THE SERMON PREACHED AT the Crosse, Feb. xiiij. 1607.
By W. CRASHAWE, Batchelour of Diuinitie, and preacher at the TEMPLE;
Iustified by the Authour, both against Papist, and Brownist, to be the truth:
Wherein, this point is principally followed; namely, that the religion of Rome, as now it stands established, is worse then euer it was.
Imprinted at London by H. L. for Edmond Weauer: and are to be solde at the great North-gate of S. Paules Church. 1608.
Academiae Cantabrigionsis Liber
TO THE RIGHT HONORABLE LORD, ROBERT, Earle of Salsburie, Vicount Cramborne, Lord High Treasorer of England, principall Secretarie of Estate: Master of his Maiesties Court of Wards & Liueries: Knight of the noble order of the Garter: and most worthi [...] Chauncellour of the Vniuersitie of Cambridge, GRACE & PEACE.
THe controuersies betwixt G [...]s Church and the Romish, haue been on both sides sufficiently debated heeretofore: on our side with that plainness & pourefulness that beseemes the truth; on the other, with such cunning and shiftes of wit, as falsehood needes: but on both sides with learning inough On our side by Luther. Zuinglius. Oecolampadius. Caluine. P. Martir., especially in these later times. By this meanes the particular points in question, are now either opened sufficiently, or neuer will bee: for when two men goe to lawe, (as we and the Papists doe for our freehold, and title to the truth) if one declare, the other answer, he again replie, and the other reioin; it is not possible but the matter will bee brought to a cleare issue, if it can haue a full hearing and an indifferent Iudge. Who should be [Page] the Iudge herein, but Gods Church, by the holy Scriptures? butBucer. Melanct hon. Iewell. Fulke. Whitaker. Reinolds. Zanchius. Beza. Iunius. Sadeel. &c. those the Pope refuseth. And then, how the Church, rather then in a free generall councel? but that the pope feares, as a theefe the Assises See his Bulla coenae which ye Pope himselfe denounceth in his own person on the euening before good-Friday: where he excommunicates, first, all hereticks, as Caluinists, Lutherans, &c. Next, all such as appeal from the Pope to a general Councel, vid. Cōstit. pont. Rom. per Pet. Mathaeum. pag. 883.. Til then, it is reason that euery man, as far as it cōcerns his saluation, be a iudge herein according to the measure of his knowledge: for man is a reasonable creature, & can iudge of reason, when he hears it: so that vndoubtedly if the particular points (debated as they haue been) had but a full hearing, and an equall Iudge: the differences betwixt vs would soon receiue an end.
But our english papists are too blame in both: for first, they wilOn theirs, by Eccius. Pighius. Clictoueus. Hosius. Harding. Bellarmine. Greg. de Valentia. Genebrarde. Stapleton. Heskins, &c. not heare both parties, nor reade our bookes, but onely theirs: (Here wants the full hearing). Secondly, if they do, it is with a preiudicate conceit, that whatsoeuer we saie, the other are in the right; and here wants an indifferent Iudge. W [...]ilst it is thus, there will be no end of controuersies.
Hereupon, wise and godly learnedmen, haue vpon great and mature deliberation, thought it fit to spare the labour, (so often formerly spent in vaine), and to supersede for a time from arguing any more, the matters so sufficiently already debated, but so insufficiently heard and iudged: and haue held it a better course, (both for their conuersion, and setling of our owne) to discouer the fouleness & manifold abhominations of poperie, both for doctrine & practice: which if many that be seduced, did but see in the true colors, surely they would strike themselues on the brest, & be ashamed; & hating this darkness, would long & look for light.
At this end haue I aimed in the course of my poor studies: and that I might be furnished with their own records, I haue spared no cost to get them, nor time to peruse them; and do protest vnto your Ho. & the world, the reading of their owne books (especially the latest of all) hath driuē me into a deeper detestation of popery, then any thing that euer I heard or read of it, out of our writers. wherof whether ther be cause or no, I dare refer my self to be iudged by your Lp. or any of indifferency, vpon sight of these exceptions I here make against them; which were for the most part deliuered at the Crosse before a reuerend & honorable audiēce: where hauing first discouered in the body of that religion xx. woundes, wide, and deep, & deadly, euen such as strike at the hart & life of [Page] a Church; the end I then droue at was to proue, that the Romish Babylon is not healed of these wounds, to this day.
This being done, it is strange to see how they spurned at it, and me for it; affirming openly, it was nothing but a heape of lyes and slaunders, that I am not able to proue what I sayd, nor dare stand to it, that wee are set vp to raile on them, and haue licences to lie on them, and make them odious before our people: and in the countrie they dispersed, I was call'd before authoritie for it, and censured, and silenced for slandering & rayling on the catholicks and that I was stricken by Gods hand, with a strange hoarcenesse after I began to raile on them; and could not speak, &c.
Therfore to honour the truth, and to cleer my selfe, but much more to shewe that it is no trick nor policy of our State (as it is in poperie A book was printed in english in the colledge at Rome, wherin it is affirmed that wee take Catholicks, and drawe vppon their legs bootes ful of hot boiling liquor, and vpon their feet hot burning shooes: and do put them into beares skins, and cast them to the dogs to be pulld in peeces: all this and many such other set down in pictures.), to set vp men with authority to raile and lie, therby to make our enemies odious; I haue bin induced to publish what was said & so to iustifie out of their own records what was affirmed of them. I ask them no fauor, I seek no corners, I refuse no triall; but let me be heard, and then iudged and spare not. If the particularsFeuardent a learned Frier, yet liuing at Par wrot in latine 7. yeares agoe, that we reuile & reiect that praier to the holy Trinitie; Sancta Trinitas vnus Deus miscrere nobis. Thus writes he in his Comment on 1. Pet. cap. 1. What will not he say, that dare say this? for, all our common prayerbooks, now, and those in Q. ELIZABETHS, and K. EDWARDS times, doe testifie the contrarie. I lay to their charge be true, then how can they be the true Church? if they be false, I refuse no censure: and wil further say that if these 20. woūds be yet heal'd, or if they can find such in our religion, he that can shew me either of these I will be his Conuert.
To this end I haue presumed to present it first to your Honour, and vnder your honorable name, to the worlds viewe, not only as a testimonie of the loyaltie, loue and dutie I owe your Honour for your many particular honorable fauours; but especially, for that we to our ioy do find, and the Papists to their grief doe feare, that God hath hath raised vp your Honor, in these declining and desperate times (for so hath Poperie made them) to defeat their deuises, to countermine their plots, and to make them the instruments of their own ruine; fit therfore and worthy to be the patron of that Treatise, which is a discouerer of the [...]r spiritual impieties.
And surely (right Honorable) the churches hope ouer the Christian world is, that God hath ordayned his Ma. of England to be the means (by the aduise & assistance of your Hon. & others like you wherof God send vs more) to giue the whore of Babylō hir last blow, wherof she shall neuer recouer: which most worthy worke as [Page] God raised vp your honorable Father (of happie memorie) to begin:Gretserꝰ a Iesuite was suffered to write within these 2. yeares that we rackt and tortured Garnet, euen neere to death to make him confesse himself guilty of the powder treason, but he did not, & so we hauing no proof hāgd him onely for being a priest, and not for it. And that Ouē (his man) was puld in pieces on the racke, and when wee had so killed him, then wee gaue out hee had killd himselfe wt a knife: But for the 1. wee appeale to publicke records and the worlds knowledge: and for the second, there yet liue witnesses whose eies saw the woundes and bloudy knife, and whose eares heard him freely and penitently confesse hee did it with that knife, to escape the racke which hee sayde hee feared but had neuer tasted. So hath he your Lordship, (paternarum virtutū, (cur non etiam & dignitatū?) ex asse haeredē) to accomplish and bring to perfection. The Father of mercie, and the Sonne of consolation, be praysed for euer, for sending such a father, and such a sonne, to bee the Children of the Church of England. Go on, noble Lord with courage and constancie, and this worke of God shall prosper in your hand. To this end, the same God assist, strengthen, and protect your Lordship: and the blessed Father, for the blessed Sonnes sake, double vpon you his holy and blessed Spirit: wherto I am sure all good Christians will say, Amen, With
The XX. Wounds found to be in the body of the present Romish religion, in doctrine and in manners: & Proued in this Sermon not to bee yet healed.
1. THe Pope is a God, & the Lord God, and such a head of the Church, as infuseth spiritual life & heauenly grace into the body of the Church. pag. 53. &c.
2. The Pope hath done more then God: for he deliuered a soule out of hell. pag. 57. &c.
3. God hath diuided his kingdome with the Virgine Marie, keeping Iustice to himselfe, but committing and giuing vp his mercie to her; so that a man may appeale from him to hir, pag. 60. &c.
4. The Popes decrees bee equall to the Canonicall scripture. pag. 69. &c.
5. The Christian Religion is founded rather from the Popes mouth, then from Gods in the Scripture. pag. 71. &c.
6. The holy Scriptures are therefore of credit, and to be belieued, because they are allowed and autorized by the Pope: and being by him authorized, they are then of as good authority, as if the Pope himselfe had made them. pag. 73. &c.
7. Images are good books for lay men, and better & easier then the Scriptures. pag. 80. &c.
8. An Image of God or a Crucifixe, or a Crosse are to be worshipped with the same worship as God and Christ, with latria that is diuine worship. pag. 82. &c. and that we may speake and pray to the Crosse it selfe, as we do to Christ.
[Page]9. Frier Francis was like to Christ in all things, and had 5. wounds as Christ, that did bleede on good-Fridaie; yea, he did more then Christ euer did. pag. 96. &c.
10. The Pope may and doth grant Indulgences, for a hundred thousand yeares, and giue men a power to redeem soules out of Purgatory. pag. 103. &c.
11. The Pope may annexe Indulgences for many thousands of yeares, to such beades, Crucifixes, pictures and other like toies, that are hallowed by his hands. pag. 107. &c.
The popish Church baptizeth bells. pag. 115. &c.
12. The Pope denieth the Cup in the Sacrament to the Laitie, tho Christ ordained the contrarie. pag. 120. &c.
13. The popish Church alloweth many sorts of sanctuaries for wilfull murder. pag. 122. &c.
14. Romish religion publickly tolerates, and permits Stewes, and takes rent for them. pag. 132. &c.
15. By the Popes lawe, he that hath not a wife may haue a Cō cubine. pag. 141. &c.
16. Some men had better lie with another mans Wife, or keepe a whore, then marry a wife of his owne. pag. 143. &c.
17. Priests in popery may not marry, but are permitted to keep their whores, vnder a yeerely rent. pag. 147. &c.
18. Such Priests as be continent, and haue no whores, yet must pay a yearely rent, as they that haue, because they may haue if they will. pag. 150. &c.
19. Their Liturgie is ful of blasphemie, their Legend ful of lies, their Ceremonies of superstition. pag. 153. &c.
20. A generall corruption of manners in all estates. pag. 156 &c.
To the Christian Reader whosoeuer, be he a true Catholicke, or a Romish.
TO prevent all misconceits that might arise vpon the so late cōming forth of this Sermon, so many weekes expected, I desire thee good Reader be satisfied; the cause thereof, was a long & vnlooked for journey. And now that you haue it, let me desire all men in the reading & iudging therof, to deale with that ingenuity and sinceritie, as I haue endevored in the writing of it. My cōscience speakes for me, I haue forged no new Author, I haue falsified none, I haue corrupted none, I haue to my knowledge misalledged none: I haue taken no proofe vpō bare report, nor haue I produced our men to proue what I lay against them: nor is there [Page] one quotation of any Authour of theirs, which I haue not diligently perused afore-hand, and the whole scope of the place. If any should thinke of answere, I desire him let passe all personall rayling, and by-matters, and come directly to the points in issue: which be these;
1 Whether the Church of Rome teach & practice in these xx. or xxi. points, as I haue charged her withall, or no.
2 If she do, whether they be healed of these wounds as yet, or no.
3 If she be not, thē how she can be the true Church, which is so wounded, and will not be healed.
If they doe not teach and practice so, I will yeeld the Cause. And hee that can shew me that either she is healed since, or beeing not healed, how she can be the true Church, I shall willingly heare him, and thank him. I desire all that professe themselues Papists, or their fauourers, not to be so wilfull as to condemne what they know not, but onely to giue it reading, and then iudge as they see cause. Wright, in his Articles, layeth to our charge many strange Paradoxes: as, that wee are all Atheists, and Infidels by our doctrine; that wee are bounde by our doctrine to doe no good workes, and many such. And Kellison in his Survaies, [Page] thrusts vpon vs that wee deny Christ to bee the onely Sauiour, and Judge of quicke and dead, and many such abhominations; all which we renounce, and detest: yet, do what we can, we must haue them layd vpon vs; and our Writers & teachers haue their speeches wrung and wrested, beyond their meaning to make them sound that way. I dare appeale to the iudgement of Gods Church, and all Iudicious Readers heereof, that I haue not done so with them, nor taken vantage of their words, when it's apparant they meant otherwise; but charged thē onely with such points of doctrine and practice, as themselues cannot deny but to be their owne: and that not of one or two, but (for the most part) generally received. Commending it to thy reading, and my selfe to thy prayers, I leaue vs all to Gods blessing. At the Temple. May, 21. 1608.
The names of the Popish Authors produced in this Treatise; together with the impressions heere vsed.
- AQuinatis summa. Ven. 509 Idem, Antuerp. 85.
- Fr. Agricola de verbo dei &c. Leod. 97. 8
- Cor. Agrippa, de vanitate scient.
- BReuiarium Romanū vetust. Idem. 92. 4
- Bernardini de Busto Manuale. Lugd. 511. 4 Idem, Colon. 607. 4
- Bellarmini opera. Ingolst. 601. fol.
- Bernardi Morlanensis poemata. 607. 8
- Brigittae reuelationes. 517. Nuremb. fol.
- Bonauenturae opera. Romae.
- Cl. Bonarscij Amphitheatrum honoris &c. 605. 4
- Geo. Cassandri Consultatio.
- Covarruvias variarum resolutio num.
- Corpus Iuris Canon [...]ci per Greg. 13. Lugd. 91. 4
- Idem cum glossis. edit. vetust. 507. & 510
- Constitutiones Pont. Rom. per Pet. Mathaeum. Lugd. 88
- Caeremoniale Romanum. Aug. Taur. 602. 4
- Capella in Ieremiam. Tarracon. 86. 4
- Coccij thesaurus catholicus. Col. 99. fol.
- Costeri Enchiridion controuersiarum &c. Col. 600. 8
- Alp. Ciaconus. Apologia pro Traiano &c. Ro.
- Caietanus, in Aquinatis summā. Ant. 68. fol.
- [...]h. de Combis compendium theologicae verit. Lugd. 79
- B. Corradus. Quaestiones cas. cons. Ven. 600. 4
- H. Cuickij speculum concubinariorum &c. Lov. 600. 8.
- Decretalium sextus.
- St. Durantus, de ritibus ecclesiae catholicae. Ro. 918
- D. Erasmiopera. Bas. 4. fol.
- Espencaeus, in Titū. Par. 68. Idem de Continentia. 4.
- [Page]Io. Ferrariensis Practica Papiensis.
- Feuardentius in Petrum. 600. homiliae. Par. 605
- Firmamenta trium ord. S. Frā cisci. Par. 512. 4
- I. de Graffijs decis. aureae cas. cons. 604. 4
- Ado. Gualandus de morali facultate. Ro. 603. fol.
- Gregorius de Valentia. Ingolst. 98. fol.
- Ia. Gretserus de Cruce. Ib idem 60. 4
- Anas. Germonius de sacrorū immunitatibus. Ro. 91
- Io. Gersonis opera. fol.
- D. Hessi Synodus protestātium. Graeciae. Stir. 93. 8
- Heskins his parliament. Ant. 66. fol.
- Hosij. opera. Col. 84. fol.
- Io. Chrysost. a visitatione, de verbis dominae. Ven. 600. 4
- Index librorum prohibitorum. Clem. 8. 97
- Liber Conformitatum beati Frā cisci &c. Bon. 90. fol.
- Litaniae & preces pro fide Catholica in Anglia &c. Ro. 603
- Liber voc exercitium Christianae piet. &c. Col. 92
- Missalia vetust. & noua edit. 905 fol.
- Magnum speculum exemplorū. Duaci. 605. 4
- Monumenta ordinis Minorum. Salmant. 511. 4.
- Nauarri Enchiridion. Wirce. 93
- Onuphrius de praecipuis vrbis Ecclesijs. Col. 84
- Oleaster in Pentateuchum. Ant. 68. fol.
- Posseuini Apparatus sacer. Ven 603 fol.
- Pontificale Romanum vetust. Ven. 520. fol. Idem, Romae. 1595. fol.
- Proctor his way home to Christ. 8
- Pistorius contra Mentzerum.
- Peraldi summa virt. & vit. Ant. 71. 8
- Alb. Pighius de controv. in Com. Ratispon. 42. & 49. 8
- Rhemes testamēt: at Rhemes. 82
- [Page]D. Stapleton. doctrin. princip. Par. 79. fol.
- Simancae Institutiones cathol. Vallisol. 55. fol.
- Tolleti instructio sacerdotum. Ant. 603. 8
- H. Tursellinus de virgine lauretana. Mog. 601. 8
- Viualdi Candelabrum aureum. Brix. 95. 4
- Vincentij ferrariensis prognosticon. 4.
- Vasquez, de cultu adorationis. Mog. 601. 8
- Watsons quodlibets. 4
- Lae. Zecchius. Summa moralis theologiae: de casibus consciē tiae. Brix. 98. 4
- Ludouicus Viues de causis corruptionis artium.
- Catalogus reliquiarū & Indulgentiarum in 7. Ecclesiis vrbis: Manuscript.
Other Authors alledged, not popish, or but in part.
- Augustinus.
- Concilia per Crab. Col. 57. fol. Eadem per Bininum. Col. 606. fol.
- Cābedeni Britannia. Lond. 607
- Colloquium Ratisbonēse. 4. 600
- Epistolae Iesuiticae. 601. 8.
- Euangelium Romanum. 600. 8
- Centum grauamina Germanorum. 4.
- Hospinianus de Templis. Tig. 603. fol.
- Harmonie of confessions. 4.
- Zuinglius.
- Cyprianus.
A SERMON PREAched at the Crosse.
THis is not spoken in person of the Angelles that were set ouer Babylon (as some think) Dion. Carthus. in hoc cap Hoc secundum Glossā est verbum Angelorum sanctorū qui ad custodiā Babylonis fuerunt delegati: quasi dicerent curare voluimus Babylonem, sed non▪ est sanata &c. Et idem ipse Carthus. tenet in moralitate eiusdē capitis.; for Angells haue no charge of curing mens soules: they mourn for mens sinnes, and reioyce at their conuersion Lu 15. 7. 10.; they guarde their bodies, Psal. 34 7 and carry their soules to heauen Luke. 16. 22 but the curing and conuerting of the soule hath God delegated to his Prophets, being men like our selues; that so he might make man to loue man, seeing he hath made man a sauer of man.
Neither is it the speech and protestation of hypocriticall and fained friends, who say thus to Babel, to make a great boast of their little loue (tho some hold so, whose iudgement otherwise is of great respecte Zuinglius in annot. suis [...]uper complan. in Ierem. super haec verba. for the reason heere giuen is too good, and the [Page 2] cause too diuine, to proceede from a profane heart. Her iudgement (say they) is come vp to heauen, &c.
But rather, it seemeth to be the voyce of the trueOecolampadius: Tremel. Iunius Calu. et fere omnes: & ex. Pap. Andr. Capella in suis Comment: & pleris (que) ex doctoribus. Church shewing their loue to Babell, and their longing desire to haue done good to their soules: Bring balme, (sayth the former verse) if she may be healed. Heereunto, the Church aunswereth: For our parts, Wee woulde haue cured Babell, but shee could not bee healed: wee did our indeuours, but found her incurable; therefore now, seeing we can doe her no good, let vs looke to our owne safetie, let vs forsake her, & goe euery man to his owne Country. For now wee see God will take the matter into his owne hands; seeing man cannot heale her, hee will destroie her. Her iudgement is come vp into Heauen, and lifted vp to the cloudes.
The particulars, considerable in this Text, be 4.
1. The Churches loue to her very enemies, manifested in her desire to haue healed them: We woulde haue cured Babylon.
2. The malitious nature and incurable state of Babell, causing a comfortless issue of the Churches labours: Shee cannot be healed.
3. The Churches dutie, vpon consideratiō of her obstinacie and incurablenesse: namely to lose no more labour vpon her, but to abandon her and looke to herselfe: Forsake her, and let vs goe euery man to his owne countrie.
4. What becomes of Babylon being incurable, and forsaken of the Church? what further remaines [Page 3] for her? vengeance and destruction from God: her iudgement is come vp into Heauen, &c.
All these are true in a double sense: namely, both
in the literall | Babylon. |
and | |
in the mysticall |
There is a Babell spoken of and literally vnderstood in the old Testament: there is a spiritual Babylon, mystically meant in the Olde, & literally spoken of in the New Testament. Both are spoken of in this place: the one historically and literally; the other allegorically, and in a mysterie: and this interpretation is not without warrant; for it is ordinarie with the Prophets in the old Testament, when they speake of matters literally true at that time, in & vnder them to point at further matters, of a more spirituall and higher nature. For howsoeuer to destroy the literall and historical sense of the olde Testament (with some old, and many late writers that be Papists) is worthily condemned by the Church as iniurious to Gods word: Yet the literall sense once layd, we may then warrantably extend the text to the allegoricall sense, as far as we see the holy Ghost in the New Testament, to go before vs, or to giue vs leaue. Thus Peter makes an allegory, of Noahs Ark, and makes that business a type of Baptisme Pet. 3. 20. 21: & Gal. 4. 24. &c. Paul of Sarah & Agar, saith by them another thing is meant: and [...]o less saith S. Iohn, of Babylon, as we shall see heereafter.
Touching the olde and literall Babylon, all those points haue beene long agoe verified vpon her, since the Prophet vttred them: The Church of the old Testament [Page 4] 1 would haue cured her: But she 2 could not be healed: therefore shee 3 forsooke her: and God 4 hath destroied her. And touching the mysticall Babylon, the kingdome of Sathan and Anti-christ, partlie they are and partly shall bee made good vppon her. The Church of the new Testament, 1 would haue healed her: But 2 she is found incurable: therefore when Christendome 3 forsakes her, God 4 will destroy her: the two first are already performed: the third is a doing, and the fourth is sure to be fulfilled in Gods good time.
Of all these in their order:
Of the olde and literall BABYLON.
Touching the olde and literall Babylon, theThe first Point. first point is the Churches loue and care of her good, in these words;
Wee would haue cured Babylon.
COncerning which point & all the rest, we will not pursue the particular historical maters: cōsidering that the history of Babylons carying Israel captiue, of their vsage in their captiuitie, of their forsaking Babylon and returning home againe, and lastly, of Gods iust vengeance and destruction of Babylon, are so notoriously know [...]n. Therefore we will passe by the [Page 5] story, and stand rather vpon matter of doctrine.
First therfore let vs obserue this generall doctrine, namely, that a good man loues his very enemies, and not desireth onely but euen seeketh their good: this did the Church of Israel to their enemies & persecutors. For these Babylonians had done the greatest hurt to the Church and kingdome of Israel, that euer one nation did to another: for first they inuaded their land vniustly; then they besieged and took Ierusalem, the seate of the kingdome, tooke and slew their kings, ouerthrew their Kingdom, ruinated their State, burnt their Temple, defaced their Religion, killed whome they would, caryed captiue whom they would, and so left their land a heape of desolation Read for this purpose the last chapt. of this prophecy together wt the ends of the books of kings and Chronicles.: And yet worse then all this; being their Captiues at Babylon, there they mockt them in their miserie, and scoft at their Religion. Come, (say they) you that are these singers, and haue had your Kings to bee singers 2. Sam. 23. 1▪ Dauid &c.: you that are these great Psalme-men, and haue had your Kings such base fooles, as some of them to bee Prophets, some Preachers Salomon. [...]. 1. 1. 2. 12., some song-makers Dauid, Salomon, Hezekia [...] &c.: Come make vs mery with one of your Psalmes; let vs haue part of your Hebrewe musicke: Sing vs one of your songes of Syon Psal. 137. 3. Psalme 137. The least of these wrongs is heauie to be borne: but all put together, and especially, for a Christian after all these miseries to be mockt for his religion, and to see his God dishonored, oh how bitter is it to the spirit of a man! Yet, after all this what do Gods people? not only pardon it and put it vp; but further, doe both wish and seeke their good; We would haue healed.
Thus to doe is a mark of Gods childe, and a signe [Page 6] of a true Church. For to doe euill for euill, and good for good, is no more then nature; euen the publicans, (sayth Christ) doe so much Mat. 5. 46: to recompence euill for good, is worse then nature; it is malice, & peruerse corruption: and therefore (sayth Salomon); Hee that dooth so, euill shall neuer depart from his house Pro. 17. 13. But to doe good against euill, that is aboue nature, it is grace, and a god euidence of Gods spirit: thus doing▪ saith Christ, you are the children of your heauenly father Mat. 5 44. 45.
Heereupon for the vse of this doctrine, we may see a comfortable euidence, that our Church is the true Church of God; seeing that wee pray dayly for the Church of Rome, which curseth vs: and it is very obseruable, that whereas the Pope, with all solemnity excommunicates and curseth vs all to hell, on the euening before good-Fryday Vide Bullam Coenae inter Constitutiones Pontificū Roman. pag. 883. In Constit. 13. Sixti 5. Consueuerunt Rom. Pontif. praedecessores nostri &c. Nos igitur vetustum & solennem hunc morem sequē tes, excommunicamus & ana thematizamus exparte Dei omnipotentis, &c. quoscun (que) Vssitas, Wiclyfitas, Lutheranos, Zuinglianos, Calumistas, & omnes alios haereticos [...]orum (que) fautores, receptores, librorū lectores, &c.; we, for recompence, the next day morning in euery Church & chappell of this kingdom, & many places more, pray for the conuersion & saluation of him and al his sect See one of the prayers apointed by publicke authoritie in the common prayer booke for good-Fryday.: and so by Gods prouidence it falleth out that our publick praier for them, is the same or the next day, when they haue publikely cursed vs: and this is the facte of the whole Church in the publick liturgy, appointed of old, & stil confirmed by authoritie. Therefore if Christs argument be good, that priuate men blessing their cursers, are the children of God; then sure this is not ill: the church that blesseth their cursers is y• church of God. Let them therfore, stil go on in cursing, if they needes wil: but let thē take heed, least as they loue cursing, so it come vnto thē, & as they clothe themselues with cursing like a garment, so it come into their bowels like water and [Page 7] like oyl into their bones Psal. 109. 17. 18: we, cōtrariwise, let vs not be wearie of well doing: let vs follow that blessed Peter, whom they pretend to follow but do not, vnlesse it be in denying Christ) whose blessed counsell is; Render not euill for their euill, nor curse for their curse; but contrariwise blesse, knowing that we are therunto called, that we should be heires of blessing 1. Pet. 3. 9: thus doing we haue Peters owne testimony against them, that we are a Church of blessing, a blessed Church: and the Father of blessings, blesse it more and more, and all that seeke the peace of it, Amen.
Thus we see generally, they wished her well: But what is the particular good they wished her? namely, her healing and conuersion. We would haue healed her: heere many things might be pressed, I wil but point at them. 1. That it is the property of a holy man, to wish aboue all things the spiritual good of them with whō he liues: the wicked man seekes the spirituall hurt of men; the naturall man the carnall good: but the holy man their spiritual & eternall good. Worldly matters haue their time & place in his thoughts: but that that takes vp, & possesseth his desires, is the spirituall good of them he loues, namely, their conuersion, their repentance, their saluation: these things be worthie their praiers, and worthy of their pains. Heerin Gods children are like to God their Father, who wishing good to his people, crieth out: Oh that there were in them (not the skill to rise in this world, and attaine the honours & ease of this life, but) a heart to feare my Commaundements, that so it might goe well with them and theirs Deut. 5. 25. God wisheth no trifles to his children: But oh (sayth God) that Israel were healed: [Page 8] and oh sayth Israel that Babylon were healed! Thus do God and good men accord in their wishes. Learn thou, here, thy duty, if thou be Gods: thou wishest for, and prayest for, and seekest for many things for thy children, and thy friends, thy wife and family. Thou clothest them, & feedest them, & prouidest for them (else thou art worse then an Infidell) and preferrest them, and much more: but all this is for the bodie. But, canst thou say, from a good conscience, I woulde haue healed their spirituall diseases: I haue heartily wished, and faithfully endeuoured their saluation. This is to be a true friend, a true father, a worthy husband, and a good wife: happie they that haue such friends neere them. 2. Obserue further, they seeke the saluation euen of their persecutors: so doth alwaies the holy man. Paul was put in prison, the gayler tormented his body, and Paul healed and saued his soule Act. 16. 24. to the 35.. Many a sinner, is made a happie man, by his prisoner: & the Martyrs oft times by their patience, their praiers & holy instructions, conuerted their executioners and tormentors. As in the former point, a holy man is like to God: so herin, to Christ, who when Iudas and the Iewes were conspiring his destruction, the same houre was ordaining the holy sacrament, and establishing the meanes of their saluation 1. Cor. 11. 23. &c..
Thirdly, Israel liues in Babel, & would gladly haue her as holy as themselues; wee would haue healed her. It sheweth the excellency of the nature of holy things: they are fire, not in the flint, hardly bet out; but, in the bosome, that will not be concealed. A man is not couetous of them: He is indeede greedie to gaine them; but not to keepe them secret and to himselfe, as in [Page 9] worldly things wee are: nay he desires and ioyes to impart them to others; and it is the ioye of his heart to see others as good or better than himselfe. Woulde God (sayth Moses) all Gods people were Prophets: and Paul wished from his heart, not Felix the president and Agrippa the king alone, but that all that hearde him, were like him; not a prisoner and in bonds, but in grace and goodness Act. 26. 29. Hardly shall a man heare such voices in the world; I wish others were as rich as I, as high as I, as learned as I, as much in credit and fauor as I. No: these things make men base and seruile, selflouers and priuately minded: but grace and holinesse is of a royall and excellent nature, and inlargeth the heart wherein it is, with such loue to other men, as nothing more contents him that inoyeth it, then to make others as good as himselfe. Lastly, where it is sayde, they woulde haue healed the Babylonians with whom they liued; see what a good neighbour, a holy man is: he comes, he dwelles, he soiournes in no place, but hee seekes the good of it. Lot would gladly do good in Sodom: if hee can doe none, at least his righteous soule shall be vexed, for their sinnes 2. Pet. 2. 8. Israel soiournes in Babel, and had rather be awaie; yet while they be there they will cure her if they can: and if she cannot, yet Babell shall therby knowe that Israel was amongst them. Thus the whole shyre and parish shall fare the better by one good man dwelling among them. Hee comes no where but presently hee considers what that people wants, what is their disease, what he may do to heal them, or any way to help them: he comes no where but he leaues behinde him signes of his goodnesse, monuments of his holinesse, [Page 10] and a sweet sauour of his vertues. Thus euery place is better for him where he comes: and when he is gone, his memory is blessed, his vertues praysed, his name honored, & his person loued. Cōtrariwise, the wickedExtinctus amabitur idem. leaues behind him the stink of his vngodliness, & monumēts of his pride, his cruelty, his wantonness: Come (say they) let vs leaue som token of our pleasures in euery place Wisd. cap. 29. Thus euery place is worse for him, while he staies, and his memory rots when he is gone. Let vs learne of Gods Church here, so to behaue our selues in all places, where wee liue, or where wee come, that the good may be helped, and the euill healed by vs, that we may be able to say; Them I found good, I encouraged: whom I found sinfull, I would haue healed. Thus shall we be honoured while we are there, praysed when wee are gone, and euer loued and blessed both of God and good men: and the mouth of wickednesse shall be stopped. And thus we haue the particular good they wisht to Babylon, namely, her curing, that is her conuersion and saluation.
Touching which healing of Babylon, there be three particular circumstances, implied in these words;
namely, | who | they would haue healed. | how | whom |
The first is Who they be that would haue cured Babylon: the Text saith, We would, that is not the Prophets alone, or the people alone, or the Princes alone, but Wee, that is all together: the Prophets would, as wee may see in Daniel and Ezekiel See their prophecies.: the Princes would, as wee may see in SHIDRAK, MISAK, and ABEDN [...]GO Dan. cap. 3.. Noble young Gentlemen of Israel, [Page 11] and the people would haue cured her, as is plaine both here, and in the 137. Psalme.
Where wee may learne, that howsoeuer properly, and peculiarly, and more principally it is the office of the Minister: Yet it belongs also to euery Christian, to performe the duties of holy and spirituall edification, to them with whome hee liues, for their spirituall good. Not onely the Prophets here would haue cured Babylon, but euen those three young gallants, being noble Courtiers, gaue a worthie example, to all of their age and ranke, of admirable courage and constancie in Gods cause, chusing rather to die, then deny their God and worship an Idoll, checking the Kings impietie, and condemning his idolatrie to his face, rather like Prophets then Courtiers. Such were their speeches, and such their sufferings, their words so wise, their sufferings, so valorous, and all for their God, that this alone had been sufficient to haue cured Babell, had she not been incurable. Oh happy kingdome where be such Nobles, and blessed that Court, that cherisheth such Courtiers: the diuell should neuer haue his church, where God hath but his Chappell, if it were thus in Christian kingdoms. The people also had their hand in this good businesse, they ceased not in all the time of their captiuitie, to vse all the meanes they could to bring Babel from her gentilisme, and Idolatry; and therefore here are bolde to affirm when she is at the point of her destructiō, We for our parts are no way guilty of it: nay, if she would haue beene ruled by vs, she had neuer come to this, for▪ Wee would haue healed her.
But how woulde they haue healed her (may some [Page 12] say) what meanes vsed they? it is soone sayde, Wee would: words are cheape. But gaue they Babell nothing but sweete wordes? Certainely, they were carefull to vse all good meanes: which especially are
- these 3.
- Instruction,
- Example,
- Prayer.
1. By continuall instruction, laying open their errors, discouering their impyeties, and laying before them the excellency of true religion.
2. By their continuall example, practicing their own religion euen before their very faces, not fearing their scornes, and rebukes, no not the contrary lawes made purposely against them; as we may see in the example of Daniels thrise a day praying to his God towards Ierusalem Dan. 6, 10.: the people also in midst of their mirth would weep when they remembred Syon Psal. 137. 1. 2, and would cast away their musicke and depriue themselues of all comforts, when they remembred the desolatiō of their religion. Which practices did no doubt amaze the Babylonians, and had bin sufficient to haue driuen them into deeper and better cōsiderations (had they not been incurable) and it is to be hoped that the sight hereof did good on some of them.
3. They endeuoured to heale them by their prayers, praying continually and desiring God to heale them: for as the Parent is sayd to blesse his child, by praying to God to blesse him Gen. 27. per totum. & 48. 15 &c. to 21.; so one may be sayde to heale another, by praying that GOD may heale him. And that they did this dutie, is no question: for it was so commanded them by the Lord; Seeke the prosperity of Babylon, & pray to the Lord for it, Ierem. 29. 7. [Page 13] By these meanes, they endeuoured the curing of Babylon, tho they were no Prophets: and by these means, may one priuate man further the saluatiō of another. Thus euery good man is as it were a litle pastor to his neighbour: and happy were it for the Church of God, if all priuate persons would performe these duties, one to another.
The third & last circumstance is, whom they would haue healed: the Text answereth; Babel: where wee obserue two points.
First, that the Israelites aymed not at the conuersion of the great ones, and men of State only, but euen at all the people of Babell. Whereby, it is apparant they sought not themselues: for then they would haue fisht for the great ones onely, or especially (as doe the Iesuites, and craftier sort of Friers at this day See Watson in his Quodlibets often.; but they sought the saluation of soules, which they knew to be all alike before God. For they had learned, afore they came at Babel, that euery soule is Gods, the soule of the sonne, as well as of the father Ezech. 18. 4., and consequently of the subiect and seruant as wel as of the king and Commaunder, and the meanest mans as well as the mightiest: and therfore they endeuoured the conuersion of all.
The godly and conscionable Minister, must heere learne to haue care of the least and poorest soule in his parish, considering it is as deare and precious as the best. For, as good hāds made it, as the best Pro 22. 2.: as precious bloud was shed to saue it, as for the greatest mans on earth Gal. 3. 28. 14. Therfore, let them not bee like those proud spirits, and carnall minded men, that thinke ordinarie parishes not worthy of them, and therefore [Page 14] will preach no where but at the Court, or in great & solemne assemblies nor like those who in their parish, will be acquainted with none, conuerse with none, cō fer with none, visit none, but the rich and mighty; but as for the poore, they may liue & die as they can for them. Such men might remember the blessed Apostle who kept back nothing, but taught (not in Courts and Palaces, and great house [...] but) through euery house, n Acts. 20. 20. ver. 31. ver. 26 and that he ceased not to w [...] euery one, & stood vpon it boldly, that hee was cleere from the bloud of all men (see: not some, but all): and in another place expounding himselfe sayth, his continuall course is to witnesse Gods will both to small and great Act. 26. 22. He that lookes for Pauls reward, at Gods hand, must thus behaue himselfe to Gods people, remembring his account is not for trifles, but for soules, and to that God who hath told vs afore hand, Euery soule is mine Ezech. 18. 4.
The good father of the family must learn here, not himself, and his wife only, but to see that his children, and seruants, & those not some of the chiefe, but all, euen the meanest may know & serue God. Such a man was Abraham, he was not carefull for Isaac alone, his deere sonne, the sonne of the beloued: but oh (sayth he to God) that euen Ishmael might liue in thy sight Gen. 17. 18: and therfore God becomes Abrahams suretie, he giues his word for him; I knowe Abraham that he will (not looke to some of his principall officers, but) commaund not this sonne or that daughter, but his sonnes and his family to keep the way of the Lord Gen. 18. 19: & yet in Abrahams house were 318. persons born and brought vp, &c. Gen. 14. 14. More shame for the great men of this age, both in City & country (who though they be great, & daily plot [Page 15] to be greater, yet keepe they not so great houses and families as Abraham did); in whose families, many of their inferiour officers, and seruants, doe scarce euer come to Church: and much more shame to some parents, who being blessed of God with many childrē do partially respect some of them, & seeke their good of soule and body, & neglect others, who it may be are more worthy: what would they do if they were profane & vndutiful Ishmaels, when they are so vnmindful, & respectless euen of such as be holy, & dutiful Isaacs: but let such children cōfort themselues in this, that God their better father and best friend is no respecter of persons. These are the ordinary faults of fathers and mothers in these daies: but assuredly, those that be heires of Abrahams faith Gal. 3. 7, wil distribute their loue to euery one & care for the soule of their meanest seruants, & take order in their families, that all their officers, euery day (at least in their course) may go to Church, & their very kitchinboies, & horse-boyes, may learne to knowe the God of their saluation 1. C [...] [...]. 9; that so he may be able to say with a good conscience, I found my family a confused Babell of disorder & profaneness, but I haue heartily endeuored to make it a little Church: & tho my family be great yet there is not one whō I would not haue healed. Thus they would haue healed al: but where began they? whom did they desire to win first & principally? certainly the greatest: as namely, the K. & Counsellers of State. This course took Daniel, in whō (more then in any one) this prophecy was fulfilled: who after he had done the business for which the K. sent for him, then fel he to the business of God, wherof is spoken in this text, namely to see if he could heal the king: ô King (saith he) thou art a king; [Page 16] but there is a higher; know, know, that the heauens bear rule. Wherefore ô King, let my counsell be acceptable vnto thee, breake of thy sinnes by repentance, &c. Lo, let there be a healing of thine errour Dan 4. 24.. Well knew Daniel, that if once the King would abandon his Idolatrie, and imbrace the truth, easily would the people be induced to follow him: So, where euer is true reformation either of errors in doctrine, or corruption in manners, it must begin at the highest; els it will be to little purpose. To little effect, were it in the natural body, to heale the hand and foote, when the head is deadly sicke; but heale the head first, and then more easily the body will be cured: So in the spirituall bodie, how should Babel be healed, when the King will not? how should they become Christian, when the king persists a heathen: euen so in our State, how shal poperie be extinguisht? how shall vain swearing, wantonness, profaning of the Sabboth, bribery, and other the sins of this age be reformed in the body of the people, if they be suffred to harbor in the court, & to creep into the Kings priuy Chamber? Priuate persons will hardly be brought to esteem those to be sinnes, that are the common practices of great persons. Therefore wee haue cause to blesse God for giuing vs such a King, as hath care of religion, and who in his owne person, is an enemie to poperie, a detester of wantonnesse, and iniustice, and manie vile sinnes too commonly found in persons of his place. And let vs not cease to pray, that GOD would confirme him in all goodnesse, and that he may still goe on with Dauid to reforme the sinnes of the greatest▪ and them that are neerest him: for when a King sayth, No wicked person [Page 17] shall serue me, nor abide in my sight; then all wicked workers wil easily be destroyed out of the land Ps. 101. see the whole psalme.. If this had been in Babel, she had been cured: but the want of this was the cause of that that followeth.
But shee could not be healed.
HItherto we haue spoken of the first generall point; namely, the louing and holy care of Israel, They would haue cured Babell: Now followes the second, that is, the ill issue of their labors, caused by the obstinate malice of the Babylonians, She wold not be healed; some read, she could not be healed, som she is not healed, all to one end; for he that wil not be healed, is not, nay cannot be healed: for God heals no man, conuerts no man, saues no man against his wil: therfore, he that wil not be healed, cannot be healed; and so Babel is incurable because she contemned the meane, and would not be healed. The godly Israelites did all they could: but the Babylonians had their answere, (as ready as now haue the papists) Think you, you (seely Israelites) that you are able to teach Babylon a better religion then it hath? is not hers of so many, and so many years continuance? was it not the religion our forefathers liued and dyed in? and is it not generall and vniuersall ouer the world, and yours but in a corner? and is not ours visible? and dooth it not prosper and flourish? and is not yours condemned by the consent of all the world? and you for holding it, iustly ouerthrowen and conquerd by vs? is not your visible Temple [Page 18] now defaced? your publick daily sacrifice ceased and your succession cut off? and if you haue any thing left is it not inuisible, and in secret corners? and what can you alleadge for your religion? That you haue manie learned men. Alas poore men, for one learned Rabbine that you haue, haue not wee twenty? are not the Chaldeans the famoust learned men of the world, renowned for their high wisedome, their skill in Astrologie, interpretation of dreames, and other the most secret and supernaturall Sciences of the world? & do you think it possible that so many learned Doctors can be deceiued, nay all the world be in an error, and onely you that holde a particular faction, and a singular new found religion, by your selues, should haue the truth amongst you? Goe, go, poore soules, and sing the Hebrue songs by your selues: but meddle not with the high mysteries of the Chaldeans religion. And what will you haue more? Shew if you can one nation of your religion, but your selues: but all the world is of ours. You wil say you haue a succession from Noah, and haue not wee so too? you came from Shem: and came not we also from him, or at least from som other of Noahs sons? You are but one poor branch of Shems roote: there be many others lineally descended from him, greater nations then you are; and do any of them follow your faction? Looke into the world at this daie, and see if anie nation of all that came from all the sons of Noah be of your religion: all that came of Cham are of ours, all that came of Iaphet are of ours, and all that came of Shem, but only your selues. See then what fooles you are to striue against so strong a streame, and to forsake the a [...]ntient [Page 19] and knowen high-vvaie, so long, and so well trodden and to take and chuse a singular by-waie of your owne. For, did not all Nations walke in our waie, and was there anie one Nation of your Religion, till one MOYSES, and after him one SAMVEL, and DAVID, and a fewe others (to make themselues great and to bring to passe their owne purposes) made a publique reuolte from the Religion of all other Nations, and set you vp first a Tabernacle, and then a Temple of your owne? Therefore you are to bee deemed and condemned for Schismatickes, who haue cut your selues off from the auntient and vniuersall Religion of the World. And vvhat though you can pleade continuance of some hundreths of yeares, yet vvhat is that to our time? for when you can scarce shewe three poore householdes in all the earth of your Religion, (as namelie, in the dayes of ABRAHAM and long both before and after) then can we prooue that all the Kingdomes and Nations of the whole earth were of ours.
Neuer bragge that Abraham is of your religion, and therefore you are antient: for his Father and his Grand-father were ours, and therefore we are elder. During the time that you haue had your Kings and Priestes, shewe one nation by you conuerted, or one that came and ioyned with you of all that time: and tho God suffred you for a time, yet see how at the last hee hath brought you downe; and as you forsook vs and the antient religion, which we stil keep & maintain, so he hath now giuen vs power ouer you, to conquer your kingdom & deface your religion, as it [Page 20] hath deserued: therefore neuer labour to bring vs to your noueltie and new fangled religion, but rather come home to vs and to the auntient religion of our forefathers: neuer endeuour to seduce vs into your secret and schismaticall, and inuisible; but rather come you into the light & sun-shine of our glorious profession: neuer tell vs, of healing vs: heale your selues seely fooles, for you haue need; as for vs, we are well, we are far better then Israel can make vs.
Thus did Babell cast away the good counsell that the Israelites gaue them, and pleased themselues in the like carnall arguments, and fleshly conceits, as Papists in their poperie, & other profane men in their carnalitie, do at this daie; setting these and many more faire glosses on their religion, and think thēselues in far better case then the Israelites: & when God coms to giue the verdite, they are sicke, and which is worse are past healing. Heere we may learn: 1. First the pittifull estate of wicked men, They are wounded; nay, they will bee wounded, but will not bee healed; they will wound themselues, but neither can heale themselues, nor will let others heale them: are not they worthy to perish? they are in the fire and neither will come out, nor let others pull them out: are they not worthy to burne? being in prison, the doore set open to them, and they will not stir to come out; are they not worthy to bee slaues for euer? they are deadly sicke: the Physition comes to them that is able to heale them, and they will not heare him: are they not worthy to die? O deafe adders that stop their eares against the voice of the best and wisest charmers! and yet these men are the mockers, and scorners of them that bee [Page 21] godly, & the discouragers of many a man in the waies of God. Som seeing their worldly prosperity, stand amazed, and enuy their estate: but alas, why should any man do so? for if their estate be rightly considered, they deserue rather to be pittied, then either enuied, or any waie regarded.
Further, heere wee may see how it fares with Gods children in this world; oft times they must lose their labour, when they haue sincerely, and zealously endeuoured the conuersion of sinners. Israel would haue healed Babel: but when all is done, shee will not bee healed. So saith Salomon, Rebuke a scorner and he will hate thee Prou. 9. 8. No maruell, if this be so with priuate men, when the Ministers & Prophets of the Lord, finde oftentimes so little profit of their great labours, that they crie out; I haue laboured in vaine, and spent my strength in vaine Esay. 49. 4. And Ministers may not think much hereat: for the Prophet makes that complaint, not in his owne person only, and his fellow Prophets, but euen in the person of Christ himselfe, whose labor was much of it lost in this respect. For it is apparant in the Gospell how little he preuayled with many of his own nation, yea with the learned Rabbines the Scribes and Pharisies Luke. 7. 30: And after all the excellent sermons made all the time before, went not Iudas away fuller of Sathan then he came Ioh. 13. 27? And to conclude, did not God himselfe preach from heauen, a notable sermon to Cain? and was he not worse for it, & being hellishly inraged, instantly after the Sermon ranne out and slewe his Brother Genes. 4. 7? Thus howsoeuer Gods word neuer returns in vaine, but prospers in the work whereabout the Lord doth send it Esay. 55. 11.: Yet, it is heere apparant, [Page 22] that it is not alwaies the sauour of life to life, but often of death to death, in whose mouth soeuer it is spoken.
Wee must heere learne, not to bee discouraged in our courses of seeking mens conuersions; Priuate men to practice the duties of admonition, exhortation, &c. vnto their neighbours that bee out of the waie: Nor Ministers, to preach the word, with all diligence. For howsoeuer thy labour may be lost to some, yet knowe thy labour is neuer lost before God: for be it the sa [...]our of life, or of death, it is a sweete sauour to God, (sayth the Apostle 2. Cor. 2. 14. 15. 16.): and tho in regarde of men that will not be cured; thou hast laboured in vain, and spent thy strength in vaine, yet, sayth the Prophet, My iudgement is with the Lord, and my worke with my God Esay. 49. 4. And let not the good man of God be too much cast down, tho he see little fruite of his great labours; remembring that IESVS CHRIST and God himselfe haue lost their labour vppon manie men: and heere the Church haue manie yeares endeuoured to cure Babel, and all is in vaine. For shee will not bee healed: And will shee not, what then remaines but this that followeth?
Let vs forsake her, &c.
FOr, after all meanes vsed and all in vaine, then what should we doe but forsake them that needs will be forsaken of God, and haue nothing to doe with them, who will haue no fellowship with the Lord? This is the third point, and touching it there be three points
examinable; namely, | 1. how | Babel is to be forsaken. |
2. why | ||
3. whē |
For the first, how is Babel to be forsaken when there is no more hope of curing her? the answere is, not in loue and affectionate desire to do her good: but still the wicked man is to bee pittied, still to be loued, still to be mourned for, still must the godly man wish well to him, tho he care not for it, but scoffe at all. Thus when the Prophet had called vpon the people, Ier. 13. 16. 17 Heare and giue eare, be not proud, but yeelde and turne and repent, and giue glory to God before he send darkeness, &c. Hee then addeth: But if you will not heare and obaye, my soule shall weepe in secret for your pride, and mine eyes shall drop downe teares, &c. Thus the good man sends vp many a sigh, and sheads many a teare for the wicked, that neuer gaue one groane for themselues.
Nor must we forsake them in prayer; but tho they seeme to vs neuer so incurable, wee must still pray without ceasing to GOD for them: for that that is impossible to vs, is possible inough with the Lord (h). [Page 24] God forbid (sayth Samuel) that I should cease to praie for you 1. Sam. 12: and so must we say of all, euen the greatest sinners; saue only them that sinne against the holy Ghost, which no priuate men, but only the whole Church can discerne and iudge of: God forbid that I should cease to pray for them. Neither must wee forsake them by a final separatiō, neuer to come at them, nor to assist them any more: but still we must be willing to go againe, and do our endeuour, if euer there be hope that they wil be healed. Forgiue (saith Christ) not seuen onely, but 70. times 7. times. When a sicke man is froward and impatient, then the good Physition must be the Patient; and tho hee haue come oft, & to no purpose, yet if at last he wil be healed, he must not forsake him; so must Gods children reioyce, if after neuer so many repulses, the wicked will be content at the last to heare and to be healed. Thus wee must still loue and pittie them, stil pray for them, and still be readie to doe them good: and in these three respectes we must not forsake them.
But we must forsake Babel. First in regard of conuersation: wee must separate our selues▪ from the wicked mans companie and societie, as far as lawfully & conueniently we may, after we see him obstinate and incurable: it is Gods commandement, Flee from the midst of Babel; depart out of the land of the Chaldeans Ierem. 50. 8: and do not this slackly & slowly (like Lots wife Gen. 19. [...]6 but be as the hee Goates before the flock. Secondly, in regard of the meanes: for after that by her often and obstinate refusall, (ioyned with spightfull contempt both of the means and the men that brings them) she hath shewed her selfe to be a filthy swine, then pearles [Page 25] are no longer to bee cast before her, holy things must no more bee giuen to such Dogges; but they are to bee left to their vomit and mire, till God shew either his mercy, or iustice vpon them, either in their conuersion or confusion.
Thus must shee be forsaken: and the reason why (which is the second point) is double.
First, in regarde of our selues: wee must forsake the wicked when they are incurable, least in steede of dooing good to them, wee take hurt our selues, by beeing polluted by her contagion, or made partaker of her sinnes; and consequently, of her punishment. God giueth this reason himselfe: Flee out of the middest of Babel, and deliuer euerie man his soule, be not destroyed in her iniquitie Ierem. 51. 6. Therfore, after that a christian man perceiues there is more danger to get hurt from them, then hope to do good to them, he is bound no longer to stay; nay, hee is bound to leaue them and look to the safety of his owne soule and body.
Secondly, in regard of the means vsed to heal them: which because they be the holy ordinances of God, & pretious pearls; therfore are they not to be exposed to the contempt of wicked men, nor to be trodden vnder the foule feete of their peruerse and scornefull spirits: Both these reasons doth Christ couple together, Giue not that (saith hee) that is holy to dogs, neither cast your pearles before swine, least they treade them vnder their feet, and turning again all to rent you Mat. 7. 6.. Christ would neither haue his ordinances abused, nor his children hurt by the wicked men.
Thus wee see the maner how, and the reasons why: [Page 26] Now let vs see the time when Babel must be forsaken; when she is incurable, but not til then: first, long time is to be spent, all meanes to be vsed, all waies to be tried, all patience to be practiced, and all wisdome to be exercised, all occasions to bee taken, that probably may preuaile to doe them good. But if after all this, they be incurable, and out of hope; then must we forsake them, but not till then, not till there bee no hope at all: he that forsakes Babel till then, is wanting in his dutie, and hath much to answere for before God. For if the Physician may not forsake this vile body Phil. 3. 21 as long as there is any hope of life; then how may anie man forsake the soule that is pretious, and that cost so pretious bloud 1. Pet. 1. 19? Surely, the spirituall Physician must neuer forsake a Church, a people, or a man, as long as there is anie hope of curing and conuerting him.
Heere is condemned the practice of two sorts of men amongst vs. First, such as be now tearmed of the separation, formerly and vsually called Brownists; who forsake our Church, and cut off themselues from our congregations, and separate themselues to a faction, and fashion, or as they call it, into a couenant and communion of their owne deuising; these men haue made a grieuous rent, and giuen a deepe wounde into the peace of our Church: they vse this place and others like against vs, & say; We would haue healed you, but you will not bee healed, therefore we forsake you: but they abuse the place; therefore, I will turne the point of this their weapon against themselues: I meane against their errors, and this their bitter and schismaticall separation. To this end I would aske these men [Page 27] but 4. questions: whereunto if they can giue me satisfaction, I will be one of them.
First therefore, whereas you say that Wee are wounded incurably, and will not be healed, I aske: Wherein are wee deadly or incurably wounded? what fundamentall wound is in our doctrine? what deadly corruption is in our discipline, such as eats out the heart, and life, and being of a Church? what book of Canonicall scripture receiue we not? what holde wee for Canonicall, that is not? what sacrament that Christ ordained do we want? and what haue we more then Christ ordained? what article of faith deny wee? or what holde we for an article of faith that is not? what fundamentall heresie doth our doctrine maintaine? what haue wee in our Church, that ouerthrowes the being of a Church? what is necessarily required to make a Church, that we do want? Do not say, These be many questions: for if you wil haue them all in one generall, I will end it as I began; Wherein are wee deadly & incurably wounded? If I should walk a while on your owne grounds, & grant you that which you can neuer proue; yet will it not follow that we are incurably, or deadly, wounded. A man may want a finger, or haue some blemishes in his face, and yet bee a strong and perfect man, sound, and heart-whole, and able to ouerthrowe his enemies: so, tho there were in our Church, those wounds you speake of, yet do they not come neere the heart, they bee not deadly, they may blemish the beauty, but endanger not the life of our Church. The Churches of Corinth and Galatia, had other kind of blemishes then ours hath; blessed be God. Corinth doubted or erred in the great article [Page 28] of the Resurrection. 1. Cor. 15. The Galathians erred fouly in the high and maine point of Iustification, and yet Corinth a Church of God sanctified in Christ Iesus. 1. Corinth. 1. 2. And Galatia, though almost remooued to another Gospell, Galathians. 1. 6. yet not withstanding a Church for all that. Galat. 1. 2. And if you will adde to these fundamentall errours in doctrine, corruptions in manners, and disorders in Gods seruice, you can with no shewe of truth lay such to the charge of our Church, as is apparant were rife in the Church of Corinth: and then shall Corinth bee a Church, and not England? Let the Lord bee Iudge betwixt you and vs. Therefore, if wee should grant vnto you that our Church were blemished or wounded; yet not beeing deadly wounded, your separation from vs is schismaticall and vniust: and more cruell and vnchristianlie deale you with our Church, then did Gods Church with Babell; who forsooke her not til she was deadly wounded, and past life. To conclude, if Israel might not forsake Babel til then; then what are you that dare forsake a Church of God, wherin they haue found God, if euer they haue found him yet, & wherein the diuell himselfe cannot shewe one deadly wound: Blessed be the Lord that hath so healed vs.
Secondly, seeing they say that we are wounded, but as for themselues they be healed, & therfore they must separate, and so keep the sound from the sicke; I aske them this question: Are they healed? then where were they healed? where were they called? where were they regenerat & begotten to Christ? was it not in the wombe of this our Church, & by means of the immortall seede of Gods word, that is daily sowen in [Page 29] our Church, & by the ministry of those men that were called by our Church, and yet cleaue to our Church, and mourn for their separatiō; and by the dewe of that blessing from aboue, which is dayly poured vpon our assemblies, from Gods merciful right hand? Then how can they deny that to be a true Church, a holy church, a Church of God, wherein ordinarily men are called, and brought to God? And how vnthankfull and vndutifull are they to their spirituall mother, to forsake hir and cast the dust of contempt in her face that bore them in her wombe, and brought them foorth the sonnes of God? To auoid this, what can they say, but one of these two things: either that there is indeed a true Ministery of the word amongst vs; but it is not powerfull to anie but themselues: that wee haue the word truly preached, and so as it may conuert a man; but it is not the sauour of life to anie, but such as come into their couenant: (but from this horrible, and hellish pride, good Lord deliuer them; or els let them be assured such a height of pride, is sure to haue a fearful fal.) Or if not this, then must they say that they were not called, in our Church, but since they left vs: But they haue bard thēselues already from that plea. For, it being obiected to them that they haue left our church, not out of conscience, but out of carnal discontents, and vpon fleshly reasons, worldly grounds; they all stoutly answer and stifly stand to it, that they do it not vpon any such grounds, nor for anie reasons of flesh and bloud; but meerely and onely out of conscience and for their saluation, and that gladly they would haue staied, but with a good conscience they could not. If this be true, then they had conscience before they left vs: then [Page 30] where came they to that conscience and care of their saluation, but in our Church? Now, a good cōscience cannot be seuered from regeneration and an effectual calling: therefore, they cannot deny, but they were regenerate, and called in our Church; vnlesse they wil say, they had no conscience when they forsooke vs: which if they doe, then I will yeelde that my question is answered.
If they grant they were called a fore they went, and that stil they who fall from vs to them, are called; then how can that be but a true Church, wherein by their own cōfession, men are ordinarily begotten to God? & how can that be but a lawful & holy ministery, which brings men to saluation? therefore, (vpon their own grounds) they haue no iust cause to leaue vs. For that Church and Ministry that brings a man to grace, and to faith, is able to bring him to glory & saluation: and that which is able effectually to begin, is able effectually to finish the good worke of God in any man.
Thirdly, if they be healed, and we still deadly woū ded, then I ask them: How haue they sought, and sufficiently endeuoured our healing? and till they haue done all that possible can be done for our healing, how dare they forsake vs? For if the Israelites might not forsake Babel till then; shall they forsake vs, afore they haue put all meanes to the farthest? if they be healed alreadie, why doe they not more seriously labour the healing of others? They cannot but knowe, there bee manie in our Church curable inough, if they coulde shew them to neede their healing: why then doe not they stay amongst vs, to heale and helpe vs? He is no good Physician, that flies and forsakes his Patient: [Page 31] they therfore, if they be healers, and would heale vs as they pretend, why do they not stay with vs, & shew vs our wounds, and apply the means to heale vs? But contrariwise, they forsake vs, and runne into corners and raile on vs, and call vs Babylon, Antichristian, and the synagogue of the wicked, and that wee are no Church, and CHRIST is not amongst vs. Are these the plaisters with which you will heale vs? is this the waie to heale, to make wounds wider and deeper then indeed they be? Hee is a pitifull Physician that makes his Patient worse then hee findes him: but he is not tolerable, that makes him worse then indeed he is, or will make him belieue he is hearte-sicke and deadly, when his finger aketh. They alledge persecution, and that therfore they cannot stay with vs but are constrained to leaue vs: but assuredly (were it true that they say, that we were deadly wounded, and they able to heale vs) then, seeing they cannot saie that all amongst vs are incurable, they would care for no danger that could befall their bodies, so that they might heale our soules and gaine them to God. Therfore I conclude, that if wee would grant them their owne grounds, that they are as good as they pretend to be, and wee as ill as they would make vs; yet notwithstanding, their separation is vnchristian, because its certaine none of them can haue assured testimony to his conscience, that hee hath done all hee can possibly for our healing: till which time no man may forsake another; especially no Christian forsake another: & least of all a priuate man forsake a Church. Fourthly, and lastly, if they will needes leaue our Church, whither wil they go? To leaue one thing, for another [Page 32] no better, is seely; but for a worse, is folly and madnes. But they will say they leaue vs to take the better: then shewe me a better religion, and a better Church then the Protestant Churches of Europe are, and the religion amongst them. You will not goe to the Lutheranes, for they (you say) are worse then we: much lesse to the Papists, for they apparantly are worst of all: whither then? will you goe to the Church of the Lowe▪ Countries? but they are of our confession. will you go to the Churches of France? but they are of our confession? will you goe to the Church of Geneua, or the free Cities of the Empire? but they are of our religion. will you goe to the Church of Scotland, to the Cantons of Switzerland, to the States, and Princes of Germany? but they are all of our confession, and so professe themselues to be See the harmonie of confessions.. Looke ouer all Christendome, and you shall not find a Church that condemneth ours, nor any that is not of our religion, nor anie one but that professeth it selfe to bee of the same confession with vs, and not to differ from vs in anie substantiall or fundamental point. Whither then wil you go, or what remains for you to go vnto, but vnto your corners & conuenticles, where you are your own caruers, your owne Iudges, your own approuers, but haue not one Church in Christendome to approoue you.
So that thē it remains, it must either be granted you, that you are better then all others, and that (notwithstanding the Gospell preached thus long, since the reuealing of Anti-christ) there is not one true Church in ye world but your selues: or els you must grant that there is no better Church for you to goe vnto, if you forsake vs. Therefore plaie the wise mens part; forsake [Page 33] not our church, til you can shew a better. And tell vs not of France, Scotland, Geneua, Zurick, Basil, &c. for they be all ours, and not yours: they will and do all approue vs as a glorious Church, and condemn you, as factious, and schismaticall. And seeing you can finde none better (all things considered) and haue none to fly to but your selues (who are the parties now in question, and therefore no fit Iudges of the matter) look well about you; and if vnaduised zeale haue caused this bitter separation, then by your returne make vp that b [...]each again, which by your reuolt you made in our Church: Returne againe into the bosome of the Church, aske pardon of that your Mother, who brought you forth children of light: Come, & ioine with vs against the Papist, the common enemy; who, by our diuision hath gotten ground vpon vs all.
Remember Peters answere, when Christ asked the Apostles, after so many fell from him, what (sayth he) Will you also go awaie? Alas Master, saith Peter, Whither shall we go? thou hast the words of eternall life Iohn. 6. 61. So will you say, if true humilitie and sauing grace possesse you, when your deere Mother in whose wombe you were conceiued, and with whose brests you haue been fed, shall ask you (after so many reuolters to poperie) what, Will you also go awaie? Alas! whither should we goe from thee? Thou hast the words, and thou hast the Sacraments, of eternall life. Yea, malice it selfe cannot denie but wee haue them; and he who gaue them vs, grant wee may long enioy them, Amen.
And as for you, my brethren (Brethren I call you, because I am sure wee had both one mother) looke [Page 34] well about you, and consider of the bitter effects like to follow, vpon this your separation: remember that they will all lie heauy vpon you. And do not say, you are driuen out: for if it be the Church, and if the words of eternall life be here, nothing in the world ought to driue you from it. Nay, your separation was wilfull: therefore, let your returne be voluntarie: and till then, esteeme as basely and censure as sharpely of vs as you list; but knowe, that for this diuision of Ruben, are great thoughts of heart Iudg. 5. 15.
The second sort of men, whose practice is reprooued by this doctrine, be such, as refuse publick places in the Church, and Common-wealth, and retire themselues into priuate and discontented cours [...]s, and will not be imployed for the publicke; because they pretend the daies are euill, and many sores in our bodie incurable, vnlesse there bee other order taken for their healing. To these men I would say but two words.
1. Are the daies euill? the more need haue they to be amēded by each ones helping hand. And if we haue any wounds in Church or State, more cause hath each one that loues the peace and health of Ierusalem, to indeuour the present healing therof, least they fester and growe worse.
But secondly, are the times euill? Nay, are they not made euil by thee? at least, are they not the worse for thee and thy sinnes? Who can shew his face and saie; I haue committed no sins, that may be in part a cause to bring downe the spirituall and corporall plagues that are amongst vs? Then what are they that are so busie to complaine of the times, and so slacke to complain [Page 35] of their sins? But it is a trick of hypocrisie, to be so eagle eied in prying into the illnesse of the times, & so blind and dull in considering his owne sinnes, the cause of all that ill. Thou therfore, contrariwise, out of a holy and humbled heart confess, that seeing thy sins haue made the times worse then els they would haue bin, therfore thou hast cause to endeuor for thy part to make them better. Then set thy shoulder to the burthen, and put thy necke to the yoke, remembring that euen Babel it selfe is not to be forsaken, till it be altogether incurable, & past all hope: But being incurable (as here the text saith) she is; therfore, saith the church, Let vs forsake her.
And now Babel being forsakē of the Church, what remaines to be expected? nothing but vengeance and destruction.
For her iudgement is come vp vnto heauen, &c.
IN these words is laid downe the last point; namely, what becomes of Babel, when being incurable shee is forsaken by the Church: she is made ready for iudgement and destruction. Here we may learne (amongst many others) 2. most worthy doctrines.
First, what the wicked get by persecuting, and banishing, and seeking to roote out Gods children: surely, euē nothing but the hastening of their own destructiō. The Babylonians cared not for the Israelites company: but as soone as they were gone, destruction came [Page 36] vpon Babell. Whilst they stay, the wicked are spared: but whē they are gone, vengeance breaks out. Whilst Lot was in Sodom it perished not: Nay, (saith the Angell to him) haste thee awaie, for I can do nothing till thou be safe from amongst them Gen. 19. 22. See, God the good King is more carefull to saue one of his own seruants, then to destroy a thousand enemies: but see their madnesse, they mocked and flowted this Lot, scorned him as a stranger, and many waies grieued his righteous soule, were weary of him, and his company, and tryed euery waie, to make him wearie of the Towne; for they held it worse, as long as he was in it: at last they haue their wills, and hee forsakes them; but with him their protection is gone, and now fire, and brimstone, falls from heauen on them. So, at this day do the wicked and worldly men: whom hate they, whom accuse they, whom abuse they, whom lie they in waite for, whom persecute they, whom would they destroie, whom banish they, whom are they weary of, but of the godly men? When they die, they bid them be gone, and wish that all were gone after them; not knowing (poor fools) that if these men stood not in the gap, the fire of Gods wrath had long since brokē out vpō them; and when they are gone, then they are well apayed, and are glad: But alas! what haue they gayned? euen as much as Sodom did when they had cast out Lot.
Secondly, we may here learn what a feareful & dangerous thing it is not to be healed by spiritual Physick (that is) not to profit by the word of God, nor to bee conuerted from sinne, when God giues meanes. For what is this but an euident testimony of Gods heauie wrath, and a certaine forerūner of damnation? Wil not [Page 37] Babylō be healed? then what followes but destruction? So in the newe Testament, if our Gospell be hid, (saith Paul it is hid frō them that perish 1. Cor. 4. 3. For as if at noon day any man say the sunne shines not, it is because hee is blinded and cannot see: so, if in the sun-shine of the Gospell, some see it not, but in the midst of that light liue in darknesse, its certaine they are blinded by Sathan, and if they continue so are marked vp for iust damnation. A fearfull example we haue hereof in the sonnes of Eli, of whom the Text sayth, their Father hearing of all the euil they did, called them and reproued them, and gaue them good and ghostly counsell, able (a man would haue thought) to haue turned their hearts; especially comming from a Father, and from him that was the Iudge and Prophet of the Church: But all in vaine; for, notwithstanding, they obayed not the voice of their father: and mark the reason; because the Lord would slay them. Whereby its apparant, that there is not (ordinarily) a surer signe of a reprobate, then not to obey the voice and word of God, nor to profit by those meanes that God giues a man for his conuersion.
A matter of speciall vse to our Church, which hath so long enioyed the Gospell: but to you of this Citie especially, who haue long and liberally been fed from heauen, with abundance and variety of spiritual food. Therfore, euery one looke to thy selfe how thou profitest by these good means. For be assured, if any congregation or particular man haue vse of the meanes & profiteth not, but runneth on hardned in his sinnes; it is because he is a vessel of Gods wrath and prepared for damnation: but contrariwise, he that heareth and [Page 38] yeeldeth, and obeieth, and repenteth, it is an vndoubted pledge to him of his saluation, layed vp in heauen assuredly for him. Therfore, let euery one take heed: for otherwise his lot will be like Babylons; of whome we here finde that because all meanes vsed to conuert her were in vaine, therefore she is now iustly destroied, and remains a monument of misery, and a spectacle of Gods iustice, to all posterities Read, for this end, the 50. and 51. Chapt. of Ieremie, and other places of the Prophets..
And hauing thus performed the first part of my task, namely touching the old & literall Babell: it now remaines that we come to the Mysticall Babylon; in and concerning whom, all these 4. are as true as in the former.
The Second Part, touching mysticall Babylon.
THat which we haue heard of the literal, is also true in the mystical Babylon. Mystical Babylon is the spiritual kingdome of darkenesse, the kingdome of Satan. And this kingdom is partly temporarie; which is the kingdom of Antichrist: and partly permanēt, and perpetuall; and that is the kingdom of Sin. That the kingdome of Antichrist, namely, the Church of Rome, is mysticall Babylon, I will not stand to proue, seeing it is granted by Bellarmin Bellar. de Romano pontif. lib. 3. cap. 13. in resp. ad argu., compelled thereunto by the cleere authorities of some Fathers, but especially by the euidence of the holy Text in the Reuelation; where, by two notable arguments it is ineuitably concluded. For first, if the mysticall Babylon be the Citie seated on 7. hills Reuel. 17. 9 (as the Text sayth) then Rome is Babylon, which aboue all or anie Citie in the world, is so: and that not on seauen obscure or little hillocks, but seauen hills famously and notoriously knowen by name Mons Coelius. Exquilinus. Palatinus. Viminalis. Quirinalis. Auentinus. Capitolinus.. Nor is it any thing worth, to say that olde Rome was indeede so seated, but that now it is shrunke into the plain of Campo Martio. For notwithstanding that it be true for the body of the town; yet diuers publicke [Page 40] places where Antichrist exerciseth his authoritie and tyrannicall iurisdiction, are yet to this daie on those hils; as namely, & especially, the Lateran Church and Palace: which Church one of their Popes hath by Bull & Charter made the head of all the Churches of the world; to wit Gregory the eleuenth Gregorius xj. vide constitut. pont. Rom. per Pet. Mathae um, inter constitut. Greg. xj. constit. 1. p. 61 almost 250. yeares agoe: and after him Pius the fourth Vide eundem inter constitut. Pij. 4. constit. 19. pag. 454., and of late, Pius quintus Vide eundem inter constitut. Pij. 5. constit. [...]g. 618. [...]de eiusdē ▪ Mathaei commentaria in illam constitutionem Pij. 5. pag. 621. haue by publicke constitution confirmed the same: and in which Church or palace there haue been held by seuerall Popes, some xxxiij. prouinciall or nationall, & 5. generall Councells (g) all or most of them for the raising vp and establishing of Antichrists Throne: and in which the most horrible and hainous canons were concluded against God and his Church that euer were before: as (to name but 2.)
1. That monster of transubstantiation, that the substance of breade and wine in the sacrament ceaseth, and is turned into the substance of Christs bodie & bloud Vide Concil. Later. sub Innocentio. 3. c. 1
2. That a King, an hereticke, not reforming himselfe and his land, meaning to poperie, is to be deposed by the Pope, his subiects to be discharged from his obedience: and his land to be giuen to Papists; to whom the popes gift shall be good and effectuall Concil. idem cap. 3..
This Church and palace, besides many of inferior note, stands to this day on the hil Coelius Vide Onuphrium in lib. de Ecclesijs vrbis. Et eundē Mathaeum in loco cirato.: and tho now the Pope for his pleasure hath remooued himself ouer the Riuer to the Vaticane, yet in former times, for many hundred yeeres, (as Blondus himself confesseth) it was the principall seate of the Popes: which appeareth also by the verses written vp & down the church: [Page 41] especially those that are grauē ouer the marble chaire, which is hard by the high altar where the Pope sitteth at masse.
Thus its apparant, his chief throne is vpō one of the 7. hils: and it is very obseruable, that howsoeuer they make their succession from Peter; and that therfore in reason his Church should haue bin chief yet that God may shewe to the world that their Citie is the Whore that sitteth on seauen hilles; therefore, by Gods iust iudgement they are so blinded, that they haue made a Church and Palace, that is on one of the hils, superior to that they call S. Peters, and haue given it not only prioritie, and precedence, but euen priuiledge & preheminence aboue S. Peters.
Another answerable reason out of the Text is; That Citie (saith the Text is Babylon) which reigneth ouer the kingdoms of the earth Reu. 17. 18; but Rome & no other Citie, at that daie & long after, reigned ouer the world. Therfore Rome is that Babylon.
Seeing then the holy Text cleers it, the Fathers approue it, Bellarmine himselfe grants it; and the Rhemists also (vpon condition we will yeelde that Peter was at Rome) doe willingly yeelde it Rhemist in 1. Pet. cap. 5.: therefore wee will not stand vppon further proofe. And as for their distinction that Rome heathen is BABYLON, but not Rome Christian: I answere briefely, that if heathenish Rome bee BABYLON in regard [Page 42] of her sinfulnesse and persecution of the Saints; then this Rome is Babylon also, seeing in her sinfull abhominations and cruel persecutions, she is nothing inferiour to olde heathenish Rome, as may bee easily prooued & shewed at large, if this time and place required it, & as hath been alreadie shewed by diuerse learned writers, and (in good part) confessed by many of their owne. Now then to goe forward touching this mysticall Babel, I propound these 4. points to be considered.
- 1. That we would haue healed her.
- 2. That she will not be cured.
- 3. That therfore we ought to forsake her.
- 4. That God will take iust vengeance on her.
The 1. and 2. is past, the 3. is in hand, & the fourth is sure to come: its true wee would haue healed her; its most true shee is past cure, I hope it shall be as true that we shall quite forsake her; and the last hastens fast on, her destruction is at hand and sleepes not.
For the first. That we would haue cured the Papists, we dare call the world to witnesse, and appeale euen to God himselfe; and this not onely desired but endeuoured it by all good means, both in the daies of that renowned Q. Elizabeth of happie memorie, and in the present gouernment of our Souereigne that now is.
The meanes we haue vsed for their healing be diuerse. 1. By instructing, & informing them in the truth, & discouering their errours both by holy Scriptures, and by the ancient Fathers of the best & purest times. Iewel, Fulk, Whitakers, Rainolds, Perkins, and manie other, who now sleep in Christ, haue left behind them such testimonies of this truth as shall liue whilst the [Page 43] world lasteth, and neuer can be confuted, as appeares in that they haue not dared to answere most of their books to this day. Secondly, our continuall praiers for them, both publick, and priuate; in performance of which dutie, both our Church in generall, and all amongst vs (that vse to pray for themselues) haue the testimony of a good cōscience, that they haue not failed to indeuour their healing by this means. This our diligence in this duty, so shamed them for their negligence in ye same for vs, that 4. years ago they published at Rome a forme of Litanie, and publick praier, for the peruerting of the Realms of Eng. and Scotland, to Poperie Vide libellū inscriptū Litaniae & pre [...] recitandae p [...] fide catholica Romana in reg nis Ang. & Sco. restituenda & propaganda, & eorundem vnitate cum eadē Ro. eccles. Romae. & duaci. 1603. But by the waie let it be obserued, that as when Cain left his frowning at his brother, and began to make shew of friendship with him, and entised him by fair words into the fields, then he harbored the heauiest malice in his hart, & there slew him Genes. 4. 7: So when these men had conceiued, and hatcht at Rome the pouder treason; then to make vs secure, and beleeue they loued vs, they framed prayers for vs, as tho the worst thing they wisht vs were our conuersion; when as indeede they plotted the subuersion of vs all. Hee that sitteth in heauen, & laughed both them and hel to scorn, for that their deuise, knoweth we haue not dealt so with them. Wel, if their praiers herafter come so accōpanied, let vs haue their curses, and let their prayers turne into their owne bosomes. Thirdly, we haue indeuoured to heale them by our example, professing and practicing our owne religion, daily in their sight: & many of our fathers professed it openly, euen in the times when they preuailed, and gaue their liues in the fire for it. And heerin the example of noble Queen [Page 44] ELIZABETH is worthie of eternall memorie, whose constant zeale to the truth was such, as that all her dayes they could not by their brags, and treasons, and curses, cause her once to feare them; nor by all their sleights, could euer win the least estimation with her, nor gaine an inch of ground in her heart: nay, her last Proclamation, not two Moneths afore her death, wounded them as deeply, or rather more then euer any one before. See the proclamatiō published in Feb. before her death.
Fourthly, and lastly; wee endeuoured their healing, by deuising and enacting good and wholesome lawes against their errours, superstitions, impyeties, & seditious courses: somtime in iustice executing them, oftentimes in great mercy suspending them; thus trying all meanes that might possibly perswade or worke vpon them: and in this course (our State by wise foresight, and discreete managing the lawes; our Ministerie by instruction and confutation, and all by their prayers and example) did we continue to endeuor hir healing, all the happie daies of Q. Elizabeth.
But especially dare wee call the Lord to witnesse, that wee haue endeuoured her healing since the happie comming of his Maiestie to this crowne; wherein all the forenamed meanes haue beene vsed and one more: their errours haue beene most learnedly discouered and confuted, their bookes and libells aunswered; and if I may giue my iudgement of these daies, the skirtes of the Romish Whore were neuer better discouered, her grossest absurdities and fowlest impyeties neuer so cleerlie displayed, as haue beene by the Diuines of this present age. I spare their names, in regarde they bee aliue: and long may they liue, [Page 45] to the happinesse of this CHVRCH.
And beyond all meanes then vsed, and now continued, his Maiestie hath vsed one more; namely, admirable lenitie, and extraordinarie patience towardes them, notwithstanding all their ill deseruings: which as it was alwaies great; so, since the hellish powdertreason it is incredible: for he whose patience is not prouoked, and whose iust anger is not wakened by such an attempt, sure there is somthing more then ordinarily humane, in that man.
Neither do I think is there a King in Christendom, that after such a treason would haue left one of that faction in his kingdome, but onely his Maiestie. Oh mirror of mercie! how famously in future ages shall this princely bountie be renowned! and how fit is he to be the Lords annointed, and to be the Lieutenant of that God whose mercie is ouer all his workes; seeing his mercie is so largely extended euen ouer his worst deseruing subiects. Thus Heauen hath seene it, euen the Lord himselfe will witnesse with vs, that as all his Church euery where ouer the world, so wee in England for our parts, would gladly haue healed Babylon, and haue done our full endeuour to that ende: But now alas see the effect of our labours, all is lost; for she is Babylon, and therfore past cure: She wil not, & therfore cannot be healed.
Som wil say this is harsh & bitter: but I say it is true, and therfore is not to be cōcealed: let her blame them that haue made her incurable, and not them that discouer it: and for me that affirme it, I craue not to be belieued, but rather to be reprooued, if the euidence of the fact do not fully proue what I haue sayd.
To this end I will first lay downe a ground or two.
First that in former times there haue been great cō plaints of foule deformities in the Romish Church, made by men of great learning, and such as either are, or at least whom they say are, their owne: and these deformities not onely in priuate persons, but in the publicke bodie; not in the members only, but in the heade of their Church. I wil not stand to proue this, it beingc 48. & 56. & lib. 3. cap. 27. & lib. 4. cap. 33 Et Bonauent. in Apologet. pro Franciscanis. & in reg. Frācisci. quaest. 2. & 27. Et Bernardum [...] diuersis Epistolis. E [...] Vincentium Ferrar in suo prognostico cum mult. al. not the end of my purpose at this time: they that look into the monuments of elder ages do knowe this to be true; and whosoeuer will but looke into the Authors here in the margent named, will soone acknowledge it Reuelat. Brigittae passim. maxime. lib. 1..
Another ground: these deformities were so fowle and so apparant, that the Councels of Constance, and Basil, and (of later times) that of Trent, were called to this principall end, for the reformation of the Church both in the head, and in the members. For that of Constance, the Councell it selfe confesteth it in the publicke acts thereof more then once Concil. Constant. ses. 1: and [...]r that of Trent, howsoeuer they pretended it against E [...]ther & his doctrine; yet it is confessed by a learned Bishop of their side Espencaeus in Titum, cap. 1., that it was wrought out and brought to passe at last, and after much resistance, for the reformation of the Romish Church, & euen of the Popes own Court, wherin there reigned at that time many abhominable things, as one of the better sort of Popes himself freely confessed Adrianus 6. In orat▪ per nuntiū suum facta ad Comitia imperialia anno. 1522.. Vpon these grounds I proceed to lay downe 3. propositions, touching the incurablenesse of Romish Babel.
1. That these Councels, assembled to reform and amend, did contrariwise establish diuers impious errors [Page 47] neuer be fore decreed in the world.
2. That those foule deformities in the Romish Church, both in the head and members, and both for doctrine and manners, that were in that Church before those Councells, and for the redresse whereof, those councells were called, did neuerthelesse, and yet do, continue vnreformed.
3. That since then, in steed of redresse and reformation of the euills then found, there haue contrariwise growen vp in their Church more horrible & hainous practices, and more erronious and impious doctrines then euer before; and at this day stand vnreproued and maintained by their Church. And these three propositions being proued, I hope there is none but wil confesse that the Romish Church, for ought that man can see, is past cure.
Touching the first, I proue it by a fewe particulars in steed of manie: and first for the Councell of Constance, that Councell decreed▪ 2. such decrees, as tend rather to the ruinating of all religion, and ouerthrowing all humane societie, then any whit to the curing of diseases either in the one or other.
For first, whereas it is knowen and granted, that Christ at his last Supper ordaining the holy Communion, did consecrate and giue it both in bread and wine, and commanded his Ministers after him, Doe this See all the Euangelists, & S. Paul. 1. Cor. 11 23. &c.: and tho it cannot be denied but that the primitiue & antient Church did so receiue it, as Christ left it; yet for all that comes the Popish Councell of Constance, and calls it a peruerse fashion, and an ill order of those that giue their people the sacrament in both kindes: and do further decree, that,
And howsoeuer Bellar. Bellar. de Sacram▪ Euch. lib. 4. cap. 26 much ashamed of the matter, wil needs that the Non-obstante is not referd to the institution in both kindes, but to the celebration after supper (and therfore accuseth Luther and others, as lyers for so reporting of the Councell) yet many others of his fellows make no bones to grant it: and if they all denyed it, the very words themselues of the Canon are plaine inough.
Now, thus to decree and make a Canon contrarie to the direct institution & commandement of Christ; what is it but to controll Christ himselfe, and to weaken the certainty of all truth and religion? Secondly, whereas there can be no firme societie amongst men, if othe [...] and couenants (especially made by publicke persons) be of no force, and therefore God himselfe would haue the Israelites oath to the Gibeonits, performed, thogh it was craftily extorted Iosh. 9. 19; & after seuerely punished Saul in his posteritie, for the breach of it 2. Sam. 21. 1. 2.: yet the Romish Councell in this latter age hath decreed, that ‘Concil. Constant. sessione. 19. Though the Emperour or King giue a safe conduct, to one accused of heresie, to come to a Councell or Disputation, &c. and tho he bind and confirme that safe conduct with any bonde whatsoeuer; and tho he would not haue come, but vpon the assurance of the safe conduct: Yet (hoc non obstante) this notwithstanding, hee [Page 49] may bee taken and proceeded against and burned as an hereticke, without anie preiudice to the Catholicke faith, &c.’
If this bee good diuinitie, that Oathes and Couenants to hereticks are of no force, & binde not the makers; then it is in vaine for men to haue anie dealing one with another: for if oathes bee once of no force in any one thing, they will in time be weakened in all things.
Thus this Romish Councell that should haue amended, hath contrariwise decreed two conclusions of monstrous impyetie: and such, as (for ought I could euer see) were neuer till then decreed nor receiued; no, not in the Romish Church it selfe.
But is this reformed since? No, saith a great Spanish Bishop Simancha. Institut. cathol. cap. 45. art. 14. edit. Hispan. Fides data haereticis a priuato non est seruāda, nec a magistratibus data seruā da est haereticis: quod exemplo Concilij Constantiensis probatur: nā Ioh. Huss. & Hieronimus eius discip. legitima flāma concremati sunt, quā uis promissa illis securitas fuisset., (more then a hundred yeares after this Councell); it is so farre from beeing altered, that contrariwise, by the authority of this decree, it is now a rule in our Church that faith made to an hereticke, by a priuate man, is not to bee kept; no, nor if it be made by a Magistrate, as (sayth he) is prooued by the practice of the Councell of CONSTANCE. Marke howe they are healed: afore it was true in publique persons, now it is true in priuate men also: afore it might bee broaken without anie fault; but nowe it may not bee kept. See howe Babylon is cured.
But the Councell of Trent is of latter times: hath not it done much good and reformed much ill? Nay on the other side, it hath decreed and made 2. Canons to the high disgrace of holie SCRIPTVRES, and much derogating from the souereigne [Page 50] authority thereof; which til then were neuer decreed, not in the darkest times of poperie, when her ignorance and superstition was without all controll: As namely, first Concil. Trident. sess. 4,
This wrong was neuer offered to the holy Scriptures before: neither was there euer any Popish generall Councell, so presumptuous afore this of Trent, that euer durst adde more books to the sacred Canon, then we receiued from the Church of the old Testament. Some bolde Papists say, that the Florentine Councell, before Trent, did make them Canonicall: which if it had, it had bin little materiall, seeing it was but a small time before Trent, scarce 100. yeares: but the truth is, it did not; and therefore Bellarmine and Coccius are more careful of their credit, and wil not affirme it Bellar tō. 1. lib. de verbo dei. Coccius in the sauro cathol. tom. 1.. So that its cleere, there neuer was generall Councell that made them Canonicall before Trent, nor anie prouinciall but one Concil. Carthag. 3.: and they are not able to bring one Father that helde them so within 400. yeares after Christ, nor very manie after till of late; and contrariwise we are able to proue, that all the Fathers for 400. yeares did reiect them, and many after; yea, the greater part of all learned Papists themselues till the Councell of Trent. And thus wee see how Romish Babylon is still the elder the worse: But this is not all: a Romish Councell will neuer meete for one euill. Therefore secondly they decree Concil. Trident sess. 4.,
Here is a strange decree, that the streame shall bee of more vertue then the Fountaine, a translation of more authoritie then the Originall. The former ages neuer heard of this indignitie: but whensoeuer doubt was made, or difference found, recourse was forthwith had to the Originalls for the determining of the matter. Many learned Papists are ashamed of this, if they durst vtter it. Bellarmine and Coccius doe bewray it by their slight handling of the matter; for they would gladly prooue if they could, that Hierome was the author of that translation: but as for the magnifying of it (whosoeuer was the translator) aboue the Originalls, they are wiser then to venture their credits vpon so false a matter, and therefore do wholly leaue it vpon the credit of that Conuenticle that concluded it. Neither do I wrong, to call it a Conuenticle: for tho I should grant the whole to be a Councell; yet the number that past this bill was so small, that I may safely call it a Conuenticle. For as an ill motion may pass in Parliament betimes in a morning before all the house be set, so was this bil caried at Trent. For wheras the Councel in his fulness consisted of 300. or more that had voice of decision, they took the aduantage at the beginning of the Councell, and caried these two bills when there were scarce 60. in the house (whereof how manie went against them is vncertaine) fo [...] the Pope durst not (for one of his Crowns) haue p [...] th [...]e [Page 52] two bils, especially the latter, to the ful house: for how would they haue entertained it then, when as they had libertie of speech against it, who since their tongues were tyed and the bill passed, yet haue dared (andArias Montanus, Sixtus Senensis, Olea [...]er, &c. some of them who were of the Councell themselues) euen to resist the decree, and haue taken so contrarie a course themselues in expounding the Scripture, that howsoeuer they were tolerated for their learning whilest they liued; yet being dead, their books are eyther purged, that is altered, or els reproued: So that its apparant to all that will vnderstand, that this decree was so far from being established in any former ages, that it is euen misliked of many of the better sort of themselues now that it is made.
And thus I hope wee haue cleered it, that these two Councells, called in the corrupt and declining times of the Popish Church, in shewe to haue reformed it, haue been so far from that, that contrariwise they haue cōcluded diuerse enormous impyeties that were not before: Then is not the Romish Babylon well cured?
I hasten to the second Proposition: which is, that the deformities that were before, both in doctrine and practice, both in heade and members, and manie whereof were complayned on by some of themselues, doe yet remaine without redresse or reformation.
For the demonstration of this Proposition, I might inlarge my selfe into many particulars; but I will insist but vppon fewe: and those I shall produce shall not bee trifles, nor triuiall, but of great moment, euen touching the mayne and morall duties [Page 53] which a Christian man oweth to his God; and which to denie, is to denie God, to falsifie his word and nullifie his lawe. And to this ende, it were no harde matter, to passe through the most of the tenne Commaundementes of the Morall and eternall lawe: But I will stande vppon some fewe of the principall.
In all which, my course shall bee fairest for them, and safest for my selfe: for I will not relie vppon the credite of any reporter nor other writer, how great soeuer his authoritie bee; but produce the recordes themselues, and the authenticall originalls of their owne bookes, as they stand at this day allowed by authoritie.
Now, therefore whether the Romish Babylon bee yet cured or no, let the Christian world iudge by these particulars:
The pride of the Romish Antichrist in times past, was such, that hee exalted himselfe, at least suffered himselfe to bee set in the throne of God; yea, and to be called of men God, and their Lord God The first wound; The Pope is a God, and their Lord God.: and this not onely in priuate Authors, but euen in his own Canon lawe: these be the wordes in the glosse vpon the extrauagants Extrauag. Iohānis 22. tit. 14. cap. 4. Cū inter. in glossa Credere autē Dom. Deum nostrum Papam conditorem huius Decretalis no [...] potuisse slatue▪ reprovt. statuit, haereticum censeretur.;
The wordes are plaine inoughe. But if anie man say this is but the glosse, and not the text: I answere; first, that the glosse is of greater authoritie [Page 54] amongst them then any, or then many Doctors. But further, what if we finde as much or worse, out of theDecret. dist. 96 cap. satis euidēt ostenditur a seculari potestate nec solui prorsus necligari pontificē posse, quem cōstat a Constantino Deum appellatum, cum nec posse Deum ab hominibus iudicari manifestum sit. very Text of the Popes lawe it selfe? Look in the Decree the 96. distinction, there the Pope himself frames this argument, writing to the Emperor against them that would call his Holinesse to account.
Its certaine that the Emperour Constantine called the Pope God.
But its as cleere that God may not bee iudged of men. Ergo the Pope may not be iudged of anie man.
Thus the Pope that canonizeth so many men and women Saints, hath heere taken paines to canonize himself a God, both in the Text and glosse of his own lawe: his glossers call him their Lord God, and hee is content to take it to himselfe. Constantine (he saith in the text) cals him God, and he is content both to take it, and make good vse of it. Whether this bee not Herods sinne Acts. 12. at least, let him looke to it, but let vs goe forwarde. Heere Babylon is sicke of a deadly euil: but is she healed? I wish she were: but I cannot shewe it. The first wound not healed. If any say shee is, then let him shewe me that Pope, or name mee that Writer, Doctor, Inquisitor, Bishop, or any other, who by commandment or authoritie, or but with the approbation of the Pope, hath confuted, or but as much as reprooued this blasphemie; or shewe any that hath reprooued it, whom they haue not blamed or condemned. But that shee is not cured in this point, I can make it apparant. For looke in the Canon lawe reuiued and as they pretende(c) Vide Corpus iuris Canonici, iussu Gregorij 13. emendatum & editum, anno 91. dist. 96. cap. 7. reformed and reprinted of late (b) by the authoritie [Page 55] and with the approbation of the Pope vnder his bull▪ where though many things be altered, or taken out that made against the Popes primacie: yet this that makes so much against Gods holy Maiestie is not in one point helped, nor in one word altered, but still this is good and Catholicke Diuinitie in the popes lawe, that
But wil you haue yet better euidence, that She is not cured? Hearken a little: A great Italian Doctor, no lesse then a Bishop, writes thus to the Pope himselfe (for to the Pope either the Authour or his Nephew dooth dedicate it) some three or foure yeares agoe Vide Adoardum Gualā dum Episcopū Caesenatem, de morali & ciuili facultate, lib. 14 cap. 3. A Papa tanquā a Capite in vniuersum Eccle siae corpus, hoc est in omnem Christianā Remp. spiritus influunt. caelestium gratiarum sensum fructum (que) praestantes, & efficicem mo [...] ad sempiternam [...]eatitudinem. Merito igitur sanctissimus & beatissimus appellatur & [...] Christianam [...] quasi quidam Deusad oratur & coli [...]t. Liber impressus est Romae. 1604. & Clementi 8. Papae dicatus..
Loe heere as bad or worse then the former: the Pope is such a Head of the church, as infuseth spiritual life and heauenly grace into the body of the Church (Doth Christ himself anie more?) and he is worthily worshipped as a God. And this dooth Pope Clement the 8. suffer to be spoken and written of him, and not 4. yeares agoe to be printed vnder his nose at Rome; and thence to bee sent ouer the world: & [Page 48] now iudge, is not Romish Babylon well healed? nay, rather alasse, doth not her wound fester and rankle more and more? Well then seeing this is the Romish doctrine and practise, both olde and newe, both long agoe and now present, let vs make a little vse of it.
First, wee see heere good reason, why a Papist should holde the Pope aboue a Councell, and euen the holy scripture it selfe: for the Pope is God; and wee knowe that GOD is aboue the scripture.
Secondly, why also the Pope holdes himselfe aboue kings: for hee is God, and GOD is King of kinges: in a word, no maruell why hee should take appeals from all the world, we are a triple Crowne, bee caried on mens shoulders, giue his foote to be kissed, dispose of kingdomes and kings at his pleasure; for hee that is God may do more then all these. And surely, we Protestants must needes grant, that as truely as he is a God, so lawfully may hee do all these. All these vses are as good as that is the Pope himselfe makes, when hee sayth: God may not be iudged by men; but I am God, and therefore may not bee iudged by man: these bee his arguments: but now hee shall giue mee leaue to make but one for him and his fellowes.
The God that admitteth another Lord God, and to bee worshipped as God; is not the Lord Iehouah, the true God: for the true God, is God alone Deut. 6. 4.: but the Papists God admittes of another Lord God, and to be worshipped as God, therefore hee is not the true God. If they denie the Maior, they denie scripture: if the Mi [...]r, they denie their doctrine, and their owne [Page 57] bookes: if they graunt both, they are worthy of the conclusion.
I would end this: but I cannot omit to make one vse more of this their doctrine. It hath been made a question amongst them, whether the Pope might no [...] emptie all Purgatorie, if he see cause; and no maruell [...] for he being God, surely (if there be a purgatorie) God can emptie it. Now to conclude, all these doe but equalize the Pope with God: but what if hee haue made himselfe greater then God The secōd wound; The pope hath done more then God.? I will be but the relatour, let the Reader iudge. Almost two hundred yeeres agoe, hee did with publicke authoritie and after long examination, by a great Cardinall This Cardinal was Iohā nes de turre cremata: as appears in the prefaces before the book of the Reuelations of Saint Brigit. and other Commissioners, approue Posseuinus, in apparatu sacro. lit. B. to. 1. Brig. Reuelationes diligē ter examinatae & approbatae à viris doctis fuerunt. & after suffered to be published to the World, a booke in latine, called
Where it is dogmatically deliuered and as a matter without question, That Pope Gregory by his prayers lifted the heathen Emperour Traiane out of hell Reuelationes Brigittae lib. 4. cap. 13. Bonus Gregorius, oratione sua, etiam infidelem Caesarem eleuauit ad altiorem gradum.: and another long afore, (whome they pretend also to bee theirs) deliuereth it more amplie, adding further that God answered the Pope thus: I haue heard thy prayers, and I grant mercy and pardon to Traiane; but see that thou hereafter offer me no sacrifice, for an vngodly man Damascenus in ser. de mortuis adiuuandis: Cum enixè Deum precaretur Gregorius pro salute Traiani, annis ante sua tempora fere 500. defuncti audiuit vocem diuinitùs allatam, dicentem, preces tuas audiui, & veniam Traiano do: tu vero deinceps pro impio hostiam mihi ne offeras.. From hence I offer them this argument to thinke on; The true God neuer deliuered a damned [Page 58] soule out of hell: but the Pope hath deliuered a soule out of hell: therefore he hath done that, that GOD neuer did, nor for ought that is reuealed euer will doe.
Heer is a soule wound, but is this healed vp? No, The second wound not healed. this booke stands allowed by the Pope: and in his Catalogue of the bookes which hee forbiddes to bee read Vide Indicē lib prohib per Clem. 8., where many a learned and godly booke is condemned, this is not toucht; and therefore, as Posseuine himselfe (a Iesuite) grants Posseuinus loco citato. not 2. yeares agoe, not onely the booke stands vncondemned, but this foule blalphemy vncontrolled: and to shewe that the head of Babylon, namely the Pope is incurable, let it be obserued, that tho many particular learned Papists Mel. Canus. lib. 11. c. 2. Bellar. de Purgat. lib. 2. cap. 8. Blas. Vieg. in Apoc. c. 6. comment. 3. sect. 3. Baronius annal. circa temp. Traiani. haue misliked, and condemned it as far as in them lyeth; yet to this daie was it neuer condemned, nor the book forbidden or amended by the Pope: so vnwilling is BABYLON to be healed of her wounds.
Yea, the Pope is so farre from healing it; that contrariwise, he suffred a Spanish Dominican Frier to defend it, and that not in word, but writing, not priuatly, but openly: not in a corner of the World, but to come to Rome within these fewe yeares, and there euen to write and publish vnder his nose, and by his authoritie, an Apologie of this blasphemous fable, endeuouring to proue it by many arguments; That Gregory did deliuer Traian out of hell Alphonsus Ciaconus Romae edidit..
Thus tho it containe neuer so great an impietie against God; yet, because it tendes to the magnifying of the Popes power & prerogatiue (let as many learned men as will speake against it, Hanc Apologiam vti & historiam validis refutat argum. Bellar. lib 2. de purgat. cap. 8. vt & Mel. Canus eandem antea improbauerat historiam, &c. haec dem Posseu. [...] pr [...]. it shall stand and [Page 59] be maintained: so true it is that Babylon will not bee healed of her deadliest wounds. And wonder not tho I call them deadly; for consider of these consequences: The Pope deliuered a soule out of hell, therefore he did that which God neuer did. Again, therfore there may be redemption out of hell. Againe, therfore the Popes praiers did that which Christs praiers neuer could do: againe, Christ sayth, I pray not for the world Iohn. 17. The world, that is for the wicked & damned. Apologiā pro historia Traiani quem precibus Sancti Gregorij ex inferno aiunt quidamin caelum ascendisse: haec Possev. Ies in apparatu sacro t [...]m. 1. litera A.: the Pope saith, but I do; Ergo the Popes pity & charitie is more then Christs: Alas, alas, is Rome the holy Church, and sees not these blemishes? Is she the liuing Church and feeles not these wounds? nay rather, is she not that Babylon that will not be healed?
But to conclude: all this is the worse because hee hath razed out manie sentences, and passages out of manie Authors, wherin he thought himselfe and his seat to be wronged Ludou. viues: Ferus, Erasmus, Stella, Oleaster Espencaeus and infinite others.; but this that so highly dishonoreth God himselfe, he can patiently suffer: but had he beene as zealous of Gods glory as carefull of his own, then he that forbids Espencaeus his commenta [...]ies on Titus till they be purged, and the book called Onus Ecclesiae (absolutly without any limitatiō) because they touch his freehold too neere, would also haue forbidden the Reuelation of S. Bridgit, til this foule blasphemie had been purged out: which, seeing he hath so carelesly and wilfully neglected, (tho his Catalogue of forbidden bookes hath so often been renued It was first made by Pius 4. and so si [...]ce cōtinued renued & augmē mented til Clement the 8.; it appears what an vnworthy Vicar of God hee is, who lookes onely to himselfe, but suffers his master to bee dishonored before his face: Therfore, Arise, O Lord, maintaine thine owne cause.
Well then, seeing this wound is incurable, let vs [Page 60] leaue it rankling & come to another. Some 120. yeers( [...]) The third [...] God hath diuided his kingdome with the Virgin Mary: And that a man may appeal from Gods iustice to the Mercy of the Virgin Mary▪ because God hath kept iustice to himself but committed his mercy to his Mother. agoe, an Italian Frier wittie and learned, as the most in those daies, a principall Preacher and as famous in his time as Mussus, or Panegirola in these latter, by name Bernardinus de Busto Bernard. de busto Marial. par. 3. ser. 3. pag 96. editionis Lugd. anni. 517 Licet ad Mariā appellare a diabolo, a Tyranno, imo a Deo, si quis a Dei iustitia grauari se sentiat. quod significatū fuit H [...]ster 5▪ vbi dicitur quod cum Rex Assuerus Iudaeis esset iratus, Regina Ester ad ipsū placandum accessi [...]: Cui Rex ait, etiam si di [...]idiam partē regni mei petieris dabitur tibi: ista ergo imperatrix figurauit imperatricem coelorum, cum qua Deus regnum suum diuisit. Cum enim Deus habeat iustitiam & misericordiam, iusticiam sibi reti [...]it in hoc mundo exercendam; Misericordiam vero matri concessit: ideo si quis sentit s [...]grauari in foro iustitiae Dei, appellet ad forum misericordiae Matris cius. preached this doctrine publikely, after wrote it, & sent it to Alexander the 6. and vnder his name published it,
The impiety is so execrable and seemes so incredible, that I will put downe the words out of the booke it selfe, as it was dedicated to the Pope.
What is this we heare? do there lie appeales from God? and from God to a creature? is Gods Iustice such, as a man may iustly be agrieued at it? and further, is God kingdome diuisible? and hath God indeede diuided his kingdome? and diuided it with a creature, yea with a woman? and hath God graunted his Mercie from himself to a creature? wee may say with the Prophet, Oh heauens be astonied at this: and let all Christian harts tremble to heare such blasphemies: & yet these be good doctrins in Popery, fit for their pulpits, & their people, and after they be preached worthy to bee published to the world. Surely, if they grant these bee false doctrines, then blame & shame belongs to the papists that preach thē, write thē, publish them, and allow thē for Catholick doctrine: but if they stand to thē as true, then mark what consequences will follow vpon them: first it is here taught, that a man may appeale frō God. Herupon this argument is easily framed, but I beleeue not so easily answered;
Poperie teacheth there lies no appeale frō the Pope Cōm [...]i [...] opinio ca [...]o [...]istarum, & doctorum.: and here teacheth that their lies appeale frō God.
But in reason, he and themselues grant, he from whom no appeal can lie, is greater then he from whom one may Decret. caus. 2. quaest. 6. cap. 9. prouocandum est ad eos Iudice [...] vbi est autoritas maior..
Ergo, by popish doctrin the Pope is greater then God▪
This conclusion is ineuitable, if their doctrine be true. Againe, here it is taught that we may appeale from God to the Virgin Marie: If that be true, let them answere this argument;
He vnto whom appeale doth lie from another, is greater then hee from whome it is made; this is their owne doctrine Pet. Mathaeus in comment. suis super constitut. 2 Pij. [...]. pag. 120. lege tum pontificia tum ciuili decretum esse scimus appellationem non deuolui [...]isi ad superiorem. l. praecipimus. C. de appellat: & appellationem illam ratam haberi, qua à Minore ad Maiorem appellatur ergo appellamus a Concilio ad papam, no [...] [...]contra..
[Page 62]But from the Lord God appeale doth lie to the Virgin Marie. Ergo, shee by popish doctrine is greater then God.
If this conclusion be heresie and blasphemie; then Bernar [...]ine de busto his bookes are to bee burnt, and yet they are both allowed and commended by the Romish Church Bernardinus de Bustis, scripsit de excellentijs Reginae Caeli Cōmentarium siue vberrimum & cruditissimum rosarium & complures alios sermones plenos pietatis & bonarum rerum: sic Posseu. in apparatu sacro to. 1. Litera. B.: But let vs go forward.
Thirdly, here it is taught, that God hath diuided his kingdome with a creature, euen with a woman: This being true here wee learne many pointes.
First, the reason why they call her in their Seruice booke allowed by supreame and soueraigne authoritie, Reginam Coelorum, the Queene of heauen Vide Missalia, Breuiaria & officia vltima & correctissima.; for shee that hath gotte possession of the halfe of Gods kingdome, may well and worthily be held the Queene of heauen.
Secondly, heere is a verie good reason, why the Church of Rome keepes the Bible from the vulgar people, and will not haue it divulged in their Mother tongues: for if they had it in their owne tongues, they would startle at this doctrine, and when they hearde it deliuered in Pulpit, that God had diuided his kingdome, would soone haue sayde, that is false doctrine: for the Psalme sayth, The kingdome is the Lords Psal. 22. 29.: and Dauid in his thankesgiuing, at the preparation for the Temple building, confesseth to God; Thine O Lord, is greatnesse, power and glorie, aeternitie and Maiestie: Thine O Lord is the kingdome, and thou excellest ouer all 1. Chron. 29. 11.: and if the Frier had obiected, that the kingdome indeede is Gods, yet not so, but he may diuide it to another: then they would haue aunswered, that cannot bee: for hee himselfe [Page 63] saith, I am the Lord, &c. My glorie, I will not giue to another Esay. 42. 8: and if hee still obiected, that was true in the olde Testament, when there was none capable and worthie of this honour, because then the Virgin Marie was not; they would readily aunswere, that in the newe Testament after the Virgin Marie was, and after shee was the mother of Christ, Christ her sonne speakes to God his Father, (but not to her his Mother) Thine is the kingdome, powre and glorie Matth. 6. 13. The kingdome is Gods: and how longe? (not till shee bee assumed and crowned in heauen, as they say, but) for euer and euer.
And whereas they further teach, that hee hath kept Iustice to himselfe, but commited mercie to his Mother: they would crie out vpon that doctrine and him that taught it; and tell him that they finde it sixe and twentie times in one Psalme, that Gods mercie indureth for euer Psal. 136, in euerie verse., and that his mercie is ouer all his workes Psal. 145. 9: if ouer all, then ouer her also, or else shee is not of his making: and if his mercie bee vpon her, without which shee could neuer haue beene saued: then how dare any say, that Mercie is Hers, and not Gods? and if mercie bee Gods, and that mercie of his endureth his, (not for the time of the olde Testament one [...]y, but) for euer: Then it is foule and false doctrine to say, that now since Christ, God hath resigned vppe mercie from himselfe to a creature: thus would the people come vpon him that taught this doctrine, and vppon the Romish Church that alloweth it: and therefore doth not that Church wisely, to keepe the people from reading the holy Scriptures?
Thirdly, seeing it is doctrine currant in the Romish Church, that God hath giuen vp mercie from himselfe to the Virgin Marie, here is a good defence of their Ladies Psalter Vide officia, & Psalteria beatae Mariae Virgin is cuiuseun que generis seu impressionis.: wherein they turne the Psalmes from Dominus to Domina, from GOD to our Ladie: and when Dauid saith, Lord haue mercie on mee; they say, O Lady haue mercie on mee: and in thee O Lady is my trust. They say this was compiled by Bonauenture Bonauenturae opera omnia excusa fuere Romae in Vaticano: in parte 2. (inter alia) est Psalterium beatae Mariae virginis ab ipso cōpilatū. haec Possev. in apparatu sacro, litera b. 10. i.: but tho hee liued in ill times Circa annū. 1272. in concilio Lugdunensi sub Gregorio 10 Bonauentura obijt. Possev. in loco citato., yet his other writinges giue cause to hope hee made it not: for hee saieth, that wee must take heede we so inlarge not the excellencie of the Mother, that wee diminish the glorie of the sonne Ex Perkinso in suo problemate, pag.. Sure hee that sayde so, would not bee so lauish and carelesse of Gods glorie, as to turne the Psalmes from him to a creature.
Fourthly, here wee see the reason why the Popish Synagogue do maime the Lords prayer, leauing out the conclusion, For thine is the kingdome and power and glorie for euer and euer See the Rhemish Testament in Mat. 6 and Luk. the 11 & al their Mis [...]als & breuiaries, Ma [...]uals & allowed pri [...]ers: in all which they cut short the lords praier, leauing out the wordes of the conclusiō, for thine is y• kingdom &c.. For if the kingdome bee diuided, then it is not all his for euer: no maruel therefore, though they will haue their Pater noster in Latine for their common people; for if it were in English, there is none so simple but would see their vngodly dealing.
But to conclude, (leauing this robberie and sacriledge in cutting off part of the Lords prayer, for another place and purpose) it is here euident that no Papist in the World can with a good conscience say the whole Lords prayer. For if God haue now diuided his kingdome, then how can hee say with Dauid in the olde testament 1. Chr. 29. 11, and Christ in the newe Math. 6.: Thine O [Page 65] Lord is the kingdome for euer: therefore hee must either alter the Lords prayer and say, Thine is halfe the kingdome, &c. or neuer say it at all: or else curse and detest his owne teachers that write, and his Lord God the Pope that alloweth such doctrine. Alas, poore soules, what should a simple honest hearted Papist do in this case! See therefore in what pitifull state they liue, who haue subiected themselues to such teachers.
Lastly, let it bee obserued that here they teach, that there bee in spiritual matters touching the soule 2. diuine Courts: the one of Iustice, and that is Gods; the other a Chancerie, a Court of Mercie, and that is Maries; these bee their verie wordes: and further, that if any man feele himselfe agrieued in Gods Court of Iustice, let him appeale to the Court of mercie of his Mother: Oh-strange diuinitie! Canne Gods iudgements bee vniust, or his proceedinges erroneous and vnequall? If they bee not, then why do they talke of appealing to a higher Court? for why do writtes of error lye from one Court to another, but that it is presupposed that they may erre? and why is there a Chauncerie, but that the rigour, and extremitie of the Lawe may bee mitigated? But if the Scripture say true in the text, Righteous art thou O Lord, and iust in thy iudgements; Psal. 119. 137. then this is blasphemie of a high nature, that there needes a Chancerie to rectifie his proceedinges and mitigate his Iudgements. But as for this doctrine, that the Chauncerie or Court of mercie is not Gods, but his Mothers, and that therfore Gods iudgmēts are to be mitigated by another, and therefore that shee and her Court are in this respect [...] [Page 68] rant shee is not healed.
And yet for the better satisfaction of all men, that as shee is not yet, so shee purposeth neuer to bee healed, nor to reforme any thing, and that this is not the priuate opinion of that or any other one doctor; I desire all that loue the trueth to take knowledge, that of late within these seauen yeares, an Italian doctor a Iesuite, and an approued writer, writing a storie of the miracles of our Ladie of Loretto teacheth euen the same doctrin, and makes no bones to bluster out almost the very same words: which for better assurance I will put down. Horatiu [...] Tursellinus: hist. virginis lauretanae in Epistola dedic. virgo Maria salutem vndi (que) cinctam periculis expedire, vitam veris & salutaribus bonis cumulare & vult & potest▪ Matrem quippe suam omnipotens deus diuinae potestatis & Maiestatis sociam (quatenus licuit) asciuit.
See here the new and refined diuinity of the Iesuites: what is this, but the same with that afore? for if shee bee made partaker & fellow with God in his diuine power and Maiestie, it is no maruel, that God hath cōmitted his mercy to her: & if frō these words we look into the body of the book, we shal find he ascribes such works & miracles to her as can belong to none but him or her that is a fellow with God, or rather God himself. It cannot bee saide, the booke wants authoritie: for it is formally allowed, dedicated to the Cardinall Aldobrandino, printed at Rome, and since often elsewhere; and of late [Page 69] both the Authour and his booke highly commended by the greatest Romish censurers Posseu. in apparatu sacro. to. 2. litera. H. Horat. Tursellinus Romanus è societate Iesu, lauretanae historiae 5. libros latinos & elegantes ad fidē historicae veritatis conscripsit Romae excu [...]os: quos qui legerit, vt miranda beatissimae Virginis opera suspiciet, sic lauretanam illam domum percupidè curabit inuisere. Vlterin [...] autem de eodem Tursellino vide C. Bonarscij Amphitheatrum honoris Libro 2. cap. 13.. So that now I will end my euidence, for this point, and dare put the matter to a Iurie of any conscionable men, whether this wound be healed yet, or no.
Now to go forward: from the Person and Maiesty of God, let vs proceede to his Holy SCRIPTVRES, and see how the Romish Church held of olde, and yet holdeth and teacheth of them. I will not stand vppon those v [...]le and base speeches vttered and written of them by Eccius, Pighius, Hosius, and manie other of that generation, for that they haue beene both detected, and with shame inough re [...]ected by many reuerend men of our nation, both in Latine and English Whitaker Fulke, Iewel, Reinolds, and others.; but vppon some that often haue not bin touched by many, nor euer can be sufficiently condemned by any.
In the Canon Lawe, the Pope spareth not to disgrace the holy Scriptures in express tearmes; sometimes equaling his own Constitutions with them, somtimes preferring them.
In the Decree hee shameth not to affirme that The fourth wound; The Popes decrees be equall to the Canonicall Scriptures. his decretall Epistles are numbred amongst the Canocall Scriptures Vide decretū cum glossa. Lugd. 1510. In fol. dist. 19. cap, 6. Inter Scripturas canonicas Epistolae decretales connume [...]antur., and impudently alleadgeth Saint Augustine to proue it, who neuer spake nor meant any such thing; as in the later end of the decree they cannot but confess with shame inough: this was his doctrine in the old impressions of the Canon lawe, a hundreth [Page 70] yeares agoe. But some will say, this wounde is now healed: No, look in the new impression reuiewed at the Popes commandement, and printed by his authoritie within these fewe years Vide Corpus Iuris Cano [...]ici iussu Gregorij 13. recognitum & editum Lugduni. 1591., and there stand the very same words without the least reformation in the Rubricke or title of the Chapter;
Which is the more shamefull in it self, and shamelesse in the doers, in as much as in the same newe edition they are forced to confesse, that Augustine (out of whom they cite the whole Chapter) did not at all meane the Popes decretall Epistles, but the holy and Canonicall Scriptures Quae quidem sententia beati Augustini non ad decretales Ro. pontificum, sed ad Canonicas & sacras Scripturas referenda est: Corp. Iur. Cā. edit. 91. in additione. ad dist. 19. cap. 6.: and no maruell, for the name of decretall Epistles of the Popes, was to get and to beare, many a faire yeere after his daies.
To conclude this point, let wise men obserue here this point; how vnwilling the Romish Church is to amēd or alter any thing, especially if it concern Gods honour and not their own free-hold: els why should they maintain that blasphemie in the Rubrick and title of the Chapter, which in the bodie of the Chapter they condemn? But well doe they know, that manie a man reades the contents of books and chapters, which neuer read more. Therfore, because the words of this title giue honour to his decretalls, tho they be neuer so dishonorable to Gods holy Scriptures, they are suffred to stand, whereas they haue put out many [Page 71] things disgracefull to themselues: Thus vnwilling is Babylon to be healed in any thing.
This doth but make them equall, and that may bee thought no great wound in that Church: but shall wee see a deeper and more deadly; namely, where the authoritie and determination of the Pope is made higher, and of more respect then the holy Scriptures themselues? In the same booke the XL. Distinction, the Pope alleadgeth for good doctrine, and canonizeth for a lawe, these words taken out of one Boniface; The fift wound. The religion of Christianitie is to bee founded rather from the Popes mouth then from the [...]oly Scriptures, that is from Gods mouth. Vide Decret. dist. 40. in appendice ad cap. 6. Et reuera tā ta reuerentia apicē praefatae Apostolicae sedis omnes suspiciunt, vt nonnullam sanctorum Canonum disciplinam & antiquam Christianae religionis institutionem magis ab ore praecessoris eius quàm a sacris paginis & paternis traditionibus expetant: Illius velle, illius nolle tantum explorant, vt ad eius arbitrium suam conuersationē & ipsi remittant aut intendant. Haec in Corp. Iur. Canonici, editionis Lugdun. 91. in 4..
Loe what doctrine is here: the discipline, nay the religion it selfe of christianitie is sought for rather at the mouth of the Pope, then at Gods mouth in the10 The fift wound not healed. holy Scriptures: and all that a Christian man cares for, is (not what God, but) what the Pope will, and what he wills not; and according to that are they to frame thē selues: Is this a doctrine [...]it to be inserted in the popes lawe? Is this the holy and the onelie true Church that teacheth this? If to be a Catholicke be to holde this, and to denie this to be an heretike, I am content [Page 72] to be an hereticke, let who will bee the Catholicke: but if a true Catholicke ought to holde the doctrine of the Scriptures, and to depende vppon the mouth and reuealed will of GOD, then woe bee to that Church and religion that reacheth, wee maie rather depende on the Popes mouth, then on Gods. But some will say, this is healed. Nay alas, they be so farre from that The fift wound not healed., that contrariwise for ought that I knowe, this is not be found in the elder editions: but I am sure it is in the latter and last of all, set forth by speciall authoritie from the Pope; from whence also I cite it at this time.
Thus I haue shewed, First, that the Pope makes his Decrees equall with the Scriptures; Secondly, that they are of greater authoritie then the Scriptures: Is it possible to haue a worse? Yes: for the measure of her iniquitie will neuer be full; and therefore shee goeth one steppe higher in this impietie, and teacheth that the holy Scripture is so farre inferiour vnto the Popes decrees, that vnless he by his authority giue them strength they are not of credit, nor necessarie to be belieued.
Let me be of no credit nor worthy to be beleeued, if I repeate not their wordes truely out of their owne booke; namely, their authenticall glosse vpon the Popes Decretalls: where the Text of the Decretall being no more nor lesse, then only one verse of the 26. Chapter of the Prouerbs, the glosse (that is the approued Commentarie) vpō that decretall is in these words; Vide Decretal. lib. 2. tit. 23 de praesumptionibus, cap. 1. sicut. Aduerte quod verba textus non sunt verba Papae sed Salomonis in Parabolis, & habentur originaliter in c. 26. Sed quia textus hic est canonizatus, facit fidem, & inducit necessitatem, sicut si editus [...]uīsset a Papa, quia omnia nostra facimus, quibus nostrā autoritatē impertimur. Glossa.
The high and holy God, that is the Author of the holy Scriptures, bee mercifull vnto vs, in hauing anie thing to doe with this vnchristian blasphemie; and graunt that wee may not anie waie communicate with their sinnes, not haue fellowship with this wicked worke of darkenesse. The Impietie and Atheisme that lyeth in it is such, as if it had but crept into some secret pamphlet, I would neuer haue brought it into light: but beeing that it is registred in the Glosse vppon their lawe, a booke of so great authoritie, and so common in the hands of all the learned, I cannot but discharge my dutie to the truth, tho it may giue vantage to the Atheist and Libertine. For what can such men thinke, when they heare him that pretends to bee Christs Viker and Peters successor, teache that Salomons wordes are not of as good authoritie as his bee; when as Christ himselfe did approoue and iustifie himselfe, and all his words, and deedes, and doctrines, by the olde Testament; and that the words of God in the olde Testament doe therefore binde, and are [Page 74] therefore to bee beleeued, because the Pope pleaseth to insert and canonize them in his lawe; and that being by him so canonized, they bee therefore as good as if the Pope himselfe had spoken them. VVhat I saie can they iudge but that the Pope is one of their religion, a plaine Atheist, that holdes the Scripture and all religion, as farre as pleaseth his humour & serueth his turnes.
And if anie of his faction holde this too hard a censure, I would intreate him to answere mee but this question (grounded vpon these words of his);
Whether is God the Authour of the olde Testament,2. Pet. 1. 20. 21 or no? If they say no, Saint Peter answereth; that Prophecie in olde time came not by the will of man, but holy men of God spake as they were inspired by the holie Ghost: If hee bee, then the Prouerbes of Salomon, beeing a Canonicall Booke of the Olde Testament, is Gods Booke, and the wordes of this Text are Gods words, and not Salomons. This beeing so, let vs then take the wordes as they are in their true and full meaning, and see what a peece of Popish diuinitie heere is;A strāge peece of popish doctrine, that Gods word if it be authorized by the Pope, is then of as good credit, as if the Pope himselfe had spoken it: therefore if the Pope please not to canonize it, then it is not. So that either Gods word must be beholden to the Pope for the authoritie of it, or els it hath none.
Loe heere the Pope in his owne colours: this is Diuinitie fit to be hatched at Rome, and to be coyned [Page 75] in his mint. Let the words be examined, and see what can followe of them but that either the Pope holdes not the Prouerbs to be Gods booke, but SALOMONS (which is horrible Atheisme) or els if hee holde them Gods, that the words of God beare no credit, nor haue authoritie to binde mens conscience till the Pope doe canonize them; and that Gods word, in a book knowen, receiued, and graunted to bee Canonicall, is not of as good authoritie in that booke, as being translated into the Popes Canon lawe: if he refuse both these, then let him refuse his owne lawe, and burne his glosse vpon his decretalles, as contayning Atheisme, and Heresie in a high degree. The sixt wound not healed.
But to goe forward; is this wound healed? Surely, if they haue left it out, or reformed it in any later impression, so it bee with open confession and detestation of the fault, it is well: But sure I am, it is in the impression I haue, and in all other which I could borrow. And further I do not know any Pope, or popish writer that hath with authoritie and allowance condemned or reprooued this Atheisme: if they knowe any, they may doe well to produce them: Meane time, I am also sure of this, that in stead of healing it, they haue suffered their Doctors, and Writers continually since to speake and write almost as ill, if not worse. In Queene Maries time, an English Papist wrote thus Proctor. in his booke called the way home to Christ, printed at Londō in 8.,
See, we are more beholden to the Church then to the Scripture, for our Religion. About the same time [Page 76] Cardinal Poole out of his Pope-holy deuotion is sayde to haue affirmed, that
And certaine Popish Doctors in Germanie, beeing pressed in a disputation with the euidēce of Scripture, boldely answered,
I will not affirme these two vpon my owne credit: but they haue beene charged with them both, manie yeeres agoe, and neuer yet disproued them. But that that followeth I speak vpon knowledge.
A little after, a great english Papist pretending to summon a Parliament for Poperie, in his booke so called, telles a storie of one whom hee hearde, vpon reading the Booke of Ecclesiastes, earnestly say, that
He voweth to God, and cals him to witnes, that this he heard him, himselfe: but what was hee that spake it, a Protestant? no, a Papist: and no mad fellow, nor ignorant foole, nor profane scoffer; but (sayth Heskins) hee was a man of worship, of grauitie, of wisedome, of godly life and competent learning, able to vnderstand, and likewise exercised in the Scriptures: and this is all the censure hee giues of him that spake these wordes.
Hee addeth further (a little after in the same Chap.) that a popish Gentlewoman hearing a text (out of a boooke that papists holde to bee Scripture) [Page 77] which shee misliked: and being tolde by him (for he heard her speak the words) that the booke was Scripture; shee aunswered, that if the Scripture had such (I will not say what shee saide) words in it,
Shee would no more beleeue the scripture, for it was naught Heskins in his parliamēt, the next page after.:
And what was shee that saide this? a vertuous Catholicke gentlewoman and one that feared GOD Obserue wel, how a great popish doctor commēds that man and woman, for deuout and zealous papists, who blasphemously saide, that the scriptures were naught and not to be belieued, and doth not reprooue the parties for their blasphemie. So little doth it touch a papists hart to heare Gods word abused in the highest kind.. (Lo, what tokens Poperie giueth of a vertuous Catholicke woman, and that feares God). And tho Heskins cannot but graunt that these are blasphemies: Yet did hee not reproue the one nor the other; But contrariw [...]se, commends them both, and turnes it to the aduantage of the Romish cause, and sayth that hereby wee may see, what a perillous thing it is for Lay people to read the Scriptures. But (with his lea [...]e) hereby we may see, what a filthie heart and vile estimation popish doctors haue of the holy Scriptures, who hearing their disciples thus horribly blaspheme them, and God in them, do not reproue it, but make vse of it; nor burie and quench them, but write and publish them, rather with an approbation, then any detestation of them.
But will you heare his owne wordes, and his owne iudgement, not related from others (as these) but vttered out of his owne heart: ‘How little incitement to vertue appeareth to bee in the songes of Salomon? yea, rather how vngodly and wanton seeme they to bee, in the outward face, rather teaching and prouoking (I craue pardon of all Christian cares) Wantonnesse then [Page 76] [...] [Page 77] [...] [Page 78] godlinesse: and what can the vnlearned finde, or vnderstand in many sentences? any thing to edification of godly life? or rather a prouocation to wanton life. And▪ after certaine sentences alledged, hee concludes: The whole booke is no better: like vnto these, saith hee, is all that booke.’
You haue heard how the proue [...]bes were disgraced in the glosse vpon the decretalls, and here the Canticles: Now that Salomon may not haue one book left in credite, Heskins Vide approbationem & laudem huius autoris & libri apud Possev. in appar. sacro to. 3. lit. T. verbo. Thomas Hardingus. addeth touching Ecclesiastes;
And to conclude, of another booke which they holde also to be canonicall scripture, and some of them to be Salomons, hee sayth, that
If the wordes bee as immodest as hee pretendes they bee: then why doe they holde such a booke to be Scripture? and if they holde it to bee Scripture, then how dare a Christian man say, that it hath such speeches in it, as an honest man would bee ashamed to speake or write? I leaue this for them to aunswere; [Page 79] in the meane time I go forward:
Not longe after, comes Hosius, a greate Doctor of theirs, and after a Cardinall, and writes thus Hosius editionis vlt. tom. 20. lib. de expresso dei verbo. pag. 5. Pronuntiamus (non verbum dei sed) scripturam pendere ad authoritate testimonio & approbatione Ecclesiae: quae non aliter verbum esse dei censeri debet nisi quatenus ecclesiae fuerit autoritate cō probata.;
Lo, what doctrine here is: for hence it followeth, that therefore if the Church should not allowe the newe Testament, it were not scripture.
Put all these together, and then it will soone appeare, how pitifully this wound is healed. Nay further, if the time and present occasion would giue leaue to looke into their latter and moderne writers, wee should see by the last, and latest of all, this wound is so farre from being healed, that it rankles further and deeper, euen like an incurable leprosie, that cannot bee healed: but let it suffice to name some of the Authors, and referre the learned Reader to them Pistoriu [...] cont. Mentz. disp. 1. Stapleton, lib. 9. doct. princip. cap. 14. Bellar. tom. 1. Controv. 1. lib. 4. cap. 4. Fran. Agricola de verbo dei scripto & non scripto. cap. 7, & cap. 9. Perouu. de incertitudine &c. scripturarū.. And let vs go forward to another wound.
They taught the People in olde time, namely, for two or three hundred yeares past, that Images were good laye mens bookes: and euen then, when they denied them the scripture as vnfit for them, and obscure, & dangerous for seducing them to heresies, were Images allowed and cōmended vnto them as good meanes of Instruction The seauēth wound; Images are good laye mens bookes..
Some three hundred years ago, liued a Frier called Gulielmus Peraldus, learned (for that time) and well approued Guliel. Peraldus ord. praed: & postea Epistola Lugdunens. scripsit (inter alia) summa virtutū & vitiorum pervtilem illā quidem & cō modam concionatoribus: quae saepius est recusa: haec Possev. appar. sac. to. 1. lit. G. of their Moderne Censurers: hee writes thus:
Lo here, how Images are associated and ioyned with the Bible: Search the scripture, saith Christ: look on them; and on▪ Images sayth the Pope▪ how readest thou, saieth Christ: what seest thou, saith the Pope: It is written sayeth Christ: it is painted and grauen sayeth the Pope: thy worde (sayeth Dauid) is my light, (not the golden Ch [...]rubins): but nowe sayeth Poperie euen in the newe Testament, the scriptures and Images are laye mens lights: What a wronge is this to GOD, and what an iniurie to his worde?
But is this healed? Oh that it were! but let the reader iudge, by that that followeth The seauenth wound not healed, but made worse and worse..
One of their greatest Casuists, Laelius Zecchius, a great Diuine, a famous Lawyer, and of late yeares Penitentiarie of Bresse, writing a great volume of Cases of Conscience dedicated to Pope Clement the viij. amongst many other strange doctrines touching Images, teacheth, that ‘It is not lawfull onely, but profitable to haue Images in Churches, to cherish and encrease charitie towards God and men, &c. and to preserue faith; seeing Images are to bee held as bookes for them that bee vnlearned, to draw them vnto [Page 81] knowledge, memorie, and imitation of holy and diuine matters, &c. Laelius Zecchius Summa moral. theolog. & casuum. consci. tom. 2. cap. 90. art 18. pag. 609. Imagines poni [...]n Ecclesijs, vtile est ad charitatem erga deum & sanctos fouendam & augendam &c. & ad fidem conseruandam, cum Imagine, babeantur pro libris, his qui▪ literas ignorāt, ex quibus ducuntur in cognitionem memoriā & imitationem diuinorum &c. Brixiae. 1598.’
Lo here, this doctor, who heing Penitentiarie, is by his place and calling to heale woundes and satisfie Consciences, comming to touch this wound, handled it so roughly, that in steede of healing it, hee makes it sorer then it was. For whereas Peraldus gaue Scripture so much honour, as to be ioyned in commission with Images, they two to be ioynt teachers of the Laity; Now comes the great Penitentiarie, and is well allowed by the Pope to leaue out the scripture, as needlesse, and to giue all the power to Images, not onely to put men in minde, but euen t [...] cherish and increase faith and charitie. And certainely, if Images can do so, it is no maruell that Poperie cast ou [...] the scriptures, and in roome thereof, do bring Images into the Churches.
But to make vp the measure of this iniquitie; Feuardent the famous Franciscan frier, yet preaching at Paris, and to whome Possevine wisheth a long life (r); goeth one step further, and to heale vp this wound perfectly, teacheth this doctrine Fran. Feuardentius in lib. homiliarum. pag. 16. & 17. hom. 2 Ex [...]arū (.i. imaginum) contemplatione, discunt & facile & breuiter simplices ac Idiotae illa diuina mysteria, miracula & opera, quae ex sacris libris aut vix aut nunquam percipere valeant.;Possev. app. sac tom. 1. lit. f.
Heere now is Poperie growen to his ful ripenesse. [Page 82] And marke the degrees how this wound hath beene made still deeper and wider.
First, they taught, the Scripture and Images together were good bookes for Lay-men Peraldus..
Then that, Images without the scripture were to be accounted bookes for Lay men Laelius Zec chius..
Now at last, Images are readier and easier, and therfore better bookes for Layemen then be the scriptures Feuardentius..
So then seeing this wound is so well healed, let vs leaue it and search another.
In former ages, as superstition grew, and religion decayed, so Images began to bee worshipped more & more; and ceased not till at the last they came to this, that euerie Image was to bee worshipped with the same worship that was due to him whose Image it is: so that some three hundred yeares agoe, or somewhat more, it seemed by Aquinas to bee their generall & receiued doctrine, that The eight wound; That an Image of God or a Crucifix are to bee worshipped as God and Christ, that is, with diuine worship.
A fearefull doctrine, maintaining horrible Idolatrie; for nothing, but GOD, may bee worshipped with diuine worshippe: but they teach that those creatures may bee worshipped as God himselfe is, that is, with diuine worshippe: therefore they make those creatures God: and by this argument it is apparant, that the present religion of the Church of Rome [Page 83] is an Idolatrous religion, as long as this doctrine stands vnrepealed.
Let vs then see, if this bee healed: The eight wound not healed, but made vvider and deeper and deadlier euerie day. But alas, it is so farre from beeing in any part reformed, that it is rather the generall and common receiued doctrine of all their approoued writers. I will not stande (as I coulde) to shewe it successiuelie through all ages since the dayes of Aquinas, till these times: but sparinge that labour, till better leasure, I will referre the Reader to most of the elder Authors Alexander Hallensis 3. par. quaest. 3. memb. 3. art. 3. Albertus in 3. sent. dist. 9. art. 4▪ Bonauentura eadem distinct. art. 1. q. 2. Richardus. art. 2. q. 2. Capreolus ibidem art. 1. conclus. 2. Waldensis tō. cap. 156. nu. 6. Caietanus in par. 3. q. 25. art. 3. hoc modo citantur hi Auctores apud Greg. de valēt. tom. 4. disp. 1. q. 24. Et multos alios addit Bellarminus, lib. de Imag. sanct. 2. cap. 20. &c. and insist onely on some fewe, and those of the latest: it being my speciall purpose at this time to shew that the Romish Babylon is euen now not healed of her deadliest wounds. Which in this particular I will labour a little the more fully to demonstrate out of the moderne authors, now extant and approued, because this imputation is generally cast off with this aunswere; It is not so, it is but an ignorant or malitious slander: for the Romish Church giues onely a certaine reuerence to holy Images; but doth not worshippe them, at all, at least with no diuine worshippe. And some of our owne profession are either so ignorant they knowe it not, or so malitious, they will not confesse it, or else so hollow hearted to vs, and such secrete friendes to them▪ they would not haue it discouered tho it bee so: for my part, I pittie the Ignorant, (knoweinge my owne weakenesse) I care not for the malitious, and I hate the hollownesse of all dissemblinge professors. And therefore let others come and conceale her shame, and hide the whore of Babylons filthinesse, as they will; I say for my selfe, let [Page 84] the tongue cleane to the roofe of my mouth, if I spare to discouer her skirts, and lay open her filthinesse to the world; that all men seeing her as shee is, may detest and forsake her. Therefore in the words of truth and sobernesse, I do heere offer to this honourable audience, that I will willingly come to this place and recant it with shame, if I proue not apparantly to the iudgement of euerie reasonable man, that this is the common and generall doctrine of the greatest number of their best approued authors that haue written in these later daies; namely,
And first of all, I will in this case spare Bellarmine, Vide Bellarminū to 2 lib. de Imag. sanctorum 2. cap. 20. 21. 22, 23. 24. & de Concil. lib. 2. cap. 8. seeing hee (as hauing some grace in him) seemes somewhat ashamed of the matter, and therefore playeth fast and loose: and betwixt God and his conscience on the one side, and the Pope and his allegeance to him on the other, hee cannot tell what to say: and therfore winding himselfe into a labyrinth of generall and confused distinctions of per se & per accidens, primariò & secundariò, propriè & impropriè, and such other which may serue for al purposes; at last he leaues the matter as doubtfull as hee findes it: yet must it bee confessed, if hee incline either way, it is to the worse: which, by conference of his other writings, I thinke he doth rather for feare, or to please the Pope, then out of his owne iudgement and conscience.
Therfore leauing him, I begin with Gregorie de Valentia a Iesuite, & a Professor of diuinitie as Bellarmine is, of his owne sect, of his owne time, and accounted by some papists more learned, but approued Vide approbationes praefixas 4. tom. disputat. Greg de Valent. of all: hee writeth thus;
Hee cannot denie, but manie learned of his owne side teach the contrarie: but he reproues them all, and embraceth this as the commoner and truer opinion, and confirmes it and concludes it for truth.
Next to him I produce another Iesuite, Gretserus, of the same vniuersitie, and either succes [...]or or fellow to Gregory de Valentia in the same place & profession, he who was chosen for the papists Champion, in the famous disputation holden at Regensperg 1600. Vide collo. quium Ratifbonense. anno 600.; and whom Posseuine the Iesuite calls the very hammer of heretikes Iac Gretserus: in Acadē. Ingolst. professor. theol. haereticorum malleus: sic Posseu. tom. 2. lit. I.: Thus he writeth e;
Can anie speake more plainely then both these doe? Now, these bee Iesuites, and to these two I coulde adde more Vide Pos. Bib. select. tom. 1. lib. 8 c. 7. ex. Thyraeo l [...]s. Gab. Vazquez de cultu adorationis. lib. 1. disp. 8. c. 2. & 3. & disp. 9. cap. 1: but let vs see what their Summists, and Casuists saie to this matter; which are the more to bee regarded because they pretende to write such resolutions as may settle vnquiet and doubting consciences. If therfore any poore Papist aske the Romish Confessors and Casuists, How farre may I worship a Crosse, and with what kind of worship; hearken how they answere.
And to let one speake for all, Iacobus de Graffijs, a Monke of great name, and Graund Penitentiarie at Naples, writing (as hee calls them) his Golden decisions of cases of conscience, some 3. yeares agoe, answereth thus Iac. de Graffiis decis. aureae. cas. conscientiae. tom. 1 lib. 2. c. 2. art. 3. Imagines sacrae, si vt res quaedam cōsiderātur, nulla eis tribuenda est reuerentia; sed in illis ima go ipsius, cuius sunt attenditur, non materia ex qua formatae fuerūt: vnde quae reuerentia illi cuius est imago debetur, [...] adē & imagini iure im pertitur Et postea ibidem, art. 15. Mand at primū praeceptū, vt vnāquamquam (que) imaginem eodem cultu quo ille cuius est imago, veneremur; vt imagini dei vel Christi, vel etiam crucis signo, prout dominicam passionem ad mentem reuocat, latriam impertiamur: Sacrae Virginis hyperduliam, & sanctorum imaginibus duliam.;
And to speak more fully & plainly, if it be possible: a little after he addeth;
How now? is not Babylon well healed? what can be said against this? that these be priuate men? no, they be publicke professors, and their bookes allowed with as great authority as can bee: But will you haue that that is of souereigne authoritie, and that maie not bee questioned? Then look in their publick liturgy, which is of more credit and account then a 100. Doctors, & there you shall find the crosse saluted and praied vnto in these words, Vide Breuiar. Rom. par. hyemal. in fine. Ara Crucis. lampas luci [...], vera salus hominū nobis pronum fac patronum, quem tulisti dominum. Salue lignum vitae, dignum ferre mūdi pretiū: Confer isti plebi Christi crucis beneficiū.
Oh admirable doctrine! First, heer is a prayer to the Crosse it selfe (but of that heerafter): then the Crosse is made a mediatour to Christ for vs. And surely wee shall lesse wonder heereafter that they make Saints Mediatours to CHRIST; seeing heer they shame not [Page 88] to send the wodden crosse to him, to make intercession for them: but as for that, where they giue a power to the Crosse to procure Christ to be good vnto vs, how it can bee spoken without Atheisticall blasphemie, let them answere that made it.
Further, obserue how the Crosse is sayde to haue deserued to beare Christ: surely no maruell tho Saints can merite, when a peece of wood can merit at Gods hands. Lastly, let all reasonable men iudge what the Romish Church holds of Christs death; seeing they praie to a wodden Crosse, to bestowe the fruite and benefite of it vpon them.
But sure (will some saie) this is healed: I will not deny but that in some of their newe and latter Breuiaries this is left out: but thereunto I answere;
First, that it is not reformed, but couered: for to the healing of a spirituall wounde, there needes confession and publique satisfaction to the Church offended by the fault: but here is no confession of anie fault nor euill, in these words to the Crosse; only they bee cunningly kept out in the newer bookes: so that they are ashamed of them, & yet haue not the grace to confesse it, and therfore will leaue it out and yet shew no cause why. Now if it bee naught, why doe they not say so, and therfore put it out? if it be good, why do they put it out? So then it may be couered, but is not cured.
Secondly, I answere that though they haue left out that, yet they haue kept in as bad or worse: for euen in their newest editions, and as they say most reformed, there is praier to this Crosse. Breuiarium Rom. autoritate Concil. Trident. & sū morum pontificum, Pij 5. & al. restitutum. & editum: Sabbato infra hebdomadam passionis, in Hymno pag. 302. editionis in 4. O Crux aue spes vnica hoc passionis tempore: auge pijs iusticiam reis (que) dona veniam.
Heere the very wodden Crosse is called vpon, and prayed vnto, to doe that which Christ himselfe could neuer haue done, if hee had not beene God. Some will say, Surely they speake to Christ, howsoeuer the words seeme to bee spoken to the Crosse: I answere, if they direct their hearts to Christ, why then direct they the words to the Crosse? Verely Christ is worthy of both, as well as one: But I answere further, it is a cleere case that they make and direct this prayer not to Christ, but to the very Crosse it selfe: else let Aquinas bee Iudge, who makes this argument Aquinas summae par. 3. q. 25. art. 4. Illi exhibemus latriae cultū, in quo spem salutis ponimus: sed in Cruce Christi ponimus spem salutis, cantat enim Ecclesia, O Crux aue [...]pes vnica hoc passionis tempo [...]e auge pijs Iusticia reis (que) dona veniam: (In dominica de paff. in Hym.) ergo crux Christi est adoranda adoratione latrie.;
These bee his owne very words, and are spoken of the Crosse, and not of Christ; as any man may see that will but looke on the booke it selfe: for the question in generall, beeing concerning the adoration of Christ Quaest [...] 25. de adoratione Christi in sex Articulas diuisa. hee diuides the generall into sixe particular questions, which are these m,
- [Page 90]1. Whether Christs humanitie bee to be worshipped with the same worship as his diuinity. 1. Vtr [...] vna & eadem adoratione sit adorāda diuinitas Christi & eius humanitas.
- 2. Whether Christs humane flesh bee to be worshipped with latria.2. Vtrū caro Christi sit adoranda adoratione latriae.
- 3. Whether the adoration or worship of latria be to be giuen to the Image of Christ.3. Vtrum adoratio latriae sit exhibenda imagini Christi
- 4. Whether to the crosse of Christ.4. Vtrum sit exhibēda cruci Christi.
- 5. Whether to the Mother of Christ.5. Vtrum sit exhibend Matri eius.
- 6. How the Relickes of Saints are to be worshipped. 6. De adoratione reliquiarum sanctorum.
So that we see, here is Christ and his Crosse, and his Image, and his Mother are made 4. seuerall matters and of seueral and distinct consideration: then falling into the particulars, for the 2. first questions, hee argueth them negatiuely, but concludes them affirmatiuely; touching which two wee haue no controuersie with them at this time: then comming to the 3. & 4. which bee these in question; touching the Image of Christ, whether it be to be worshipped with latria or no? he answereth, that it seemes no; and giues such reasons as he nor the world is able to answere, but concludes affirmatiuely that it is Artic. 3. vtrum Imago Christi sit adoranda adoratione latriae. Videtur quod non &c. sed contra est &c. Conclusio, Cum Christus latriae adoratione sit adorandus, Imago quo (que) eius eadē adoratione est adoranda. as I haue set downe: namelie, that
So comming to the fourth question, which is of the Crosse, demaunding whether it be to be worshipped with latria or no; Hee aunswereth that it seemes no: but concludes affirmatiuelie that it is Aquinas [...]bidem art 4. vtrum crux Christi sit adoranda adoratione latriae? videtur quod non: sed contra est, &c.; and then giues his reason as I haue afore set it downe, and from [Page 91] thence drawes his conclusion in these words Conclusio: Crux Christi in qua Christus crucifixus est, tum propter representationem, tum etiam propter membrorum Christi contactum, latria adoranda est: Crucis vero effigies in alia quauis materia priori tantum ratione adoranda est latria.;
These be his verie words. And heere by the way, obserue how ridiculous and absurd poperie is, in this point: for it giues greater worship to the dead image and wodden crosse, then to the blessed Virgin Mary the mother of Christ; of whom he concludes in the next article, that shee is by no meanes to bee worshipped with latria, but onely with an inferior worship called hyperdulia Ibidem art. 5. videtur quod mater Christi est adoranda latria: sed cō tra est &c. Conclusio: mater Christi cùm sit creatura rationalis, non latria sed in quantu mater Dei est hyperdulia adoranda est.; and marke what wodden arguments are giuen for it: One, Shee is a reasonable creature▪ and therefore must not be worshipped with latria: Lo, she must not because shee is a reasonable creature, and yet the Crosse shall which is vnreasonable and dead. Another; A Crucifixe is like to Christ, therefore it shall bee worshipped with latria Crux Christi propter representationem adoranda est latria. ibid. art. 4.: But is not shee liker to Christ then anie Crosse can be?
A third; the Crosse did beare CHRIST, and did touche his bodie: therefore it must be worshipped with latria Crux Christi ex cōtactu ad mēbra Christi & quia eius fuit sanguine perfusa, est adoranda latria ibid. art 4.. But did not shee beare him, and touche him and his blessed Bodie in a farre more excellent manner then the CROSSE eyther did or could? See what pittifull arguments be heer brought [Page 92] to fortifie this damnable Idolatrie: Who could think that so great learned Doctors should thus childishlie dally with holy things, and bee so blinded in their vnderstandings? but this it is to be drunke with the wine of the spirituall Babylons abhominations.
But to returne to the matter: by these wordes of his, Aquinas hath cleared that doubt and aunswered that obiection made afore; that these wordes are not spoken to the Crosse or image, but to Christ: No, sayth Aquinas; they are spoken to the Crosse.
What can bee sayde to all this? but one thing more, that in the time of Aquinas it may be this was holden, but since then it is reformed, and now it is not so. But I answere; this wound is not healed: for as it is thus as I haue reported in the olde copies of Aquinas both Manuscript, and printed; so is it also without the least alteration in the newe and later editions Vide editionem Antuerp [...]ensem: summa Aquinatis anno 1585. & sequentibus. reformed and purged as they pretende: and printed within these fewe yeares. And (which is more euill) whereas, some thirtie yeares agoe, all Aquinas was reuiewed at Rome by commaundement of Pope Pius Quintus, and purged and altered Opera omnia D. Thomae, P [...]j quintj Pont. Max. autoritate, in locis plurimis tam in textu, quam in commentarijs restituta sunt: & Romae excusa 1570. & expuncta sunt varia ex eisdē commentarijs &c. Haec Posseu. in apparatu sacro, tom. 3. lit. T. as they thought good, and so printed: yet had not the Pope so much grace in him, nor so much zeale of Christs glorie as to amend this horrible impietie, but to the perpetuall blemish of Aquinas, and euerlasting shame of their Romish synagogue, lets it stand for good currant Catholicke doctrine, euen at this daie, that
A Crosse to be worshipped with the same worship as Christ himselfe.
Yet if any will stand vpon it, that this wound is healed, [Page 93] then let him shew vs what Pope hath condemned this doctrine; nay what popish Doctor approoued by their Church hath reproued this doctrine, or taught and written the contrarie. Which when they or any other that take their part, can neuer be able to shewe: I contrariwise to make it manifest to all the world that this wound is not healed, but rankles deeper, and spreds further, will shewe out of their latest and moderne writers, that this their doctrine is rather made worse then any way reformed. To this end, let the Reader bee pleased to marke the wordes of a great Doctor of theirs well approued amongst them Ioh. Chrisost. a visitatione, Lu [...]itan. theologus & professor Cisterciēsi [...] scripsit libros 12. de verbis dominae, hoc est quae Maria, &c. locuta est Venetijs 1600. Posseu. apparat. sacro, tom. 2. lit. I. and a spanish professor of diuinitie for the order of the Cistercians: who not 7. yeares agoe writing 2. volumes of Commentaries, which he entitles de verbis Dominae, ‘Of the words of our Lady.’ and dedicating his booke vnto the Pope himselfe CLEMENT the viij. hath these words, Iohan. Chrisostomus a visitatione, de verbis dominae, tom. 1. lib 6. cap. 7. in fine▪ Verum de cruce cur tantum loquimur, vbi nihil fuit in passione Christi quod sine suo honore remaneret. Cum honore remanserunt claui, lancea, corona, vestes, & huiusmodi alia: Et in tali honore remanserunt, vt propter Christi contactum ab hominibus adorentur; sed tamen non eadē adoratione qua ipsam crucem adoramus: quam in quantum nobis representat figuram Christi in ea extensi, & in quantum habuit contactum ad membra, & in quantum etiam eius pretiosissimo sanguine fuit persusa, eadem adoratione cum Christo adoramus; nempe adoratione latriae: propter quod etiā ipsam Crucem alloquimur & deprecamur quasi ipsum crucifixum & in ipsa spem salutis ponimus: vnde de illa canit Ecclesia; O Crux aue spes vnica, hoc passionis tempore, auge pijs iustitiam, reis (que) dona veniam &c. ‘(x) But what doe we speak so much of the Crosse, seeing seeing there is nothing vsed in the passion of Christ that is without honour: the nailes, the speare, the coate, the crowne, and all such other things, are honoured so much, as that (in regard [Page 94] they touched Christ) men doe therefore worship them, yet not with the same worship with which wee worship the Crosse it selfe: which, inasmuch as it represēts vnto vs the figure of Christ extended vpon it, and inasmuch as it touched the seuerall parts of his bodie, and inasmuch as it was died with a good part of his most pretious bloud: Wee doe therefore worship it with the same worship with which wee adore Christ himselfe; namely, with the worship of latria. For which cause it is, that we speake to the verie Crosse it selfe, and praie vnto it, as vnto him that was crucified on it, and doe repose the hope of our saluation vpon it: heerupon the Church singeth in the liturgie, these words of the Crosse; All haile ô Crosse our onely hope: in this time of Lent do thou increase righteousnesse in good men, and grant pardon to sinners, &c.’
Loe, heere is a peece of refined poperie indeed: we worship the Crosse sayth hee as Christ, we speake to the Crosse it selfe, wee pray to the Crosse it selfe, as well as to him that dyed on it; and hee confesseth freely, that the prayer in the liturgie or masse booke is not made to CHRIST, but to the Crosse it selfe. From hence I gather these two conclusions;
This I collect thus: Latria (sayth Augustine August Epistola 49. vni & soli deo debetur seruitus illa religionis quam vno nomine Graeci latriā vocāt: Et in Faustum l. 15. latria est seruitꝰ illa qua tantummodo Deo seruitur. is that worship of religion, which is due onely and solely to God himselfe: and poperie it selfe confesseth with one consent, that prayer is a part of latria Ioh. de Combis Compendiū theologicae verit. c. de dulia & latria Latria continet. 5. fidem, spem, sacrificium, orationem, &c.: But [Page 95] popish religion prayeth to a wodden crosse, euen to the crosse it selfe; therfore by popish religion the wodden Crosse is a God.
This I collect thus: their Missalls and Breuairies which containe their Liturgie are confirmed both by the Pope and the Councell of Trent Vide Missalia & Breuiaria omnia ab anno. 70 & deinceps.: but the Popes determination, especiallie together vvith a Councell is the publicke and vncontroleable act of their Church None acknowledging himselfe a papist can denie this.: Therefore the doctrine and practice in their Liturgie is not priuate, or such as may be questioned, or doubted of, but publicke and generall, and may not be called in question. But in their late and reformed Breuiarie allovved and confirmed by the Pope and Councell, they praie to the Crosse and call vppon the Crosse, as wee heard before, and their owne Doctors doe expounde it that it is not to Christ but to the Crosse Aquinas of old, and Chrisostomus a visitatione of late.. Therefore by the doctrine and religion of the Church of Rome the Crosse is a God.
Bellarmine would gladly heale this wound, or at least couer it ouer, and saith Bellar. in tom. 2. de Imag. sanctorū. lib. 2. c. 24. in resp. ad argū. Respondeo vbi eccles. canit, O Crux aue, spes vnica. &c. vel ibi accipi crucē pro Christo ipso: vel illam esse prosopopoeiā rhetoricam. &c.; that whereas the Church praieth so, surely either the Crosse is taken for Christ, or els it is but a figure; as Moses saith, Heare O Heauens, Deutero. 32. No, no, say the Romish Doctors, (that wrote since Bellarmine) there is no such matter: that praier is to the Crosse it selfe.
And his brother Ga. Vazq. Ies. de cultu adorationis li. 2. disp. 3. cap. 4 Iesuite, Gabriel Vazquez, being also much ashamed of the matter, would gladlie help it, and to that ende is constrayned to confesse, that [Page 96] there is not (as Bellarmine sayth) one alone, but two figures in that prayer: which (saith he) vnlesse they be admitted, it is an vnapt and absurd prayer; for it speaks vnto the Crosse as vnto our God and Sauiour. Hee therefore for his part saith, hee should thinke that by the Crosse they meane Christ, and pray to him, not to the Crosse: and further sayth, that many others thinke so, but he names not one; (tho in other points hee is a plentifull citer of other Authours): but against him or who-euer els thinke so (beeing papists) I produce the Cistercian Doctor Chrisostome a visitatione, who writing since them all For Vazquez wrote since Bellarmine: namely, about the yeare 92. but this Chrisostome wrote since Vazquez some seauen yeares agoe., and whose booke is of more authoritie then his For Vazquez is dedicated but to a spanish ordinarie Bishop, but Chrisostome to the Pope himselfe., answereth all these doubtes, and preuents all other obiections; saying plainely that in that prayer of the Church,
And no more, nor no worse, saith he, then Aquinas himselfe, totidem verbis, spake before him Aquinas summa par. 3. q 25. art. 4.. Therfore (to conclude) till this doctrine of Aquinas bee condemned for heresie, and till this fellow that calles himselfe golden mouth, be adiudged as hee is, a leaden mouthed and blacke-mouthed blasphemer, and his booke burnt as hereticall, and til the Romish Church haue satisfied the World for this great wrong, till then (I say) it is apparant to all men, that in this wound She is not healed.
This wound hath been deepe and wide, and therefore long in searching: and seeing it is found incurable, let vs proceed. Not many hundred yeares agoe, liued a Frier they called S. Francis, an ignorant man for learning, but wittie: hee beeing the founder of the [Page 97] Franciscans, the Pope hath suffered his fauorites and followers to set him vp as another Christ The ninth wound; An Italian Frier Francis was like to Christ in all things, and in some things did more then he, and bare 5. woundes in his body as Christ did. and blasphemously to compare him, and oftentimes to prefer him afore Christ himselfe. And to this end amongst many other vile ones Vide monumēta ordinis fratrū Min. Salamācae. 1511 in 4. Et firmamenta trium ordinū. D. Frā cisci Paris. 1512 4 & mult. al., he suffred to be published a great volume called, The golden booke of the Conformities of the holy father S. Francis with the life of our Sauiour Iesus Christ Liber aureus, inscriptus liber cōformitatū vitae beati ac seraphici patris Frācisci ad vitam Iesu Christi Domini nostri, correctus & illustratꝰ a Ieremiah Bucchio ord. Min. doctore theo [...]. Bononiae 1590.. In which booke with strange impietie first they paint in the first lease Christ bearing a Crosse and Saint Francis following him with one as bigge as his, where Christ hath nothing but precedence: but after thinking that too much, they paint one Crosse, and vppon it one of Christs armes, and another of S. Francises, one acrosse ouer the other: then begins the book; In the name of Iesus Christ and of S. Francis In nomine Domini nostri Iesu Christi &c. & beati patris nostri Francisci, &c.: where, Iesus Christ is called our Lord and S. Francis our blessed Father; and the Authour saith not, that he compiles the booke to the honour of God, or Christ, but of the foresayd holy father S. Francis.
Then he salutes Saint Francis with a prayer Francisce Iesu typice dux forma (que) Minorum, per te Christi mirificè sunt gesta▪ & donorū. Mala pater egregie propelle animorum sede [...] nobis perpetuas da regni supernorum. fit for none but God himselfe: First, blasphemously calling him typicall Iesus; then desiring him to cure the sinnes and driue away the spirituall maladyes of their soules, and to giue vnto them place in the glorie of heauen.
Then he comes to the point of Conformitie▪ and to shewe this the better, hee paintes a tree at the toppe whereof is Christ, and at the roote Saint Francis: the tree hath twenty branches on the right, & twenty [Page 98] on the left side, & euery branch hath foure particular fruits; in all eightie: these are equally diuided betwixt Christ and S. Francis, 40. to the one, and 40. to the other: and each couple or paire of these is one point of conformitie betwixt Christ and S. Francis, consisting in all vpon 40. particulars; wherin they begin at the birth and conception, nay at the very prophecies and promises made of Christ, and so proceede to his life, his death, resurrection, and ascension: and in all and euery of these, and in euery thing els whatsoeuer may be sayd of Christ, the very same doe they not shame to affirme of that man Francis. For example, thus Iesus Prophetis. cognitus, Franciscus declaratur. Iesus emissus coelitus, Franciscus destinatur &c. Vide librū conformitatum. pag. 6.: Christ was foretolde by the Prophets. So was S. Francis: Christ was sent from God, so was S. Francis. Thus go they ouer all his life, in such a manner as there is nothing giuen to Christ, but bare precedence. And which surpasseth all admiration, those two things wherein Christ did most apparantly, as God declare his power, and his loue as Mediatour; namely, his miracles & his passion, euen in these two is this Francis matcht with Christ our Sauiour: nay rather in his passion he is matcht, but in his miracles aduaunced farre before Christ.
And first for his passion, whereas by their doctrine Christ had 5. wounds in his bodie, (tho indeed he had more) they make S. Francis nothing his inferiour in that point: for they say that he had fiue wounds in his hands and feete, proportionable to Christs Vide librum conformitatū: lib. 3. conformit. 31. par. 2. pag. 298. Franciscus consignatus erat a Christo suae sacrae passionis stigmatibus: ita vt in manibus pedibus (que) eius erant clauià carne diuisi, grossi, solidi & obtusi, inter quos & carnem erat apertura, vnde semper sanguis exibat, ad cuius repressionem, excepto à vespere diei Iovis vs (que) ad sero diei Veneris sequentis, semper paeciae interponebantur: habuit etiam vulnus laterale, ad instar vulneris lateris Christi., and had certaine things like nailes in his feete and hands so [Page 99] diuided from the flesh, that they would open from it, so as his wounds did continually bleede; insomuch, as hee was faine to puttents into them to keepe them from bleeding: which hee continually did, sauing on good Friday, when alwaies this popish Iesus did pul out his tents, and let his wounds bleede, as the true Christs that day did for our saluation; & this not only in hands and feet, but that he had a wound in his side like to that in our Sauiour Christ, and all this (saith the book) was not fained nor imaginarie, but truly & really imprinted in his body by the power of God, that so he might make his friend Francis like to his sonne Christ in all things Vide Ba [...] tholomei de pisis Epistolā ad Generalem & capital. ord. Min. Christus ipsum Patrem Franciscum sibi per omnia similem reddidit et conformem.. And all this was not the superfluitie of idle & superstitious Monks brains; but the publicke act of their Church, and manie Popes one after another haue allowed it, and by their bulles and charters confirmed and auouched the truth of this story, concerning the wounds of S. Francis Vide librū conformit. lib. 3. confor. 31. par. 2. pag. 308 Apparet ergo 8. bullis summorum▪ pontificum. scilicet tribus Gregorij 9. tribus Alexād. 4. vna Nicholai tertij & alia Benedicti 12. quòd beatus Franciscus stigmatizatus fuit.; and in monument and memory therof they haue their holy day of the 5. wounds to this day established by all authoritie Dominus papa Benedictus 12. b [...]llam dedi [...] ordini vt festum celebraretur de stigmatibus beati Francisci..
Thus Christ, touching his passion, is made equall with a mortall man, & an ignorant Frier (by the Popes diuinitie) is made equall with Christ in the manner of his suffring; not in that fashion as euery Christian may be, but so as none at all, no (saith this booke) not S. Iohn the Euangelist, nor the Virgin Marie her selfe could be.
But if we come to his Miracles, then surely Christ must come after him; for whereas Christ▪ wrought a miracle, he they say wrought ten, and those that Christ did are nothing to his. Christ neuer shewed that humilitie and charitie & patience that S. Francis did. Christ [Page 100] neuer gaue awaie all his clothes till hee was starke naked, as S. Francis did For al these being too lōg to write in the margēt I must refer ye Reader to the book it selfe, if he will not beleeue me: or els let him suspende his iudgemēt till I haue leisure to exemplifie these at large by themselues.: he neuer preached to beasts and birds, as Saint Francis did: he neuer by his words and the signe of the Crosse tamed and conuerted wild beastes as Saint Francis did. All this may easily bee shewed and much more; but I will insist only in one, and on that the rather, least they should take it in snuffe that I say their father FRANCIS conuerted beasts: harken therfore to the storie, and then iudge and spare not.
S. Francis on a time comming to preach at the city of Eugubium Vide librū conformitatū lib. 1. conformit. 10. pa [...]. 2. pag. 140. Francis preacheth to a wolfe. Francis calleth the wolfe brother: a couple of rauening Wolues well met. Francis offereth the wolfe his brother to make peace betwixt him & the rowne. The Wolfe is content. found that the saide Citie was much troubled with a great and cruell Wolfe, that killd not their cattell onely▪ but their people if they were vnarmed. Francis▪ would needs goe to him, to turne him from his rauenousnesse: and seeing the wolfe come against him with open mouth, he made the signe of the Crosse vpon him, and commanded the wolfe to shut his mouth and hurt him not: the wolfe presently obeied and fel downe, as tho he had beene a meeke Lamb: then spake Francis to him and sayde; Brother Wolfe thou hast shed much bloud and done much hurt, and therefore art worthie to die, and all this Citie iustly complaines of thee: but brother, if thou wilt be content I will make peace betwixt them & thee: the wolf by wagging his taile, and mouing his eares, shewed that he was verie glad. Then brother Wolfe▪ (sayth S. FRANCIS) seeing thou art content to bee at peace with them I, will take order that they shall giue thee daily allowance of meate, if thou wilt promise mee heereafter to hurt no hodie: the wolfe bowing his heade aunswered by signes that hee woulde. Yea, [Page 101] but then (sayth Francis), Brother Wolfe, giue mee thyFrancis bids his brother wolf giue him his hand and faith that hee will performe his order. faith and credit that I may beleeue thee: and the wolfe presently lifted vp his right fore-foote and layed it in Francis his hand, therby giuing his faith that he would performe it. Then Brother Wolfe (sayth Francis) I command thee in the name of the Lord Iesus that thou go with me into the Citie, and there feare not to make peace, in the name of the Lord: the wolfe forthwith followed him, as meeke as a Lambe. So comming into the Citie, all the people, togither with the Magistrates being assembled, S. Francis made vnto them anBrother wolfe standeth by, whilst S. Francis preacheth to the people. excellēt sermon, the wolfe being by: which being done he sayd to them these words;
This brother of mine, this wolfe that standeth here, hath promised me, & vpon his promise hath giuen me his faith that hee will be friends with you, and doe no more hurt; prouided that you shall dayly giue him an allowance, and portion of meate: which if you doeFrancis is surety for his brother wolfe to the towne. for your partes, then I will bee suretie for my brother Wolfe that he shall perform the conditions on his part required. Then said S. Francis; Brother Wolf, it is reason that as thou did before, so here before all this peopleBrother wolfe giueth his faith againe. thou giue me thy faith againe, that thou wilt keep the couenants on thy part: and the wolfe immediately lift vp his right fore-foot, and laid it in the hand of S. Francis, his suretie, in the sight of all the people, and so gaue his faith againe: and then all the people shouted and wondred, and praised Christ for sending S. Francis amongst thē, by whose merits they were deliuered frō the cruel wolf. And from that day forward, the peopleBrother wolfe liueth in the towne, & takes his meate at the dores. to the wolf & wolf to the people, performed their couenants made by S. Francis: & the wolf liued 2. years after [Page 102] FRANCIS was gone, and went vp and downe the streets, and tooke his meate, from door to door, hurting no man, and was well and daintily fed; and there was neuer so much as a dog that barked at him. And at last, after 2. yeares, Brother Wolfe beeing stricken inBrother wolfe dieth, & is lamented. yeares dyed, for whose death the Citizens did very much lament.
Heere is a miracle worth the marking. Now let all Huguenots, and Heretickes shewe such a miracle in their religion; no, no, they neuer can doe it: And no maruell; for Iesus Christ, who is the King and Captain of their religion, neuer did the like in his time to this which S. Francis the king and captaine of the Franciscans Francisce Iesu typicè dux forma (que) Minorum. hath heere done.
If the time would giue leaue, I could bring 20. more as impious, as incredible, and as absurd in their kinde as this: but leauing it to a further opportunitie, and referring the learned to the booke it selfe, I proceed.
What may bee saide to all this? are not these wide and wofull wounds? Oh! but they are healed; I may answere as the Prophet doth: Were they ashamed when Ierem. 7. 12 they had committed abhomination? Nay, they were (18) The ninth wound not healed. not ashamed. For whereas this booke was written aboue two hundred yeares agoe by Bartholomeus Pisanus, a Franciscan Frier; it was not then only suffred to passe to publique viewe in those daies of darknesse and superstition, but now of late within lesse then 20. yeares when one would haue thought they woulde (if not repented of the impieties, yet) haue beene ashamed of the absurdities; they contrariwise haue reprinted the Booke The newe edition is at Bononie in Italie. 1590. & is dedicated to a Cardinal: in this editiō is all that I haue alleaged., and haue not taken ou [...] [Page 103] nor reformed one worde of all these euilles, nor of many more, which do so directly disgrace the merits of CHRIST IESVS: onely some things haue they altered, which they thought might make against themselues, but not one of these which doe so farre dishonour God and Christ and all religion. Compare together the olde and newe bookes, who will; and he shall finde this to be true: wherefore the conclusion is, that this wound is farre from being healed. Let vs then go forward, and see if wee can finde one wound healed(19) The tenth wound; The Pope may giue Indulgences for 20000. yeers & grant men power to redeeme soules out of Purgatory. in the Romane Church.
Two or three hundred yeares agoe, the Popes Indulgences did growe to that height of rotten ripenesse, that all men of vnderstanding, euen of his owne broode were ashamed of it, and manie a one of the wiser sort, euen in these mystie times, did see and laugh at the nakednesse of Poperie in that poynt; the excesse whereof grewe so great, as they cannot denie but it gaue at last an occasion of LVTHERS reuolte from them. There is a Manuscript extant, written some two hundreth yeeres agoe, and another not much differing from it, some 130. yeares ago printed at Rome, containing a catalogue onely of those Indulgences belonging to the parish Churches of Rome, amongst which (they say) are 7. principall: let vs but consider of some fewe He that wāts this booke let him looke in Hospinian de Templis. lib. 2 c. 28. pag. 348. edition is Tigur. 603. where he shall finde both mention of the book & a particular recitall of a great part of it..
In the Laterane Church, it is graunted thus by Pope Boniface.
If any Pilgrime come for deuotion to this Church, hee shall be absolued from all his sinnes.
And in the Chappel there called sanctum sanctorum, there is full and true remission of all sinnes.
[Page 104]And one daie in the yeare, which is the daie of the dedication of the Church, there is full remission of all sinnes both à poena & culpa: and this Indulgence is so certaine (sayth the booke) that when the Pope first pronounced it, the AngellsAngels say Amen, to the Popes Indulgences: but they shold first proue, y• God saith Amen to them; for els the Angells will not, vnlesse it bee the euill Angells. in the hearing of all the people sayd Amen.
If these things bee true, then it is strange that all Papists in the world are not saued: for hee that hath full remission of all sinnes, both à poena & culpa, dying in that state cannot be damned. And certainly, he that for the obtaining therof, wil not take the pains to visite that Church one daie in a yeer, is not worthy of saluation.
In Saint Peters Church, there bee euerie daie eight and fortie yeeres of pardon, which is in one yeere aboue fifteene thousand yeeres: Euerie daie of the Annuntiation there bee one thousand yeers; and hee that with deuotion goeth vp Saint Peters stayres, hath for euery steppe seauen yeeres of pardon. Surely purgatorie paines are not so fearefull as they beare the world in hand; if going vp two and twentie steps may purchase releasement of a hundred & fiftie yeers thereof. And if these seeme too little Alexander the Pope like a liberall Lord opens his treasure, and giues to euery steppe a thousand yeares: So that now there is not a Papist in the world that needes to be in Purgatorie one daie except hee will: For, for going vpXXij. thousand yeers of pardō grāted for going vp 22. steps If the Pope say true in this no Papist need to come in Purgatory. twentie two steppes with deuotion, hee may be released out of Purgatorie, for two and twentie thousand yeeres: and I hope they do not think the World will last so long, and Purgatorie (they saie) ends with the World.
Further, whosoeuer will go through the 3. dooresThree doores of one Church in Rome of so great vertue that whosoeuer goeth through them shall be as free from sinne [...] when he was newly baptized. Oh what a great power the Pope hath, who can giue power to another so easily to deliuer soules out of purgatorie. How easie purgatorie might be emptied by Popish doctrine. of the Laterane Church▪ shall bee as free from all his sinnes, as hee was the houre hee was baptized: Likewise at the Altar in Saint Peters Church, there be xiiii. thousand years of pardon and deliuerance of one soule out of Purgatorie.
And in the Church of Saint Lawrence, whosoeuer visiteth that Church euerie Thursday for a yeare, and [...]ittes vpon the stone whereon Saint Lawrence was broyled, shall deliuer one soule out of Purgatorie.
And in the Church of Saint Iohn, at the gate called Porta Latina, a man by either saying a Masse, or causing it to bee sayde, may deliuer one soule out of Purgatorie.
Are these true? then why is there one soule left in purgatorie? or else where is the charitie of the Papistes (which they so much bragge of) seeing so easilie they may deliuer so many thousands soules out of purgatorie in one yeare? Certainely, if these bee true as they be written, then granting that there is a purgatotorie, it might soone be emptied.
But if it be false and fabulous and friuolous, and hath no other ende but to mocke poore people and to sucke out their siluer: then what a religion is that which maintaines such dealings? especially seeing this is not the deede of any priuate men, but of the Popes themselues: nor of a fewe, but euen all since Boniface the eight.
Thus wee haue searched deepe, into a foule and filthie wound. Now what remaines? but to see if it bee healed yet or no The tenth wound not healed, but groweth more desperate & deadly to this day.,
But alas, Babylon will not be healed: for as they [Page 106] feared not to put these trickes vpon the people 100. and 200. yeares agoe, in the times of superstition; so haue they presumed euen still in these dayes of light to do the like. And as the whore is shamelesse in her sinne, so is this whore of Babylon in her impietie; for shee hath not at all amended this enormitie, nor in any sort reformed it, but rather lets it growe from bad, to worse. For euidence wherof, let any man read Onuphrius Pauvinius Vide O [...]uphrium Pauuinium, de praecipuis vrbis Romae sanctiorious basilicis quas septem Ecclesias vulgo v [...]cant. Colon. 1584. passim., who not past 24. yeares agoe, hath written (with publike authoritie) a booke to this verie purpose of the seauē principal Churches of Rome, and of the Indulgences belonging to them; wherein all that is deliuered before is auerred, and much more added: some part whereof I would put downe, saue for that it may bee reserued to a further purpose and fitter opportunitie. And for better euidence, that as she hath not, so shee purposeth neuer to heale vp this wound▪ within these two yeares they haue allowed & published with authoritie, the pilgrimage or voiages of Seigneur Villamont, Les voyages du St de Villamont diuisez e [...] trois livres: der [...]iere edition, reueuce & augmentee &c. A. A [...]ra [...]. 16 [...]5. vide (inter alia) librum 1. cap. 12. &c., one of the Gentlemen of the French Kings Chamber; wherein the poore deceiued Gentleman, out of his superstitious deuotion hauing visited all those Churches, and made himselfe (as hee saith) blessed by being partaker of all the Indulgences thereto belonging; and hauing ascended those holy staires to euerie steppe whereof belong so manie thousand yeares of pardon: after all, returning home at last much poorer, but nothing wiser then hee went, hee wrote a booke of his voiage and pilgrimage to Ierusalem: and taking Rome in his way, hee describes at large the Indulgences granted of olde, and at this day in force to the Churches in Rome. Which booke (being [Page 107] written in French) whoeuer list to reade, will soon confesse, that in this wound the Romish Babylon is not yet healed. The eleuēth wound; Granting of Indulgences & thousands of yeares, & deliuerance of Soules out of purgatory, to Beades, Meddalls; Crosses, Pictures and such like toyes being blessed and hallowed by the Popes holy hands.
And herevnto I will adde another wound, because it is so neere to this, in popish consanguinitie.
The wiser sort of Popes, and the rest of the craftier politicians in that hierarchie, perceiuing that all the Nations of the earth, (many of them being so farre distant) could not come to their market of Indulgences being kept in Rome, therefore least they should lose their trafficke into those parts, they deuised away, that seeing a greate part of the worlde could not come to Rome, Rome should send to them: To which ende, out of his bountie and spirituall liberalitie, for the incredible good of mens soules, the Pope ordained that certaine Crucifixes, and Meddalls, and Agnus dei The principall of all these toyes is the Agnus dei, which euerie one may not make, but onely the Pope: nor hee alwayes, but onely at Easter: nor at euerie Easter, but the first next his entrance, and euerie seauenth Easter after: nor of any matter, nor in any manner, but preciselie of such simples, and with such ceremonies as are prescribed for that purpose; which together with the prayers (or rather coniurations) then to bee vsed▪ are to bee seene in the booke called Caeremoniale pontil. lib. 1. And hee that hath not that booke, let him looke in the Cōmentaries of Peter Mathew vpon the Constitutions of Gregorie the 13. Constit. the 1. & holy Graines, & beads & other such Iewels, should be first consecrated and hallowed by the hands of his Holinesse, and haue all the holinesse powred vppon them that hee canne spare, and further should haue annexed vnto them all those mightie Indulgences, or the like, that are graunted vnto the Churches and stations at Rome: and by this meanes they could sell an Agnus dei, that is, a little piece of white waxe, or a Crucifixe of a little metall, [Page 108] it may be brasse or copper (such as the Iesuites of late sent into England by thousandes at once, as good inoughe to serue the English Catholickes), or a little meddall, or a little beade or bugle, or other matter of no more value: these toyes and trinkets, I say they can sell by this meanes, and euerie day do vtter, at a higher rate then the Ieweller can his pearles or his diamonds.
Thus did not onely the former Popes gull the people of elder ages in those times of ignorance, making them beleeue that these toyes so hallowed and blessed by them, were of such vertue as Christs bloud it selfe could be of no more; as one of them sending an Agnis dei to an Emperour, shamed not to write to him, that Vrbanus. 5. circa annum 1368. mific ad Imperatorem Graecorum tres agnos dei. cum his versibus, Balsamus & munda Cera cū Chrismatis vnda, Conficiunt agnum quod munus do tibi magnum, &c. Peccatum frahgit, vt Christi sanguis & angit. Fulgura desursum depellit & omne malignū: Praegnans seruatur simul & partus liberatur: Dona confert dignis; virtutē destruit ignis: Portatus mundè, de fluctibus cripit vndae. vide Petrum Mathaeum, Constitut. Pont. Rom. in Constit. 1. Greg. 13. Pag. 685.
But euen in these times of light and knowledge, these owles dare still flie abroade: and euen of late, nay euerie yeare, the Pope shameth not to sette his trumperies to sale, annexing vnto them such large and liberall Indulgences, as Christes owne bloud can haue no more The eleuenth wound not healed.. I could insist vpon late and notorious examples, practiced euen at home and vpon our owne Nation: but I spare them at this time, because the proofes thereof, tho neuer so certaine to vs, are not so authenticall as yet, as bee these two examples, I shall now produce; one of them touching Poland, the other France.
For Polande: Not many yeares agoe, Pope Clement the eight granted as followeth, as is to bee seene in printed coppies,
Vide libr [...] inscriptum Euangelium Romanum, edit. anno. 1600, Indulgentia concessa a sanctitate nostri S. patris Papae Clementis octaui, Instantia illustrissimi & reuerendissimi Cardinalis Radzivillij, Episcopi Cracouiensis & legati in Polonia, Granis, Crucibus, Medallis & Imagimbus &c. Indulgences graunted by the Holinesse of our most Holy Father, Pope Clement the eight,
At
The Instance of the most Illustrious and most reuerend Lord Cardinall Radz iuillius, Bishop of Cracowe and Legate in Polande,
Vnto
Certaine Holy Beades, Crosses, Medals and Images.
Quicunque habens prope se vnum ex hi [...] granis, Crucibus, Medallis, aut Imaginibus benedictis, [...]otie scunque recitauerit Corollam, confessus, aut cum proposito confitendi saltem semel in mense, acquiret sibi singulis vicibus 5. annos Indulgentiae.. Whosoeuer hauing one of these holy beades &c. shall say ouer the Rosarie, being confessed, or hauing a purpose to confesse once a month, shall for euerie time hee doth so obtaine v. yeares of pardon.
Is cui moris fuerit singulis diebus facere examen suae conscientiae ad finem recitando 3. patres nostros et tres aue Marias orando &c. acquiret sibi 10. annos Indulg.. But if hee doe euerie day after examination of his Conscience, say three Pater nosters and three Aue Maries &c. shal haue x. yeares.
Is cui moris fuerit recitare singulis diebus officium nostrae dominae, singulis diebus sabbathi, acquiret sibi Indulgentiam centum annorum.. But if hee vse euerie day to saie ouer the Psalter of our Ladie, shall for euerie Saturday weekely obtaine a hundred yeares.
[Page 110]Is cui moris fuerit recitare ter in hebdomade: Corollā, & confessus fuerit et communicauerit & precatus fuerit vt supra, acquiret sibi plenariam Indulgentiam.. Hee that shall thrise in a weeke say ouer the Coronet of our Ladie, & confesse and communicate, and pray, shal obtaine a plenarie, that is, a full remission of all sinnes.
Quicunque in articulo mortis, dicet in corde Iesus cum non possit proferreore, acquiret sibi plena [...]iam Indulgentiam: modo habuerit vnam ex Corollis, Granis, Crucibus, aut Medallis supradictis.. And whosoeuer in the houre and point of death shall but say in his heart, when he cannot speak with his tongue, the name Iesus, shall haue a plenarie and full forgiuenesse of all his sinnes: prouided that hee haue one of these blessed and holy Graines, Meddalls, Crucifixes or Pictures.
Hae omnes Indulgentiae acquirantur habendo prope aut ante se vnam Medallam, Crucem, Imagine [...] aut Gra [...]um huiu [...] benedictionis, obseruando quae supra dicta sunt, [...] [...]leant [...]ibus & [...] [...]mni loco. Impressum Romae a Paulo Blado Typographo Camerae. 1592. All these Indulgences may bee procured and obtained, by hauing either about a man, or lying before him one or more of these holy Medalles, Crosses, Graines, or Images, and obseruing what is afore appointed: and his Holinesses wil is, that they shall bee of force to all kinde of men and in euerie place.
Printed at Rome by the printer of his Holinesses priuie Chamber, Paulus Bladus, 1592.
Lo here how Babylon is healed: If a man at the point of death, canne in his minde but thinke of [Page 111] Iesus, he shall haue full forgiuenesse of all his sinnes, if hee haue one of these holy Crosses, or Graines about him. And is this the Diuinitie of the Romish Church? is this procured by a Cardinall and graunted by the Pope? then aunswere mee but one worde: Shall the thinking or naming of Iesus, without true faith and repentance saue him tho hee haue a hundreth of these holy Graines about him? or if hee doe truely repent and beleeue in CHRIST, tho hee haue not one of these, shall hee not bee saued?
If those both bee true, (as who dare denie them?) then phie vpon these Impostors and deceiuers, who by these their Atheisticall mockeries expose religion to all contempt: and these thinges beeing so common and notorious, noe maruell tho Italie, where (these are rifest) haue, beside some priuie protestantes, fewe but that are either Atheistes or fooles.
Concerning France: Of late yeares Peroun the French Cardinall, hauing made a costly Iorney to Rome, comming home, procured of the Pope (for the bearing of his charges) to bee the bearer of certaine hallowed & holy matters consecrated and blessed by the Pope, in such a fashion, as if that were true the Pope saith, he were more then mad that would not (as the wise Merchant) sell all hee hath to buie one of them.
Indulgentiae concessae a nostro S. Patre Papa Clement 8 Corollis Granis Cruciculis, Rosorijs Crucibus Crucifixis Medallis & Imaginibus benedictis, Instante Reuerendo Patre in deo domino Iacobo Danie Episc. Ebrodunensi, Consiliario regio in ipsius Consilijs summa et pietate & ipsius prim [...] Eleemosynario. Grana benedicta sunt tantùm in vsum regni Galliae. Indulgences granted by the Holinesse of our most Holy Father Pope Clement the eight,
Vnto
Holy Beades, Graynes, Rosaries, Crosses, Crucifixes, Medalls and Images, being hallowed and blessed by his owne holy hands,
At the Instance of the Reuerende Father and Lord, James Dauie, Bishoppe of Eureux, Counsellor to the King in his Counsell of Estate, and also of his priuate Counsell and principall Almoner to his Maiestie.
Quicunque habuerit ex Corollis aut Rosarijs vnū aut etiam Corollam vnam in quam insertum sit vnum ex his granis &c. quotiescunque fecerit aliquid opus misericordiae, corporalis aut spiritualis, aut audierit Missam, aut sermonem, aut veneratus fuerit sacramentum aut Cruceia, aut aliam quandam sanctam Imaginem, acquiret sibi veniam centum annorum. Whosoeuer hauing one of these beades &c. shall 1. A hundreth 1. yeares of pardon, at an easie rate. do any worke of mercie corporall or spirituall, or heare a Masse or a Sermon, or shall but doe reuerence to the Sacrament, or to a Crosse, or to a holy Image, shall obtaine a hundreth yeares of pardon.
See what a bountiful father, the Pope is. Who would offer lesse for a hundreth yeares? surely hee that will not do thus much, he is worthy to lye and fry in purgatorie.
Quicun (que) confitebitur aut cōmunicabit, aut si Presbyter sit dixerit missam recitās deuotè praeter confessionum cō munionē aut missam, vnum patrem nostrū aut vnum aue Mariam, aut aliqua alia ratione orans Deum pro sancta Ecclesia Catholica, aut pro nostro sancto Patre, aut pro Rege Galliae, aut pro pace huius Regni, aut pro conuersione Haereticorum, aut pro conuersione peccatorum, acquiret sibi singulis vicibus Indulge [...] tiam plenariā & remissionem omnium peccatorum suorum, Modò super se habeat supradictarum rerum aliquam. Whosoeuer shall confesse and communicate, or being a Priest, shall besides his masse, say deuoutely one Pater noster, or one Aue Mary, for the Catholick Church, or for the holy Father, or for the King of France, or for the peace of France, or for the conuersion of Heretickes, or other sinners: shall haue for euery time hee doth this a plenarie Indulgence, and remission of all his sinnes, so as hee haue about him one of these holy beades graines or Crucifixes.
And what if one want all these trumperies, shall he not haue forgiuenesse, if he do truely beleeue and repent? Oh when will Babylon be ashamed of such abhomination?
Quicun (que) exosculatus fuerit, cum deuotione, &c aliquam eiusmodi medallorum, &c. acquiret sibi singulis vicibus 10. annos Indulgentiae. Whosoeuer shall kisse one of these beades &c. with deuotion, shal haue for euery time he doth so, tenne yeares of pardon.
Habens super se vnam ex supradictis rebus orans pro conseruatione, &c. aut pro Rege Galliae, &c. particeps erit singulis diebus &c. omnium sacrificiorum, Ieiuniorum, precum & aliorum operum quae fiunt in coenobijs, ac si esset membrum particulare eorum. Whosoeuer hath one of them about him, and praieth for the success of the Catholick Romish religion, or for the K. of France, shall be (so oft as he doth so) partaker of all the Sacrifices, Prayers, and Fasts and other good workes done in anie Abbie, as well as if hee were a particular member of the same societie.
Habens super se vnam ex supradictis rebus in periculo mortis in bello aut alio in loco, vbi non fuerit illi commodum, recitans, cum contritione, Domine Iesu suscipe spiritum meum &c. aut proferens sanctum nomē Iesu, acquiret sibi Indulgentiam plenariam, & remissionem omnium suorum peccatorum, tam culpae quam poenae, &c. Hee that hath one of these about him, if hee be in danger of death, or in the battell, or in any place where he cannot go to confession, & shal with contrition but repeate these words, Lord Iesus receiue my spirit, or name the holy name Iesus, shal haue forgiuenesse of all his sinnes, and be discharged both a à poena & à cu [...]pa.
Sua sanctitas concedit vt valeant pro omnibus & in omni loco (exceptis granis) ea conditione, vt qui non sint Galli precentur pro Rege & Regno Galliae &c. Impressum Romae cum permissione superiorum, &c. His Holinesse graunts that these Indulgences shall be good for all men, and in all places; but conditionally, that those that be not French-men, shall praie for the King and Realme of France: Except alwaies the holy Graynes; for those are limited to belong onely to France, and to bee good to none but onely French men.
Imprinted at Rome with licence, &c.
I haue named some, but not all; looke for the rest in the book: but in them all let it be obserued, that there is not the least mention of faith in Christ, nor once so much as the name of it, nor anie relation to Christ, nor his holy merits: No, these are well if they may be vnderstood; and yet these men (if they bee not Atheists) doe knowe that all these their large promises are but winde, and their Indulgences but fome and froth, if there be not liuely faith and true repentance: and if these be in a man, then let vs see that Pope, Cardinall, or other Papist, who dare say that hee shall not haue ful remission that neuer sawe nor touched one of thei [Page 115] blessed beades nor hallowed Graines. Thus wee see how farre Babylon is from beeing healed in this point.
The twelfth and last wound, concerning the first Table, shal be cōcerning the Sacraments: both which are horribly peruerted and profaned by Romish doctrine and practice. The 12. wound; The Popish Church baptizeth Belles.
First, Baptisme is profanely applied, not to reasonable creatures onlie, men and women, according to the Institution Mat. 28. 19; but euen to vnreasonable & dead creatures. I will insist onely vpon one: they vse to baptize bels, in most points so as Christians do Children, & in som points with much more ceremony & solemnity.
Bellarm [...]n is ashamed of it, and would willingly hide and couer it, tho he cannot cure it: but if hee were not a Cardinall and a Iesuite, hee would bee ashamed to cloake it with so loude a lie, as he doth: for (saith he) Bellar. de Rō Pont. Tom. 1. lib. 4. cap. 12. Si rem reprehēdunt, apertè decipiuntur aut mētiūtur: non enim cā panae reuera baptizantur, sed solum benedicūtur, &c. vt altaria, &c. Vt patet ex pō tificali, &c. it is a false slander of the Heretickes; wee do not baptize bels, neither in respect of the name, nor ye matter of baptism: look saith he the book of the Pontificale there is no such matter: only (saith he) we blesse them as we do Churches, Altars Crosses, and other things, &c.
Is it true? then let vs follow Bellarmines aduise, and looke into the Pontificale, and omitting the name or word, let vs stand vpon the matter of Baptism. Compare therefore their baptisme of a child and a Bell together, and see then whether it may not be truly sayde they baptize Bells. Vide librum inscriptū Pontificale Romanū autoritate pontificia impressum Venetijs 1520. [...]ib. 2 cap. de Benedictione signi vel campanae. Cāpana debet benedici antequā ponatur in campanili: parāda sint ide o vas aquae b [...] nedicendae, aspersoriū, vas cum sale, lintea munda, oleum sanctum, sanctum Chrisma, thimyama, thus, myrrha, thuribulū cum igne: Pontifex & diaconus &c. sint in tuis vestimētis: precibus peractis Pontifex lauat campanam cum dicta aqua, & cum pollice dexterae manus facit crucē supra campanā ab extra, cum oleo infirmorū, & intus cum chrismate, & profert interim haec verba; Sāctificetur & cōsecretur (Domine) signū istud in nomine Pa†tris & Fi†lij & spiritus † sancti. In honorē sancti talis Pax tibi &c.
1. The Childe must first bee baptized, before it can be accounted one of the Church. | The Bell must first be blessed, afore it may be hung in the steeple. |
2. The Childe must bee baptized by a Minister, or a Priest. | The Bel must, by a Bishop; or his deputie. |
3. For a Childes baptisme must be vsed holy-water, cream, salt, oyle spettle, and manie such. | The Bells baptism or blessing must also bee in holy-water, oyle, salt, cream, tapers for light, &c. |
4. They giue the Childe a name. | Soe doe they to the Bell. |
5. The Child must haue Godfathers, &c. | So must the Bell; and they bee persons of great note. |
6. The Childe must be washt in water. | So must the Bell; and that by none but the Bishop & Priests. |
7. The Child must be crossed. | So must the Bell. |
8. The Child must be anointed. | So must the Bell. |
[Page 117]9. The Childe must bee baptized, in the name of the Trinitie. | So the Bell is washt and anointed in the name of the Trinitie. |
10. They praie for the Childe. | Soe doo they for the Bell. |
11. At the Childes baptisme the Scripture is read: | So at the washing of the Bell, more Psalmes are read, then at a Childes baptisme, also a Gospell: and more prayers are made▪ and (excepting saluation) greater things are prayed for, and more blessings on the bel, then be for a childe. |
12. And publick praiers made |
For better euidence heereof, and because the booke is not easie to come by, take heere a part of the prayers they vse to that purpose.
Pontifical. ibid. Benedic Domine hanc aquam benedictione coelesti, & assistat super eam virtus spiritus sancti, vt cum hoc vasculum &c. in ca fuerit tinctum, vbicun (que) sonuerit hoc tintinnabulum procul recedat virtus insidiantium, vmbra phantasmatum, incursio turbinum, percussio fulminum, laesio tonitruorum, calamitas tempestatum &c. & cùm clangorem illius audierint filij Christianorum, crescat in eis deuotionis augmentum, &c. et postea Presta quaesumus vt hoc vasculum sanctificetur à spiritu sancto &c. vt cùm melodia illius auribus insonuerit populorum, crescat in eis deuotio fidei, procul pellantur omnes infidiae Inimici, fragor grandinum, &c. aereae potestates hoc tintinnabulum audientes contremiscant. Lord grant that wheresoeuer this holy Bell thus (baptized, or) washed and blessed shal sound, al deceits of Sathan, all phantasies, all danger of whirlwindes, thunders, lightnings, and tempests, may be driuen awaie, and that deuotion may increase in Christiāmen when they heare it: O Lord sanctifie it by thy holy Spirit, that when it sounds in thy peoples eares, their faith and deuotion may increase, [Page 118] the diuell may bee affrayed, and tremble et postca, Omnipotens Deus, qui, &c. tu hoc tiatinabulū coe esti benedictione perfunde, vt ante sonitū eius longius effugentur ignita iacula diaboli, percussio fulminum, &c. & quicū (que) ad sonitum eius conuenerint ab omnibus Inimici tentationibus liberi sint, &c. & paulo post, Omnipotens Christe, qui &c. tu hoc tintinnabulum sancti spiritus rore perfunde, vtante sonitū eius semper fugiat bonorū inimicꝰ, &c. and flie awaie at the sound of it. O Lord poure vpon it thy heauenly blessing, that the fierie darts of the Diuell, may be made to flie backward at the sound thereof, and that it may deliuer from danger of wind, thunder, &c. And grant Lord that all that come to the Church at the sound of it, may be free from all temptations of the Diuell. O Lord infuse into it the heauenly dewe of the holy Ghost that the diuel may alwaies flie awaie before the sounde of it, &c.
Thus at Bellarmines request we haue lookt into the Popes Pontificale, and let the Reader iudge what we haue found: he rebukes vs for laying it to their charge that they baptize bells, and for proof that they do not, sends vs to the Pontificale; but surely he thought that we could not haue seene the book, els he would neuer haue referred vs therunto: for vpon sight therof, it is apparant to be a more solemne baptisme then that of the child is; for the solemnitie is longer, the Ceremonies more, the prayers to greater purpose, the minister of greater place, then be required to a childs baptism; & euery thing doth so concur in it that is in baptism, that Bellarmin himself cōfesseth that tho the pope doth not, yet others generally do call it the baptizing of belles, because they see them sprinkled with water, and haue names giuen them Bellar. tom. 1. de Rom. pōt. lib. 4. cap. 12. Nomen Baptismi non a Pontificibus sed avulgo campanarum benedictioni accommodatur &c. quia vidēt eas aqua aspergiet eis nomina imponi, &c..
But it is not the name we stand vpon, but the matter: concerning which, whereas they pray that the sound of that bel so washed and sanctified as afore may driue [Page 119] awaie the diuell and all his fierie dartes, I would aske Bellarmine, or anie of his Chaplains, whether this be spoken in iest or in earnest, in formalitie as words of course, or in faith as a holy prayer. If they knowe the prayer to be impossible, not to haue anie warrant, but meerelie to bee a state Ceremonie, and done to amaze the poore people &c. then it appeares they bee Cozeners and Atheists that make Religion a pretence to all their purposes: But if it be in earnest, and they knowe it to bee a prayer of faith, and haue warrant from Gods word for it, then it were possible to driue awaie the diuell and all his temptations out of a kingdome: for so manie Belles might bee hallowed and washed, as might hang, one within the reach of anothers sound; and so if the wordes of this prayer be true, a Diuell might not stay in the realme: and that Realme were very worthie to haue the Diuells companie, that would not willinglie be at the cost to haue so manie bels though they were of siluer, and to haue them baptized though it were in costly water.
To conclude, Bellarmine pleaseth to sport himselfe a little with vs and sayth; The Heretickes obiect to vs that wee baptize Belles; but its maruell (sayth hee) that they doe not also say, wee catechize and instruct them, that so they may sound out the Articles of Fayth Obijciunt nobis haeretici quod baptizamus Campanas. Mirum vero est quod non etiam dicunt campanas a nobis antea catechizari et instrui, vt possint fidei symbolum resonare. Bellar. ibid. 24. 4: But it is verie likelie the Iesuite had not seene or not well perused the Pontificale: for if he had, hee might haue found that they pray to GOD to giue the HOLIE GHOST to the Bell, to blesse it, to sanctifie it, to puri [...]e it, to poure heauenlie blessings vppon it, and the dewe of Gods grace. Certainelie if this bee a [Page 120] lawfull an apt and fit prayer for the bell, they may also catechise it: for it is doubtless as capable of instructiō from man, as of anie spirituall and heauenly blessing from God.
Thus it is proued, I hope, that the Romish Church (in some sort for the name, but especially for the matter) doth baptize Bells.
It remains but to see The twelfth wound not healed; for the Romish Church still baptizeth belles. if this wound be healed, or no.
But I answere, this was not the superstition of the olde and ignorant times onely, but is euen the present impietie of that Church: for, of late, Clement the eight, pretending to haue the Pontificall reuiued and reformed, caused it to be printed at Rome before his face Vide Pontificale Romanum Clementis 8. Pont. Max. iussu resti tutum at (que) editum Romae 1895. et legatur eiusdem Clementis Constitutio. ibid. praefixa, pro eiusdem libri autoritate & approbatione. by his authoritie, in a faire letter, and with most goodly pictures: and indeede many things are left that might make against the Pope, and many added that may make for him.
But as for this blasphemie and abuse of Gods holy Sacrament, it stands vntouched, vnaltered, and allowed for a good and Catholicke practice in euerie particular as I haue afore set it downe, and in manie more: Oh BABYLON, BABYLON, when wilt thou be healed?
The other sore of this wounde is touching the Lords Supper The other sore of the 12. wound; That though Christ ordained the contrary; yet it is not necessary for Christiās of the Laitie to haue the sacrament in both kinds, but onely the bread & not the Cup. which they maime and mangle, sacrilegiously taking the Cuppe from the whole Laitie. This wound is not very deepe, for it is not olde: but it is wide, for it is generall: and it is a foule one; for it maymeth the Sacrament, and crosseth Christ [...] owne Institution. They were a hatching it sometime before, but at last the monster was brought foorth [Page 121] in the Councell of Constance when they decreed thus, Concil. Cō stant. sess. 13. Synodus declarat decernit & definit, quod licet Christꝰ instituerit et suis discipulis administrauerit sub vtra (que) specie panis et vini; et similiter quod licet in primitiua ecclesia hoc sacramentum reciperetur a fidelibus sub vtra (que) specie: tamen haec consuetudo est rationabiliter introducta, quod a conficientibus sub vtra (que), à laicis tantummodo sub specie panis suscipiatur. Et habenda est pro lege haec consuetudo, &c. et pertinaciter asserentes oppositum tanquā haeretici arcendi et puniendi sunt: et quod nullus Presbiter sub poena excomunicationis cōmunicet populum sub vtra (que) specie panis et vini, &c.
That notwithstāding Christ or dained the Sacramēt in both kinds, and tho the eldest Church did so receiue it, yet for al that, this custom is lawfully and laudably brought into the Church, that the laitie shal receiue but in one kinde onely; and that whosoeuer shall holde the contrary, shall be proceeded against as heretickes: and all Priests are commanded vnder paine of excommunication, that they giue not the Cuppe to the laitie: and they that do and recant not shall be punished as heretickes.
This wound hath Bellarmine, and other of the craftier sort of them sought to couer, but not to cure: and it would satisfie a man in this point tho he wauered before, to see how slily & superficially he deals in this questiō Bellar. de sacram. Euchar. lib. 4. cap. 26. tom. 3.: This abuse is so horrible, the iniury to the sacrament, & the wrong to the laitie so notorious, the absurdity & impiety of the practice so without all colour of defence, that if they were not without grace and past hope of recouery, & such as haue resolued to amend nothing, they would haue reformed this long agoe.
But heerby it is apparant they are plain States-men & Politicians, who haue nothing els in their head, but to maintaine the height of their hierarchie, and Maiestie of their Monarchy. Euen this one particular is sufficient to make demōstration hereof; seeing they will [Page 122] not amend that which they see and know to be contrary to Christs Institution; and wherof many of the better sort of themselues are vtterly ashamed.
But it is so farre from being healed at all, that it is rather worse and worse The latter sore of the 12. wound not yet healed, but spreades further.. Look in their newe edition of the Councells this last yeare, and there is no reformation of this euill Vide postre [...]am edit. Cō cil. per Bininum. Colon. 1606. Concil. Constant. sess. 13. in. 2. parte tomi tertij. p. 1589., no plaister laid vpon this sore, not so much as a marginall note to qualifie the Non-obstante to Christs Institution; but rather all is made worse then it was afore in the former and elder impressions.
Nay, it is so farre from being healed, that contrariwise, it is made daily a wider and deeper wound: For now it is made in that Church a sinne against the first Commandement of the morall lawe, for a man to receiue the Sacrament in both kindes Vide librū inscriptū Excercitium pietatis, in gratiā studiosorum, autoritate Cardinalis Radzivilij, scriptum & editum. Colon. 92. In cap. de methodo rectè confitendi, Circa primū praeceptum inquiratur an fecerit aliquē exteriorē actum infidelitatis vel haeresis &c. vt sub vtraque specie communicā do, &c.. So then seeing we knowe Christ appointed it in both kindes, and now the Romish Church prohibites it vnder paine of mortall sin; alas what hope is there that this Church will euer be reformed, that condemnes the obedience to Christs institution and commandement, as a deadly sinne?
Let vs now proceede to such wounds, as may bee more properly referred to the secōd Table of the morall lawe.
Touching wilfull murder, it hath beene their doctrine and practice since the mistie times of ignorance, that The 13. wound; That it is lawefull to haue sanctuaries forwillfull murder. Churches and Churchyards, and Bishops houses, and some such other places bee sanctuaries, that is, places for refuge for the offender; vnto which if he do flie, and settle him [...]elfe, he cannot, nor may not bee prosecuted by course of lawe and iustice, but is there [Page 123] safe, as long as it pleaseth the Cleargie to retayne him.
Thus writeth Pope Innocent the 3. in his Decretalles to the King of Scotland, who in those euill daies (poore man) helde himselfe not of power to punish malefactors of his owne kingdome that had taken sanctuarie, vntill hee had sent to the Pope for his aduise.
Corp. Iuri [...] Can [...]nici Decretal. li. 3. tit. 49. cap. 6. Si fugiens ad ecclesiā liber sit quantumcun (que) grauia maleficia perpetrauerit, non est violenter ab ecclesia extrahendus, nec inde damnari debet ad mortē, vel ad poenā; sed rectores ecclesiarū sibi obtinere debent membra & vitam, &c. To your question, Sir (sayth the Pope) I answer thus; If hee that hath taken sanctuarie be a freeman, then is he not to be taken violently out of the Church, not tho he haue committed neuer so grieuous crimes, neither may he be condemned thereupon either to death or other punishment; but the Clergie, and gouernors of that Church are to obtain for him libertie and safetie of life and limme &c.
Some may here obiect that afterward in the decretall hee makes exception of some crimes: true, of night robbers, but not of murderers. Neither was this proper to Italie or to Scotland, but the generall sore of all nations. In England wee had manie, but especially 3. most famous sanctuaries:
One at Beuerley, in Yorke-shire, erected by K. Athelstane, where in the Church was set a chaire of stone, and this inscription written ouer it;
This stone chaire is called Freedstoole, that is the chaire Vide Britā niā Camdeni in Com. Eborū. Haec sedes lapidea dicitur Freedstool id est p [...]cis cathedra, ad quam reus [...]ugiendo perueni [...]ns omnimodam habe [...] securitatem. of peace, whereunto if one that is guiltie do fly and sit in it, he shall haue all sufficient securitie.
Another at Battel Abbie in Sussex, where the Conquerer wonne the victorie, and in memorie thereof, [Page 124] building that Abby hee endowed it (with the popes consent) amongst others, with this priuiledge Vide eundem Camdenū, in com. Sussex haec sunt verba diplomatis; Si quis latro vel homicida, vel aliquo crimine reus, timore mortis fugiens ad hanc ecclesiam peruenerit, in nullo laedatur, sed liber omnino dimittatur: Abbati vero ipsius Ecclesiae liceat vbi (que) latronem vel furem de suspendio liberare [...]i forte superuenerit.;
These bee the very words of the Charter it selfe. The third and not the least was at Westminster: wherof there is often and famous mention in our Chronicles, as being a place of frequent and ordinarie refuge for great Malefactors, and the name remains there to this daie. And these were not so much the facts of ignorant and superstitious Kings, as the generall receiued doctrine of the Romish teachers, & the publick deed of their Popes themselues Vide decretal, Sext. & Clement: in tit. de ecclesiarum & coemeteriorū immunitatibus, &c..
This was so in the olde time (will some say) but now it is otherwise. I answere: Nay, this is not healed, but rather is much worse. To this end, let vs consider a little of some of their latest and principall writers in this case The 13. woūd not healed; for Poperie alloweth sanctuaries for wilfull murder still.. A great Clarke of Rome, a fauourite of Pope Gregories the xiiii. and one of his principall Secretaries, some 12. yeares agoe writes a great volume of this and other Immunities, which hee saith by their religion belongs to holy persons and places; let vs obserue a fewe of his words Vide Anastasium Germoniū de sacrorū immunitatibus. lib. 3: cap. 16. art. [...]. &c..
Not Clergie men onely, but euen the very Churches Habent et ecclesiarū aedificia, suas immu nitates. Nā qui ad eas cōfugiunt, quodammodo sacrosancti effecti, nequeūt inde extrahi, nec in vincula cō ijci vltimóue supplicio affici, aut aliqua membrorum detrūcatione plecti, sed veluti in arce tutissima positi ab inquirentibus inuiolati remanent. themselues haue their priuiledge: for Malefactours flying to them, are in a sort made holy thereby, insomuch as they may not bee taken awaie thence, nor bee cast into prison, nor be toucht in life, nor limme, but shall there be safe from all pursuers, as in a Castle or most strong holde, &c.
And not onely puts he downe this for Catholicke doctrine, but he will also needs haue it to bee ex iure diuino: and whereas Couarruvias (as learned as himself at least) disproues it verie sufficiently Didac. Couarruvias. variarum resolut. lib. 2. cap. 20. Num. 2. v. 2. & 3. and concludes it to bee but de iure positivo, this darling of the Popes will not suffer so much amendment as this, but condemnes Couarruvias, tho hee cannot confute his reasons, and concludes it to bee de iure diuino. Idem Germoniꝰ ibid. art. 7..
And wheras one Iohannes Ferrariensis, a famous and learned Lawyer, argueth foundly and truely that Churches should not receiue murtherers not be sanctuaries for theeues, seeing Christ cast out euen buyers and sellers which are not so ill Ioh. Pet. de Ferrar. practica Papiensis, cap. de forma inquisi. vers. ex his potest.; The Popes Secretarie, scornfully casteth away both his opinion and his reason Germoniꝰ ibid. art. 15.; yet is he neuer able to ouerthrowe either the truth of his opinion, or strength of his reason: but so vnwilling are they to bee healed in anie thing, that if anie one of them doe but begin to see the truth, and doe but glaunce at it or incline to it, presently hee is nipt in the head and condemned, as heere the olde Lawyer is reproued by the later; and whē as he would haue had this wound healed, this darling of the popes will not suffer him, but answeres that his reason is naught and not worth a rush.
And yet not content, he goeth further, and saith; that not onely Churches consecrated, but tho they bee not as yet consecrated Idē ibid. art. 23. 24., yet they be sanctuaries: and not the Church onely, but euen the Churchyard, yea tho it be disioined from the Church Idē ibid. art. 30. & 34..
Nay further, that euen hospitalls Idē ibid. art. 27, yea priuate Chappells in mens houses, if they were built by the Bishops authority Idē ibid. art. 29., haue priuiledge of sanctuarie to receiue a murderer flying vnto them. And least murder should not finde sufficient shelter in Romish religion, he telles vs further, that euen the Bishops Palace is a sanctuarie, if a murderer fly vnto it, if it bee within 40. pases of the Church; or (tho it bee more then 40. pases off) if it haue a Chappell in it Idē ibid. art. 43. &c.. And yet further, if a murtherer going to execution, after a iust sentence, or afore triall, being pursued, doe meete a Priest carying his breaden God, and doe fly to him, he is priuiledged from the power of the lawe Idē ibid. art. 52..
And least we should thinke it strange, to giue this honor to the church that is Gods house, or to the bread which they say is their God, he goeth yet one steppe further, and tells vs that Idem Germonius ibid. lib. 3. cap. 6. art. 51. &c. Tāta est huius dignitatis Maiestas, vt non Cardinalis solum velut sacrosanctus abs (que) sacrilegij culpa tāgi non possit, verū nec ille quiad capitale supplicium ducitur, si Cardinali ob [...]iam factus cius (que) pileum aut vestem attigerit &c. occidi nequeat: sic Baldus & reliqui; vnus tantum Cor [...]etus tenet i [...] contrarium: sedeius argumentis excellenter satisfacit Cardinalis▪ Albanus.,
Loe, heere is a holy person indeede; a Cardinalls coate, or hat, shall haue more priuiledge then had eyther the coate or the flesh it selfe of Christ Iesus: hee [Page 127] would not deliuer anie murderers from death, onelie one he deliuered; namely, Barrabas, and he himselfe died in his roome See the story of the passion.: and if my Lords the Cardinalls should do so, surely they would meete no murderers in the streete.
But to goe forward; the lawe sayth, the Murderer shall die Gen. 9. 6; and Christ saith, he came not to dissolue the lawe, but to fulfill it Matth. 5. 18: but the Cardinalls wil not fulfil the lawe, but dissolue it. The Murderer shall die, sayth God: true, saith the Pope, vnlesse hee happe to touch the hem of one of my Cardinalls coats, for then he is acquitted.
But is this healed and reformed? nay alas, one Antonius Corsetus, a learned Lawyer, misliking this, because as he saith truely Hoc stante, daretur materia delinquē di, propterea quod homines audaciores fierēt & delicta remanerent impunita: sic Anto. Corsetꝰ in suis singular. in verbo Cardinalis.; this being so, there wil be an occasion giuen of much euill, and bloudie men will heereby take libertie to offend: He is not suffred to make anie motion for reforming of anie thing, but is contrariwise turned awaie with this censure, that his reasons are slender and nothing worth. And thus, when he is dasht out of countenance, who would haue healed this wound, then comes the Popes Secretary (a true childe of Babylon that will not be healed) and to make the wound wider and deeper, brings a reason for this power of Cardinalls, worthy of himself Idem Germonius ibid. cap. 6. art. 51. Non sunt hodie Cardinales deterioris cōditionis quam olim fuerunt Virgines vestales: quarum autoritas apud Romanos tanta fuit. vt si ad capitale aliquis supplicium duceretur, & fortè fortuna transisset Vestalis, is necari non posset.; ‘If (saith he) the Virgin-vestalls in Rome healthenish had this power, that if a person condemned met one of them in his way to executiō, and could get to touch them, he was thereby deliuered from death; [Page 128] as he proueth out of Aul. Gellius Aul. Gellius, noct. Att. lib. 10. cap. 15.: Then much more ought the Cardinalls to haue this honour in Rome being now Christian.’
Yea, but is there not danger to multiplie murders, and defeat the lawe by this means? for may not a Cardinall come for fauour, and on set purpose? may hee not be intreated, may he not be corrupt and bee hired to come? There be now also many Cardinalls, about 60. or 70. if anie of all these be in the streetes, murderers may escape; and there be fewe daies, wherin some of these stirre not abroad: To all these materiall obiections, what doth he answer? surelie an easie answer hath he for all:
But how shall it appeare, that hee comes not purposely? In that case the vestall Virgins, that neuer might swear, were put to their oath Aul. Gellius ibid..
But for al that (saith this Popes dearling) my Lords the Cardinalls may not sweare, they may not bee so disgraced as to be put to their oathes: How shall it then appeare? hee must (saith hee Licet Vestalis nunquam iurasset, hoc tamen casu eas iurasse, certum est. At Cardinalem deuinci Iusiurandi religione minime vel lem: ita (que) non iuranti sed asserēti se forte fortuna in dā natū incidisse credendum est, cum ei in grauioribus negotijs fides adhiberi solet: vt si sedis Apostolicae legatum se esse dixerit, fidem ei habendam volunt nostri Ioh. Andr. Bal. Alb. &c. Idem Germonius ibid. art. 53. &c. bee beleeued vpon his bare word. So then if a Cardinall haue but the conscience to tell a lie (which, how small a thing it is in poperie, and how manie excuses it hath, who knoweth not?) then it is heere apparant that the vilest theefe, and murderer in a countrie, may easily escape the halter at Rome.
Now to conclude, see how many helpes there be for a Murderer in Romish religion; first by places, then by persons priuiledged. Places priuiledged be, 1. a Church, 2. a Churchyard, 3. an hospitall, 4. a Bishops house, 5. a priuate Chappell; all these shall deliuer a man from tryall (were this so in London, how should any murderer be brought to the Bar? no street could he passe through, but he shall finde one of these 5. places): then by persons priuiledged; which be, first, a Cardinall riding by: which because it is but in fewe places; therefore the second is a Priest carying the Sacrament, and that is in euery towne: To touch either of these, doth deliuer from death a murtherer cō demned by law.
Thus we see, a bloudy Church is a defender of bloud and murther; for let anie wise man consider, how many thousand murders in a yeere, may bee sheltred and shuffled ouer by these meanes. And yet sanctuaries are but one means to cloak murther, they haue many more (not so fit to be stood vpon at this time): but the end and effect of them all is this, that poisoning, stabbing, killing, and all kind of bloud-shedding is so rise in popish States, that the better sort of themselues do bitterlie complaine of it. Oleaster a spanish Inquisitor (and therefore not partiall on our side) hath these words; ‘Vide Hieronimum ab Oleastro, inquisitorem vlissiponens. in suis Cōment. in Pentat: In cap. 4. Genes. pag. 17. Video (in quit) homicidia fieri, netamen video homicidas puniri: sunt enim hodie mille modi excusandi homicidam; quorū vnuꝰ est ecclesiā appellare, Clericum se dicere, & statim Iudices quos volunt a summo pōtifice impetrate, qui eos absoluunt, parua aut nulla poena imposita; & sic homicidia multi plicantur. I see daily (sayth he) murders are committed: but I doe not see the murderers are punished: for we haue at this daie a thousand waies to excuse murderers; wherof one is to appeale to the Church, & to say he is a Cleargie man, and presently to get frō the Pope such Iudges or Commissioners, as themselues [Page 130] will, who by and by discharge and absolue them, vpon a little punishment or none at all, and thus murders are multiplied euerie daie, &c.’
Let these words be well obserued, and what he was that spake them; and if this be so, so fa [...]re from Rome as Portingale is, thē we may easily iudge how the world goeth at Rome and neere vnto it.
Against all this what can be said? that this Anastasius is an Author suborned by vs? Nay, Posseuine the Iesuite will for that answer for vs, hauing canonized him in his catalogue of catholick Doctors Possev. Ies. appar. sac. tom. 1. lit. A. Anastasius Germoniꝰ Archidiaconꝰ Taurinensis edidit libros de immunitatibus ecclesiasticis, inter al. &c.: what then? that he is but a triuiall fellow, and of no credit nor authority? Nor so: for he was publicke professor of the Popes lawe, at Turin, & in great office and authority both with Gregory the 14. and Clement the 8. Idem Posseu. ibid. Augustae Taurinorum publicè Canones interpretabatur & nuper orator ad Clement 8. pro sereniss. vrbini duce & vtrius (que) Romanae signaturae referendarius. and his bookes be dedicated to the Popes and Cardinalls, printed at Rome with soueraigne authoritie, and speciall commendation (u). Nay the Pope himselfe withAnastasij Germonij, Ciuit. Ro. Archidiaconi Taurinēsis & protonotarij Apostolici de sacrorū immutatibus lib. 3. ad Gregorium 14. Romae. 1591. his own mouth commended the book, to the Cardinals, and said that the whole Clergie, and the Councel of Cardinalls by name were greatly beholden to the Author for it Vide eiusdem Anastasij Epistolam dedicat. ad Gregorium 14. Pont. Max.: So that it is more then impudencie for anie Papist, to make question of the authoritie of his doctrine.
What then can be said? that these sanctuaries stand indeed allowed for some faultes, but not for murder? If it were so, the fault were lesse: but the truth is otherwise.
For tho it be certaine and confessed by themselues, that by the ciuile lawe, Murderers, and Rauishers, and Adulterers are excepted In §. Quod si delinquentes Authent. de mand princip.: Yet Germonius shameth not to answere that the Ciuile lawe is corrected in this [Page 131] point by the Popes law, and that therfore we are to stand to it Iure Ciuili, adulteri, homicidae, raptores ex eccl. abduci possunt: sed Ius Ciuile per pontificiū hac in parte correctū est; & ideo standū est huiꝰ dispositioni &c. sic Germoniꝰ de sacrorum immunitatibus, lib. 3. cap. 16. art. 57, &c. and not to the Ciuile lawe: Now who are excepted by the popes lawe? only night-robbers, and setters of high waies Germonius ibid. art. 56. ex Iure Canonico & communi sententia.: but as for murderers, adulterers, and rauishers, these finde fauor in the Popes lawe; for they be Amici Curiae: but theeues, and robbers are not so: and therfore this Germonius cōcludes that tho the Scripture be plain and many Doctors; yet, a murderer is not to bee taken out of sanctuarie, vnlesse there bee more then murder, as deceit, and treacherie. What then may be said? that this Germonius is but one Doctor, and his opinion is not to be taken for a doctrine? I answere, his iudgement is allowed by the Pope himselfe, and his opinions are fortified with consent of other popish Doctors: But that we may see he walkes not alone in this waie; one Stephanus Durantus, writing also of late, of the rites of the Romish Church, deliuereth y• same for a general doctrin of that church, tho he being a French-man, is therfore the bolder and saith that neither in France nor in England they haue beene permitted by the kings with such absolute allowance as elswhere. Stephanus Durantꝰ de ritibꝰ ecclesiae catholicae Romae 91. ad G [...] gor. 14. vid. 1. ca. 26. art. 10. Ea erat ecclesiae religio & immunitas, vt ad eam confugientes non liceret inde extrahere, vel eis aliquam vim inferre.
This book also is of speciall authoritie, dedicated to P. Gregorie the 14. and by him accepted with speciall allowance: and in a Bull or constitution of his, hee affirmeth it is a worke, seruing greatly for Gods glorie and the edification of Christian people, and that it is approued and allowed by the great M. of his palace Vide bullam Gregorij 14, Duranti libro praefixā: hoc opꝰ &c. ad gloriā Dei & totius populi Christiani aedificationé, &c. & à Magistro sacri palatij nostri visum & approbatum., [Page 132] to whom belonges the soueraigne and highest authoritie to censure all sort of bookes.
And last of all, Iacobus de Graffijs, the great Casuist, and Grande Poenitentiarie, within these 7. yeares hath determined this question; affirming that the murderer may not be taken out of the Church, no not tho hee broke prison and fled thither, vnlesse it were murder ioyned with trecherie and treason Iacobus de Graffijs decis. aur. cas. cons. to. 1. cap. 48. libri secundi: art. 5. 6. 7. reus in causa ciuili & criminali gaudet immunitate ecclesiae etiamsi carcerem cōfregerit, & ad ecclesiam confugerit: Et non ex [...]pitur homi [...]idium nisi proditione cōmissum aut ab Assasinis..
Thus we see how Babylon is healed in this wound. And heereby it is apparant to all that will see, that she is a bloudie Babylon: and as in many other respects for her crueltie, so this waie also, for this doctrine and practice she is a bloudy synagogue: and no maruell tho the holy Ghost say, that in her is found the bloud, not onely of the Saints and Martyrs, but of all that was shed vpon the earth Reuel. 18. 24.. For as she hath made her selfe the principall agent in shedding the bloud of Saints and Martyrs: so hath shee made her selfe accessarie by this her doctrine and practice to al the murthers & bloudshed vpon the earth: for, to maintaine so many refuges and defences for a sinne, is to maintaine the sinne it selfe. Therefore leauing this bloudie Church weltring, and wallowing, and bathing her selfe in bloud, let vs proceed to that remaines.
Touching the honorable estate of marriage, and the dishonor of it, which is, adulterie, & fornicatiō; it is lamentable to see what is the doctrine and practice of the Romish Church. For first, they giue a publicke and open toleration of the stewes, wherein whoredome is practiced as dayly and commonly, as other ciuile and lawfull actions The 14. wound; Romish Religion permits stewes publickelie.: nay their rent is taken, and duely paide, (a part of it) to the Pope, or as hee [Page 133] shall appoint it: Thus complaines and cries out Agrippa, a man of no meane place, nor ordinarie vnderstanding; Cornel. Agrippa de vanitate scient. cap. 64. Corinthij, Cyprij, Babylonij alij (que) Ethnici Graeci, nonnihil a meretricio quaestu aerario suo addiderut, quod quidem in Italia non rarū, vbi etiā Romana scorta, in singulis hebdomadis Iulium pendēt pontifici: qui census annuus saepe excedit viginti millia ducatus.
The Corinthians (sayth he) and Cyprians, and Babylonians, and other heathen Graecians did increase their reuenue, by the gaine of the stewes, which in Italy also is at this daie no rare nor vnusuall matter. For the whores of Rome doe paie weekely to the pope a Iulio a piece (about six pence sterling) the whole reuenue whereof in the yeare, doth often exceede the sum of twentie thousand Duckets, &c.
Alas! wil some say; the Pope cannot hinder this: therefore seeing he cannot helpe it, he hath vsed, (such was the wisdom of elder ages) to make the best vse he can of an ill matter.
But I answere; first, the holy Ghost commands vs to haue nothing to doe with an ill matter, but keepe vs farre from it Exod. 23. 7 Ephes. 5. 11, though wee cannot hinder it: Againe, if the Pope cannot hinder it, yet hee can refuse to haue anie gayne from it; and so hee woulde but that hee thinkes it sweete: but if hee were of Dauids mind who would not drinke that drink, that cost men the venture of their liues 2. Sam. 23. 14., surely he would not take that gain that costs men and women their soules.
But I answere further, he could and might hinder it, and will not. If he himselfe and his fauorites speak truth, hee wants no power for nothing that hee will doe: therefore for reforming the stewes, it is cleere he wants wil, but no power. Against Gods truth, and vs the Professors of it, whom he cals hereticks, he wants no will, and therefore he wants no power. Let him punish whoredome, as he doth that, that he calls heresie [Page 134] (tho it be the truth): let it be as vnlawfull in Rome to keep a stewes, as to haue a Protestant Church, and then we should soon see as fewe, and fewer whores in Rome, then there be good Protestants. But whoredom is none of the vnderminers of his State, nor enemies of his Crowne as our religion is: therefore our religion must down when stewes must stand. But som wil further obiect, If this haue bin so, it is the faulte or corruption of his officers, & not to be imputed to his Holinesse. But I answere, the pope vseth not to be so negligent of his estate, as not to looke at a reuenue of 20000. duckates a yeare. And to take away all cause of this cauill, and to make it more apparant that the Pope is the head of the whoreof Babylon; Pope Sixtus 4. scarce 120. yeares agoe, built a stewes in Rome, of his owne erection and foundation, so saith the same Agrippa. Cornel. Agrip. de vanit. scient. cap. 64 Lycurgus & Solon lupanaria aedificauere, &c. sed & recentioribus hisce temporibus Sixtus pōtifex Max. quartꝰ, Romae nobile admodum lupanar exstruxit.
Licurgus & Solon, heathē law-giuers, erected publick stewes: but that is no maruel; for of late yeeres, Pope Sixtus the fourth builded a goodly stewes in Rome.
Loe heer, the Popes Holinesse, the founder of a Colledge of diuells, a stewes for whores: surely because he scorned ordinarie company, he built that for himselfe, and his Princes & peers, the Cardinalls. Thus we see it cōfessed & proued by a learned Papist, that a 100. yeers agoe stewes were maintained, nay erected by the Pope: and that he takes gain & rent of them. If any man obiect against Agrippa, as no competent witnesse: I answere, the Pope indeed hath prohibited Vide indicem lib. prohibit. Clementis 8. in litera H. his books to be read; but it had been more reason to haue disproued and confuted his assertions: but let the Pope condemne him as he will, for his bold speaking of truth; it is knowen to all that know him, or his bookes, hee was a Papist [Page 135] for the most part: and whatsoeuer he was, he had no reason to bely the Pope; we hired him not, we thanke him not for anie thing but truth: yet for more certaintie hereof, hearken to another, who being an Inquisitor, is beyond all exception that waie.
Thus complains Oleaster (a Spanish Doctor), vpon that Text of Deuteronomy Deut. 23. 18 thou shalt not bring into my house the hire of a whore, for it is abhominable.
Oleaster in Commēt. suis in Pentateu. In Deut. cap. 23. fol. 270. Displicuerunt semper Deo turpia lucra, ideo (que) vetat ne merces meretricū ei offeratur: at nunc cùm ecclesia & ministri mūdiores esse deberent, omnia haec acceptantur, qualiacun (que) sunt & vndecun (que) venerint. Filthy gaines, saith he, were euer abhominable to God, & therfore he forbids to bring into his house the hire of a whore. But now in the new Testament, when the Church and Ministers thereof should bee much more cleane and pure then afore, all manner of filthy gaines are accepted and taken, how vile soeuer they be, and whencesoeuer they come.
Thus all gaine is sweete, and all rent welcome to the Pope, tho it come frō whores: so true a friend to stewes and whores, is the whore of Babylon.
But wil some say, this might be so in the elder times, that were of more libertie, because all was quiet: but now since Luther rose, and the Church hath beene wakened by heretickes, this wound is healed.
No, this wound is not healed, as I wil proue by their late and moderne writers. The 14. wound not healed: for the Romish religion, doctrine & practice tolerate stewes still.
Navarrus one of their greatest Canonists of this last age, and one whom the Popes helde worthy to be cald to Rome, for his continuall aduise & direction Martinus Azpil. Nauar. Hisp. Iuris cononici sciētis. ide (que) theolog. insignis &c. Haec Posseu. in apparatu sac. tom. 2. lit. M., deals very plainly in this matter, and saith, that Nau. Manual. c. 17. nu 195. pa. 433. edit. Wirceb. in 8. 1593. Licet potestati publicae permittere meretrices in aliqua parte ciuitatis: et postea, alicubi constituuntur eis patroni, & domus eis locā tur carius quā honestis locarentur: et in hac vrbe Romana, sciente & patiēte papa locantur et semper consueuerunt locari domus meretricibꝰ: et confessarij absoluūt et semper absoluerunt locatores eorū sine proposito abstinēdi à tali locatione, &c.
See here a peece of spanish deuotion and modesty. Surely, no maruell tho this man were sent for, from Spaine to Rome: for it seemes by this doctrine he was for the Popes tooth, and much more for his Cardinalles.
Alphonsus Viualdus, another learned Spaniarde, wrote a booke of matters of conscience not long agoe, of so great account amongst them that they call it the golden Candlesticke. It hath beene often printed, and within these 7. yeares was by the Popes speciall Commission purged, and reprinted: hee writes thus Martinus Alphōsus Vivaldꝰ, theol. & Iuris canon. professor & poenitentiariꝰ maior, &c. In Candelabro aureo. tit. de Confessione, numero 60 Vtrum hae meretices censeantur excommunicatae, per synodales cō stitutiones, quae nec consitentur, nec cō municant? respondeo, &c. Meretrices nū quā publicantur nec denū tiantur pro excōmunicatis in ecclesia: nec visum vnquam fuit, aliquem hac de causa ab earū participatione fugisse, &c. Pro resolutione dico, quod si non cōfiteā tur nec communicent per 10. aut 20. annos, non ideo incurrūt poenas ecclesiae in detestationem sui pessimi statꝰ, quia meretrices non sunt dignae laqueis legum. pag. 81. editionis Brixiensis 1588..
Oh excellent doctrine, and fit for the Romish [Page 137] Church: but all this will some say is salued by this that followeth. Nay, contrariwise say I, the wound is made worse; and by the craft of that that followeth, obserue the subtiltie and iniquity of Romish teachers: for this is done (saith he) in detestation of their ill life: the Church doth so detest their maner of life, that she will not thinke them worthy of her censures: oh notable shift! are they too bad to bee punished, & not too bad to bee suffered? doth the Romish Clergie thinke them so vile that way, and yet allow them? see the iniquitie and filthinesse of this religion.
Thus its apparant by the great Confessor Vivaldus, that the Romish Church excōmunicats not common whores, nor them that go to them: & another as great a Clark as himself, saith it is the common opinion Iac de Graffijs. tom. 1. lib. 1. cap. 9. art. 8. & 9..
But yet to shewe better that this wound is not healed, harke a little what the grand poenitentiarie, Iacobus de Graffijs, saith; ‘Iacobꝰ de Graffijs decis. aur. cas. cons. tom. 1. lib▪ 2 cap. 75. art. 3. et 4. pag. 348. Sed quare ipsa ecclesia lupanaria permittit & per consequens fornicar. quod est mortale peccatum. Respondeo quod ecclesia quando (que) tollerat minus malum praesens, vt euitet maius malum futurum, quod verisimilibus coniecturis speratur: sic ca [...] &c. vbi ecclesia tolerat meretrices ad euitandas promiscuas luxurias et foedissimas coiunctiones: & sic non illud peccatum approbat, sed dissimulando tolerat, vt eo medio adulteria, Incest (que) at (que) alia luxuriae crimina compescat. Hinc &c. Et in tantum tolerat lex huiusmodi fornicationes, vt etiam cogat publicas meretrices ad fornicandum cum quocun (que) iuxta tamen mercedem. But if fornication be a sin, then why doth the church her selfe permit stewes, & consequently fornication, which is a mortall sinne? I answere (saith he) that the church somtime tolerateth a less euill present that she may auoide a greater euill to come, that is probable to fal out: and this he proues out of the Canon law; & so concludes that the church doth tolerate stewes and whores, to auoide greater sins not approuing the sin of fornicatiō, but by cōniuence, or dissimulatiō tolerats it, that so she may restraine & keep yong men from adulteries, incests, and other crimes of that kinde: then he goeth further to proue his conclusiō; which he doth out [Page 138] of the practice of heathen lawegiuers, and by the ciuile lawe, & would proue it out of the Fathers: & then to make vp the measure of his iniquitie, he addeth that the law doth so far forth tolerate fornications in stews, that it takes order to compel the whores to refuse no man, if hee offer her, her pay: the words are too bad to be repeated in english.’
And to shew that he is a true childe of that Babylon that wil neuer be healed, & that he is as graceless in this point as his mother, afterward in his 2. tome (which he put out in his more mature yeares) he hath againe the same doctrin in as ill or worse words; Idem Graffiꝰ ibid. tom. 2. li. 3. c. 28. art. 3 6. Ad meretrices accedere, quā uis sit peccatū mortale, tamē ecclesia illud peccatum tolerat, ad euitā dū maius malum, &c. et in hoc casu ecclesia censurā restringit, ne forsan deteriores sint, &c.
And to conclude, for the better encoragement for women to bee whores, and the better to please their carnall & wicked minds, Cardinall Tollet a Iesuite, out of his Iesuitical modestie, and his Cardinal like respect to the stewes, deliuers this doctrine; Fran. Tolletꝰ Ies. Cardinal. Instructio sacerdotū. lib. 5. cap. 17. art. 3. Mulieres accipientes pretiū pro vitio carnis, nō obligantur ad restitutionem, (quia ista actio non est mala cōtra iustitiā) quamuis sint Virgines et coniugatae, et cuiuscun (que) cō ditionis: et quamuis accipiāt pecunias in excessu, vltra pretium actꝰ turpis, si liberè donetur illis.
Certainly the stewes are much beholden to Cardinal Tollet for this doctrine: but, what Iustice and modestie, and the Church, and the truth and God himselfe do owe him for it, hee feeles afore this time, except he repented. Obijt Tolletꝰ. Romae. 1596
Thus it is the present doctrin of the Romish church that she alloweth stewes by publicke toleration, to auoide greater euills, and censureth not the whores for it; nay, ties them by a lawe to refuse no man, and [Page 139] tyes men by a lawe to pay the hire; and for this ende allowes them Courts, Iudges, and Officers, and takes part of the benefit arising. Now, that their practice is according to this doctrine, I appeale to all that haue trauelled in those partes where poperie reigneth; as Spaine, Italie▪ &c. And further, to giue one euidence out of my owne reading for the practice, Iacobus de Graffijs telles vs plainely in these words, Iacobus de Graff. decis. aur cas. cons. tom. 1. lib. 1. c. 28. art. 20. Sic licitum est dominis domorū locare eas meretricibꝰ, non quidē ad meretricandum, sed ad alios fines bonos, id est vt ipsae vitā suā seruent et domini domorū lucrentur iustas pensiones, cum displicentia peccati, &c. ita etiā praxis Romana videtur seruare. pag. 105.
Thus both for Romish doctrine & practice, it is apparant that stewes are allowed to this daie, and common whores not censured.
Against all this but one thing can bee obiected; namely, that all these be priuate Doctors: I answere, thē let vs see what the Pope doth. Doth he supply the negligence of other Bishops? they do not excommunicate them: doth hee? No, no, he is as bad or worse then the worst. Princes tolerate them, so doth he Nay, by the places alleaged afore, it is manifest y• it is not princes, but the Pope & the Church that tolerates and permittes thē, & princes permit them, because the Church doth.; they in their kingdoms, he in Rome: they build thē houses, so did he: they take part of their gain, so doth hee: the Bishops excommunicate them not, no more doth he to this daie. For this end we are to knowe, that besides all particular and personall excommunications, [Page 140] he vseth once a yeere, that he may meete with all his enemies at once, and pay them at one payment, to excommunicate together all such sorts and kinds of people, as he holdes his enemies: but are whores any of them? no such matter: nay, these be they; Vide Bullam Coenae in Cō stit. Rom. pōt. per Petrū Mathaeūed. inter Cōstitut. Sixti quinti pa. 883. vbi Papa excō municat & anathematizat in propria sua persona,
Hereticos, vt Lutheranos, Caluinistas. &c.. Caluinists, Lutherans, and such heretickes.
Appellantes à sentētijs papalibꝰ ad futurum generale concilium.. All that appeal from the Pope to a generall Councell.
Piratos in Mari suo & capientes bona naufragantiū.. Forgers and Falsifiers of the Popes hande, or seale.
Imponentes [...]t exigentes nova pedagia.. All that hurt and hinder Pilgrimes that come to Rome.
Falsificatores literarum, &c. Apostolicarū.. All lay men that draw Clergy men to their Courts, or would bring them vnder their iurisdiction.
Deferentes prohibita infidelibꝰ.. All that hinder the iurisdiction of the Clergie.
Impediētes eos qui victualia ad vrbem deferant. 8. Offendentes peregrinos ad vrbem venientes. 9. Offendentes venientes Romam, aut ibi commorantes. 10. Manusinijcientes in Cardinales, praelatos seu nuntios papae. 11. Causarum in Curia Ro. cursum impedientes, seu literarum Apostolicarum executionem. 12. Officiales et praelatos causas à curia Ro. auocantes. 13. Personas ecclesiasticas ad suū tribunal trahentes, et statuta contra libertatem ecclesiae facientes. 14. Impedientes Iudicum ecclesiasticorum iurisdictionem. 15. Ecclesiasticos aliquo modo vexantes. 16. Laicos se intromittentes in causis contra Clericos. 17. Occupantes terras seu Iura, et rapientes bona palatij Apostolici, &c.. All that seize vpon anie lands belonging to the Pope, &c.
These and such other like to the number of 17. or 18. be the enemies against whome the Pope hath cause to plant his ordinaunce; but as for whores, and stewes, and such other hainous transgressors of the morall law, these neuer hurt the Romish Church, and therfore she bends not her power against them.
So then, seeing poperie and the stewes are so linked, that (we perceiue) do what we can, man cannot separate those whom the diuell hath ioined togither: let vs [Page 141] then leaue the stews in Rome, & the Pope in his stewes; and mourning for their miserie, let vs proceed.
The next wound is this: That whereas God hath euer allowed and honoured marriage, in the old, & new Testament; and Concubines were neuer allowed in the old, and absolutely condemned in the newe: Now coms popery, & makes it as lawfull to haue a Concubine as a wife The 15. wound; He that hath not a wife may haue a Concubine. & this is done by no priuat persons, but the Popes lawe it selfe. Thus saith the Canon; Decret. dist. 34. cap. 4. Is qui non habet vxorem, & pro vxore Concubinam habet, a Communione non repellatur; tamen vt vnius mulieris aut vxoris aut Cō cubinae sit cō iunctione cō tentus.
Is not heere a piece of good licentious poperie? I know they say they haue this from the first councell of Toledo, which is ancient: true, but what if Spaine, not long afore conuerted to the faith, was not purged as yet from these dregs of heathenisme, and Iudaism; are they therfore fit to be taken vp by the Pope, & inserted in his lawe, as a Canon to binde and direct for euer? If they think that poor prouincial Councel (but of 19. Bishops) bee a sufficient warrant for this decree, then why take they not all▪ and why put they it not downe a wife or a Concubine, as it pleaseth him; for so it is in the words of the Councell Concil. General. per Binniū. Col. 1607 tom. 1. pa. 560. In Concil. 1. Tolet. cap. 17 Is qui non habet vxorem sed, &c. tantum vt vnius Mulieris, aut vxoris, aut Cōcubinae (Vt [...]i placuerit) sit coniunctione contentus..
I know also, that they haue coyned a distinction, whereby they would couer this wound, and saie that a Concubine heere is to bee taken for a woman whom a man hath, and keepeth with the affection of a Husband; onely in outward fashion and solemnity shee is not a wife, nor publickly maried: but I aunswere, the best of it is nought if wee did grant them [Page 142] all they saie: but distinguish as they can, the words are so plaine, that the suttlest distinction they can deuise, wil be too short a cloak to couer the shame of it: nay the shame of this Canon is written in the fore-head of it: for the Rubrick or contents, written with red letters, is worse then the text it selfe; Vide Decretū cum glossa, editionis lugdun. in fol. 1510 dist. 34. cap. 4. Is, qui non habet vxorē, loco illiꝰ debet habere concubinam.
These be the very words in the impression at Lions, 1510. tho I confess the Diuines of Paris, hauing a little more care what past their hands, ashamed of the word debet (that is, ought to haue), put it out, and put in liceat, that is, he may haue Vide decretū edit. parisiens. in fol. anni 1507. ibid. Is qui non habet vxorem loco illius, concubinam habere liceat.: but take the best of all, and is it not bad inough? well let vs go forward; this wound is olde and wide, and deepe.
But is it yet healed? No, not to this day The 15. wound not yet healed; for still by the Popes Canon lawe he that hath not a Wife may haue a concubine.; for the Popes Canon lawe was of late yeares commaunded by the Pope to be corrected and purged, as well the Text as the Glosse: and is this amended, or left out as being false and filthy doctrine? No: other places indeed are altered, for the greater vantage and honor of the Pope: but this dishonorable Canon, so disgracefull to Gods lawe, stands vntouched in this newe and last edition of all Vide corpus iuris Canonici, autoritate Gregorij. 13. pont. max. emendatum et editum. 91. et 600.: onely the Rubricke, or title, or Contens, whereof wee spake before is altered thus;
Thus it is amended; but in a poore fashion, as wee may see: But what may the Church of Rome meane to amend the Rubrick or title, & not the Text? Surely because they knowe manie a one hastily runnes ouer [Page 143] the Contents, and titles of books and Chapters, who neuer looke into the body of the books thēselues. But take this wound healed as it is: Is this good diuinitie at Rome, that he who hath no wife, but in a wiues steede keepes a Concubine, shall not for that bee kept from the Communion? Is not this a holy table of the Romish Sacrament, from which he shall not bee forbidden, that openly keeps a whore in roome of a wife? Certainely this wound is notably healed: let vs then goe forward to the next.
Wee haue heard that a Wife is made equall to a Concubine: but what if shee bee made worse then a Whore, an Adultresse, or a common Strumpet? None dare say this, none dare vndertake this, but the Whore of Babylon: but shee dare. For this is her doctrine, that it is a lesse sinne for many men to lie with another mans wife, or a common whore, then it is to marrie a wife of their owne The 16. wound; Some men had better lie with another mans wife, or keep a whore, then marie a wife of his owne.. Mariage, which God hath made so honorable, hath been of long time disgraced in poperie; but not in this high measure (I speak of) abused, that I know, till these later and more shamelesse times that the whore hath got her a brazen face.
In Luthers time, not yet a 100. yeeres agoe, liued one Albertus Pighius, one of the Popes Chāpions Albert. Pighiꝰ scripsit in Lutherum, Bucerum, &c. de ecclesia catholica bene meritꝰ. Posseu. appar. sac. tom. 1. lit. A., who for the defence of that hierarchie and maintenance of that cause, amongst other his bold and blasphemous assertions, teacheth this hoggish and hatefull doctrine; Pighiꝰ explicatio controuersiarum: controu. 15. de Caelib. et coniug. Sacerd. p. 215. edit. Parisi. 1549. ‘Go to (sayth he) suppose all that vowed continencie, do not keep it so wel as they should: What then? had they better marrie? Nay, assuredly: for wee must [Page 144] resist the temptation by all meanes we can: but if Sed esto, non faciunt obligati voto omnes quod possunt & debēt, &c. et proinde tentantur, & fortasse vruntur eorū pleri (que): quid igitur an nubere his minus malum erit, et minꝰ damnabile? tu vide, &c. tentationi proinde quibꝰ possimꝰ remedijs, resistendum est: in quibus si quando remissiores ex infirmitate carnis ceciderimus, tolerabilius hoc peccatum est, quam si iugum in totum excutiamus, &c. non quòd hic probemus fornicationem, sed casum ex infirmitate ad deliberatum immo perpetuum abiecto omni pudore Incestum, comparamus. sometime we be too remisse, and so by infirmity of the flesh doe fall (into fornication, or &c.) Certainly this is a less sin and more tolerable offence then it is to marie; for this is wholly to cast off Gods yoke: not that we allow fornicatiō (in it self); but here we compare a slip or fall of infirmitie to mariage, which in this case wee account no better then a resolued, or deliberate, or continual Incest, vtterly without all shame.’
Heere is a piece of holy poperie indeede: but it is pope-holy, that is, beastly and profane; so filthy that I had rather the particulars were cōsidered of by a mans owne discretion, then deciphered by me. But let vs see if this be healed or no: For the Iesuits may say, this Pighius wrote so hoggishly in licentious times, and when we were in the egge and scarce hatched For the Iesuites order was established by Paul the 3. and this booke of Pighius published within 3. yeares together, namely, about the yeare. 1540.; for had we then been in that power and place as now, we would haue restrained him.
But the truth is, that contrariwise this impious and filthy doctrine was but obscurely and timorously broched by Pighius; but hath been since boldly and plainly blustered out by the Iesuites The 16. wound not healed; for this is still the doctrine of the Romish Church.: he brought forth an imperfect heap, but they haue lickt it & brought it to form & perfection. Costerus a Iesuite of great name amongst them Vide Posseu. appar. sac. tō. 1. lit. T. writing a book, fit to be (as he calls it, & they esteem it) in euery Catholicks hand, deliuereth this for sound and dogmaticall doctrine.
Costerus, Enchiridion controuersiarū, &c. cap. de coelibatu propos. 9 p. 528. Sacerdos si fornicetur, aut domi concubinam fouear, tametsi graui sacrilegio se obstringat, grauiùs tamen peccat si contrahat matrimonium, &c. A Priest, if he commit fornication, or keepe a whore at home, though hee sinne grieuously, yet sinnes hee more grieuously if he marrie a wife.
This is one of his propositions or conclusions. But hee wrote this many yeeres agoe, is it not since healed? No, the booke hath indeed bin often printed, and with many alterations Vide Poss [...]uinum ibid.. But this stands in his last impression vntouched, as a doctrine for the Pope to glorie in: which I speake not at randon, but vpon too good ground. For this doctrine, and the writer of it, haue been often reprooued by our Diuines: but in stead of reformation, Costerus hath been defended, and the doctrine iustified by other of his learned brethren. I will name but one example: Chamier a learned French Minister obiected it to the Iesuites at Turrone; and it is at large defended by Ignatius Armandus, the principall of the Colledge there, for Catholike and good doctrine. Vide Epistolas Iesuiticas, part. 2. in epistola 1. Iesuitae Ignatii ad Chamierū. pag. 33 &c. Vides igitur Chamiere non esse contra doctrinam Christi, nec Apostolorum, nec Conciliorum, nec Patrum, quod asserit Costerus, &c. The Epistles on both sides are in print to bee seene. And if these be not of authoritie sufficient, let Bellarmine come to helpe them. Thus he teacheth:
Bellarm. tom. 2. lib. 2. de Monachis, cap. 30. pag 545. De ijs qui vouerunt non recte dicitur, Qui non se continent, nubant, melius est nubere quam vri, nam vtrumque est malum, & nubere & vri, imo peius est nubere, quicquid reclament aduersarij, &c. Et postea. Quae nubit post votum simplex, vetum matrimoniū contrahit, tamen aliquo modo magis peccat quam quae fornicatur. That speech of the Apostle (They that cannot containe let them marrie: for it is better to marrie then to burne) cannot bee rightly said of them that haue vowed: for both are naught, both to burne and to marrie: yea it is worse of the two to marrie, whatsoeuer the Protestants say to the contrarie.
And a little after in the same Chapter: ‘She that marrieth after a single vow, contracteth [Page 146] indeede a true Matrimonie, yet in some sort she sinnes more then she that playes the whore.’
Thus this Popeholy doctrine is now brought to ripenes and perfection, by the diligence, deuotion and modestie of the Iesuites. But they haue a reason for all this, so good and so strong, as they think, that thereby all is well healed: for, say they, fornication or whoring wee doe not simply allow to be better then mariage; but in respect that a man hath afore made a vow not to marrie, Bellar. [...]bid. Costerus ibid. Ignatius ibid. therefore to marrie after the vow, is to breake promise with God. A notable reason, if it be well considered: for hereby it is apparent that Poperie teacheth her people to vow against mariage, but not against fornication; against wiues, but not against whores. Alas, alas, what doctrine is this, doth mariage breake their vow, and not fornication? God keepe all Christians from such vowes. But that this is true, I say, let Bellarmine iudge.
Bellar. ibid. Quae nubit reddit se impotentem ad seruandum votum, quod non facit quae fornicatur. Ergo quae nubit magis peccat. She that marrieth after a simple vow, in some sort sinneth more grieuously then she that commits fornication, because (marke his reason) she that marieth makes her selfe vnable to keep her vow, which she doth not that commits fornication.
Thus it is plaine: Poperie voweth against mariage, not against whoredome, adulterie nor fornication. And thus three great Iesuites haue made good what Pighius taught, and that more plainly and palpably then he did. And to make vp a messe of Iesuites, Posseuinus their grand Censor, comming to giue his censure of Pighius, Posseuinus in Appar. sac. tom. 1. lit. A. Vide quid dicat de Alberto Pighio. findes many faults and errors in his bookes: but as for this hee [Page 147] hath nothing to say against it, but passeth it ouer as good holy catholike Romish doctrine: therefore seeing (as Bellarmine said afore, say we what we can) they will not forsake, nor amend this doctrine, let them keepe it, and let it be one of the sweete flowers of the Popes garland.
The next wound is neere a kin to this, The 17. wound; Priests in Poperie may not marrie, but are permitted to keepe their whores, vnder a yeereli [...] rent. namely, that their Church hauing alwaies forbidden mariage to their Clergie, hath notwithstanding either tolerated and permitted them concubines, or at least not punished it to reformation.
Thus was it complained of almost an hundred yeeres agoe, by the Germane nation, then being Papists:
Vide Cen tum grauami na Germanicae nationis: grauamen 75. & 91. In locis plaerisque Episcopi & eorum Officiales sacerdotū tollerant concubinatum, dūmodo certa persoluatur pecunia & recepto ab eisdē hoc annuo cē su publice cum suis concubinis, pellicibus & alijs id genus meretricibus, illegitime cohabitare, liberosque procreare sinunt, &c. In most places (say they) Bishops and their Officials doe tolerate and suffer the Priests to haue concubines, vnder the paiment of a certaine annuall rent of money, and further doe euen permit them to keepe their whores openly, and haue them in their houses, and to beget children of them, &c.
Of these and certaine other grieuances (one hundred in all) the Germane nation complained to their Bishops and Clergie, in their owne Diets or Parliaments held at home. But hauing no redresse they went further, and about the yeere 1522. complained to the Popes Legats and Nuntios at Noremberge, who gaue them good words, and promised they would make report thereof to his Holinesse, and procure them a gratious answere. But hauing long waited to no end, they published their grieuances and sent them to the Pope, crauing with much humilitie, audience, redresse and reformation; [Page 148] promising vpon that condition, they would still and euer shew themselues dutifull and obedient children to the Pope, and all whom hee set ouer them: but if they had no redresse, they assured him they could not, nor would endure them longer. Hereupon the Pope, not willing to venture the losse of so faire a childe as Germany, pacified them for a time with goodly promises. But what reformation followed in whole or in any part, the stories of those ages make it apparant. But for the particular I haue in hand, The 17. woūd not healed: for stil in Poperie to this day, their Clergie are forbiddē mariage, but whores and concubines are not taken from them. what notable reformatiō was wrought herein, let a Bishop of their owne, Espencaeus, as wise and learned as that age did yeeld, let him, I say, deliuer for me; who fortie yeeres after, writing of this matter, saith:
Espencaeus de Continentia, lib 2. cap. 7 pag. 176. Pro praetenso puro mundo (que) caelibatu, successit impurus immundusque concubinatus, vt latere nec prae multitudine queat, nec p [...]ae impudentia quaerat: at haec tollerantia al [...]iùs radices egit permissis alicubi sub annuo censu Clericis at que laicis cum suis concubinis cohabitare, quod vtinam & falso & immerito extaret inter grauamina Germaniae, &c. Impress. Paris. 1560. In stead of pure and honest single life, succeeded impure fornication, and filthie keeping of concubines, in such sort as neither can they be concealed for multitude, nor seeke they to be, they are so shamelesse. Nay of later times this tollerancie hath spread further, insomuch as in some places, both Clergie and laitie haue their whores permitted them, vnder a yeerely rent: whereof (saith he) the Germane nation complained long agoe too truly and vpon too great cause.
But was not this wound healed, and this abuse reformed vpon this complaint of Espencaeus? A man might haue thought it would, and the rather seeing he was a man of so great esteeme in those daies, not in France only, but euen in the Court of Rome. [Page 149] Espencaeus vvas in special fauour vvith Pope Paul the 4. insomuch as after much cō sultation had vvith him, he found bine so vvise and learned a man, as he had made him Cardinall if he had liued: this is apparēt in his bookes de Continent, lib. 3. cap. 4. and in his Cō mentarie on Titus, cap. 1. pag 91. But what amendment insued, let himselfe tell vs in his Commentarie vpon Titus, which he wrote many yeeres after his former booke.
Episcopi, Archidiaconi, &c. plae: unque dum dioeceses, & parociam obequitant, non tam facinorosos, & criminum reos poenis & correctionibus à vitijs deterrēt quo sine pere grina [...]iones huiusmodi olim iam suerūt iure Canonico ordinata, quam pecunia praesenti & numerata, titulo procurationis, ne dicam ficticiae iurisdictionis [...]mungunt & exugunt tum Clericos tum laicos: turpissimum, quod & hos cum concubinis, pellicibus, & meretriculis cohabitare, liberosque procreare sinunt, accepto ab eis certo quotannis censu, &c. Our Bishops and Archdeacons, &c. (in Poperie) when they ride their visitations, do not so much punish the euill doers, (for which end the visitations were first ordained) as rake vp siluer, and sucke it both from laitie and Clergie, vnder false and fained pretences of iurisdiction: but it is most filthie of all, that they suffer them to keepe their whores in their houses, and haue children of them, at a certaine annuall and yeerely rent, &c.
This is the healing and reformation wrought in those daies. Oh but (will some say) that is 40. yeers agoe, sure it is better in these latter daies. Indeede this enormitie was so generall and so scandalous, that euen the Councell of Trent it selfe was ashamed, and made great adoe for reformation of it. Vide Concil. Trid. sess. 24. cap. 8. But what effect it tooke, how they executed it, and what is done in the matter, let another Bishop of theirs tell vs, who in these late daies, scarce seuen yeeres agoe, Henricus Cuickius: Rutemundensis Episcopus scripsit speculum concubinariorum, Sacerdotum, Monachorum & Clericorum: Colon. 1599. found it to bee so common and shamelesse a sinne all ouer all the Low Countries, (where Poperie raigned) not onely in secular, but euen in Monkes, Friers, and regular Priests, that hee writes a booke against the sinne, bitterly but iustly inueighing against it, and shewing how dangerous [Page 150] and damnable a sinne it is: and so much the more (saith he) because it is so common and so little regarded, and so farre are they from shaming with it, that (mark how it is healed) they will take their concubines and whores, and carrie them vp and downe the countrie (as men doe their wiues) to feasts and meetings, and challenge place and precedence for them (as for honest Matrons). And further freelie confesseth (but with great griefe and shame) that there bee very few in their Clergie, free from this crime. Idem Cuickius, in praefatione eiusdē libri. Ad vos qui casti, &c. qui (dolenter dico) ra [...]i estis & vt Esai 24. tanquam racemi, &c.
The 18. wound: Such Priests as be continent & haue no whores, yet must pay a yeerly rent as they that haue, because they may haue if they will. And no maruel though there be but few of their Clergie that haue not concubines, seeing they take that course they doe with them, which is such as though they would inuite, nay hire, or rather presse and prouoke men to the sinne. For was it not also complained on at the same time by the Germanes, that
Grauamina 100. Ger. grau. 91. Sed & sacerdotes continentes & qui absque concubinis degunt, concubinatus censum persoluere cogunt, asserentes Episcopum pecuniae indigum esse, qua soluta, licere sacerdotibus, vt vel coelibes permaneant, vel concubinas alant. Not only those Priests that had their whores paid yeerely rent for it, but euen those that were continent, and would haue no concubines, yet for all that must pay the rent? for, say they, my Lord the Bishop hath need of it, and cause to imploy much money: therefore pay you must, and then be it at your owne choice, whether you will haue a concubine or no.
What is this but euen to trie mens strengths, and as it were to presse them to the sinne: for he that either by constitution is vnfit, or out of morall honestie will not, or out of conscience dare not keepe a concubine, seeing he must pay his rent as well as he that doth, will not this make him say to himselfe; I [Page 151] see this is done by my superiours, they haue more learning and knowledge then I: I am to follow them, and may rather trust them then my own conceit: and certainly if it were so great a sinne as I haue imagined it to be, our Bishops would not take a yeerely rent to suffer it; and if they would, yet his Holinesse, it being so old and so notorious a practise, would haue reformed it long ere this. Therfore seeing the case stands thus, and that I must and do pay, doubtlesse I will not pay for nothing, &c. Surely he must haue a great measure of grace, that liuing vnder popish subiection, can resist this temptation and the like: and therefore no maruell though, as themselues confesse, not one of their Clergie of a great number that hath not his whores in corners, or else publikely in their houses. Erasmus liuing about that time, or soone after, complaineth of it, and saith:
Erasmus annotat. in 1. Tim. 3. Si quis perpendat horū temporū statum, quàm innumeri sunt Monachi publico incesti & impudici, fortassis iudicabit magis expedire vt ijs, qui prorsus non continent ius fiat publici matrimonij, &c. He that considereth the state of these times how in numerable the number is of such Monks and Priests as liue in open whoredome and incest, would thinke it perhaps more conuenient to giue leaue to such as cannot containe rather to marrie then, &c.
And not long after him florished Cassander, a man of great name and account in his time both for wisdome and learning, and hee finding the world still worse in this point, confesseth Cassander lib. Consult. art. 23. cap. 1. lam [...]ò res redijt vt vix centesimum inuenias qui ab omni commercio foeminarū abstineat, &c.
Thus we see the fruit of this their practise to take rent for concubines, and to make them pay that [Page 152] had none, that almost none of their Clergie, but are stained with this pollution.
But is this healed? The 18. woūd not healed: for such as haue no concubines must pay their rēt, because they may haue, if they will. No, saith Espencaeus, it is too horrible to beleeue. But it is too true that
Thus here was no amendement for fortie yeeres after the villanie was discouered, and the grieuance complained of: and that there was nothing done in the daies of Espencaeus, which was for some ten yeers more, we may see by his words in his other booke.
Since the time of Espencaeus, whether this wound be healed or no, I cannot tell: and therefore if any of that side can shew me any good authoritie that now it is reformed, and that either no Priests pay yeerly rent for concubines at all, or at least not those that haue none; I shall be willing to heare it, and to see that any thing at all is amended But whosoeuer will but look into their latest Casuists and Summists, as be Tollet the Cardinall, Iac de Graffijs, Loel. Zecchius, Baptista Corradus, Berarduccius, Raphael de Caesare, Llamas & others, will finde it more then suspitious (though now they couer it more cunningly then formerly they did) that this wound is farre from being healed.: Meane time I haue proued it apparently that till that time [Page 153] it was not amended: and whosoeuer reades the Low Countrie Bishop Cuickius his booke aforenamed, written but seuen yeeres agoe, will iudge it as ill in these daies still, as it was in the time of Espencaeus the French Bishop.
These Authors I haue named, hauing some remorse of conscience and feare of God, ingenuously and honestly wished that rather mariage might bee permitted then whoredom should so preuaile ouer the world. But what hath bin done? They for their labour are ill spoken of when they are dead, their bookes partly prohibited to bee read at all, partly purged and altered as they list; Opera Era [...]m [...], Espencaei, Cassandri prohibentur donec expurgentur. Vide Indicem lib. prohibit. per Clem. 8. & Indices expurgatorios Hisp. & Belg. and for the matter it self, mariage is still forbidden, whoredome still practised and winkt at, if not permitted, stewes still tolerated, and that vnder the Popes nose, and no where so much as euen in Rome it selfe: and still this doctrine is Catholike and currant,
And why (alas) all this, but because Mariage hath been an enemie to the Popes Crowne and dignitie; but stewes, adulterie and fornication neuer were? Let vs hasten forward.
I must needes say (if I say truly) I could discouer many more of these particular old festring wounds, not as yet healed, but this time will not well permit it: therefore referring it to a further opportunitie, I will stand but vpon one particular more, and so come to a generall, which shall conclude all.
It hath bin long ago laid to their charge The 19. wound: Their Liturgie is full of blasphemie: their Legend full of lies, their Ceremonies of superstition. that their Liturgies are full of idolatrie and blasphemies, their Legends full of lies, their Ceremonies of [Page 154] superstition: which I will not at this time (being almost past) stand particularly to prooue, seeing for their Liturgie and Ceremonies, the Pope himselfe, Vide Bullas Clem. 8. de Pontificali, anno 95. & de Ceremoniali anno 1600. or else his Conuentibleat Trent Vide Concil. Trident. Sess. vult. Dec. 4. haue granted it, and pretended that they should be reformed; and touching their liues of Saints and their Legends, a great Doctor of their owne long agoe found them so full of ridiculous absurdities, impieties and vntruths, that he affirmed him to be a man Ludouicus Viues. lib. 2. de Caus. corrupt. art. de Lumbardica historia. of a brasen face, and a leaden heart that wrote them. Now all these three sort of bookes are in shew reformed of late, but the truth is there is neuer a materiall wound healed, but rather a number made worse.
1. For their Liturgie and seruice either publike or priuate, it is contained in their books called, Missalia, Breuiaria, Officia, Manualia, Portiforia, and such other: all these haue been reuiewed, and (as they say) corrected since the Councell of Trent. Vide Bullas Pontif. praefixas. Missal. & Breuiar. editionis 70. & post. But let them be examined and compared together, and I dare say, that for one euill taken out there is another put in, and tenne stand vnremoued, and that both in diuers pictures, as also for points of doctrine, they are as ill as the former, Compare for this end the Missalles, Breuiaries, Manuals and Primeri, printed before the Coūcell of Trent, with those printed since. at the least.
2. Their Ceremonies of state, or, as they say, of deuotion, are contained in the bookes called, Pontificale Romanum, and Ceremoniale Romanum, Adde hereunto also their Processionale, Rationale, and Sacerdotale Romanum. wherein what apish toyes there be, what absurdities, what superstitions, sometimes ridiculous, sometimes impious, is incredible to them that see it not: insomuch as some Papists, Vide Epist [...]lam Alberti Castellani ad Leonem 10. praefixam Pontif. vlt. edit. Venet. yea the later Popes, Vide Bullas praed. Clem. 8. haue not [Page 155] spared to confesse that they neede great reformation, and therefore vndertooke that worke themselues. But if a man did see how they haue amended them, they would out of this one (if there were no more euidences) conclude that Rome is that Babylon that will neuer be healed: for looke into the Pontificale, and the Ceremoniale, which were reformed, and are indeede much altered by the authoritie of Clement the 8. and printed at Rome within these few yeeres, and you shall finde some small deformities taken away, but many great enormities suffered to stand, & some put in that were not there before: Compare for this end the Pontificale and Ceremoniale, new and old. which I will not stand at this time to particularise, both because the particulars are so many, and also for that seeing the bookes being so rare are not for each mans reading, it may hap hereafter that the exact comparison of them together, the old with40 The 19. wound not healed: for all these are as bad still, as afore. the new, may be a worke of it selfe not vnworthie of some mens labours.
3. Their stories, or tales, are comprised in the bookes called, Speculum exemplorum, Vitae Sanctorum, Legenda, &c. These also are lately reformed, as they pretend. But how? If any would know what is done herein, take but one example. The Iesuites in the Low Coūtries pretending these Legends or stories, needed much reformation, tooke the matter vpon themselues, because it was of great weight and consequence, and appointed it to some of their societie to be reformed, and now of late they haue published it at Doway, some two or three yeeres agoe, and would make vs beleeue that it is amended in innumerable places. Vide librū intitulatum: Magnum speculum exemplorum ab innumeris mendis, &c. vindicatum per quendam Patrem è societate Iesu & pereundem locuple tatum: Duaci. anno But if any man haue lost any [Page 156] time in turning ouer their Legends, and perusing the prodigious stories there laid downe, let him venture euen a little more, & compare this new reformed Speculum exemplorum, with the former, and if he find as impious and ridiculous Legends, as improbable, and as impossible tales in that, as in the other; then let him make report what good reformers the Iesuites bee, and how well the Romish Church is healed in this wound. To this end compare the old Speculum Exemplorum, or the Legend vvith the new Magnum speculum exemploru [...], set out by the Jesuites this last yeare. The conclusion is, that the Missals and Breuiaries, though vndertaken by Trent: the Pontificale and Ceremoniale, though vndertaken by the Pope: the Legend and Speculum, though vndertaken by the Iesuites, and all in shew reformed; yet stand all at this day as foule and deformed, and though some things bee taken out, yet (all laid together) as bad or worse then they were afore.
These straits of time hinder mee from inlarging my selfe any further, therefore to conclude, and wrap vp all in one generall exception:
The last point wherewith I will charge the Romish Church and religion, is not so fitly to be called a wound, as a leprosie, or a generall consumption; but all to one end: for as it is no difference vpon the matter, whether a man bee deepe and desperatelie wounded, or haue a leprosie ouer all the bodie, or a generall consumption, for both are deadly, and both incurable: so is it in this case; wherein the exception I take against them, is, that their Church and State declined long agoe, into that generall corruption & vniuersal pollution in al estates. The 20. wound: A generall corruption of manners in all estates. That the prophanenesse, licentiousnesse, and sinfulnesse [Page 157] of all sorts of people in that Church, both head and members, is like a spirituall leprosie without, or a generall consumption within, threatning ruine to the whole bodie. This point is worthie to be enlarged, but I must deferre it, and referre the Reader to the records of antiquitie, I meane such as be their owne men, but hauing some remorse of conscience, and feare of God, did confesse freely, and bitterly deplore the miserie that the sinfulnesse of the popish Church and religion would bring vpon all the world. Let them reade (that haue them,) these books named in the margent, Vide Gersonis opera passi [...]. Reuelationes Brigi [...]tae. Vincentij Ferrariens. prognostie. Perrū de Aliaco de reformatione eccl. Nicolai de Clemangi [...] opera: in Bibliotheca Patrum, editionis primae. Poemata Walteri Mapes. Maillardi & Menotti Sermones. Holcot in Sapient. lect. 182. & passim. & Onus Ecclesiae passim. and those that haue them not, it may bee shortly they may haue some helpe therein, and then you will grant with me, that the former and better times, confessed that which I now lay to their charge.
I will insist particularly but vpon two, the one of so great antiquitie, the other of so great authoritie, as both are beyond exception. Some 400. yeares ago liued a Monke learned for those times, called (as Posseuine confesseth Vide Posleu in Appar. sac. In append. priori ad [...]om. 1. lit. B. Bernardus Morlanen [...]is: hee wrote three bookes of the contempt of the world, in an artificiall kind of Poetrie, but much more artificially describing, and zealously deploring the sinfulnesse of the Romish Church, and state in those daies, from the head to the foote, describing particularly their adulteries, Casta cubilia sunt modò v [...]a, lata petun [...]ur &c. drunkennesse, Cura stat vnica luctaque publica carnis in esu: eb [...]ietas placet & tua vox [...]acet ô bone Iesu. ambition, idlenesse, dissimulation, deceits, cosenages, [Page 158] murders, Arcta relinquitur & via carpitur ampla quibusque. Quae [...]imus in via, fluxa fluentia, con fluit ansque. Archit [...]icl [...]iu [...], sceptra, sedilia rima petendo. Quis (que) tumultuat, instat & aestuat, haec satagendo. Stat simulatio, dissimulatio, crimen vt ū que. Alea, crapula, fraus, facinus, gula flagitiumque. Ora bilinguia, lis, homicidia Mars, tuba, terror. Vis, probra Iergia: quid moror? omnia me docet error. whoredomes I am meretricia (pene) cubilia ni [...] reputātur. Et venialia, quod genialia vociferātur. of all estates: then particularly for their Clergie, their ignorance and negligence, Grex flet amarius, est operarius in grege ra [...]us. Pontificum [...]tatus excidia datus, extat auarus, &c. their Sodomie, Parcite credere quae pudet edere, sed tamen edam. Horrida nomine, plus mala crimine, crimina quaedam. Heu male publicus est Sodomiticus ignis & aestus. Nemo seelus tegit, aut premit, aut fugit esse scelestus. Plangite saecula, plangite singula, crimine p [...]ena. Mas, maris immemor (ô furor, ô tremor) est vt hyaena. their Simonie and other corruptions in attaining places in the Church: Non sine Simone, sed sine canone, dux animarum. Mox docet inscius & sibi n [...]scius ipse praeesse. O mala saecula, vendi [...]u [...] infula Pontificalis, Infula venditur, nec reprehenditur empti [...] talis. Roma dat omnibus omnia dantibus, omnia Romae. Cum pretio, quia iuris ibi via ius perit omne. Roma nocens nocet, at (que) viam docet ipsa noc [...]ndi: lura relinquere, lu [...]ra requirere, pallia vendi. and then at last comming to Rome it selfe, so layes open the filthinesse of the whore of Babylon, Roma ruens rora, foeda satis nota cante [...]iat te▪ Scilla vorax rapis, & cupis & capis, & trahis ad te: Gurges es al [...]ior, area, capacior alta lacuna. Insatiabilis, insociabilis omnibus vna. Si tibi det sua, non repleat tua guttura, Croesus: Merca, vel aureus à modo, non Deus est tibi Iesus. as it is doubtfull whether her sinfulnes be more hatefull, then his boldnes is admirable. Let him that would bee able to answere all their false slanders, which they lay to the charge and disgrace of Protestant Churches; and to retort vpon themselues their obiection of the liues of our Professors; and he that would see the Church and state of Rome in her owne natural colours; let him, I say, reade but that one Author, who beside that hee is Manuscript in many Libraries, he was also published at Amsterdam, or somewhere neere therabouts, this present yeare 1607.
And after hee hath discouered her corruptions, and laid open her sinnes from head to foote, then [Page 159] he vrgeth her vehemently to repentance and reformation, Roma resurgito, te tibi reddito Romam. Cuius eras prius, ordinis illius exprime formam. Quo modo corpora tū [...], ita pectora nune rege fracta. Fracta recollige deuia di [...]ige, [...]er lab [...]facta, &c. Sed facis haec secus, &c. Roma quid exequar, imò quid eloquar, aut tibi promam? Vncia te ro [...]at, vncia te notat haud fore Romā. Tu populos tibi, te rutilans sibi marca subegit. Semper e [...]im lucra progenies tua, vult, agit, egit. which because he seeth no hope of, but that still she falleth from euill to worse; therefore he denounceth Gods iudgements against her, and assures her that vengeance, ruine and destruction shal fall vpon her. Fas mihi dicere, fas mihi scribere, Roma fuisti. Ecce relaberis, ecce reuoluer is ordine tristi. Fas mihi scribere, [...]as mihi dicere, Roma peristi. Obruta maenibus, obruta moribus occubuisti. Vrbs ruis inclita, tam modo subdita, quam prius al [...]as Quo prius altior, hoc modo pressior est labefacta. Fas mihi scribere, fas mihi dicere, Roma ruisti, Sunt tua maenia voci [...]erantia, Roma peristi. Haec omnia, & multa huiusmodi, Bernardus Marlanensis, Monacus Cloniacensis in libris sui [...] de contemptu mundi, ante 400. annos scriptis, & 1607. editis. Some part of his owne words I haue here put downe in Latine, but not in English, because the sinnes he laieth against her are such, as some of them are better vnnamed then reprooued. What can they say to it? is he some fained and forged new found Author, deuised by some of vs, or was he some late writer hired by Luther, or suborned by Caluine to raile on the Pope or Poperie? Nay Posseuine the Iesuite confesseth in the place aforenamed (and if he did not, it is well enough knowne by other good and ancient records) he was a professed Monke, and liued aboue foure hundred yeeres ago: therefore his testimonie in this case is beyond exception.
Now whether these wounds and corruptions in the Romish Church and State were healed, in the subsequent ages, or no, if any man doubt, let him looke vpon the Authors named afore, who liued in the ages succeeding one after another. Gualterus Mapus, and their S. Brigid, not much more then a hundred yeares after him: about 100. yeeres after them, Bonauenture and Wiclieffe: about a hundred [Page 160] yeeres after them, Gerson, Clemangius, Vincentius, and others: these if any man looke vpon he shall see that those wounds stood vnhealed, and those corruptions vnreformed, vntill we come to the yeere 1500. namely to this last age of all: and though Posseuine malitiously conceale the name of Gual [...]er Mapes, because hee is too plaine, yet hee cannot denie, but many, whereof some he nameth, Posseu. Appar. sac. tom. 2. lit. I. Iacobus lunterbeck German. Carthus. anno 1460. scripfi [...] auisamentum ad Papam pro reforma ione Ecclesiae, &c. did in all ages write to the Pope for reformation, and told him plainly what would follow if hee did not reforme the Church.
Now what good all these men could doe, and what reformation followed at last, let a Pope himselfe speake, one of the honestest hearts that euer had the hindrance to be a Pope, Adrian the 6. the best that was these many yeeres, and of whom (if it bee possible of any) there was expectation of some reformation in the Church: for, as Peter Matthew in his life confesseth, hee was not so proud, nor couetous, as most of them are Petr. Matthaeus in Cō ment. suis ad papales constitut. de Adriano 6. Pauperrima familia exortus, se dedit studijs, doctrina & morum integritate conspicuus: praeter omnem expectationem, Pont. Max. renū [...]iatus est: expectabatur Romae summa Cleri & totius populi laetitia, parabantur triumphi & theatra, sed cessare fecit in medio opere artifices: Gentilium haec ostentationes, non Christianorum esse insignia, & Ecclesiastici ordinis homines parum decere ratus.. How he found the Romish Church when he came to it, and how he left it at his sudden taking from it, iudge by his owne pitifull and passionate speech, which he commanded his Nuntio to deliuer from him, and in his name to the assembly of the States of Germanie, in their Imperiall Parliament, about the yeere 1522. These bee his words, as Espencaeus a learned Bishop of their owne reporteth.
Tell them from vs that we freely confesse God hath sent [Page 161] this trouble and affliction vpon the Church, for the sins of men, and especiallie of Priests and Prelates, from whose sinnes (the Scriptures are plaine) bee deriued the sinnes of the people: therefore our Sauiour (about to heale and reforme Ierusalem a diseased citie) first enters into the Temple, that first of all he may correct the sinnes of the Clergie (especially concerning buying and selling) herein playing the good Physition, who begins to heale a wound at the roote and bottome.
Wee know that for many yeeres there haue been many abominations euen in this holy Apostolike seate, abuses in the cariage of matters spirituall, excessiue enormities in our commandements, and in a word, all things turned topsie turuie, and from ill to worse; and no maruell if the disease grow frō the head into the mēbers, that is, frō the Popes into common persons.
I confesse, all we (that is, all Prelates of the Clergie) haue gone out of the way, each one into our own waies, neither hath there been of a long time any that did good: therefore there is good reason that wee all giue glorie to God, and humble our selues, euen our soules vnto him: let each one of vs remember whence wee are fallen, and rather iudge our selues, then stand to be iudged of God in his wrath and furie.
Wherein, for our parts, make promise in our name that wee will giue all diligence, that first of all this our Court of Rome may be reformed, from which it is likely all this mischiefe hath proceeded: that so, health and reformation may begin there to the good example of all, whence the corruption first bred, and spred to the ill example and hurt of all. To the furtherance and effecting of which happie reformation, wee hold our selues so much [Page 163]the more straitly tied, by how much the more earnestly wee see the whole world to expect and desire it.
Dices quòd Deus hanc persecutionem Ecclesiae [Page 161] suae inferri permittit, propter hominū peccata, sacerdotū maximè ac praelatorum, à quorū peccatis populi peccata deriuari scripturae clamant. Ideoque saluator (interprete Chrysostomo) curaturus infirmā ciuitatē Ierusalem, prius templum ingressus est, vt sacerdotum peccata, ementium inprimis & vendentium, primò castigaret, instar boni medici, morbum à radice curantis.
Scimus in sancta sede, aliquot iam annis, multa abominanda fuisse, abusus in spiritualibus, excessus in mandatis, omnia denique in peruersum mutata, nec mirum si aegritudo à capite in membra, à summis pontificibus in alios descenderit.
Omnes nos, id est, praelati Ecclesiastici, declinauimus, vnusquis (que) in vias suas, nec fuit iamdiu qui bonum faceret: vnde necesse est, vt omnes demus gloriam deo, humiliemus ei animas nostras, videamus vnusquisque vnde ceciderit, & se potius quisque iudicet quàm à Deo in virga furoris iudicari velit.
Qua in re, quod ad nos attinet, polliceberis nos omnem operam adhibituros, vt haec primū Curia, vnde forte malum hoc omne processit, reformetur, vt sicut in omnes inde corruptio emanauit, sic ab eadem etiam sede sanitas & omnium emanet reformatio. Ad quod procurandū nos tanto arctius obligatos reputamus, quā to mundum, vniuersu [...] huiusmodi reformationem [Page 163] auidius desiderare videmus.
Haec apud Espencaeum in Comment. in Titum, cap. 1. pag. 69. & 70.
These were the words of this good man, too good to bee a Pope, at least too good to be long a Pope: for after that he had so much forgot himself, and his Papall dignitie, and the honour of his Apostolicall seate (which cannot erre, nor doe amisse, as he like a foole confessed) as to grant that not the Church alone, but the holy Court of Rome did need reformation, forthwith there was order taken that hee should not trouble the world nor disgrace his place any longer, for shortly after he died: & for his sake, they prouided that their seate should neuer be so farre abused and abased againe by any plaine hearted Northren man, making sure from that day to this, that the Popedom should not be trusted out of the hands of an Italian, lest he should euer haue a thought of reformation. For what followed after all this? Was there any reformation in the Romish Church? were any of the euils and diseases confessed by Adrian redressed? I had rather Espencaeus their own Bishop should tell, then I; which because he doth very largely, I will contract it into a compendium, and hope that some will take paines to put all that wise and learned discourse of his into our vulgar tongue: the rather for that it cōtaineth much matter of great moment, & yet not vulgarly knowne to this day. Meane time the effect of it is this:
Legatur Espencaeus in Comment. ad Titum. cap. 1. [...] pag. 65. ad 91. That after all Christendome had complained of the enormous and intolerable grieuances, sustained from the Pope and his Court of Rome, al which and more the good Pope Adrian had confessed (but was taken away, lest hee had redressed) and after at their motion, he had intended a Councell should be called for reformation: all this determined by his death. His successor Clement the 7. was not so idle to hearken to such toyes, nor giue way to such innouations, hee would haue no Councell, he saw no cause of reformation. But from his successor Paul the 3. plaine necessitie did wring out an vnwilling consent, and so after many difficulties, the Councell of Trent was called, wherein first of all this point of reformation was so vrged, that a Committe was chosen of nine principall Diuines, some of them Cardinals, to consider what reformation was requisite in the Church; who after mature deliberation, plainly told the Pope, that all these euils proceeded from the abuses raigning in the Court of Rome: and concluding something for reformation of pluralities (one only abuse), the Pope did so interpret it, and alter it, when it came to him, as it did no good but hurt. He then dying, and the Councell being intermitted, was set on foote again by his successor Iulius the 3: who also confessed there were innumerable abuses in administring the Sacraments: but when it came to reforme them, in stead thereof hee suspended the Councell, though many Bishops, that desired reformation, did protest against it, affirming confidently that they had not as yet dispatched one of the businesses, for which they [Page 165] had assembled: but the Pope preuailed, and so for tenne yeeres it was discontinued. And at last being againe assembled by Pius the 4. he made shew hee would referre the whole matter of reformation to the Fathers of the Councell: but when it came to trial, it was with a prouiso, that, first, they should not meddle with the Court of Rome: secondly, that in their reformation, laid vpon other persons and places, they should alwaies enact it thus; Sauing alwaies holy and vntouched the Authoritie of the Apostolical sea: for which their courtesie to him & his seate, he afterward gaue them thankes in an oration in the Consistorie at Rome, assuring them (but it was in the word of a Pope) that he would be more rigide and seuere in purging his owne Court, and house and offices, then they would haue bin. With these good words the Pope dissolued the Councell. But frō that day to this (saith this Bishop) through these so many yeeres, nothing is done, nothing is changed, nothing is amended in the Church: and no maruell (saith he) for nothing haue they amended in Rome vnder their owne nose, where they might reforme any thing if they had conscience and will to doe it. So that now seeing all is finally referred and reserued to the Pope, there is (saith he) no more hope of any reformation left, nor any thing else remaines, but to see one miserie after another fall vpon the Apostolicall seate and the whole Church.
These and many more words to this purpose hath this wise and learned Bishop. Out of all which I conclude: therefore 30. or 40. yeeres agoe in the [Page 166] daies of Espencaeus, the Church of Rome, being found and confessed to be most fearefully corrupt, is not healed nor reformed, nay that all hope of reformation is now taken away. Since which time I shall thanke him that will shew me that there hath been any publike and generall reformation of the notorious abuses in that Church: prouided hee prooue it out of as good records, and with as faire euidence, as I haue done the contrary: which as I should reioyce in my heart once to behold, so tillFor as for the third point I haue vndertaken, namelie, that in stead of being healed and reformed, there haue contrariwise growne vp in the Romish Church, more horrible and haynous practises, more erroneous and [...]us do [...] [...]hen e [...] [...]re were kn [...]vne or heard of, and at this day stand maintained, at least vnreproued by their Church. This, I say, I must be constrained to referre to a peculiar Treatise by it selfe. then I must needes with griefe of heart conclude, that
And wil she not? what then remaines? but as our text leades vs,
But how? not in loue or affection; let vs neuer cease to wish to her as to our owne soules: nor let vs cease to pray for her, publikely and priuately, yea let vs blesse her when she curseth vs.
But let vs (as we haue well begun) proceed to separate our selues from her societie, and emptie our Church and kingdome of her and hers. And if they say we be schismatikes for separating from her: we answere, nay; she is the schismatike that hath separated her selfe from Christ.
Now therefore you honourable Magistrates and Iudges of this nation, set your shoulders to the worke of your God, rouse vp your spirits to execute the good lawes your selues and your forefathers [Page 167] haue enacted: our lawes are enowe and good enough, they want nothing but execution, and that belongs to you: vnto which dutie wee of the Ministerie do exhort you in the Lord: execute our lawes against thē, yet rather against Poperie then the Papists: remember the blessed promise in the Psalme, though it was spoken of literall Babylon, it hath a mysticall and true relation to spirituall Babylon: O Psal. 137. 8. 9. daughter of Babylon, worthie to be destroyed, happie shall he be that rewardeth thee as thou hast serued vs, yea blessed shal he be that taketh thy young childrē & dasheth thē against the stones. Oh pul this blessing on your heads, kill her infants, that is, her errors, impieties, superstitions, blasphemies, idolatries, equiuocations, treasons, &c. these be her Impes, her naturall brood; but they are now of more age and growne to greatnes, the more danger is there of them, and more cause to kill them: which if you doe with diligence and discretion, you see you draw a blessing from heauen vpon your selues. If you do not, you do for a time maintaine prickes in your eyes, and thornes in your sides, and your negligence will prouoke the great and iust Lord, to take the matter into his owne hands, which as he hath alreadie, not onely threatned, but begun, so he will, (though he deferre it till his owne time) bring it to full execution:
And then when she hath drunke vp the dregges of the cup of Gods wrath, and by the breath of his [Page 168] mouth is fearefully confounded, then I say, shall all her Merchants and all her louers, (whereof we haue too many that lurke amongst vs, and euen some that notwithstanding will needs be of vs) bee ashamed for their louing of her, whom they see God hated; and for their labouring so basely to couer her filthie skirts, which he would haue to her shame discouered to the view of the world: and then shall they shrinke to bea [...]e a part of her punishment, which so much delighted to wallow with her in her pollution. Therefore let the holy Ghost make the conclusion, and giue vs our last lesson: Go out of her Reuel. 18. 4. my people, and be not partakers of her sinnes, lest you receiue of her plagues. From both which good Lord deliuer vs. Amen.
And thus much for the kingdome of Antichrist.
There is also another mysticall Babylon, and that is the kingdome of sinne, the throne whereof is in this world, for hell is the place of execution, rather then of sinning: of this also is this text verified: for we do naturally (without grace) so loue this world, that though we find it miserable and confused, yet by our sensualitie, and daily deuising and practising new pleasures, we endeuour to heale it, and to make it a paradise, and they that are bewitched with it, would here set vp their rests. But when all is done that can be, it cannot be healed, but it is still a very Babel of confusion and disorder, a miserable world, a vale of teares, and a sea of trouble and turmoile to whosoeuer hath the sweetest portion of it. Therefore [Page 169] though we be in it, yet let vs vse it as though wee 1. Cor 7. 31. vsed it not, let vs not set our hearts vpon, but let vs forsake it, and goe euery one to his owne countrie, that is, to our blessed inheritance the kingdome of heauen, that is a Christian mans countrie: for as for this world, her sinnes are so vile, that her iudgement is gone vp vnto heauen, and God will assuredly destroy it. But there is a better world, euen an inheritance, immortall, 1. Pet. 1. 4. vndefiled, & that fadeth not, which is reserued in heauen for vs: hereof wee are borne heires by grace in Christ. Therefore forsaking the wicked Babylon of this world in our hearts and affections, (seeing it is past cure) let vs aspire after that, and long to haue our parts in it.
Now there are also besides these two great Babels, certaine other little pettie Babylons, namely, incurable sinnes amongst vs, which are Babels, or at least daughters of Babylon, and sprigs of that cursed roote. As,
1. That great sacriledge and Church-robbing committed by Impropriations, (in which case at this day almost halfe of this kingdome is) whereby it comes to passe (aboue any other one meanes) that an ignorant and vnteaching Ministerie is set ouer a great part of our people, which is the sourse & fountaine of all other euils in our Church: this is a deep wound, yet once was it curable enough, namely, when the Abbies were first dissolued, and since was it curable enough: but now (alas) how incurable it is, and by the craftie plots of the diuell how incurable it is made more and more, hee obserues but little that sees not. Oh happie he that can say in [Page 170] his conscience, I would haue cured this daughter of Babel: and happie also hee (though not so much) that hath had no hand in making this wound incurable: such plots and deuices arise out of hell, and heauen will confound them, though the earth for a time beare the burthen of them. Meane time, vnlesse the Kings Maiestie vouchsafe to take the matter into his hands, and to heale the wounds that he neuer made; otherwise it is incurable, or as the Kings euill, to be healed by none but by a King: till then wee may say with griefe of heart; It is an impe of Babylon that will not be healed.
2. The vngodly Playes and Enterludes so rife in this nation; what are they but a bastard of Babylon, a daughter of error and confusion, a hellish deuice, (the diuels owne recreation to mock at holy things) by him deliuered to the Heathen, from them to the Papists, and from them to vs? Of this euill and plague, the Church of God in all ages can say, truly and with a good conscience, wee would haue healed her. The ancient Fathers in the time of the Primitiue Church spared no paines to discouer the vilenesse and vnlawfulnes of them [...]tullian: Cyprian: Chrysostome: &c.: in these latter daies many holy and learned men haue laboured by preaching, writing, and conferring to haue healed them, and neuer was there Diuine of note and learning, that I know, that durst so farre prostitute his credite as to write for them. They know all this, and that God accounts it abomination for a man toDeut. 22. 5. put on womans apparell, and that the ancient Fathers expound that place against them: Cyprian: Chrysost. Sexta Synod. in Trull. Can. 62. they know that Cyprian resolued, (being asked the question) [Page 171] Cyprian. in Epistola 61. Oh that all Players would reade that Epistle, and regard it! that a Player ought not to come to the Lords table; and that hee that teacheth children to play, is not an instructor, but a spoiler and destroyer of children: they know they haue no calling, but are in the State like warts on the hand, or blemishes in the face: they know, that therefore they are faine to shroud themselues vnder such shelters, as at the houre of death, and day of iudgement, will proue but figge leaues: they know they are defended with the same arguments, as the stewes in Rome bee, and little better defence can be made for them (being as they are).
All this they are daily made to know, but all in vaine, they be children of Babylon that will not bee healed: nay, they grow worse and worse, for now they bring religion and holy things vpon the stage: no maruel though the worthiest and mightiest men escape not, when God himselfe is so abused. Two hypocrites must be brought foorth; and how shall they be described but by these names, Nicolas S. Antlings, In a Church in London, euerie day in the weeke prayers, and a Sermon at sixe [...]e in the [...] ning: a [...]ssed and rare example. Simon S. Maryoueries? Thus hypocrisie a child of hell must beare the names of two Churches of God, and two wherein Gods name is called on publikely euery day in the yeere, and in one of them his blessed word preached euerie day (an example scarce matchable in the world): yet these two, wherin Gods name is thus glorified, and our Church and State honoured, shall bee by these miscreants thus dishonoured, and that not on the stage only, but euen in print. Oh what times are wee cast into, that such a wickednesse should passe vnpunished! I speake nothing of their continuall prophanenesse [Page 172] in their phrases, and sometime Atheisme and blaphemie, nor of their continuall prophaning of the Sabbath, which generally in the countrie is their play day, and oftentimes Gods diuine seruice hindred, or cut shorter to make roome and giue time for the diuels seruice.
Are they thus incurable? then happie hee that puts to his hand to pull downe this tower of Babel, this daughter of confusion, happie he that helpes to heale this wound in our State: but most happie that Magistrate, who, like zealous Phinehes, takes some iust vengeance on that publike dishonour laid vpon our Churches. But if we be negligent in this cause of God, then hee himselfe will take the matter into his owne hand, whose Church, whose religion, whose holy ordinances and most holie name are daily prophaned by them: for as their iniquities are hainous, and their basphemies against heauen; so doubtlesse their iudgement is gone vp vnto heauen and lifted vp vnto the cloudes. So wishing their repentance, I proceed.
3. The horrible abuse of the Sabbath day, in this citie, and ouer this kingdome: in some places by Faires and Markets, by May-games and Moricedencers, by Wakes and Feasts: in all places (almost) by buying & selling, & bargaining: in this citie by cariages in and out, by selling betimes in the morning and after dinner: by playing in the streetes, and in the fields.
Oft hath this bin complained of, and some haue endeuoured to heale it, but it is an Impe of Babylon [Page 173] that will not be healed, but rather it creepes as a canker thorow our whole State, from the foot to the head. But let vs take heed, for it will eate out the heart and life of a State, euen this one sinne. Did not our fathers Ierem. 17. thus (saith noble Nehemiah) and therfore God brought Nehem. vlt. all this euill vpon vs? See captiuitie, destruction, and desolation of a goodly and flourishing setled kingdome, for the publike prophaning of the Sabbath: O therfore happy he that puts to his helping hands to heale this wound, which yet is curable enough, if we would do our duties: for the CommandementThe fourth Cō mandement. is, thou & all within thy gates, keep my Sabbath. Now who is there within this Realme, but is within the gates of the Kings house? who within this Citie, but within the gates of the L. Maior? who any where, but is of some mans familie, and within some mans gates? If then Fathers and Magistrates would looke to all within their gates, this sinne could not bee so grieuous, this wound not so wide and desperate as it is. Therefore you my L. Maior bee exhorted to attempt the healing of this wound, in your yeare; set before your eyes, the noble example of worthie Nehemiah, it will excite you to this holy dutie; andNehem. then at the end of your yeare, you may with the comfort of a good conscience say with him; Remember Nehem. vl [...]. 19 me O my God in goodnesse, according to all that I haue done for this people. But if wee still neglect this cause of God, and suffer his Sabbath daily thus to be prophaned; then let vs look for nothing but continuance and increase of these grieuous plagues that haue so long lien vpon vs: and let vs be assured [Page 174] God will take the matter into his owne hands, and some way or other get himself glorie vpon vs, for he will lose his honor at no mans hand, but whosoeuer will not glorifie him in his conuersion, he will glorifie his owne name vpon him in his confusion: which heauie iudgement that God may turne from vs, let vs turne to him, &c.