THE IDEA OF THE LAW.
1. WHen GOD had made the Heavens and the Earth; the Mundus vitae, the World of Life, and Formes or [...]; And thus compleated his work in the Senary; comprehending the whole Creation in Six Orders of things: He ceased from ever creating any thing more, either in the outward Material World, or in the World of [Page 2] Life. But his Creative power retyring into himself, he enjoyed his own eternal Rest, which is his immutable and indefatigable Nature, that with ease oversees all the whole Compass of Beings; and continues Essence, Life, and Activity to them; and the better rectifies the worse; and all are better rectifies the worse; and all are guided by his eternal Word and Spirit: but nothing New hath ever been Created since the Six Dayes Production, nor shall ever be hereafter.
2. Then man fell, after all was perfect, into disobedience, by his Feminine Faculties, and the Pride of the Serpent. And being in this sinfull Estate, his First-born Cain killed his brother Abel, and therefore had the mark [...] Thau set in his Forehead: it was done by God, and according to his Promise instead of Death: he was enabled to walk and live securely among the wildest of Terestrial Creatures: [...]
[Page 3] [...] (i. e.) A sword could not enter him, fire could not burn him, water could not drown him, the air could not blast him, nor any thunder or lightning could strike him, &c.
3. And afterwards, Lawes were given to men to be executed, One not to oppress another, but to fear God, do his Statutes, and keep his Judgments.
4. And thus God forgave Cain, and saved his life: which I cannot account a downright Punishment, but indulged by the mercy of God, and necessary to the multiplication of Mankinde, &c. So Lawes were established amongst men before Moses.
5. And I look upon Moses mainly in reference to the publick Inducement, [Page 4] in which, after this a few generations, he appeared admirable, viz. As a Politician or Lawgiver. In which his skill was so great, that even in the Judgment of Heathen Writers he had the preheminence above all the rest: the Rosie-Crucians place him in the head of their Infallible Axiomata: of the most Famous Law-givers under the name of [...], if Eugenius Theodidactus be not mistaken: or, if he be, at least he bears them company that are reputed the best, reserv'd for the last, and most notable Instance of those that entituled their Lawes Divine, and made themselves spokemen betwixt God and the people: This Mneues is said to receive his Lawes from Mercury, as Minos from Jupiter, Licurgus from Apollo, St. Chrystopher Heydon from his [...], his good Genius, As Moses from Jao, that is Jehovah; [...], But they speak like meer Hystorians in the business that say [Page 5] so, [...] is the word which they boldly abuse, to the diminution of all their Authorities promiscuously: It is said, they feigned they received Lawes from these Deities: And Aristotle adds the reason of it too; but like an errant Statesman, or an incredulous Philosopher, [...]; (i. e.) Whether it be (saies he) that they judged it an admirable and plainly Divine Project that redounded unto the Profit of a multitude, or whether they conceived, that hereby the people looking upon the greatness, and Supereminence of their Law-givers, would be more obedient to their Lawes Pretorian or Censorian: That saying in the Schools is not so trivial as true, Quicquid recipitur, recipitur admodum recipientis; Every thing is as it is taken, or at least [Page 6] appears to be so: The tincture of our own natures stains the appearance of all objects.
6. But to leave Aristotle to his Ethnicism and incredulity: As for us that ought to believe Scripture, and obey the Lawes of our Land, established in the Gospel of Jesus Christ, being a President for all Lawes and Statutes.
7. And first, if we will not gainsay the authority of the Greek Text, we shall not only be fully perswaded of Moses his receiving of Laws from Gods own mouth, but have some hints to believe, that something Analogical to it may have come to pass in other Lawgivers, [...] &c. Deut. 32. When the most High divided the Nations, when he separated the Sonnes of Adam, he set the bounds of the Nations according to the number of the Angels of God, but [Page 7] Jacob was the portion of Jehovah, that is, Jao, &c. So that it is not improbable, but that as the great Angel of the Covenant, he whom I in my Book named The Wisemans Crown: and in another entituled, A new Method of Rosie Crucian Physick call [...], (i. e.) The eldest of Angels, the Archangel, the Word, the Beginning, the name of God, which is Jehovah: I say, that as he gave Lawes to his charge, so the titular Angels of other Nations might be Instructors of those that they raised up to be Lawgivers to their charge: Though in process of time, the Nations that were at first under the Government of good Angels, by their lewdness and disobedience might make themselves obnoxious to the power and delusion of [...] tyrannical devile: But this is but a digression, that which I would briefly have intimated is, how Lawes were received, and how Politickly [Page 8] they are now used; And that the great Lawgiver of the Jews was a man instructed of God himself, to Prudence and true Policy.
8. And therefore I make account, if we will but with diligence search, we may surely finde the Footsteps of unsophisticate Policy in all the Passages of the whole Pentateuch: And here in the very entrance it will offer it self unto our view, where Moses shews himself such as that noble spirit Plato desires all Governers of Commonwealths should be, who has, in his Epistle to Dion, and his friends, foretold, That mankinde will never cease to be miserable, till such time as either true and Right Philosophers rule in the Common-wealth; or those that do rule apply themselves to true and sound Philosophy: And what is Moses his Bereshith, but a fair invitation thereto? it comprehendeth at least the whole Fabrick of Nature, and conspicuous [Page 9] Furniture of the visible world: As if he dare appeal unto the whole Assembly of Gods Creation, to the voice of the great Universe, if what he propounds to his people, over whom God hath set him, be not righteous and true; And that by acting according to his Precepts, they would but approve themselves Cosmopolitas, True Citizens of the world, and Loyal Servants of God, and Secretaries of nature. It is Mr. Thomas Heydon his Interpretation upon the place; which, how true it is in Moses vailed, I will not here dispute: That it is most true in Moses unvailed, Christ our Lord is true, without all Dispute and Controversie; And whosoever follows him, followes a Law justified by God, and the whole Creature, they speaking in several Dialects the minde of their Maker. It is a truth and life that is the safety of all Nations, and the earnest expectation of the ends of the earth; Christ, the same yesterday, to day, and for ever, [Page 10] whose Dominion and Law neither time nor place doth exclude; as you shall finde anon: But to return to Moses.
9. The Lawes and Ordinances which he gave to the Israelites, were given by him [...], (i. e.) as Statutes received from God; And therefore, the great Argument and Incitement to Obedience should lie in this first, and highest Lawgiver, God himself, the great Jehovah; whose wisdome, power, and goodness could not better be set out, then by ascribing the Creation of the whole visible World unto him: So that, for his power he might be feared, admired for his prudence, and finally for his goodness be loved, adored, and Deified: That, as he was truly in himself the most High God, so he should be acknowledged of the people to be so.
10. For, certainly there is nothing [Page 11] that doth so win away, nay ravish, or carry captive the mindes of poor Mankinde, as Bounty and Munificence, all men loving themselves most affectionately, and most of all, the meanest and basest spirits, whose soules are so far from being a little rais'd and releas'd from themselves, that they do impotently and impetuously cleave and cling to their dear carkases; hence have they, out of the strong relish and favour of the pleasures and conveniences thereof, made no scruple of honouring them for Gods, who have by their Industry, or by good Planets produced any thing that might conduce for the improvement of the happiness and comefort of the body; And thus Moses received his Lawes from God; Josuah from Moses, &c.
11. Now Christ teacheth us other Lawes: as for example, when the Pharisees came to him, and asked, Is it lawfull for a man to put away [Page 12] his Wife? tempting him.
And he answered and said unto them, What did Moses command you?
12. And they said, Moses suffer'd to write a Bill of Divorcement, and and to put her away.
13. And Jesus answered and said unto them, For the hardness of your hearts Moses wrote this Precept;
14. But, From the begining of the Creation God made them male and female.
15. For this cause shall a man leave his Father and his Mother, and shall cleave unto his wife.
16. And they twain shall be one flesh.
17. What therefore God hath joyned together let no man put asunder, Mark 10.
[Page 13]18. Wherefore dare any of you, having a Matter against another, go to Law before the unjust, and not before the Saints?
19. Do ye not know, that the Saints shall judg the World? And if the Saints shall be judged by you, are ye unworthy to judg the smallest matters?
20. Know ye not, that we shall judg Angels? How much more things that partain to this life?
Brother goeth to Law with brother; and that before the Unbelievers.
21. Now therefore there is utterly, a fault among you, because ye go to Law one with another,: Why do ye not rather take wrong? Why do not you rather suffer your selves to be defrauded?
22. Nay you do wrong, and [Page 14] defraud, and that your brethren?
But I say unto you, Love your enemies, bless them that curse you, do good to them that hate you, and pray for them that despitefully use you, and persecute you, Mat. 5.
23. Wherefore then serveth the Law? It was given because of Transgressions, till the seed should come, to whome the Promise was made, and it was ordained by Angels in the hand of a Mediator.
24. Wherefore the Law was our School-Master to bring us unto Christ, that we might be justified by Faith, Gal. 3.
25. Now let every Soul be subject unto the Higher Powers, for there is no power but of God; the powers that be are ordained of God.
26. Whosoever therefore resisteth [Page 15] the Power, resisteth the Ordinance of God; And they that resist receive to themselves Damnation.
27. For rulers are not a terrour to good works, but to the evil: Will ye then be afraid of the Power? Do that which is good, and you shall have praise of the same.
28. For they are the Ministers of God to you, for good; But if you do that which is evil, be afraid: for they bear not the sword in vain, for they are the Ministers of God, and Revengers, to execute wrath upon him that doth evil.
29. Wherefore ye must needs be Subjects, not only for wrath, but also for conscience sake.
30. For this cause pay you Tribute also: For they are Gods Ministers, attending continually upon this very thing.
[Page 16]31. Render therefore to all their Dues, Tribute to whom Tribute is due, Custome to whom Custome is due; Fear to whom fear; Honor to whom honor.
32. Owe no man any thing, but to love one another: For they that love one another, have fulfilled the Law.
33. For this, Thou shalt not commit Adultery; thou shalt not Kill; thou shalt not Steal; thou shalt not bear False-witness; thou shalt not Covet: and if there be any other Commandment, it is briefly comprehended in this saying; namely, thou shalt love thy neighbour as thy self.
34. Love worketh no ill to his Neighbour; therefore, Love is the fulfilling of the Law,
35. Rom. 13. And all other Lawes [Page 17] depend upon these: The Politick part of all Law is this following, which ought, as I have prescribed, to be practised according to the Basis of Moses and the Prophets, and Christ and his Disciples. The Method advises you how to rectifie the Errors of all Courts after this order in the Paragraphs, grounded, as you heard before, in the Old and new Testament. And these Rules you must observe.
36. In all Civill Society either Law or Power prevails; for there is a Power which pretends Law, and some Lawes taste rather of might than right, Wherefore there is a threefold Source of injustice: Cunning Illaqueation, under color of Law, and the harshness of Law it self.
37. The Force and Efficacy of private Right is this; He that doth a wrong by the Fact, receives Profit or Pleasure, by the Example, incurrs [Page 10] Prejudice and Peril: others are not Partners with him in his Profit or Pleasure; but take themselves interessed in the Example, and therefore easily combine and accord together to secure themselves by Lawes, lest Injuries by turns seize upon every Particular: But, if through the corrupt Humor of the Times, and the generalty of guilt, it fall out, that to the greater number, and the more potent, Danger is rather created than avoided, by such a Law: Faction disanulls the Law, which often comes to pass.
38. Private Right is under the Protection of Publick Law: For Lawes are for the People, Magistrates for Lawes. The Authority of Magistrates depends upon the Majesty of Kings, and the forme of Policy, upon Lawes Fundamental: Wherefore if this Government be good, sound, and healthfull, Lawes will be to good [Page 11] purpose: If otherwise, there will be little security in them.
Yet notwithstanding, the end of Publique Law is not only to be a guardian to private right, lest that should any way be violated, or to repress Injuries, but it is extended also, unto Religion, and Armes, and Discipline, and Ornaments, and Wealth. Finally, to all things which any way conduce unto the prosperous estate of a Commonwealth.
39. For the end and aim at which Lawes should level, and whereto they should direct their Decrees and Sanctions, is no other than this, That the people may live happily: This will be brought to pass, if they be rightly train'd up in Piety, and Religion, if they be honest for moral conversation, secur'd by Armes against Forraign Enemies, munited by Lawes against Seditions and private wrongs: Obedient to Government and Magistrates: Rich [Page 20] and flourishing in Forces and wealth: But the Instruments and Sinnes of all blessings are Lawes.
40. And to this end, the Lawes we receiv'd successively, by Moses, were first from God, and then from him by Josuah, and from Joshua by the 70 Elders, &c. But the best Lawes we received from Christ, the Apostles delivered them to the Bishops, &c. And the end they attain, you read before: But many Lawes miss this mark: For there is great difference and a wilde distance in the comparative value and virtue of Lawes: For some Lawes are excellent, some of a middle temper, others altogether corrupt. I will exhibite, according to the measure of my Judgment some certain Lawes (as it were) of Lawes, whereby Information may be taken, what in all Lawes is well or ill received by Massora, and established, or by Tradition tinctur'd with the virtue or vice of the Judges, and their Brethren.
[Page 21]41. But before I descend to the Body of Lawes in particular, I will briefly write the Merit and Excellency of Lawes in general: A Law may be held good, that is certain in the Intimation, just in the Precept, profitable in the Execution, Agreeing with the Form of Government, in the present State, and begetting virtue in those that live under them.
42. Certainty is so Essential to a Law, as, without it a Law cannot be just, Si enim incertam vocem det Tuba, quis se parabit ad Bellum: So, if the Law give an uncertain sound, who shall prepare himself to obey: A law must give warning before it strike: And you do not read, that Cain killed any after God had marked him: and it is a good President, That is the best Law which gives least Liberty to the Arbitrage of the Judg (and that is the reason of Moses his strict charge to the [Page 14] people, that they should not come nigh the Mountain) which is that the certainty thereof effecteth.
43. Incertainty of Lawes is of two sorts, One, where no Law is prescribed: The other, when a Law is difficile and Dark: I must therefore first speak of Causes omitted in the Law, that in these likewise there may be found some President of certainty.
44. The narrow compass of man's wisdome cannot comprehend all Cases which time hath found out: and therefore New Cases do often present themselves. In these Cases there is applyed a threefold Remedy or Supplement, either by a Proceeding upon like Cases, or by the use of Examples, though they be not grown up into Law, or by Jurisdictions, which award, according to the Arbitrement of some Good Man, Moses or Christ; [Page 15] as you may read in the Old and New Testament, how Controversies were decided, according to sound Judgment, whether in Courts Pretorian, or of Equity, or Courts Censorian, or of Penalty.
45. In new Cases your Rule of Law is to be deduced from Cases of like nature, but with Caution and Judgment, touching which these Rules following are to be observed: Let Reason be fruitfull, and Custome be barren, and not breed new Cases; Wherefore, whatsoever is accepted against the sence and Reason of a Law: or else, where the Reason thereof is not apparent, the same must not be drawn into Consequence.
46. A singular publick Good doth necessarily introduce Cases pretermitted; Wherefore, when a Law doth notably and extraordinarily respect, [Page 24] and procure the Profit and Advantage of a State. Let their Interpretation be ample and extensive. It is a hard case to torture Laws, that they may torture men: I would not therefore that Lawes penal, much less capital, should be extended to new Offences: Yet, if it be an old Crime, and known to the Lawes, but the Prosecution thereof falls upon a new Case, not foreseen by the Lawes, You must, by all means depart from the Placits of Law, rather than that offences pass unpunish'd.
47. In those Statutes which the Common Law (especially concerning Cases frequently incident, and are of long continuance) doth absolutely repeal, I like not the Proceeding by Similitude unto New Cases: For, when a State hath for a long time wanted a whole Law, and that, in cases express'd, there is no great danger, if the Cases omitted expect a Remedy by a New Statute.
[Page 25]48. Such Constitutions as were manifestly the Lawes of time, and sprung up from emergent Occasions then prevailing in the Kingdome: I think now it is called so by Carolus Magnus secundus, The State oft times now changed, they are reverenc'd enough, if they may conserve their Authority within the limits of their own proper Cases: And it were monstrously preposterous any way to extend and apply them to Cases omited, as in Olivers time.
49. There can be no Sequel of a Sequele: but the extention must be arrested within the Limits of immediate Cases, otherwise you fall by degrees upon unresembling Cases, and the Subtilty of wit will be of more force than the Authority of Law.
50. In Lawes and Statutes of a compendious Stile, extention may be [Page 18] made more freely: But in those Lawes which are punctual in the Enumeration of Cases particular, more warily; For, as exception strengthens the force of a Law, in cases not excepted, so enumeration weakens it, in cases not enumerated.
51. An explanatory Statute damms up the streams of a former Statute; neither is the Extention received afterward, in the one or the other: For there is no Superextention can be made by a Judg, where once an extention hath begun to be made by a Law.
52. The Forme of words and Acts of Court doth not admit an Extention upon like Cases; for that looseth the nature of Formality, which departs from Custome to Arbitriment; And the Introduction of Olivers Tyranical new Heavy Cases imbaseth the Majesty, and cloggs the purity of the late Sacred King Charles his Statutes.
[Page 19]53. Extention of Law is aptly applyed unto cases Post nate, which were not existent in Nature, when the Law was enacted: For, where the Case could not be exprest, because there were not such extant, a Case omitted is accepted for a Case exprest, if the reason be the same: So for extention of Lawes in Cases amiss, let this my Direction suffice: Now I shall speak of the use of Examples.
53. It follows now I speak of Examples from which Right is inferr'd, where Law is imperfect: As for Custome, which is a kinde of Law; and for Presidents, which by frequent Practice are grown into Custome, as into a Tacite Law, I will speak in due place: But now I speak of Examples or Presidents which rarely and sparsedly fall out, and are not yet grown up to the strength of a Law, namely, when, and with what caution a Rule of [Page 28] Law is to be derived from them where Law is imperfect.
54. Your Presidents must be derived from Queen Elizabeth, King James, King Charles, and his happy Son, being good and moderate: and not from the bloudy Factions, or dissolute Times of the Tyrant Oliver Cromwell, and his Sons; For Examples fetched from such times are a Bastard Issue, and do rather corrupt than instruct.
55. In his late Sacred Majesties time, the Examples are to be reputed the best, and most safe; for those were but lately done, and no inconveniences ensued: Now, Why may it not be done again? Yet nevertheless recent Examples are of less Authority, and if perchance it so fall out, that a Reformation, Modern Presidents taste more of their own times, than of right Reason.
[Page 29]56. But those Presidents betwixt Christ his Apostles, and the late King Charles must be received with caution, and choice. For, since our Saviour Christ two hundred years, the revolution of an Age altered many things; so as, what might seeme ancient for time, the same, through perturbation and Inconformity, to the present Age, may be altogether new: Wherefore leaving Moses, Joshua, and the Elders, and the succeeding Prophets to the Lawes and Statutes of their times, and following the Examples of Christ, his Apostles, Bishops, and the Judges of a middle time are best; or of such an Age as best sorts with the present times, which now and than the time farther off better represents, than the time close at hand.
57. Keep your selves within, or rather on this side the limits of an Example, and by no means surpass [Page 22] those bounds: For, where there is no Rule of Law, all ought to be entertain'd with Jealousie: Wherefore here, as in obscure cases, follow that which is least doubtfull.
58. Beware of Fragments, and Compounds of Examples: and view the example entire, and every particular p [...]ssage thereof: For, if it be inequall and unreasonable before a perfect Comprehension of the whole Law, to make a Judgment upon a part, or Paragraph thereof: much more should this Rule hold in Examples, which, unless they be very square and proper, are of doubtfull use and application.
59. In Examples, it imports very much through what hands they have past, and have been transacted: For if they have gone currant with Clarks only, and Ministers of Justice, from the course of some Courts, without [Page 23] any notice taken thereof by Superiour Counsellors, or with the Master of Errours, by the people they are to be rejected, and little to be esteemed of: but, if they have been such precise Presidents or Counsellors of Estate, Judges, to Principal Courts, as that it must needs be, that they have been strengthened by the [...]acite approbation, at least of Judges; they carry the more reverence with them.
60. Presidents that have been publish'd, however less practised, which being debated, and ventilitated by Discourses and dis [...]ptations have yet stood out unargued, are of greater Authority: but such as have remained buried, as it were, in Closets and Archives are of less: For Examples like Waters are most wholesome in the running stream.
61. Examples that refer to Lawes I would not have them drawn from [Page 32] Writers of History, but from publique Acts, and more diligent Traditions: The Hebrew word is, [...] Kibbel, and it is an Infelicity familiar, even with the best Hystorians, that they pass over Lawes, and Judicial Proceedings too slightly: and, if perhaps they have used some Diligence therein, yet they vary much from the authentick Constitutions.
62. An Example which a contemporary Age, or a time nearest unto it hath repealed, should not easily be taken up again, though the like Case should afterwards ensue: nor makes it so much for an Example, that upon Experience they have now relinquish'd it.
63. Examples are admitted into Councils, but do in like manner prescribe or command: Therefore I advise you to let them bee so moderated, that the Authority of the time [Page 33] past, may be bowed and plied to the practice of the time present; and thus much concerning Advice, and Direction, from Presidents; where Law is imperfect: it followes next, that I speak of Courts Pretorian and Ceuforian: Courts of equity, and of penalty, as I practised of Cliffords Inn, where I was sometime a Clerk.
64. I advise you let there be Courts and Jurisdictions, which may define according to the Arbitrement of some good man, and according to sound Judgment for the Law, (as is observ'd before) cannot provide for all cases, but is fitted to such occurrences as commonly fall out; and time (as was said by the Ancients) is a most wise thing, and daily the Author and Inventor of new cases.
65. New cases fall out both in matters Criminal, which have need of penalty, and in matters Civil, which [Page 34] have need of reliefe, the Courts which respect the former, I call Censorian: which respect the latter Praetorian.
66. I advise you to let the Censorian Courts of Justice have Juridiction and Power not only of punishing new offences, but also of increasing penalties assigned by the Laws for old crimes, if the be cases heinous, & enormous; so they be not Capital, for a notorious guilt, is as it were, a new case.
67. Observe also to let, in like manner, the Pretorian Courts of equity have power to quallify the rigor of Law, that none be imprisoned but those taht are able to pay their debts: their goods & chattels ought not to be engaged, but at the discreation of some good man: let time given be for payment, for the supplying the defects of Law; for if a remedy [Page 35] ought to be extended to him whom the Law hath past by, much more to him whom it hath wounded.
68. Take care that these Censorian and Praetorian Courts be by all means limited within cases extraordinary, not invade ordinary Juridictions, least peradventure the matter extend to the supplantation, rather than the supplement of Law.
69. Let these Juridictions reside only in the highest Courts of Judicature, and not be communicated to courts Inferiour: for the power of extending, or supplying or moderating Laws, little differs from the power of making them.
70. But let not these Courts be assigned over to one man, but consist of many: nor let the decrees thereof issue forth with silence, but let the Judges alledg reasons of their sentence [Page 36] and that openly in the Audience of the Court, that which is free in the power, may in the fame and reputation be confined.
71. Let their be no rubriques of blood, neither define of Capital crims, in what Court soever, but from a known and certain Law: for God himself first denounced death, afterwards inflicted it; nor is any man to be put to death, but he that knew beforehand that he sinned against his own life.
72. In Courts of Censure, give way to a third tryal, that a necessity be not imposed upon Judges of absolving, or of condemning, but that they may pronounce a non Liquet; so in like manner, let Laws Censorian, not only be a penalty but an infamy that is, which may not inflict a punishment, but either end in admonision; or else chastise the delinquet with some light touch of Ignominy, and as it were [Page 37] a blushing shame.
73. In Censorian Courts let the first aggressions, and the middle Acts of great offences, and wicked attempts be punish't: yea although they were never perfectly accomplish't: and let that be the cheifest use of those Courts, seeing it appertaines to severity, to punish the first approaches of wicked enterprises, And to Mercy to intercept the perpetration of them by correcting middle Acts.
74. Special regard must be taken, that in Pretorian Courts, such cases be not countenanced, which the Law hath not so much pretermitted, as slighted as frevilous or as odious, Judg'd unworthy redress.
75. Above all, it most imports the certainty of Laws, that Courts of equity do not so swell and overflow their banks, as under prtence of mittigating [Page 36] the rigour of Laws, they do dissert or relaxe the strength and sinnes thereof, by drawing all to Arbitrement.
76. I advise you not to let Pretorian Courts have power to decree against express Statutes, under any Pretence of equity, for if this should be permitted, a Law Interpreter would become a Law maker, and all matters should depend upon Arbitrement.
The Recorder of London; is of opinion, That the Jurisdiction of defining according to equity and conscience; and that other, which according to strict Law, should be deputed to the same Courts: but Judg Rolle sayes to several, by all meanes let there be a seperation of Courts, for there will be no distinction of Cases, where there is commixtion of Jurisdictions: but you shall have Arbitrement incroach upon, and at last, swallow up Law.
[Page 37]77. The Table of the Pretors amongst the Romans came in use upon good ground: In these the Pretor set down and publisht aforehand, by what forme of Law he would execute Judicature, after the same example, Judges in Pretorian Courts: The Kings Bench, Chancery, Common, Pleas, &c. should propound certain Rules to themselves (so far as may be) & openly publish them, for that is the best Law, which gives least liberty to the Judg; He the best Judge that takes least liberty to himself: you see how time alters Laws since Moses recieved them from God: and what Laws Christ gave you in the Gospel: and now how Pollitickly they are practised: by tedious Clerks, proud Students, covetous Councellors Self-will'd Serjeants: whose Learning is great: yet at last the Patient Clients are willing to go home, where they lament their losses, sustained through the Errors of proceedings: [Page 40] the Crasy Judge he sits quietly willing rather to sleep, then to prescribe a method of good wholsome Laws to the People: And thus the poore suffer: but I hope to give you a cleare way in passage onely, through all Courts that with these Rules before a Judge you may know and understand your Case, and the Judge also may give true and sound Judgment, and supply that which is omitted by the Law, fot rhe worst Tyranny is Law upon the rack: And where there is made a departure from the letter of Law, the Judge, of an Interpreter becomes a Law-giver.
78. I have found that there is likewise another kind of supplement of Cases omitted, when one Law falleth upon another, and withal drawes with it cases pertermitted, this comes to pass in Laws or Statutes, which (as the usual expression) look back or reflect one upon another, Laws of this [Page 41] nature, are rarely and with great caution to be alleag'd, for I like not to see a two fac'd Janus in Lawes.
79. Arguments brought against Testimonies accomplish thus much, that the case seems strange, but not that it seems true, and he that goes about to elude and circumvent the words and sentence of Law by fraud and captious fallicies, deserves in like manner to be himself insnar'd by a succeeding Law: wherefore in case of subtil shifts and sinester devices, it is very meet that Lawes should look back upon, and mutually support one another, that he who studies evasions, and eversion of Laws present may yet stand in awe of future Laws.
80. Lawes which strenghten and establish the true intentions of Records and Instruments, against the defects, and formes, and solemnities, do rightly comprehend matters past, for the [Page 40] greatest inconvenience in a Law that refers back, is, that it disturbeth; but these conformitory Laws, respect the peace and feeling of those cases which are Transacted and determined; yet you must take heed that cases already adjudg'd be not reverst or violated.
81. You must be very careful, that not those Laws alone, be thought to respect things past, which invallide cases already desided; but those also which prohidite and restrein future cases necessarily connext with matters past: As for example, If a Law should interdict some ki [...]d of Trades-men the vend of their Commodites; for hereafter, the Letter of this Law is for the future: But the sence and meaning takes hold of the time past: for now it is not warrentable for such persons to get their Livings this way.
82. Every declaratory, although [Page 41] there be no mention of time past, yet by the force of the Declaration, it is by all meanes to be extended to matters past, for the Interpretation doth not then begin to be in force, when it is declared, but is made contemporary with the Law it self, wherefore never enact declaratory Laws but in cases where Laws may in equity refer and look back one upon another: and thus I have shewen you the incertitude of Laws also; where no Law is found, I shall now engross the imperfections, perplexity and obscurity of Laws.
83. Obscurity of Laws spring from four causes: either from the excessive accumulation of Laws, specially where there is a mixture of obsolete Laws; or from an ambiguous, or not so perspicuous and delucide description of Laws: or from the manner of expounding Law, either altogether neglected, or not rightly pursued: or lastly, from contradiction and incertainty of Judgments,
[Page 44]84. The Prophetical Law-giver saith, Pluet super eos Laqueos, now there are no worse snares than the snares of Laws specially penal, if they be immense for number; and through the alterations of times unprofitable; they do not present a torch, but spread a net to our feet.
85. There are two wayes in use of making a new Statute, the one establisheth and strengthens the former Statute about the same Ject: and then adds and changes something; the other abrogates and cancels what was decreed before, and substitutes de integro, a new and uniforme Law, the latter way I approve: for by the former way Decrees become complicate and perplext; yet what is undertaken is indeed pursued: but the body of Law is the mean time corrupted; but certainly the more diligence is required in the latter where the deliberation is [Page 45] of the Law it self, that is, the Decrees heretofore made are to be searched into and duely weighed and examined before the Law be published; but but the cheif point is, that by this meanes the Harmony of Lawes is notably designed fot the future.
86. It was a custome in the State of Athens, to deligate six persons for to revise and examine every year the contrary Titles of Law, which they called Antinomies, and such as could not be reconciled, were propounded to the people, that some certainty might be defined touching them, after this Example let such in every State, as have the power of making Lawes, review Anti-nomies every third or fift year, or as they see cause: And these may be search't into and prepared by Committees assigned therto and after that exhibited to Assemblies, that so what shall be approv'd may be suffrages, be establisht and setled.
[Page 45]87. Now let there not be too scrupulous and anxious pains taken in reconciling contrary Titles of Law, and of Salving (as Mr Phillip Green terms it) all points by subtil and Studie Distinctions, for this is the web of wit, and however it may carry a shew of modesty and reverence, yet it is to be reckoned in the number of things prejudicial, and being that which makes the whole body of Law ill sorted and incoherent; it were far better that the worst Titles were cancell'd, and the rest stand in force.
88. I advise you to let such Lawes as are obsolete or growen out of use, as well as Anti-nomies, be propounded by delegates as a part of their charg to be repeall'd: for seeing express Statute cannot regurarly be voyded by Disuse, it fals out that through a Disestimation of Old Laws, the Authority of the rest is somewhat embased: [Page 46] And the Cromwells Tyrannical Torture ensues, that Lawes alive are murthered and destroyed in the feare of God, with the deceitfull imbracements of Lawes dead: But above all beware of a Gangreen in Lawes.
89. For such Lawes as are not lately published let the Pretorian Courts have power, in the mean space, to define centrary to them; for although it hath been said, not impertinently, No man ought to make himself wiser then the Lawes: yet this may be understood of Lawes, when they are awake, not when they are asleep: on the other side let not the more recent Statutes, which are found prejudicial to the Law publique be in the power of the Judges, but in the power of the King and the Counsellors of Estate, and supreem Authorities for redress, by suspending their execution through Edicts and Acts, until Parliamentary Courts, and such High Assemblies [Page 48] meet again, which have power to abrogate them, least the safty of the Commonwealth should in the mean while be endanger'd.
90. If Lawes accumulated upon Lawes, swell into such vast volumes, or be obnoctious to such confusion, that it is expedient to revise them a new, and to reduce them into a sound and solid body, intend it by all means and let such a work be reputed an Heroicall noble work: and let the Author of such a work, be rightly and deservedly ranckt in the number of The Right Worsh. Ralph Gardener, Esq Justice of Peace and Councellor of Estate to the Supream Authority of England &c. And such Founders and Restorers of Law.
91. This purging of Lawes, and the contriving of a new Digest is five wayes accomplisht; first let obsolete Lawes which Mr. Thomas Heydon [Page 49] terms, old fables be left out. Secondly, Let the most approved of Antinomies be received, the contrary abolish't. Thirdly, Let all coincident Laws which import the same thing be expung'd, and some one, the most perfect among them retain'd of all the rest: Fourthly, If there be any Laws which determine nothing, but only propound Questions, and so leave them undecided, let these likewise be Casheer'd. Lastly, let Laws too wordy and too prolix, be abridged into a more narrow compass.
92. And it will import very much for use, to compose and sort apart in a new Digest of Laws, Law recepted for Common Law, which in regard of their beginning are time out of mind, And on the other side, Statutes super-added from time to time: seeing in the delivery of a Juridical sentence the Interpretation of Common Law, and Statute Laws, in many points is not the same: This Judg Roll. [Page 50] did in the Digests and Code.
93. But in this Regeneration and new Structure of Laws, retain precisely the Words and the Text of the Ancient Laws, and of the Books of Law, though it must needs fall out that such Collection must be made by Centoes and smaller portions: then sort them in order: for although this might have been performed more aptly, and (if you respect right reason) more truely, by a new Text, than by such a Consarcination, yet in Laws, not so much the Stile and Description, as Authority, and the Patron thereof, Antiquity, you must carefully observe, otherwise such a work might seem a Scholastick business, and Method, rather than a body of Commanding Laws.
94. In this new Method of Laws, upon good advertisement a Caveat hath been put in; that the Ancient [Page 51] volumes of Law shall be utterly extinguisht, and perish in oblivion, but at least remain in Libraries, though the common and promiscuous use thereof might be retained; for in Cases of weighty consequence, it will not be amiss to consult and look into the mutation and continuation of Laws past: and indeed it is usually to sprinckle modern matters with Antiquity, and this new body of Law must be confirmed only by such, who in every State have the power of making Laws, least perchance under colour of digesting Ancient Laws, new Laws under hand be conveyed in.
95. I could wish that this Idea of Laws might be Perused, Practised, and Exalted, in the understanding of Learned and Wise men: in such times as now when Philosophy, Reason, Nature, and Experience, excels those more Ancient times, whose Acts and Deeds they recognize: which fell out otherwise [Page 52] in Acts of Oliver Cromwell; For it is a great unhappiness to the people, when the deeds of Henry the eight must be imposed upon them Tirannically maimed and compiled by the Judgment and choice of a less wise and Learned man. Thus have I shewed you the obscurity of Laws arising from the excessive and confused accumulation thereof: I shall next speak of the dark and doubtfull description of them.
96. Obscure description of Laws arise either from the Loquacity o [...] Verbosity of them; or again, from extream brevity, or from the preamble of a Law repugnant with the body of a Law.
97. I shall now instruct you how to enlighten the obscurity of Law, ariseing from a corrupt and crooked description thereof. The Loquacity and Prolixity, which hath been used in [Page 53] setting down Laws I dislike: neither doth such a writer any way compass what he desires, and labours for, but rather the quite contrary: For, while a man endeavors to pursue and express every particular case in apt and proper tearms, hoping to gain more certitude thereby, contrary-wise it fals out that through many words, multitude of Questions are engendred: so as more sound and solid interpretation of Law according to the genuine sence and mind thereof is much intercepted through the noise of words.
98. And yet notwithstanding a too concise and affected brevity for Majesties sake, or as more imperial, is not therefore to be approved specially in these times, least Law become perchance a Lesbian Rule: wherefore a middle temper'd stile is to be imbraced: and a generallity of words well stated to be sought out; which though it do [Page 54] not so throughly pursue Cases comprehended, yet it excludes Cases not comprehended deerly enough.
99. Yet in ordinary and politick Laws and Edicts, wherein for most part no man adviseth with his Counsil, but trusteth to his own Judgment, all shall be more amply explicated and pointed out, as it were with the finger, even to the meanest Capacity.
100. So neither should I allow of preambles to Laws which amongst the Ancients were held impertinencies, and which introduce disputing and not Commanding Laws: If I could well away with Ancient customes: But these prefaces commonly (as the times are now) are necessary prefixt, not so much for explication of Law, as for perswasion that such a Law, may pass in the solemn meeting of a State, and again to give satisfaction to the Communalty, yet so far as possible may be, [Page 55] let Prologues be avoided and the Law begin with a Command.
101. The mind and meaning of a Law though sometimes it may be drawn not improperly from Prefaces and Preambles, (as they term them) yet the Latitude and Extention thereof must not be fetcht from thence, for a Preamble by way of Example, sometimes fetcheth in, Layes hold upon some of the most plausible and most specious passages; when yet the Law compriseth many more: or on the contrary, the Law restraines and limits many Cases, the reason of which limitations to insert in the preface were superfluous, wherefore the dimention and Latitude of a Law, must be taken from the body of a Law: for a Preamble often fals either short or over.
102. And there is a very vitious manner of Recording of Laws, that is, [Page 56] when the Case at which the Law aimeth, is exprest at large in the Preamble, afterwards from the force of the word (the like) or some such term of relation, the body of a Law is reverst into the Preamble, so as the Preamble is inserted and incorporated into the Law it self, which is an obscure & not so safe a course, because the same diligence useth not to be taken in pondering and examining the works of a Preamble, as there useth to be done in the body of a Law it self. Touching the incertainty of laws proceeding from an ill description of them, I shall handle more at large hereafter, if this be acceptable: I shall next teach you how to expound Laws, and by what wayes.
103. The wayes of expounding Law and Solving doubts are five: for this is done either by Court Rolls and Records, or by Authentique writs: or by Subsidiary books or by prelections, [Page 57] or by responses and resolutions of wise men, all these if they be well instituted and set down, will be singular helps at hand against the obscurity and errors of Laws.
104. Now especially above all, let the Judgments delivered in higher and principal Courts of Judicature, and in matters of grave importance, specially dubious, and which have some difficulty and newness in them, be taken with faith and diligence: for Decrees are the Anchors of Law, as Laws are of the Republick.
105. The manner of collecting such Judgments and reporting them let this be, Register the Case precisely, the Judgments exactly; annex the reasons of the Judgments alleadged by the Judges, mingle not Authorities of cases brought for example with cases principal, as for perorations of Sarjeants, Counsellors, and Barresters &c. Unless there be something in them very remarkeable, pass them over with silence.
[Page 58]106. The persons which should collect these Judgments, [...]t them be of the order & rank of Sarjeant Wild, Mainard, Twisden, Sr Peter Ball &c. the Learnedst Advocates, and let them receive a liberal Remuneration from the State, let not the Judges themselves meddle at all with these Reports, least perchance, devoted to their own opinions, and supported by their own Author [...]ty they transcend the limits of a Reporter.
107. Digest these Judgments according to the order and continuation of times, not according to Method and Titles: for writings of this nature are as it were, the History and Reports of Laws; nor do the Decrees alone but their times also give light to a wise Judg.
108. I advise you to let the body of law be built only upon the laws themselves which constitutes the common-Law; next of Decrees or Statutes; in the third place of Judgments, enrolled; [Page 59] besides these, either let there he no othere Authenticks at all, or sparingly entertain'd.
109. Nothing so much imports certainty of Laws (of which I now discourse) as that Authentick writings, be confined within moderate bounds; and that the excessive multitude of Authors and Doctors of the Laws, whereby the mind and sentence of Laws are distracted, the Judg confounded; proceedings are made immortal, and the Advocate himself despairing to read over and conquer so many Books, betakes himself to Abridgmen's be discarded: It may be some good Gloss, and some few of Classick writers, or rather some small parcels of few writers, may be received for Authenticks, yet of the rest some use may be made in Libraries, where Judges are Advocates, may as occasion is offered, read their discourse [...]; but in cases to be pleaded at the Barr, let them not be permitted to be [Page 60] brought, & alledged in the Court nor grow [...]p into Authority.
110 I advise you next, that you do not let the knowledg and practise of the Law be destituted, but rather be well provided with Auxiliary Books; they are in general six sorts, Institutes, of the signification of words; of the Rules of Law; Ancient Records Abridgments of Formes of Pleadings.
111. Young Students, and Clerks, are to be entered by Institutes, that they may the more profoundly and orderly draw and take in the knowledg and difficulties of the Laws; compose these Institutes after a clear and perspicuous manner; In these Elementary Books run over the whole private Law, not passing by some Titles, and dwelling to long upon others, but briefly touching something in all; that so coming to read through the whole body of Laws nothing may be presented altogether strange, but what hath bin tasted, and preconceived by [Page 61] slight notion, touch not the publick Laws in Institutes, but let that be deduced from the Judges of themselves.
112. I advise you to compile a Commentary upon the Termes of Law, be not too curious and tedious in the explication thereof; and of rendring their sense for the scope here, is not exactly to seek out the definition of words, but such explications only, as may clear the passage to the reading of the Books of Law; digest not this Treatise by the Letters of the Alphabet; leave that to some Index: Or amend that Book already extant called The Termes of the Law: And let such words as import the same thing be sorted, together, that in the comprehension of the sense, one may Administer help unto the other.
113. A sound and well l [...]ured Treatise of divers Rules of [...]onduceth (if any thing doth) [...]certainty of Laws, a work worthy the [Page 62] Pen of the greatest Witts, and wifest Jurists, nor do I approve of what is extant in this kind. And not only noted, and common Rules are to be collected, but also othesr more subtil, and abstru [...]e, which may be abstracted out of the Harmony of Laws, and Judged Cases, such as are sometimes found in the best Rubricks; & these are the general Dictates of Reason, and the Primum Mobile as it were of Law.
114. But all Decrees and Placits of Law, must not be taken for Rules, as is wont absurdly enough: For if this should be admitted, then so many Laws, so many Rules, for a Law [...]s nothing else but a Commanding Rule; But accept those for Rules, which cleave to the very form of Justice, from whence for most part, the same Rules are commonly found through the [...] Laws of different States, unless [...] they vary for the Refferen [...] [...] formes of publick Goverment.
[Page 63]115. After you have delivered in a brief & substantial comprehension of [...], let ther be, for explication an [...]t [...] ples, & most clear & lucudent decisions of cases, distinctions & exceptions for limitations; points concurrent in sense for Amplification, of the same Rule.
116. It is well given in precepts, that a Law should not be drawn from Rules from the Law in force, neither is a proof to be taken from the words of a Rule; as it were a Text of Law: for a Rule (as the Mariners Needle doth the Poles) Indicates only, not determines Law.
117. Besides the Idea of Law, it will avail also, to surveigh the Antiquities or Ancient Records of Laws, whose Authority although it be vanisht; yet their reverence remaines still; And let the writings and Judgments concerning Laws be received for the Antiquities of Laws, which in time preceded the body of Laws, whether they were publisht or not; for [Page 64] must not be lost therefore; out of these Records select what ever is most usefull (for there will be found much vain and frivolous matter in them) And collect them into one volume, lest old Fables, (as the Learned Buxt [...] cals them) be mixt with the Laws themselves.
118. [...], because the foundation of this Treatise, lies in the Spirit of the Bible, thus collected as you see, and it much imports the practick part of Laws, that the whole Law be digested into places and Titles, whereto a man may have (as occasion shall be given) a suddain recourse, as to a furnisht promptuary for present practise, these Books of Abridgments, both reduce into order what was dispersed, and abreviate what was disused and Prolix in Law, but caution must be taken that those Breviaries make not men prompt for the practick part, and slothfull for the knowledg it self: For their proper use and office is this, that by them the [Page 65] Law may be tilled, over again, and not throughly Learned; and these Summaries must by all means be collected with great diligence faith and Judgment, least they commit Fellony against the Law.
119. [...] (i. e.) The Secret of the Lord is for them that fear him, and his Commandement is to make them know it. Thus you see the Misteries of God and Jesus Christ lies not bare to false and adulterate eyes in the Laws of the Old and New Testament, but are hid and wrapped up in decent coverings from the sight of vulgar and carnal men.
120. You Lawyers that are Servants of God, and Secretaries of Nature, make a collection of divers Formes of Pleading in every kind, for this conduceth much to the practick part: and certainly these Formes do discover the Oracles and secret misteries of Laws; but in Formes of pleading, [Page 66] they are better and more largely displayed like the fist to the palm.
121. Some course you must take for the cutting off, and saisfying particular doubts which emerge from time to time; for it is a hard case that they which desire to secure themselves from error, should find no guid to the way, but that present businesses should be hazarded; and there should be no means to know the Law before the matter be dispatcht.
122. That the resolution of the wise, given to Clients touching point of Law, whether by Advocates or Professors, should be of such Authority, that it may not be Lawfull for the Judg to depart from their opinion, I cannot approve, let Law be derived from sworn Judges.
123. To feel and sound Judgments by fained Cases and Persons, that by this means, men might find out what the course and proceeding of Law will be, I approve not, for it dishonoureth [Page 67] the Majesty of Laws, and is to be accounted a kind of prevarications o [...] double dealing: and it is a fowl sight to see places of Judicature to borrow any thing from the Stage.
124. Wherefore let as well the Decrees, as the Answers and Counsels proceed from the Judges alone; those of Suits depending; these of difficult points of law, in the general, require not these decisions whether in causes private or publick, from the Judges themselves (for this were to make the Judg an Advocate) but of the King, or of the State: From these let the order be directed unto the Judges: And let the Judges thus Authorized hear the reasons on both sides, both of the Advocates or of the Committees deputed by the parties to whom the matter appertaineth; or of them assigned by the Judges themselves if necessity so require; and weighing the Cause, let them deliver the Law upon the Case and declare it, let these verdicts [Page 68] and Counsels, be recorded and notified amongst Cases adjudged, and be of equal Authority.
125. Next in order let your Lectures of Law, and the exercise of those that address themselves to the Studies of Law, be so instituted and ordered, that all may tend rather to the laying asleep, than the awaking of Questions and Controversies in Law For (as the matter is now carried) a School is set up, and open amongst all, to the multiplying of Alterations and Questions in Law: as if their aime was only to make ostentation of wit; and this is an old desease, for even amongst the Ancients, it was, as it were, a glory, by Sects and Factions to cherish rather than extinguish many Questions concerning Law. Provide against this inconvenience.
126. Judgments become incertain either through immature and too precipitate preceedings to sentence; or through Emulation of Courts; or [Page 69] through ill and unskilful registring of Judgments; or because there is a too easie and expedite way open of reversing and rescinding them, wherefore it must be provided that Judgments Issue forth not without a staid deliberation had aforehand, and that Courts bare a reverent respect to one another, and that Decrees be drawn up faithfully and wisely; and that the way to repeal Judgments be narrow, rocky and strewed as it were with sharp stones.
127. If a Iudgment hath been awarded upon a case in a principal Court, and the like case intervene in another Court, proceed not to sentence before the matter be advised upon in some solemn Assembly of Judges: for if Judgments awarded must needs be repeal'd, yet let them be interred with Honour.
128. For Courts to be at debate [Page 70] and variance about Jurisdictions is a humane frailty; and the more because this intemperance, through a misprision and vain conceit (that it is part of a stout resolute Judg, to enlarge the priviledges of the Court,) is openly countenanced and spurred on, whereas it hath need of the bridle: but that out of this heat of stomack Courts should so easily reverse on both sides Judgments awarded, which nothing pertain to Jurisdiction, is an insufferable evil, which by all means should be repress'd and punisht by Kings or Counsels of State, or the form of Government, for it is a president of the worst Example, that Courts, that should distribute peace, should themselves practice Duels.
129. Let there not be too easie and free passage made to the repealing of Judgments by appellations, and writs of Errors or re-examination, &c. It is maintained, by a Judg in the Common [Page 71] Pleas, that a Suit may be brought into a higher Court, as entire & untried, the Judgment past upon it set aside but the execution thereof may be staid; in the Kings Bench is of opinion that the Judgment it may stand in force, but the execution thereof may be staid; neither of these is to be allowed, unless the Courts wherein the Judgment was awarded were of a base and inferiour Order, but rather that both the Judgment stand, and the execution thereof go on, so a Caveat be put in by the Defendant for damages and charges if the Judgnent should be reverst.
130. Now all they which have written of Laws hitherto; have handled many things goodly for discourse but remote from use; that I ave written is received from the best presidents [...]n the world, and is what humane society is capable of, what maketh for the Weale publiek, what natural Equity is, what the Law of Nations, [Page 72] And how Moses received them from [...] (i. e.) The all enlightning recess of Souls, how the law Christ commanded was love one another, & to do to all men, as they would be don unto, before his glorious Resurrection & Ascention into heaven where he sitteth at the right hand of God: [...] (i. e.) And thus shall he come again to Judgment, as he was seen to go up answerable to what he himself said, as the Lightning commeth out of the East and shineth unto the west so shall also the coming of the Son of man be &c. therfore let us serve God, whose Divine Majesty I humbly implore through his Son, and our Saviour, that he would vouchsafe gratiously to direct and accept [Page 73] these and such like Sacrifices of hum [...]ne understanding, seasoned with Religion as with salt, and incensed to his glory.