mankind; or some acceptable Service he may do to God or his Neighbour; or secret Reprehensions for some Faults; or Admonitions for the better ordering of his Life; Spiritu (as our Lord saith, Jo. 3.8.) Spirante ubi vult, and he not knowing whence such things come, or how they pass away? yet these [Page 71]things, we are assured, must be from God's Spirit, because no good Thought is from our selves. And why may not we imagin the same (a due Preparation being supposed) of the Thoughts injected in our Doubtings, and Requests concerning Actions left free, and undetermined by the Divine declared Will, what way in these we may rather take, the better to serve and please him? God forbid that the Name of Enthusiasm should deterr Christians from such a Practice, or hearkening to this internal Language; or (as Mr. Cressy expresses it in his Preface) should render Prayer, and by Prayer the obtaining of Divine Grace, a suspicious Exercise. And I wish the Author would a little better weigh his Words, and the malign Influence they may have on others. We say then, Divine Inspirations are necessary (for Grace, as well furthers as prevents us) to distinguish the Motions of the Good and Bad Spirit in our Minds in matters purely indifferent, (which may be proposed to us by either of these Spirits, for a different end,) where we have no other external Rule to judge these Motions by, as we have in all internal Suggestions concerning such other matters as are either directly commanded or prohibited by God's Law.
I shall conclude my Collections out of this Author, with the Explications of some of the Terms of Art which are quarrelled with, as followeth:
Divine Inaction is, in plain English, the acting of God, or his Spirit in us, which, in the Perfect, is more extraordinary, sensible, and manifest. §. 48.
Passive Ʋnions, are called Passive, not that when herein a Soul contemplates God, she may not be said in some sort Active; but, Because when God is pleased so graciously to communicate himself to the Soul, the Soul [Page 72]is taken out of her own Disposal, and doth and must see and think only what God will have her, and this no longer then his good pleasure is such. Neither can any Dispositions or Preparations that the Soul can use assuredly procure it. Thus Sancta Sophia explains this Word: And the Expression is secured by such like Scripture Language; Qui Spiritu Dei aguntur, Rom. 8.14. Not I live, but Christ in me, Gal. 2.20. Not I work, but the Grace of God which is with me, 1 Cor. 15.10. Not ye that speak, but the Spirit of your Father that speaketh in you, Matt. 10.20. So the Spirit, that is in us, is said to interceed for us with Groans unutterable, Rom. 8.26. &c. §. 48.
Deiformity and Deification are words not of late only, but anciently used, signifying an Ʋnion with God, not in Essence, but by Grace; and this Union still more intimate, as the Grace more extraordinary: secured by like Scripture Language. For Deiform, Renewed to the Image of our Greator, Col. 3.10. Changed into the Image of our Lord, 2 Cor. 3.18. Transformed by the renewing of our Mind, Rom. 12.2. For Deification, Partakers of the Divine Nature and of the Powers of the future World, Heb. 6.4, 5. The Lord and we made one Spirit, 2. Pet. 1.4. Filled with all the Fulness of God, 1 Cor. 6.17.
I have no more, but to acquaint the Reader, who this O. N. was, out of whose Book I have collected those things; his Name was ABRAHAM WOODHEAD, a good Man, who with great Modesty and Solidity hath vindicated Mystical Divinity against the Quarrel of one who charged it to be Fanaticism. His Character may be seen more at large in Mr. Wood's Oxford Antiquities.
FINIS.
POSTSCRIPT.
WHEREAS it is feared by some, that what is in the fore-going Discourse related concerning Plotinus and Porphyrius, who lived in Gospel-times, and yet were not Christians, but the latter a grand Adversary of the Christians, and of Christianity, may too much gratifie some call'd Quakers, to their hurt, who are great Magnifyers of the Gentile Dispensation: I do declare, that I should be glad to gratifie any People for their Good, but not any to their Hurt: And therefore, to prevent any such misuse of what I have written for a good purpose, which I have mentioned in the end of the Preface, they must know,
1. That as the Actions of Witches, and their Familiars, if the matter of fact be evident and undeniable, are good Evidence against Atheists and Sadduceans: and the Real Inspiration of any Spirit, if proved, is good Evidence against all such Anti-enthusiasts, as deny the Reality of Inspiration, and that there is any thing more in it than meerly the actings of Peoples Imaginations; [Page 74]so the plain apert Declarations by these Men of the Mystick Divinity, which was more occultly delivered by the Ancients, is good Evidence of the Tradition and Succession of these Mysteries, though they should be found to have erred in the Use and Application of it: And for this purpose was that Collection made.
2. That though Porphyry and Plotinus, and some others of them, might receive some Lights, Powerful Attractions, and Sensible Consolations, &c. from some considerable Spirit, yet was not that the Spirit of Christ, or any Good Ministering Spirit; not such as that of Socrates, under the Gentile Dispensation; for Porphyry ridiculed it; (v. Soc. Hist. l. 3. c. 23.) but a Spirit of Antichrist, and of Satan transformed, as appears most manifestly in Porphyry, who was a Renagado, and Apostate from Christianity; and that not upon any Grounds of Reason, but upon Passion for some Reproof, as Valesius understands it; or some more severe Discipline, he received from some Christians; possibly for some abuse by Scoffing, to which he was much addicted; and thereupon became not only an Apostate, but a spiteful Adversary, and the more impudent, through the Countenance of the Emperor Julian, who was also an Apostate, and such another Scoffer. This might be abundantly shewed, if it was needful here, and may be upon some other occasion: but this is sufficient for this. [Page 75]And this may serve for another purpose, in respect of the Quakers; viz. to undeceive them, and let them fee plainly by what Spirit they have been deceived, even this very Antichristian Porphyrian Spirit, and no better. The Spirit, I doubt not, is the very same, or of the same kind, only the Appearance is somewhat different, more bare-faced then, upon the Encouragement of an Apostate Emperor; but more covert now in this, being a Christian State. But as that soon ceased, so will this, I am well satisfied, to the Shame and Confusion of those, who obstinately persist in their Errors; but especially those, who not only are deceived, but presume to take upon them to be Ministers of Christ, and deceive others; when it shall appear that they are only Ministers of this Porphyrian Antichristian Spirit, that is, of Satan transformed; as I nothing doubt but it will in due time, and that ere long, by undeniable Moral Evidence, if not also by manifest Divine Vengeance upon some of the Obstinate; which I have sincerely endeavoured to prevent; and should still be glad to help them out, if they would humble themselves, and give Glory to God, as their Case doth require: otherwise they will certainly be called to account for neglected Divine Favours.
As for the Gentile Dispensation, there is plainly a Fallacy concerning it put upon them by the [Page 76]Subtilty and Fraud of that Spirit, which acts so sensibly amongst them. For as the Israelites were chosen to be, as it were, of God's own Regiment, and are therefore call'd his Peculiar people; yet were they, for their Sin, delivered over to the Conduct of an Angel, Exod. 33. so were other Nations committed to the Conduct of certain Angels, probably of inferior Orders. And as the Israelites, after they were settled in the Promised Land, under the immediate Government of God, (v. Sam. 8.7.) were often, notwithstanding, for their Backslidings and Transgressions, delivered into the hands of their Enemies, (which was plainly a Representation of Spiritual matters:) so the other Nations, though they were committed at first to the Regiment of Good Angels, though of an inferior order, yet when they came to yield to the Inspirations of Apostate Spirits, (which was a real, though Spiritual Fornication and Defilement) were left in their Power to be abused, and ridden, and led Captive by them at their pleasure. And those who continued under their Conduct to the last, without Repentance, are like to have their part with them hereafter. And this is the Mystery of Iniquity whereby these People are imposed upon by the Subtilty of this Porphyrian Spirit. For,
There is a twofold Gentile Dispensation, or two parts of the Gentile Dispensation; the one of Grace, [Page 77]under the Good Angel, which is God's Deputy; the other of Judgment, under the Apostate Spirit, which is God's Executioner of Vengeance. And this is it, which St. Paul tells us concerning the Seduced by the Spirit of Antichrist, that God should send them strong Delusions to believe a Lye, because they received not the Love of the Truth; that they all might be damned who believe not the Truth. Now, whatever become of the rest, who have not the Favour of the Gospel communicated to them, but yet desert not the Conduct of the Spirit, by God set over them; yet those who have the Gospel in all Simplicity offered to them, and either through Pride and Conceitedness, or through the Inspiration of any Spirit, are drawn from it, their Case is very dangerous: for no Good Spirit would dare, or would offer any such thing: and then it must needs be some wicked Spirit in disguise, how specious soever his appearance be, which for some Spiritual Sin, at least, if not Carnal or Worldly, in them or their Parents, hath gotten Advantage of them: And such are very officious to offer themselves, and very subtile to deceive: And their Neglect of the Offers of Grace is like to prove fatal to them. But none are in greater danger than they, who are so unhappy as to become the Agents and Ministers of such a Spirit, whatever they may think of themselves at present.
This, I hope, may serve for this Occasion; but having for divers Months past been endeavouring, by private Conferences with, and Letters to, the Chief of their Ministers, to set this People right, in what they are out of the way, I intend ere long, if no less will serve, by the Grace of God, to discourse these matters more fully at some publick Meetings, upon sufficient Notice, and there to give a true Account of my Proceedings with them hitherto, and to discourse the Great Question now depending between us:
What that Spirit is, by which the Party hath been generally and principally acted and conducted? Whether the Spirit of Christ, or any Good Ministring Spirit; or the Spirit of Antichrist, or some Porphyrian or Apostate Spirit?
And in the mean time I only recommend this Advertisement to all, That the Holy Scriptures and the best Spiritual Writers give great Caution to beware of false Spirits, and Directions to Try the Spirits: and if the Leaders of the Quakers do not so, they are the more to be suspected: also, That it is commonly agreed by such Writers, that there is often much Deceit and Delusions of Evil and Seducing Spirits, in seeming Illuminations, and Sensible Impressions and Inspirations. See Sancta Sophia, Tr. 3. §. 4. ch. 5. &c.
FINIS.