REASONS humbly offered in the behalf of Scotland, concerning the exceeding great Dis­proportions betwixt the Assessments of that Nation at 6000 l. per mensem, and the Assessment of England at 35000 l. Monethly.

FIrst, In the year 1653. when the present Parliament was interrupted, the Assessment of Scotland was 10000 l. per mensem, and the Assessment of England 120000 l. Monethly; which was but the Thirteenth part in proportion with England then. And many Honorable Members of this Parliament may very well remember how convincingly and clearly the Scots Deputies in se­veral Conferences instructed a vast disproportion, even then betwixt Scotland and Englands Assessments.

Secondly, The then Protector and his Council without hearing that Nation, or any from them, were pleased to continue Scotland at 10000 l. Monethly still, when England was reduced to 60000 l. per mensem. And now when England is brought to 35000 l. per mensem, Scotland stands at 6000 l. Monethly. A burthen impossible for that poor Nation to bear!

Thirdly, When Scotland was in a distinct condition under the Charges of all their Forces and Armies; and when they were brought to their greatest straights in raising money, the Assessment of that Nation never exceeded 9000 l. Monethly, at most, and that neither levied in a constant way, nor the Countrey looked on as in a condition able to bear it, even in their most flourishing condition and greatest commerce.

Fourthly, Scotlands long continued burthen at 10000 l. and the exceeding great decay of Trade there (except the importing Foreign Commo­dities, and the exporting Money, which impoverisheth it) together with the taking away that constant benefit the Nation ever enjoyed, by exporting their staple Commodities which always brought in Money, hath so drained that Countrey of their Moneys, that it is well known, though the lives and fortunes of Men worth 1000 l. per annum, stood engaged, they could not at this day procure 1000 l. of ready Money to borrow any where there. And although some pay be coming in now and then to the Army from England, yet such is the frugality and sobriety of the Officers, and many of the Soldiers, that it is well known they return more Money back to England, then what comes in.

Fifthly, When Scotlands Trading was at the best, all the Customs of the Nation were Farmed seven years for 10000 l. per annum; and it can be made appear, That in Anno 1639 and after, Newcastle alone did pay 45000 l. yearly for their Customs, Bristol above 20000 l. and several Cities in England more then all Scotland. And even now by comparing the Customs of England with Scotland, a vast disproportion will appear.

Sixthly, If the old estimate or valuation of Yorkshire alone, be compared with the full valuation of all Scotland now, it will appear. That the former is equal to the latter; or, if these who have received the Rents of any forfeit Lands in Scotland lately, and have an Estate in England also, be advised with upon the disproportion, it will appear, That they have paid Twenty pound out of the Hundred in Scotland, when they did not at the same time pay Six pound out of the Hundred pound in England. And to the end it may evidently appear to all men, that Scotland pleads no ease in point of Favor, but meerly in point to Justice, That Nation is most willing to pay what Assessment the 100 l. of Rent in England pays for every 100 l Rent they have, albeit their Rents consists in Corn, which always yields little more Money then will pay the Assessment.

Seventhly, By comparing the present Assessment of several Counties and Cities in England and Scotland together, an undeniable and exceed­ing great disproportion, will manifestly appear. For instance,

 l.s.d. l.s.d.
  • Northumberland County
  • Cumberland County
  • Westmerland County
  • Durham County
pay all four Monethly but2571609Roxburghshire worse by far than any of them payes3070409
Huntingdon 3110203The Shire of AireMo.3221005
Cheshire3850000The Shire of Perth4191710
Rutland1360203Dumfriezshire2260105
Cities in England l.s.d. Burroughs in Scotland  
BristolMonethly851101in all but3320200Edinburgh City (no ways comparable to Newcastle alone) paysMonethly3341200
Chester421507
Norwich930608
Southwark920703
Newcastle171510
Exonpays Monethly but0531304DundeeMonethly0691806
Liechfield0070000Irwing0091908
Berwick0021800Haddington0180006

Thus the Honorable Members of this Parliament may consider and perceive, That i [...] will by no equal computation or estimate whatsoever, either General or Particular appear, That Scotland is the Twentieth part of England.

And though it may be said, That Scotland puts England to some Charge in keeping an Army there; it is answered, That so many of the Forces are not kept there singly in relation to Scotland, but chiefly with an eye to England. good and safety from danger elswhere: It being offered to be made appear, That a far fewer number are abundantly sufficient to keep that Nation peaceable; and that having equal Justice in Property and other Priviledges, there is as little cause to apprehend their stirring as any other part of the Commonwealth; and if it appear otherwise, it is reasonable that they who will not be peaceable, shall bear their particular burthen.

Moreover, it would seem very hard, that becaused Six or seven Regiments are kept in and about London, Westminster, and Hull, therefore these places should be assest above their due proportions.

These things being considered, it is humbly conceived, That it being the Rule of this Parliament in other things to put matters in the like con­dition as they were in at their interruption; at which time Scotland was but the Thirteenth part with England; they will at least so settle the Assess­ment of that Nation now, until it be made more plainly appear (if it be needful) that they are not the Twentieth part of England, considering that Scotland is really at this day in a worse condition then they were in Anno 1652. or 1653. That so that poor afflicted Nation may see and taste the difference betwixt the Government of a Commonwealth, and of a single Person.

Having in this Paper formerly given in to several Members of the House, hinted at the vast disproportion betwixt the present Assessment of Eng­land and Scotland, and made it clearly appear, That Scotlands proportion of Assessment can upon no accompt whatsoever be estimate the Twentieth part of Englands; and hearing that the Parliament are to Assess Scotland at the Sixth part in proportion with England, it is humbly added, That well near these Twenty years by-past, the Lord hath thought fit to exercise that poor Nation with an intestine and bloody War, wherein the vastations, spoilings, and burnings, with an universal Pestilence, made the greater part thereof desolate. During which, the Conscience of their Duty in order to Re­ligion and civil Interests, with the hope of some memorable and lasting advantage to themselves and their posterity, and the daily expectation that one year or two should have finished their troubles, Did encourage them to indure all the miseries which so many Changes did produce; albeit their Bowels were consuming all the while. But now all Estates, Families, Incorporations, and the Body of the Land being irrecoverably spent, and their money exhausted; and there being many hundreds of Families sometimes in good account there, whom no Riot or Intemperance, but the publick calamities and burthens meerly have redacted to all woful extremity: And who (if Honor and Tenderness did not restrain them) would willingly abandon all their Interests, and bid farewel to their Native Countrey, and be content their acquaintance and dwelling places should know them no more. And these and many more, having at this Parliaments return to the Government, confidently presaged, That the bitterness of death was over, and being still in expectation, that the Parliaments Moderation, Justice, and Sence of their Miseries, will make former Promises and Professions good to them; If they shall (after the late Vote in the Grand Committee on the Union, appointing Scotlands proportion the Thirteenth part of Eng­lands) meet with such an unimagined disappointment, whilst God is gone out against them in the unseasonableness of the season, and threatning an universal Famine there; most of their Corns that are reaped, being already destroyed, and the remainder given up for lost; what can they say, or to what Airth shall they look.

But if there be any Bowels, any Simpathy, any Compassions, or if Arguments from Common Justice, the Laws of God and Nature, the Moral Bonds lying on those who rule over men, Examples or Reasons of State, may be admitted to plead for a People, who can say they Agrege not their Calamities beyond the bounds of Ingenuity and Truth. It is hoped from the Justice of this Parliament, That the Assessment to be imposed on that afflicted people, shall be according to a just proportion with England; the which will very much silence their Grievances, and make them undergo the burthen with the greater satisfaction, when they finde their proportion setled according to a just Rule.

This keyboarded and encoded edition of the work described above is co-owned by the institutions providing financial support to the Text Creation Partnership. Searching, reading, printing, or downloading EEBO-TCP texts is reserved for the authorized users of these project partner institutions. Permission must be granted for subsequent distribution, in print or electronically, of this EEBO-TCP Phase II text, in whole or in part.